Biblical Perspectives on Social Media and Technology
Episode 113
Michael and Zach reinvite Jonathan White to discuss how we should think about social media and technology in our lives and our children's lives.
Original Lesson Part 1: https://www.sermonaudio.com/sermons/22325225017395
Original Lesson Part 2: https://www.sermonaudio.com/sermons/3325140534484
Resources: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/pld3cji7wnnj06srise3x/resouce-page.jpg?rlkey=eh0sm5s4qopo7dqva3z1f7j6w&st=77ffh3nn&dl=0Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/AZFxYvpWvnI
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/
0:00 Zach. Michael. How's it going for the podcast for today? I mean, we're recording. Things are different today. Things things are different. If if you're on the pod, you don't know what that is yet, but if you're on YouTube, you probably already have a good idea that our green screen's gone green. Screen's gone that, and that's not the only thing. That's probably a good idea for people to subscribe to us on YouTube so they can get this exclusive content. They'll know what's going on. And I'm going to do these in in order of importance. So probably the second biggest thing is we have a guest with us here, Jonathan White. Welcome back to the podcast.
0:40 He just waved if you are watching on YouTube. If you didn't, you missed it. So we can just kind of narrate the action as it goes. That's that's good. And then probably third, most important is that we don't more, even more important to have Jonathan, we don't have Lord of the Rings in our background. Which is, which is, to be fair, all I've ever wanted. That's why. That's why I came on the podcast in the 1st place as I wanted to be in Hobbiton or one of the other locations. Yeah, and, and every time I show up there, they take the green screen away. It is crazy if we. Could get the green screen maybe like 1 foot wider. We could probably do it with three people, but unless we, we, I guess we could just sit really, really close to each other. That's true.
1:22 That'd. Be The Hobbit house gets a little snug with three guys in there, huh? Honestly, as much as Jonathan wishes he was there, I'm so glad I'm not. So I don't know, It's like it's one man stretch. It's another man stretch or something like that. And then lastly, I'm wearing a blue shirt. Jill makes fun. Never heard of seen this before. I know Jill makes fun because I'm I want to buy a shirt. She's like you. How many blue shirts do you have? Like I have a lot of blue shirts because blue is my normal color. But without the green screen here we can. We're free to wear whatever color we want. To I would like to point out that I've been free to wear whatever color I want since the first time I was on this podcast. It's pretty amazing, but it does get texted about Jonathan and his wisdom was like is it OK? What color am I allowed to wear because he knows that you were the wrong color. Boom all.
2:06 Right. So Jonathan, we just got done teaching a series at CBC and the 1st 246 lessons in that series, well it went parallel with your Old Testament wisdom series. So send number of lessons were about marriage and then we tacked on this end piece that we thought was good for really everyone pertinent to marriage and parenting, but talking about social media usage. And so we wanted to ask, I mean, I guess if you're on YouTube, you're kind of on some type of social media platform if you're watching, but we wanted to have you here kind of give us an overview of that.
2:51 So anything to say before we take it to the next level? Once again, we should have our guests say this, and before we get into it, we should. We did this last time, But what? Give us your credentials. Assistant principal, Middle school at Northwood Academy. He is a Coulson Fellow and he is a master teacher. Do I know it? Then you think. Those do belong to me. Those titles are mine. And. Any other type Mr. Do you have his masters in in some sort of writing? In literature, yeah. Literature. But that still makes me just a Mr. not a doctor or anything like that. Yeah. It's great. Well, J Carl. White. That is my signature. Talking about social media, that's something I only know you by If they only see on Facebook, well, go ahead and just stare into the soul of the camera and tell it that we're going to take it to the next level.
3:46 Let's take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. So we are here with Jonathan, as we said. And I just want to say off the bat, really enjoy the class. I felt like I consider things some things in a different light and that even led to action. Maybe we'll talk about that, some of that action when we get to it, where, where it fits into it. Yeah, I will say this.
4:26 It's we mentioned on another podcast, we'll say it really briefly and maybe it's a teaser for a future podcast. I don't know when the other one's going to drop. But I, you know, for a short time I have got rid of my Facebook app and it actually calls me to be a worse employee at work. Came back to bite me. I did not know what's going on in my employee's life and I came off very in, you know, uncaring. But I think that's a really one off. It has to do with fires in Myrtle Beach, something that probably won't happen a lot, but you know, yeah, yeah. Anyway. So you talked about media usage in general, maybe phone usage in particular, and you've given this brief a number of times or talked to middle school kids and parents.
5:11 So is there something like just give us a broad picture of maybe the what you've seen since you started teaching, I don't know, 10-12 years ago, 14 years ago, 1515 years ago? You were all around. And. How does that make you feel? Me that I. Have been. You've been teaching for. 15 in the real world. Wow. That is. Crazy, at least. Yeah. So the little known fact is that Jonathan was, I think you were in 9th grade right when we came to CBC. That sounds about right. 2002 was your 9th grade year maybe yes yeah yeah yeah so and and Jill and I, you were in our youth group and then we had a relationship post youth group, you know, or discipled and worked through the book of Romans and maybe Galatians and so good, good time so yeah, I guess that makes me old that's.
6:07 What I was trying to get at, but just not really get right at it. I just wanted to put it out there. Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah. So we, you know, so I started teaching in 2010 and that was all high school. And it, it was one of those situations where as, as I've been in the classroom over, you know, that following decade plus, there's, there are definitely changes that have happened. And I think, I think if you were to talk to people, not even just people in education, but if you were to talk to talk to people that deal with adolescents in, in any capacity throughout their days.
6:49 There's just a lot of anecdotal evidence that like things have changed. Like there have been some differences in the way that adolescents interact with other people, the way that they are able to pay attention or not pay attention for longer period of time. Do some of that, you know, challenging mental investment when it's necessary and and all of that kind of anecdotal evidence has really actually gotten grounded in the last few years by a lot of actual hard data. So social scientists have just started to look at something that has shifted and, and really the years in question are like 2010 to 2015. That's kind of the the time span where social scientists started noticing a major upswing in what they call major depressive episodes in adolescents and teenagers and a host of other mental health related issues like a rise in anxiety and medication for anxiety.
7:53 You know, the prescriptions being handed out for that in adolescence, as well as, you know, emergency room reports and clinical reports of adolescents involved in self harm. And so with with the just kind of almost meteoric rise in those five or six years, it prompted a lot of looking, a lot of testing, a lot of research and, and data gathering. And one of the, I think maybe one of the best resources out there right now about it. I mean, it's gotten a lot of play time in media and on, you know, bestseller book list. But The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt is sort of a compendium of the research surrounding adolescence and mental health in this era, like for mostly for Gen.
8:45 Z. And you were saying Jonathan Haidt is a pillar in the Christian? I think he's a Dallas, the electrics mirror graph, is that right? Is that just a cut at Dallas? No, Jonathan Haidt is is open about his atheism. He mentions it in the book. And that was a caveat that I gave as we were talking through his book. And really, I mean, we spent a lot of time with his book. There were other things that came up in that class that I think were important, but we did spend a lot of time working through kind of the layout of his book and what led up to it and the things that he saw in the data. But the caveat was, you know, he is an atheist. His his perspective is, you know, evolutionary psychology.
9:30 And so everything that we see, whether in society or in the human psyche, he, his worldview insists that it is just the result of biological evolution. And that that kind of makes you wonder, OK, well, can I really, can I read this book and get something out of it? And it can be a that's a good concern, I think to have for Christians reading discernment. But interestingly, the that those kind of, you know, add his adherence to that worldview, which we might call materialism, is not something that interrupts his gathering and reporting of data. And it's also interesting that in his book, he actually kind of open handedly, you know, looks at data and says communities of faith that are that are tight knit communities of faith that have committed believers and, and you know, subtext. You can read committed Christians like when there when there's a family that is committed to church attendance, Bible reading, Bible memorization, when they have some of these certain factors in play. Jonathan Hayes quick to say these sorts of, you know, groups tend to see a much lower rate of some of they they kind of buck the trend of what we see in the broader culture. And that's not always true in the in the Christian community, except when you adjust for making sure that when you're looking at data, you're looking
11:02 at actual committed born again believers, right? So the there's, you know, there's a statistic that says, you know, 50% of marriages and a divorce for both believers and non believers. Well, if you, if you actually look at those data sets and say, what does it take to be called a, a believer, a Christian in that data set, It's a pretty broad spectrum. If you narrow it down to what is the divorce rate among committed Christians that would call themselves born again, that have a commitment to marriage as a covenant and attend church regularly. Man, all of a sudden the the divorce rate drops dramatically. And so again, it's it's interesting coming from an evolutionary biology, biology, biological perspective, even in psychology, Jonathan Haidt is willing to go, yeah, like faith communities are doing something right when they're when they're all in on their faith. So it's an.
11:57 It's just an interesting detail. I would just say that I'm right there with you because I've had conversations with atheists where the subject wasn't origin of life and I was able to say, hey, you believe that we evolved over a million years to this point. I believe we were designed to this point. Either way, we both believe that our bodies are adapted for this thing, either by design or the revolution. So we can agree to disagree on that right now because we're talking about this thing. And so, you know, and I guess in this particular subject we're talking about today, we have not been necessarily designed or adapted to a lot of usage of this screen.
12:37 And so that's really going to throw off our biology. So I think it's, you know, there might be some minor differences of how we what we may say with the solution is or some of the. But I think overall, like you said, the data gathering and the idea that this is really different than what we've done. Even if you even if you're a very young earther and you think 6000 years, like, OK, this is 10 years at the end of, you know, 6000 years. So this is a huge change for how humans have interacted with their environments. Right. Yeah. So the recognition of the problem, that part is kind of unavoidable. The data is unavoidable, you know, so, OK, so for, for the last, you know, I guess the last decade or so from from 2010 through the 20 teens, again, it was a lot of anecdotal evidence. It was a lot of teachers, you know, in teachers meetings saying, man, I just can't, I can't get the kids to concentrate.
13:33 It was and, and so part of that is developmentally appropriate. Like there, there are limits to, to developmentally, there are limits to what children should be expected and required to do in an academic setting. But teachers across the board, we're having these conversations and it's just, I just as something is, something's different, something has changed and, and, and now the data is here for it. So, so I I went through in our Sunday school class the sort of the layout of Jonathan hates book and we can just kind of briefly breeze through that stuff. I'll take the first one and you can take the other ones, but don't look at it. Surge of suffering, is that right? Yeah, because all the the data has started to pour in. Longitudinal studies are now pouring in about, you know, we've, we've got a decade and more of collected data on adolescents and their screen time, their Internet usage or social media app usage.
14:26 And so that the that data is all the graphs are like they just, they just kind of go up with whether it's major depressive episodes, anxiety prescriptions, whether it is the incidence of self harm or incidence of bullying and cyber bullying in schools. It's just that it's going up. So yeah, the surge of suffering was the thing that required attention. Like, let's look into these things. #2 I don't look at it well, I was going to say I, I remember like surge of suffering. Was the one I remember it so I wanted. To just had to get that one first. I remember helping out with the youth group at our church. It probably was like 2015 or something to your point, Jonathan, where it's like we did a study on social media problem, like no hard data, but everyone's kind of like, man, it definitely can't be good. And I think most people probably know a lot of people with these kind of disorders.
15:20 It's not only something that's going up, but not saying all this is bad, but very openly talked about like the way the way you talk to someone is, do you feel hurts or it's like a different even way to communicate. Again, not all of it's sad, but it's like, man, it's everywhere. Need to be very careful because if you say something wrong and you're triggering and it's a it's a complicated thing. I'm just going to go off my memory. And I think it was something about decline of play based childhood. I don't know. Yeah. So the next two sections of the book, Jonathan Haidt goes into detailing the decline of what he calls a play based childhood and the rise of what he calls a phone based childhood. And in that that first section about play based childhoods, he really starts to kind of talk about from a developmental perspective, what do children need in order to thrive as they're as they're growing through these really, really important ages.
16:13 Kids grow really fast and then really slow for a little while. And, and in that, in that kind of extended childhood that a lot of mammals don't have, there are some really important milestones for, for humans. And we would, we would say, well, this is again, this is by design. This is not something that has been just developed over millions of years. But although millions of years could have been at play at some points, depending on your creationist theorizing, whenever we talk about a play based childhood, it's it's giving opportunities for kids to develop in ways that are important for them, where they're developing resilience, the ability to be independent, to make choices, to assess, you know, risk and reward.
17:04 And so play based childhood is really, if you're, I mean, if you're older than maybe 30 or 32, it's probably, it's probably kind of describes your childhood like where you were, you kind of had the freedom after school, you just kind of go out and you're, you're just out, you're out with your friends, you're riding bikes around the neighborhood or depending, you know, depending on where you live, you're out doing chores. If you live in a rural, a rural area, maybe it's dirt bikes and four Wheelers, maybe it's chores out in the, in taking care of animals or doing something with crops. But there was just a sort of lack of adult supervision. And again, we can talk about that in both positive and negative ways, but I just know that there's there's a lot of things that happen in that, that kind of play based childhood where there's a little bit more of that unstructured freedom for kids to develop significant aspects of both their personality and their character. And Jonathan Haidt says, well, that's just really diminished as we've gotten into this information culture, this Internet saturated world, that's that kind of childhood has really gone away because there's always a stimulus there. And it's and it's easier and parents feel that it is safer, you know, with the proliferation of a 24 hour news cycle and the ability for, well, what makes people watch the news? What makes people click on stories? It's when they're horrifying
18:35 things. And so those stories tend to, you know, in in the newspaper industry, there's an old line. If it bleeds, it leads. And so saturating our minds with what we're perceived to be the dangers of our culture, Parents in elite, even back in the 90s started this development of sort of safety ISM kind of kind of bringing their kids maybe closer to home. And, and as the rise of, you know, Internet culture in the late 90s and video game systems and then phones in the mid 2000s, all that stuff sort of allowed parents to put their kid at home and just put them in front of a screen and let that thing take care of them.
19:16 Whereas they didn't have to worry about, you know, are they going to be home before the street lights turn on? And that that has some some ramifications that that we're we're still kind of seeing. But that idea of safety ISM we felt like the world became too dangerous because we just saw news stories all the time about things that were dangerous. Parents that grew up in the 70s. There's there's all kinds of serial killer. If you ever watch serial killer documentaries, it seems like the 70s was the time where all the serial killers live. Unsolved Mysteries, Dateline, all those things have helped us go and we look at the worst possible scenario and we go, I don't want that to happen to my child. And I think, well for me and I don't, I think both of y'all grew up in, you grew up in Memphis, you grew up in Charleston.
20:04 So larger towns, I grew up in a small town in Arkansas, so I could walk to school because I live 2 blocks away from school during the summer, I could ride my bike like four or five blocks away to the post office, get mail. Like my parents are at work, like they don't know where I'm at. I could just decide, you know what, I'm going to go get the mail today and stuff. And I was looking, you were teaching. I was like, I don't allow my kids that level of freedom. How can I, you know, start thinking, how can I incorporate some of that level of freedom? Because even when my, some of my girls like, can we run around the neighborhood? I'm like, have fun with you. Stay in this part of the neighborhood, you know, and is they're probably fairly safe, but you know, you hear horror stories of missing and doing sex trafficking and stuff like that. And you're like, how do we, what's the balance? And the And the irony is that statistics wise, our kids are actually safer today in public spaces than they've really ever been.
20:58 And yet it's the time when we're most controlling about where they are. And like, and I'm with you, like my neighborhood doesn't have like, amenities. So there's not like a pool or a clubhouse or that kind of stuff. And it's not, it's not like in a top area of town. And so, yeah, like I'm, I'm not in a place where I feel comfortable just letting my kids kind of wander the neighborhood like I did at their age growing up. But but that you know, that it it, it's interesting that we did, we did this sort of inverted ratio where we started pulling them in from the physical world and overprotecting in the physical space and absolutely under protecting the digital space. And I think the beginnings of it were just a lot of parents just didn't know what was going on.
21:42 Parents that were that grew up totally analog. The digital revolution was like a like, I don't even know what's going on. Like my kids are just over there playing with some fancy game in it. That's fine, it's whatever. But. Do you think parents of our generation, because Internet was hitting when I was in maybe 9th grade, of course, you all like grew up with the Internet. Do you think that we're a little bit more savvy to the dangers of the Internet? Maybe that's changed some of this because we saw it younger, whereas, you know, parents of, you know, maybe your parents didn't have that so that you were maybe let loose. I don't know, maybe generational thing? I think this generation definitely has a better handle on what it is because like so I, I had sort of 1/2 and half like so the, the millennials, it was like a good chunk of my childhood and formative years. We're pretty much analog now.
22:35 We had ATV like there was cable once in a while, but, and we got like a Nintendo Entertainment System when I was, I don't know, nine years old or so. We could play Duck Hunt or something like that. But I think I think parents of my age in general are a little bit more savvy about what the negative ramifications are. But I'll, but I'll actually tell you where I think the, the major hope is. I think it's the generation after me because there's there's some recent reports out from like the Coulson Center little plug for those Coulson fellows out there that that Gen. Z is actually starting to sat. There's some there's some preliminary data that says Gen. Z is starting to sour on some social media. And I think a lot of it has to do with, like you said, how free, how free they are to talk about mental health issues and then sort of the overwhelming realization of where those mental health issues are a lot of a lot of times stemming from. And, and that's again, major deal. But I, I think this generation might, I think generation of parents my age has an idea, but I really think the cultural tide, Gen.
23:52 Z has the opportunity to turn the cultural tide in a way that millennials, we may have lost that by just a couple of years. Good. Did you have? Yeah, I was going to say I was curious to, well, I was going to make a comment just probably come later. But you know, it's not the same as social media, but a lot of these people, a lot of people a little bit older than I do sit in front of Fox News or CNN all day every and it feeds them in a different way. They're not swiping, but it's like maybe a lesser screen that's like doing that. And then I was gonna say you have. The 24 Hour News. It's like all the time. And because we do have our phones, there are the there is that girl that went to the mailbox got abducted and that's on we've got like some video where we didn't even have video before words. So that's more real.
24:39 My question for you guys, when did you all get cell phones? Just, you know, thinking about our ages and where we were, I know I was on my 13th birthday. I was allowed to get a cell phone, but the coolest thing our cell phones did was like go through ringtones. Like we spent a lot of time, like with my ringtone, we could play snake. Maybe there was like if you had like a BlackBerry, you could do the little brick breaker thing. But I'm just curious where you guys were introduced to some of this technology. Yeah. I got my first cell phone after I graduated to high school or maybe at the very end of high school, and it was merely for safety travelling back and forth. And it was one of those things like you have so many minutes and don't even dare think about texting 'cause it's like 1/4. It was.
25:21 Yeah, it was. Crazy expensive even and if someone texted you, you still had to pay for it. It's like. Don't text. Don't text. Me. And so. They don't send a text as it's like OK oh man what a waste of a word. Right, right. And so then probably the first smart device I got was an iPod Touch, which was like an iPhone but not a phone because I still had like I had a BlackBerry for my work and I had an iPod touch just for, you know, like a digital. I'll say digital assistant, 7th, 8th grade. Not a phone, but Palm Pilots were like a thing for a little bit of high school. Like we all got them like as like kids anyway.
26:01 Whip out the stylus. Yeah, yeah. And it didn't really work well. Like the stylist didn't write like it was really difficult to work with. I think I got a flip phone when I was 16 because I was driving to school and driving a friend of mine to school. And I think that was the the time when my parents were oh, and my brother. It must have been when my brother went to college because then he wasn't the driver anymore. I was the driver for me and my friends. And so then that was it. So I was probably 16 when that happened, 16 or or 17. And it was, yeah, it was a flip phone. It was T9 texting. And so, yeah. T9 texting. Trying to explain that to to middle schoolers today, like what it was like to have to run through that system texting. Well, there was the one where you had to push them over and over again and it'll be like ABC. And then and then there was the one where it was predictive, so you could just hit the letter and it would kind of give you some options.
27:00 That was a big step up. In technology, Cool. And even I remember as like prior on that, it's like 1312, like you're on the Internet, you got mail a well, it's like even some of that like dial up stuff while it's dialing up, I could do some play based interaction. I got some time to kill. It's gonna be 3 minutes before I can get on my e-mail and instant messenger. So Jonathan, you talked about the real life play. So there's a cycle kind of at home base. I've learned from my previous adventure, I go out, I risk some, I get scared, some I come back, I get comforted and then I do that cycle over again.
27:40 And then for digital, there's kind of a different cycle, this dopamine pathway. Do you want to talk about how that differs between the two of those? Yeah, for sure. And and there was a good example that I had in my notes to share on Sunday. And I just, I told Kenya afterwards, I was like, I didn't look at my notes enough. I had things I wanted to say and I just didn't get. I've been there. So. Been there, done so that that that attachment system that you're talking about where? Where kids reach out from a secure base, they do something a little bit risky and then they kind of see the reward or lack of reward and they get a little bit anxious if they're going too far. And then they run back to that secure base to, to get kind of reaffirmed and feel good about what they did. The, the example that I have is our, our daughter Everly, who is 5.
28:28 We have these plastic knives that we bought that are like designed for kids to be able to use. So like cut their own fruit and stuff. And they're designed not to really be able to cut you very easily. Like you really kind of have to work at it if you're going to cut your hand with it. If you play spoons with plastic knives they will cut you. Just APSA for everyone out there. Not that anyone's tried it before, but Michael's hands so I can see the scars. Actually there may be a a story that needs to be revisited in that at some point. Playing spoons with knives I just it. Seems all right. We'll leave it. We'll leave it there for now. She so I've I've shown her maybe twice. We get the little, it's a little serrated kind of silicone or plastic knife.
29:12 And, and it's, it's serrated, so you have to kind of push it forward to make it cut through whatever you're trying to cut. And I've shown her, you know where to put your fingers and then go ahead and slice down and make sure it's on a flat surface. And I think probably I've done it twice with her holding her hand and holding her fingers and showing her how it goes. Well, the other day I literally think I was sitting staring at this computer working on this presentation for one of the Sundays. And she came up to me and she was like on the verge of tears. Like you could see some tears in her eyes, like a little bit of watery. And, and she was holding up her hand and there was like a little red mark on one of her fingers.
29:56 And I said, you know, I said what you, what happened? And she explained that she, she wanted strawberries and shows she got strawberries out of the fridge, which that's good or she could do that. But then without me knowing, she went and got that little plastic knife that we use and she had tried it on her own. And I was really proud of her that she went and she realized I want this strawberry cut because she she doesn't want the green stuff on the top of it. And so she decided she wanted that strawberry cut. She went and got the knife, never said anything to me about it, and then tries it herself. But when she got to the point of fear, it slipped out of the way. The knife hit her finger. Now it wasn't like it was a tiny little scratch. It wasn't even something I was going to put a Band-Aid on. It was just a little impression. But she walked up to me and that and that was that she was returning to a secure base.
30:43 And then what did I do? We we walked over and looked at the situation and helped her understand how to kind of position things a little bit better. I showed her again, but then I didn't put my hands on it whenever she was going to actually do it. And so that, that that cycle is so healthy, like to encourage independence, to affirm, you know, what they've done. And then when they get a little bit anxious or fearful because they may have gone too far, they're running back to that secure base. That's a beautiful structure. But in the, in the social media world there, there's a, there's a whole different structure that's not, that doesn't really require, you know, return to safe base.
31:23 There's a cycle that looks a lot like an addiction cycle. And so it starts with some kind of trigger, some something, and usually on a social media app, you know, it's those push notifications, they, they pop up and tell you something has happened and you need to know about it. And so after that you perform an action. So you tap on it. Or if you're at a computer, you know, you click on something. And, and the social media companies that are really smart have have learned to be like casinos where they give kind of variable rewards. It's not not every time you go to the app are you going to get something that you really like. Sometimes it's going to be something really good, like you're going to see somebody comments it on your photo or somebody liked something. But sometimes it just pops up with a push notification to say, hey, we thought you might want to see this.
32:07 And you're like, I don't, I don't care anything about that. But they're just trying to get you into the app over and over and over again, sometimes with a reward, knowing that if one out of every 8-9 or ten times you get into that app, something triggers a dopamine release, the anticipation of the next dopamine release is even greater. And it just gets you into this this cycle. So from the trigger to the action to that variable reward, to some investment in the app where you're putting part of yourself in the app. I mentioned Myspace because that was where we put all of ourselves in middle school. Our whole life was going to be displayed on that page. The colors were important, the music playing in the background was important. Your top eight friends was really important. And if you switched it out, people were going to notice and they were going to say something like you were going to cause some drama.
32:58 So all of that stuff, we invested ourselves into that. And that meant that for the future, now that I'm invested in this social media situation, I don't always need an external trigger to make me want to go to the app. Sometimes I just haven't. I just a thought, I posted something a while ago. I wonder if anybody's seen it and it. And so all of a sudden this cycle is, is it's a cycle of addiction because of the variable reward and because of the dopamine that comes from those variable rewards. It is an addictive cycle. And social media companies know this. And we know from internal documents that whistleblowers have shared or that have been shared through Freedom of Information Act or that kind of thing, We know that social media developers are keenly aware of the psychology of addiction and the psychology of adolescents. And there's just a huge incentive for social media companies to get a massive consumer base that will always be a consumer base for them because they get to sell ad space that way, right?
33:58 That that determines their numbers for their cash flow. And they're good at this, like the the social media apps, I heard someone say early on in the sort of social media revolution, if the, if the product is free, you are the product, right? Yeah, there's a whole Netflix special. I think it was on Netflix. Yeah, they have like the social, whatever it's called, but they did a really good job. Yeah. And. It's how they like curate your doom scrolling feed and stuff and how they know like how how how fast and how long exactly what you want to see they. They have all the numbers and like from what I understand, it's like, you know, people that engineer this stuff is like my kids not allowed on this because I know how addictive it is, right, right. And, and go into that like real life playing versus the digital. Even when things go bad in real life and you are anxious and nervous, it's just a different feeling than when you're scrolling and like it just zaps the lifeout. You like know it's not good.
34:54 Like even when you mess up in real life, you're like, oh, this was not good. But it's like a totally different feeling in my mind. Well, in real life, you can do something about it. That's right. Right. So like if, if I if Everly when she slipped with the knife, the strawberry popped out of the way and she hit her finger with that little part of that knife, she could do something about it because that's a real world scenario and she can run back to a secure base. If something makes me feel anxious or fearful or awful online, there's there's not really a recourse. Like there's not a lot I can do. I mean, I can fire off in the comment section, but but you're right, there's especially. If you're an adolescent, maybe even less well prepared to do something about it, maybe you don't say anything.
35:36 Maybe that haunts your. It just builds up. Yeah, it just builds up. Absolutely. Yep. All right. So I'm guessing that many of our listeners really relate to what you're talking through 'cause maybe they have had that their own experience, like complaining on Facebook about getting 15,000 words about it freezing and then going down and see 06 people laughed at that. I guess I said something pretty funny. Not that I just not that that just happened for me. So we probably really relate to that. And then hopefully you're going, man, if I am in this trap, how much more so than maybe my kids. So maybe you could speak as we're drawing, we're kind of this, maybe we should have scheduled 2, but maybe you can speak quickly to the evaluative value you say that word.
36:29 Evaluative. Process for what's good in our life. And then maybe a game plan overall for parents who are that they got young kids, maybe maybe they've already unleash Pandora's box. Is there a strategy for getting Pandora in those types of things? Yes, we don't have to follow the Greek myth on this one. So the evaluative framework I think that Christians should generally use. It's interesting. We've been talking about Romans and a lot of a lot of what I think about Christians evaluating their interactions and their participation in things comes from Romans 13 and 14 and then First Corinthians 8 through 10. I think these are two really, really strong passages for it because they're centered on for the most part, they're centered on love.
37:16 And that's that is a major defining characteristic. So I think I think in terms of kind of four laws that I want to run thing, I want to kind of let this be my rubric if I'm considering involvement. And the first one is, is what John Piper calls the the lowest question that you should ask, Still an important one, but it's the question of is it a sin, right? So there we have clear commands in Scripture of things that fall into the category of sin. Exodus 20 begins that process. But then Paul gives us numerous different lists of things that are sinful. And so we want to run things in our life through that, that filter first, is it a sin? Because that's a clear and obvious note, right? If something falls in that category, I have to, I have to step away from it.
37:58 I have to remove myself. But if it's not a sin, then you kind of have these further tiers of questions. And so I call the next one the law of honor and it's can I, can I honor God in it? Which is a good question, but then it's do I honor God in it? We look at 1st Corinthians 1031 for that one and. I'll say this is where I took action because I have some like stupid games on my phone, like a little arcade games that are ad based revenue and I'm like, OK, could I maybe conceivably, but do I, I don't know, maybe I'm like what? What is the real benefit? So those I just deleted them. Yeah, just got rid of them. That's strong clash clans really.
38:39 Gone. OK, that's been a raw. Stars gone, some other stuff just gone. Like, you know, just so I just don't have chess. Yeah, there's a mahjong game I still have on because Phoebe likes to help match tiles. So I feel like that is a way to go. But I was like, so I evaluated like what? What is God honoring and what am I God honoring? And what is just really a resource suck on my life. Get rid of it. And that's a really. I mean, I'm telling and I, and I have to say it every time I talk about these things. Like I, I like to put this evaluative framework out there, but my life doesn't perfectly follow this thing. Like I have to look, I have to look at I, I love video games. I really enjoy playing video games and I have to kind of really, I have had to take a step back in certain areas of life and, and areas of games, especially to go.
39:29 Can I honor God in it? Do I honor God in like that's a that's a really hard question to have to be confronted with and go that that hurts sometimes like that. There's a cut there. The next one is the law of love and it's can I show love in it? Can I show love in this activity or this involvement? And will it cause a brother to stumble? And that was I'm sure you guys have taken that up and we'll be releasing that. Did we cover? That. And that's a just the law of love. Like is this something that I can be involved in and not not 'cause somebody else through my? Desire to please myself even in a even in a maybe a good thing or an OK thing.
40:12 Is it going to cost somebody else to stumble and then the last one is the the law of expediency. And that is the question of does it help me run? Is this something that and that's John Piper has a great a great video great sermon on this from Hebrews. Does it help me run laying aside these these sins, but also everything that hinders us from. Yeah, everything. And man, would you run life through those four filters? You're like, I have to really be careful. Yeah. If you can expand this outside of social media, there's a lot of things you can. Run this through. Yeah. All right. Game plan for for parents.
40:52 I think if you got young parents maybe the easiest thing is just delay screen time. Yes, limit screen time. Oh well, limit screen time and delay when you give them autonomous screen time like a phone or a tablet. Well, and social media in particular like that, that is the key. So smartphones themselves are not designed in the same way as social media apps. A smartphone is, is like a Swiss army knife, right? It's not designed to be addictive. It is a tool and it's a great tool, but the social media, the. Tricorder. Because you're making those noises. I bet you could. I bet there's an app for it. Yeah, probably.
41:33 But yeah, So I would say yes, managing screen time and then delaying the time before kids get social media and really having the conversation with your teens. Why, why do you want it? Like why, why do you want the social media? What do you think you're going to get out of it? How are we going to use it as a family? And I think one of the major things is having a family technology philosophy and A and a family plan. Like we, we've got to have a conversation in our families where we go, what are these things for and how are we going to use them? And what effect is that going to have on us? And having those conversations, especially when the kids get to have input, you know, parents make the decisions.
42:14 But when kids are at the table, especially as they're getting older, preteens and teenagers, they, they need to feel a sense of ownership in some decisions that are being made Now, sometimes another idea is that sometimes you just have to tell them, I know more than you and I love you. And so I'm going to make the right decision in this situation, whether or not you understand it, because I know more than you and I love you. But as often as possible when we can give preteens and teens ownership, and really, I mean, it probably goes even further down into adolescence when we can give them ownership in some of the family decisions. At least let them have their voice heard. Like what it what is your thought on this? How are your friends using this? What are you noticing that gives them some buy in? And so it's not too late, whether you're just raising kids now that it's going to be years before they get into cell phones or whether you have teenagers that have already kind of dived into this situation.
43:09 It it is never too late to to step back and have the conversation is, is this good for us? What are we seeing here? And I think it's fair to say as well that not all social media is the same. Karis, we allowed her to have the real and good reads. Those are two social media platforms. I don't think they have. Surely they have some of the addictive cycle built in because they want, but I don't think from my understanding of this, not quite as strong as like an Instagram or a Facebook. And then there's some social things that we just, I feel like the from the ground up are designed poorly. I don't even know the one that's like makes messages disappear that we just don't Snapchat.
43:56 We just don't, Yeah, like we just, that's just not ever going to be allowed at the my house. That's right. Yeah. With good, I haven't ever had a hard time just exiting good reads. You know what I mean? It is it's cool. It's great to see updates from my favorite authors. But so family technology philosophy, like talking about it as a family, having a plan for how and where and I would even say where like so in my family, I, I shared that my kids are, are 10/8 and five and we don't really do screens during the week. We do have some screen time on weekends and again, us a feature of just our family schedule and how things work for us. But my kids know that they're not allowed to have a tablet in a room by themselves, right.
44:46 So they're not allowed in bedrooms even even at the ages of 1085. They are aware that these are common area devices. And so we don't we don't go off by ourselves with these devices. So just having those sort of standards in the household is really helpful and helps to move them in the right direction of thinking, how should I be using this thing? There's also that put off put on. So if you are in a situation where you already have teens or preteens and they have already kind of been in social media and now you're going, we got to pull this thing back. Be prepared to provide some alternatives because there's going to be there's going to be a gap there. It's not going to be a fun conversation. Nobody's going to enjoy each other's company for a little while.
45:27 Especially I've heard 21 days is like key to reset your dopamine cycle, so you may have to really be present for those first three weeks while you're retraining your kids minds and maybe even your mind to do some alternate alternate things. It's going to be some family board game time. It's going to be walks around the neighborhood like we're going to find we're going to if you really want to do this, you're going to find ways to fill the space that was taken up by just that kind of social media scrolling. But you, you do, if you're going to take something away, you've got to put something in that spot. And and boredom can be one of those things. Boredom is good for kids. It is one of the the times that our brains fire most uniquely and, and well, and, and build important connections when we're bored and have to kind of figure out what to do. Yeah, that's those would be some things also modeling behaviors, making sure that we are showing our kids what it looks like to live.
46:25 Get off your phone. Yeah, that that, that's what I was going to say, 'cause I think, you know, what are some practical ways? I mean, I guess there's easy ways, just don't get on it. But but it's different than something I feel like my solution is just don't get on social media very much or like take the app off. If I have to get on, I'll go through the browser. Like just make it like a little bit harder. But part of me is like, maybe that's a bad way to look at it where, you know, 10 years ago you could say, hey, I'm fighting pornography. I'm getting rid of my computer. Can't really do that today because it's so ubiquitous. So like, how are you going to actually have a strategy and filters and things are good, but what are you doing outside of that to help point you in the right direction?
47:05 And, you know, I don't know, but these are things I've been thinking about because, you know, it's to me, it's easy to be OK. I just don't have any of these. But I don't know if that's a, it's almost like thinking of Romans 14. It's like maybe I'm the weaker brother here. And I don't, I think alcohol, drinking alcohol is a sin. So I'm just totally cutting off and, you know, I don't know. So there, yeah. And there is there can be a danger to doing this sort of monastery move where you just pull way back from something because the reality is our kids are going to be without us in this culture at some point. So we got to do some heart. Yes, and that's, and that I think a lot of it comes down to that. And so there's, you know, there's family devotions, there's time around the dinner table. That's that's precious time.
47:47 And we don't get that much of it. Like we look at how long we have with these kids. I'm looking at pictures of your kids right now and Michael's got one that is in college and one getting ready to go, right? And one in kindergarten. So just, it's just, we just recognize the time is limited. And so the, the job of the parent is, is to do that heart training so that when we when we kind of release them, they've had exposure to things that they need to have exposure to. We've worked in their hearts. God, we've, I say, we've worked in their hearts. We don't actually get to do the work right. We are praying for them and then doing our job and the Holy Spirit is going to enter into that situation and do the work of molding hearts and changing affections and bringing them into the mind of Christ. But we, we just, we have the biggest role to play aside from the Holy Spirit.
48:45 The parents are the ones who had that biggest role to play and we can't, we can't sleep on that. It'd be interesting too. I've been thinking about, I mean, you know, going through things like Facebook and this kind of thing and just be like, who do I follow? Like what is it putting in front of my face? What am I idolizing just by what I picked to idolize? Because there's probably certain things I can just like take off because these people are just always pointing to certain things. You know what I mean? I don't know, think think could just like it's one of those things where I think Facebook just makes you or any social media just makes you think about put your focus on yourself so much and what other people think. And it's like maybe a little bit of that's OK, but I don't know. I'm always trying to grapple with how much is is good to do versus like, man, maybe I just need to not focus on myself so much.
49:32 Yeah, well, we want to keep grappling. I mean, that's, that's, that's the move is to keep grappling. So what I'm going to do is you've taught two classes. Those are on determined Audio. I'm going to link them in the description this Sunday. So this podcast will hit before this happens. We're going to have a panel discussion and so I will, if I can remember, I'll go back and add that later to to this. So maybe you can check back in and and find that there as well. Any any like big major things we didn't cover or anything that you want to add? There's just, I mean, there are resources out there for for parents that are interested in this topic and want to move.
50:13 You have a list of resources and maybe I could get a copy of those and link those in the description as well it. Will be good. I have a quick question. I don't know in in your research or this guy's book, and I know it's all different probably based on your feed and your tendencies and these kind of things. But was there a correlation between, man, you spend more than five hours a week, it's bad news or that's where you see a huge uptick or is it doesn't really matter? One of the stats that sticks out in my mind just as a mind blower is that 3 plus hours of social media a day for adolescents double S the risk of mental illness. So, you know, major depressive episodes, anxiety, suicidal ideation, these things, the, the risk of those is doubled for three plus hours a day. And your average adolescent, the statistics vary, but it's, it's 5 plus hours a day for your preteens and, and tweens and, and up to maybe 7 to 8 hours a day for teenagers. But the, the data also shows that teenagers that are, that are given that like 7 to 8 hours a day when it, when the question is asked a different way, they go. I'm basically just continuously online, like I'm continuously online as whenever I can be, I am. And so that that number is alarming. But there are resources, like I said, access.org, the Coulson Center has great videos.
51:42 The Anxious Generation is a good book if you just want to make sure you read with discernment, knowing the the ideas of the author. Yeah, there's a lot of good stuff out there. All right, Jonathan, thank you for being here. Thank you for doing all this research. I know this is like people ask me some stuff to teach them. Like how long did you study for? Like it's like my whole life. It's like, so I'm sure that some of this stuff you've been, you've been kind of, it's not just like a single thing that it's like you, you delve into it, you study it because that's kind of what you're about leading and and helping shape kids lives. So I appreciate. That and next time about that green screen Oh yeah we'll. Put, we'll figure. We'll figure something out and we'll put. We'll put some if you want it to be.
52:25 Weather Top. Back end weather top. Weather top. OK, we'll do Weather top. All right, So I think our guest has to. Has to close it out as well. Do you remember the words? I feel like. Just say what you thinking is that. Oh, that would be good. From that from now on, the guest just ended how you think it should go. All right, that's our take. Nailed it. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed