Joy to the World: The Christmas Song That Isn’t
Episode 2.65
Every December, churches sing Joy to the World as if it were written for the manger. But historically—and theologically—that’s not quite true. In this episode, Michael and Zach explore the surprising origins of one of the most beloved Christmas hymns and ask a simple question: What is this song actually about?
Written by Isaac Watts and drawn primarily from Psalm 98, Joy to the World is not a nativity hymn but a declaration of kingship. It celebrates the Lord coming to reign, judge the world with righteousness, and restore creation—not the quiet birth of a child in Bethlehem. There are no shepherds, angels, or manger scenes here. Instead, the imagery is cosmic: seas roaring, fields rejoicing, nations witnessing salvation, and creation responding to the arrival of its King.
That doesn’t make Joy to the World unfit for Christmas—it makes it richer. Christmas marks the arrival of the King whose reign Psalm 98 anticipates. Advent looks not only backward to Christ’s first coming but forward to His return. The hymn pulls Christmas out of sentimentality and anchors it in hope: sin and sorrow will not reign forever, because Christ does.
In a season often focused on comfort and nostalgia, Joy to the World reminds believers that Christmas is not just about a baby—it’s about a throne. We sing it not because the world is already joyful, but because its King has come…and He’s coming again.
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/lLg-V2hi8kA
Merch here: https://take-2-podcast.printify.me/
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at http://www.take2theology.com
0:00 It happened. It happened again. Well, it happened in a bigger way. This is I've got 4 kids. 4. And they're all at Northwood, some in daycare, some. Yeah, go ahead. Yeah. So I was in the car line today, Yeah, and I thought I saw Jordy sprinting across the from the preschool across to get in the car. Is that a thing? Maybe. Does he do that? Do you have to stop at the preschool or do they do they let you get all your except for Josh? Well, yen a lot of times walks to the preschool get the kids, but they might run ahead of her or something to like her classroom or something.
0:42 OK, well, maybe it maybe I thought I saw. Did you pick up your kids today? I. Did not, no. I did not. All right, all right. I almost never. I just must be mistaken. Caroline stressed me out, man. It it is like it's like this snake that winds in on itself. And it's crazy. People are like motioning to you. It seems hyper efficient in a good way, but it's like if you're not used to the machine, you're like, oh, that's. Why? I think like if Jill's parents were to like they're like, hey, we'll go get him. Like it is not the car line from three years ago. It has. It's gotten this is. Not your mother's car line. You weren't probably going to talk about car line. No, I wasn't. I was going to talk about, well, Northwood has a don't talk about Santa rule deal.
1:23 At school. At school. At school, yeah. Don't talk about Santa at. School rule. I can see where this is going. Last year. Yeah, so we're going to talk about Santa. We're going to talk about Santa. Oh yeah, that's right. If your kids for some reason believe in Santa, we're going to tell them the truth. So turn this podcast off. A warning. But last year, Jayden, he's like more mild mannered. He said something his teacher was like, hey, you know kids are talking about Santa Jane was just like not real whatever like they brought it up first whatever. A little bit in the pre-K they talk about Saint Amore. I think the rules are different, like lower school versus like daycare where like the they talk about Santa like the teachers maybe don't encourage it, but like, oh, what's Santa bring in?
2:08 Like we'll do that kind of thing. It's like different. It's not the school. It's it's such, it's such a worst question to ask a kid. What is Santa bringing? Why not just say, what are you wanting for Christmas? There you go. And then it's agnostic. It's that's right. That's exactly right. Jordan. He was a little bit more bombastic and just like, dropped the bomb. Santa's not real. Apparently him and another kid named Clayton were at opposite ends of this. And I and. And so teacher, like, reached out like Kotland was like, hey, you know, just so, you know, like, it was kind of, she was like, not mad. She was kind of funny, but whatever. We asked Jordan about it and we were like, oh, yeah. So how did it end up? He was like, I'm the only one that said Santa wasn't real. I was like, what did your teacher say? She said Santa was real. So it's kind of funny.
2:52 You know, he was on the island, you know, out there fighting. No, you heard my story growing up, right? Through 5th. Grade. 5th grade that is so. Old, that is, that's like is Emerson 6th grade. So it's like just shy. It's it's like, what were y'all doing Mom dad? A lot of people. Are happy PTSD. Experiences. I found out I think in second grade, my Sunday school teacher said something or something like that. My parents were like upset at it, but I was like it. It blew my mind. I was talking to people at our work Christmas party 'cause it came up like, Hey, you tell, do you tell your kids about Santa? Like no theological basis. But several people are like, oh, we don't do that because it, it messed me up or like, like, like just from a trust perspective, Like trust, no other basis. But it was like a thing.
3:41 I was like wow. Yeah, because I wondered about Santa's relationship to God. Like, how do they relate? Do they? They must work together, you know what I'm saying? And I had some. I had like I remember in 3rd grade I had this ink pad and without warning right before I went to bed, I was like, all right, Santa, if you're real, you know, leave like a hoof print or something of, of the reindeer. And my sisters faked it. They. Did and. It looked real and I was like, this is the proof that was. It that's all I did this is the. Proof. So it was crazy. I saw some, I saw some presents wrapped from Santa like two or three days before Christmas and I was like, so it's not real.
4:28 Yeah, that was the. Yeah, and I'm like. And why? Well, yeah. What? Mom, my mom's like, well, I always kind of thought you probably did know. I'm like y'all bent over backwards to deceive. Man. Yeah. And ultimately that is what it is. It's a deception. Deception. I should say this, Michael. What do? What do you gain from it though? Really I. Know you lose. Credit too if you have good kids. Yes, and you're not rich. What are you telling them as to why they didn't get something they asked for? Dude, yeah. Why did Santa like Santa's playing favorites? I will say you are in a way deceiving our viewers because you are. You're like you're doing the you got. I'm gonna say you, you run me with a mullet because you're business on top.
5:12 But Christmas, Christmas pants going on. He's got. The he's got the polo on, but he's got the holiday. Yeah, there you go. So it's funny, you know, 'cause it's like brown polo. Yeah. Yeah, Christmas. Pants. Well, I was wearing my dress pants and I was like, you know, I'm gonna be sitting in this position when we record someone row and it's just not necessarily the most comfortable position, so. Pod podcasting is not. Easy. No, it's you need to dress. Dressed in athletic gear for podcasts because it's that demanding. That's right. That's right. But Chris, we're we're going to do a Christmas episode about a a hymn. One of my favorite Christmas hymns. Man, right.
5:52 Yeah, yeah, man. It's yeah, yeah. I see what you did there. I mean, wow, I I, I should have pulled up a ranking. Like what do you think the top like 5 hymns are like? I don't, I don't. Where do you think this one we're talking about today? I would think a top ten like it would come in. I don't know for. Sure, especially if you're talking about religious. Songs. Yeah, yeah. That's what, yeah. Exactly. If you're talking about religious Christmas songs, definitely maybe the top. I would probably say probably. Most people say this is top 1-2 or three. Maybe a holy night? A holy night that's like a go. Silent Night, Yeah. Joy to the world. Hark the Herald. Probably in the top 4. Maybe a What child is this?
6:34 Maybe. Mary, did you know? Mary, did you know, I saw this video and this guy, this woman was, I don't know if it's her husband or what, but she was like reading through all the questions and then he was answering them. Like, yes, she knew that. No, she wouldn't have known that. Maybe she knew that like she was. He was just going down. I thought it was pretty funny. That's good. Mary did you know just swept the world by storm. It was like contemporary and OK for for very conservative churches. It was like it like checked all the boxes where it was like in this, you know when when did do you know when this song came out? 15 years ago maybe. I I I'm curious, I want to say it's older than that, but I. Maybe it is. Let's see, because I remember I never know 'cause my. Church.
7:19 I would. I think that's a good guess. Year it came out. Let's see, 'cause I know my church, I always envisioned my fundamental independent Baptist Church always being like 50 years in the past. So it seemed really new to us at the time. It was like a 1991. Oh my goodness, 91. With lyric, the lyrics were written in 1984, song developed. 1991 was when it was first recorded and you know, I don't know if maybe it maybe it, it took on popularity a little later. I don't know, like if it took a while to come through, but yeah. It I wouldn't have put it at the early 90s at all. Man, we're just dropping knowledge on you, maybe dropping a little more knowledge when we talk about joy to the world, the Christmas song, the.
8:01 The Christmas song, Yeah. So let's let's talk more about that. Let's take it to the next level. Let's fire up that twanga music. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. Joy to the world, like, like we were saying, classic hymn. I love that hymn. It just has like the tune to it, you know? It's like joy to the world. You know, it's easy because it just goes right down that major scale. So you know, if you, if you're familiar with music, it just starts at the top and just works down the major scale. So it's it's nice.
8:42 And you have to think it's author Isaac Watts. Just you get to see him by the Yuletide fire. He's just sipping hot cocoa. It's Christmas time, and he's writing this specifically for Christmas, you know. Yeah. Is this the same Isaac Watts that that did science stuff? Well, this Isaac Watts, I don't know. He's called the father of English. English. I don't know if this is the same Isaac watch or not he. Maybe it's a different watts you. Know this guy was born in 1674 lived to 1748, but we just did a hasn't aired yet did a podcast on worship. I did a deep dive on Isaac Watts because he really changed the game. He brought the church, a lot of the church, out of exclusive psalmody and into this hymn era, which was pushing boundaries at the time, you know, writing these hymns. James Watt.
9:37 Was the scientist. James maybe they were, you know, family reunions, they caught up or something. I don't know. But what I want to land on is Joy to the World actually a Christmas hymn or something else? Maybe. Let's dive into the history. Isaac Watts, it's. Probably a premillennial hymn. It actually assumes a very specific eschatology is great. I love it written, you know, around 300 years ago, you know, late 1600s, early 1700s. And this guy, Isaac Watts pushing the boundaries. He was not he wasn't super against just singing the Psalms, but he actually struggled that in the Psalms.
10:18 He would like them to be more Christ centered. Like maybe it he would say implicitly talk a lot. About every scripture type of thing, yes. And he was saying it's implicit, but it's not explicit. He would actually rewrite hymns and where it was maybe a little vague, he would like change it for Christ like he would like. That's how he kind of started writing some of these hymns. Oh, so he took existing hymns? And built off of them or psalms took psalms and built and tried to bring Christ into him. He thought some of the psalms for music were a little too literal. Tried to put some like imagery on it for for singing. And so his goal was to take Psalms and he would say wanted to write it in the language of the New Testament by importing Christ more clearly.
10:59 I think all of us would say, yeah, it's talking about Christ, but maybe it doesn't say Jesus Christ. And you know every Psalm, right? And so with that being said, he based this joy to the world on Psalm 98. He actually had a collection of hymns called the Psalms of David imitated in the language of the New Testament. What a name of a of like a collection of hymns. So maybe we can look at Psalm 98, see what it says. Maybe we can be looking for those parallels Maybe. We can only only if it's a chiasm. If it's a chiasm, shut this down. Yeah, go ahead. Go ahead and read. And I don't know if we need to do this, Michael. We might. I don't know if you want to also, you know, if people don't know joy to the world like we can, like most people probably know it.
11:42 You know, I don't know if it's worth like saying like the first verse or something. I don't know. Joy to the world. The Lord has come. Let Earth receive her king, let every heart prepare him room, and heaven and nature sing. I forget the next. Part and heaven and nature sing. And heaven and nature sing yes. Next one start, verse 2 starts out joy to the earth. The Savior reigns. Savior reigns. Our mortal songs employ while fields and floods, rocks, hills and plains. Repeat the sounding joy. Yeah. Repeat the sounding. Yeah. It's great. Third verse No more. Let sins and sorrows grow north, thorns infest the ground. He comes to make his blessings flow far as the curse is found. A lot of people I think we skip.
12:25 It's like a hymn thing. You skip verse. Three, you don't want verse 3 it. Was like first, second and last. We used to always be like first, second and last, you know? You know, and then bring us home with the final verse. Yeah, yeah, he rules the world with truth and grace. Let men their songs employ. This one. Is. Read it to me and makes the. Nations prove, yeah, the glories of his love, righteousness, righteousness. But and wonders of his. Love and wonders of his love there. We go so, so that's we're familiar with this. Let's see, you know how old? I'm curious how well it matches up with Psalm 90. Eight. Yeah, yeah. So you want me to read Psalm 98? I sent our notes, do you want me to read it from from your notes? If it depends, you want NASB or ESBI, don't know. I don't know which version I did the notes in all right. So I'll just read it from the notes. It says, O sing to the Lord a new song. For He has done wonderful things. His right hand and his holy arm have gained the victory for him. The Lord has made known his salvation, and he or his salvation, He has revealed his righteousness in the sight of the nations.
13:29 He has remembered his loving kindness and his faithfulness to the House of Israel. All the ends of the earth have seen the salvation of our God. Shout joyfully to the Lord. All the earth break forth and sing for joy and sing praises. Sing praises to the Lord with a liar, with a liar and the sound of melody with trumpets. In the sound of the horn. Shout joyfully before the king. The Lord. Let the sea roar, and all it contains the world and those who dwell in it. Let the rivers clap their hands. Let the mountain sing together for joy before the Lord, for He is coming to judge the earth. He will judge the world with righteousness and the peoples with equity. And you know, I was thinking, I bet it would have been better to read it in the good old King. I bet I bet it would have more overlaps, like more specifically just based on the time.
14:14 But you can even in reading it, you can like see like nature, you see all the themes kind of you're like, oh, I can see what he was doing. He's trying to stay very close to the Psalms, but make it like you're not singing the Psalm, you're singing a song. And it's very close. It's not like he's departed. But you can see how that might be a little bit easier to sing than iambic Pentanner going through where it's like, you know, but also very edgy in his day. But you see, you know the Lord coming to judge the earth, the righteousness, the equity, and then jumps off the page. All creation rejoices. Where are the wise men here in this or the shepherds? Yeah, Where's the. Yeah, Where is this?
14:55 Where's the Motel 6? He's missing a He's missing a lot of the beats, you know, for a Christmas song. Got the seas roaring, the field singing, the hills rejoicing. If we wanted to, we could go and make the connection, but I think we can really see. But like you said, no. No, no, there's no major scene. It's not even like, you know, Isaiah and the suffering Servant, You know, people who are our, you know, stripes, my, my stripes who are healed or all of us like sheep have gone astray. Every man's turned in his own way and our iniquity's been laid upon him. It's not even that type of imagery. It is, it is pretty crazy 'cause it's it's so to me, Joy to the World is like boom Christmas, no questions asked. But it doesn't hit and it's not, there's not a lot of, you know, I think joy to the joy to the world, the Lord has come and you're like, OK, I can see that being Christmassy, but you keep on going through and it's like more of a rain and judging and equity and not as much.
15:54 So what? What I hear is this not even really an Easter song either. Right, right. This is a this is a resurrection, second coming of the Lord song. So we should like, pair this with, you know, Hymn of Heaven from Phil Wickham. Yeah, there you go. Yeah. We should have a Sunday that is all about the premillennial reign of Christ, and then we should sing the song Hey. How how fitting because it is focused on things like Christ reign, Christ judging and and the renewal of creation. Like all of these things like these beats are just like that's why we're making a joyful noise to the Lord. Like you said, we're not in Bethlehem. No shepherds, no angels. The incarnation narrative isn't laid out. But at the same time, at Christmas, it's OK to celebrate the arrival of the game.
16:37 Like no. And so just like everything else, I feel like a good answer in Christianity is to say already and not yet. That's like, that's like a good place to. Be it? Is it? Is now it's it's very fitting where, you know, we get the hints in the first coming of the second coming. And this is kind of where where we we sit, where joy of the world isn't necessarily about Christ being born, but it's about Christ taking his throne, judging, reigning and all creation becoming new. So is it OK? Are we just like can take it out of the rotation or it's close enough We can, we can keep it in there? Yeah, I mean, you don't get Christ's second coming if you don't get this first coming.
17:22 That that's that's. Very true. You can't. Just so you know, he the first sets up the 2nd and you know, the 1st is what we're celebrating at Christmas. But I think I have mentioned from while we sing it, you know, yeah, this is not really a Christmas song. This is more of a Christ return song. I like that you get like the big picture too, where, you know, Christmas, it's not just like I think sometimes you're like, oh man, we're singing away in the Manger and these things. It's like truth, but it it's like sentimental where this is more like cosmic and scope where kind. Of connects with the song that I ended with for House the Holidays, which you you can tell us all about since you were there.
18:05 I was right there in the back. I was I was with your kids at the at your other kids recital. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Tell us what? What was the song you? Posted it's called In the First Light. The lyrics are basically like in the first light of the new day. No one knew he had arrived. And then it goes on to say, you know, heaven knew what happened. Mary wondered about it. He would tell them of his Kingdom, but their hearts wouldn't believe. They would hate him, and they'd kneel into a tree. And then there's this big crescendo of kind of like the death scene, but then it's like, but the sadness is broken because the song of the new day is going to arise, and the first born of creation will send and take his throne. And then it keeps on going, you know, You know, And then at the very end of the song, it makes this comparison between, you know, how great it would be to hear the Angel singing his birth, but how much greater when he come to these pictures? This is.
19:04 I love this, Yeah. Yeah, I do not like if you knew this podcast, not a big Lord of the Rings fan, not a not a big like fiction person. And really I feel 'cause I feel like the Bible's good enough for me. Michael No, I'm just kidding. But I feel like for someone who doesn't like these things, I I love these pictures. See the Bible that it's like you see like this foreshadowing. It's like all this stuff is like, so cool. You're almost there 'cause great fiction, it trades off of the real themes of history and you're like, I just need the real themes, history. Yeah, I know, I know. It's like and I'm not like super. I'm not anti fiction. I just have a hard time with I have a hard time with like elves.
19:45 This is this is the thing like point of ears like like I'm not good at like the alternate. Don't say it like that. I I hate other races. Well. Other races in the real meaning of the word races, because yeah, how we use race is not really. A it's, it's like goblins or I don't, I don't know what it is. It's something about that where? You're you can't suspend disbelief. Yeah, it's too weird for me where it's like I need, I need to like, it's hard for me to like get invested. Have we talked about the book that Frank Turek and Sean McDowell Co wrote? And it basically compared these great fantasy novels of Narnia, Harry Potter, Dang Lord of the Rings, maybe a couple other ones, maybe even some of the DC Comics and stuff. And they just showed the typographies like you cannot, like you can the best stories ever told. They have to trade on these themes from reality, you know? You know, the sacrifice for other people type of thing, the glorious return, You know, all those, those tropes. And those are always good.
20:55 Like I I when I watched Super her movie when I was younger, it's like you love all those things, so maybe I'm coming around to, but I'm like, man, I why do I need the trope? When I'm in the millennial reign, you'll you'll you'll start reading some Pansy. Get in the movie theater, it's like, and also, and where I have even a harder problem is like, I'm such I'm such a spoiled brat, but it's like into the Louvre. It's fine. Like it's great. It's fine. It was fine. I was like, it was good. But it's like the Mona Lisa. I'm just like a lot of people gather around this tiny picture. I don't get it. Like I can see that from my computer. Screen. Yeah, it's it's it's the I I have no appreciate like I'm not an artist. I wish I was. You think I would?
21:36 Respect the camera and tell Chloe. See, Chloe should tell me because you think I would respect it more because I'm so poor at it. Like I do respect it. Like, oh, that's amazing. We don't do that. But I'm like, I don't know. I don't, I don't, I don't get, and this is a different story. This is what I've heard. I don't know if this is true, though. The Mona Lisa is only really popular because it was stolen at one time from the Louvre. It helped like give it some notoriety. And then it got even more popular. I don't know, conspiracy, but joy to the world bringing it back, connecting. I like this. I like these connections, like talk about a baby and a Manger, but talk about a king, like, you know, we should be thinking about these things. Not not mutually exclusive, you know, So joy to the world, I think think a good song as we're focusing on incarnation. But you know, with our eye, we we know what has happened and what will happen.
22:26 Yeah, yeah, that's good. Yeah. And I think it helps you, you know, just connect those things, 'cause when you sing it at Christmas and you come across those words, I remember, well, I remember coming across those words as youngsters going, oh, what's going on here? But maybe it can help you think just beyond Christmas itself, You know, if you're paying attention to what you're saying. That that's true. Yeah, that's true. That's very, very good point. And you know, Joy World's great at just the repeat thing where you at least catch the, you know, you got to you got to think about the words a little. Especially if you're singing parts, because if you're singing the bass or tenor part I think it even repeats more. Yeah, there you go. Repeat the sound.
23:07 This is great. So some reflection questions. Do you think of Jesus more as a as a baby than a king at Christmas in particular? I think maybe some people that's like the default. I think a lot of places, churches, they do a good job of providing some commentary, you know, giving the framing it, you know, in the. Larger context Jesus more as a this is going to sound bad. Can I use this word, stodgy rabbi, like a really tough rabbi. That would be like, why don't you know this? Why? Why is your face so small? Like, like, you know, like he's tough sometimes on his apostles. Yeah. You know, it's, it's true. People don't. I love tough in general when we're, you know, cleansing the temple. Not only is he like pulling out the whip, but he's like fashioning the whip.
23:56 Like he's got to make the whip. It's like he's got to be premeditated. Like like it's like this is such a big deal that I'm going to make a whip right in front of everyone and do this. That's like crazy. It is crazy. So yeah, Greg Koval recently has talked about praying. He's like, I find my heart drawn more to the Father 'cause I pray to him than I do actually to Jesus, 'cause I don't normally pray to Jesus as much. And so I feel like I have an intimacy with the Father that I don't necessarily have with the person Jesus. Like, and we know that ontologically, you know, the Trinity's one being and stuff like that. But yeah, it's just odd how you you have these mental I. Think that's very true, yeah. Where it's just like functionally you just gravitate because you do.
24:39 It's it that does have to frame how you think of every single prayer is like heavenly Father and like that's just like, you know, all associated with that. Right, right. Great, so next time you sing Joy to the world, you know, keep keep this in mind that the king has come, but he is also coming again. Also, it's one of these hymns that a lot of hymns don't lean into the whole judgement theme. You know, this does it in a good way. You know what I mean? Like it talks about him judging. It's strong, doesn't. Make the nations prove the glories of his righteousness. Right That was. Yeah, that's. Right. That's right, yeah, where you just don't. Some of that I think can be lost a little bit in culture and it's a little bit I think that is a pro of pulling stuff from the Psalms a little bit. You get well-rounded.
25:30 I would have loved for like Chris Tomlin. That'd be great. Just have like the like side be imprecatory Psalms like whatever and just like just like all of. Them that way. But it is good, good, good bounce. And reading this, I was like, man, I know, I know a little bit about Isaac Watch, but I was like, I wanna get I wanna read more about this. And I didn't realize he was such an innovator. I knew he wrote a lot of Psalms, but I didn't know he was like changing the game, doing some research. This will be like in the future, but Martin Luther versus Calvin. If you can imagine very different views on singing, where you can guess which side did Martin Luther take, He wrote. Yeah, I would think he'd be like, let's sing. Yep, that's right. Mighty Fortress is our God versus, you know, Calvin's like get it out of here. But this is good.
26:13 I'm excited to to talk more about this, but anything else you want to talk about specifically on Joy to the World? No, I think, I think this has been good. And it's good to just, you know, remind ourselves because honestly, you can sing really any song anytime if it's about Christ. And so, yeah, but, you know, be thinking about, you know, the fullness of Christ's and his mission during this time, not just, you know, him being the baby. Totally joy to the world. Think about it. That's all I have. That's all Michael has. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed