The Synoptic Gospel Problem – Markan Priority
Episode 127
In Part 2 of our series on the Synoptic Problem, Zach presents the case for Markan priority—the view that Mark was the first Gospel written. We explore the literary, linguistic, and structural reasons many scholars believe Matthew and Luke used Mark as a source. The discussion also dives into the proposed existence of “Q,” a hypothetical sayings source that may explain the shared material between Matthew and Luke not found in Mark. How do these theories shape our understanding of the Gospel narratives—and why does it matter? Join us as we examine this influential view and continue our journey through the origins of the Gospels.
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/G1bOibH5qe4
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/
0:00 So we had some desserts tonight at home. Groups, fellowship groups. You weren't there though. Call. I wasn't. I wasn't there. I was absentee. But I think they were all, you know, fully baked. They were good, though. None of them were like doughy or anything on the inside. I. Love this because we've talked about it before Half Baked ideas. I got this idea from another podcast and I, I love it because they're, they're ideas that are like, there's something there, maybe not a lot. It's like you take a bite. Jill said today that ideas are easy. That this, this is a great proof ideas. It's going to start sounding good and then you're going to hit a wall and say we would this would be the dumbest thing ever to do. And one of these I was going to pitch to you, Michael.
0:42 I I was talking a little before 'cause I was like, did I did I say this? But we should have church fantasy teams like fantasy football. We should have ACVC fantasy league where you can draft, I don't know, 5 people and there's different stats. I mean, he can't pick Pastor Joel. He's off the table, right? Too much, too many, too many, you know, too many stuff. But if someone prays, you know we got. You know, like in fantasy football, you know, you can get a quarterback. Yeah, yeah, you can get so many running backs. So maybe you could have like you can get one elder. One Deacon. One Deacon. You can. How about this, you can pick instead of like special teams or a defense, you pick a song. Death was arrested. That's my song.
1:22 I think it's played. I get like bonus points. Right, and you can switch it up like each week like you get into Easter. You're like I'm betting up from the grave heroes. It's going to hit sometime. You know it's it's. It's got to happen. Maybe it's like everyone's got to have a, you know, 25 and under person on their team. You know, there's like different you got to have a lady at least you know, on you have to you round it out. You build your team different positions. Can you have multiple Hawks on your team? If you're Hawk, hawk boys are very limited because you know, they're doing offering that's like at least a few points. But what you don't, what you have to take in consideration is that if someone's daughter like dumps the offering put over, you'll lose five points.
2:04 Like if Phoebe does that or you know, hey, if Pastor slides aren't on time and you pick Clay and he was on the Sal or I don't know. If he ever I know. He just do slides or whatever, but it's like you lost points. That's like an interception, you know? So there's like the positives and the negatives. You know. So I don't know. So that's probably not great to like be hypercritical of people, be like, Clayton, why couldn't your prayer have been 10 seconds longer? Like, you know, that's probably not great, but there's something there. Yeah, I think that I mean that is an idea probably probably needs a little more more formulation any any more of those half baked ideas, you know another. Half baked idea this actually, I will give credit record as to I think Caleb Hock floated this out here.
2:44 But and I don't think this this. I think some churches do something like this, but church newspaper newsletter from the church. But I would like it to have like, you know, it's got like op eds you got you got like the front like front page news would be like pastor shade his goatee. He's just doing a mustache. Like the real big news. Like, Oh my. Goodness, the important things like or maybe critiques of dishes that showed up at potluck or something. I. Love it. I love it. Like, Can you believe Martha brought that, you know, brought up the potluck? Did anyone else get sick and if you did, what did you eat at the potluck? I'm trying to think what else would be like front page news. Like maybe you could share a recipe that wasn't supposed to be shared? Oh, there you go.
3:27 Maybe even, you know, some some feedback. Like, you know, how many times do we have to sing? I don't know. But you know, like, like we've seen this eight times. I don't know. There's a. Lot of we're missing person. Have you seen this person in three weeks? We haven't seen it. Yeah. Where? Where'd they go? There there's a lot we we we could do. So I feel like there's something there with the church newsletter I wrote down. I don't know where this goes. Church Olympics like you're training like who everyone wants to run A4440 or less. How fast can you walk with walk with offering click down the aisle. We need offering in a in a jiffy. Or not dissed any aisle the side aisles where it's like you got. You have to like suck in and like walk sideways.
4:09 If you're a normal person, if you're a normal person, it's trouble getting down that aisle. If you are a six foot 4, you know, I'll just say £300 offensive lineman. You're struggling getting down that that aisle you're saying. How about this for like another obstacle course is say Pastor's Mike isn't working, but he just said children church is dismissing you got to like dodge the kids. So like as they're going out in the back and you got to get up there and you're you're on the clock because you got to get the mic working. I don't know there there's a lot of a lot of ways that can go. I I wrote down to or I was thinking about this, like there, there's some, there's something in there with like working out and MacArthur study Bibles because those are like heavy versus like, you know, if you got, if you're like those are like the £45 plates, like if you're like working on some Jill Osteen stuff, it's like the 2 1/2 LB. I don't know, that's, that's like not even a quarterback. There's just in my mind that like, you know, yeah, there's something there with the, with the Olympics. But you know, I've been trying to think of some of these more half baked ideas.
5:07 So I'll have to go back to the drawing board, go back to the oven. You. Know and and throw some things in there. Yeah, we need an oven that works. We're still hashtagged ovenless. Man, are you guys like air frying it up? You know, like what? What's the salute like? What's the? Yeah, we do have an air fryer. Our stove works. And that's true. We got a grill, it's just the actual oven doesn't work. It stopped working right before Christmas and we're in Easter now. But I, it's not like I've been doing nothing and I'm just trying to avoid paying, you know, 7 or $800 if I can get our oven working. So right now, our last hope, it's like Obi Wan, you're our only hope is Caleb Hawk. So I bought hands. Yeah. So I know that. I know exactly. The problem is that there is a relay out on our Control Board.
5:52 I bought a new Control Board. It came in and it is exactly the same except for it's missing. Ours has like these two leads that come up and like there's a safety relay in there that and the two I org one, it doesn't have that. It's just missing. So like that's not going to work. I told the pit place, they sent me another board. Guess what? It's exactly the same as the first one. But those boards have the relay that isn't working. And so we just need to have Caitlin Ashton over some time. He's going to bring his soldering stuff. He's going to unsolder and re solder and if that works, good. If not we're just going to get a new oven. But. It's like make it make it happen. He he recently fixed, I think fixed some Honda Odyssey problems.
6:35 I was, I was having. So we we put this thing in. I don't. Know oh, you did put the thing. On there and it's not it's not like shaking anymore like like so I think that's good. I don't know if some of the damage is done or not, but it's like it it still does shake but not to the same like it just so it's like I think that's better. Yeah. So it's not as bad. It's still. I don't know if it fixes it, but. We fixed them. We had a Christmas tree and again the plug, the plug went wrong and so I bought a new plug and he resigned that for me. So, man, Caleb Hawk, fix it, Felix. Do it, fix it, Felix. I like that. Get Put that on a T-shirt. Get that to him. Maybe if we can't figure out this synoptic problem, we'll get Caleb Hawk in here to. See, you can solder that's true this. Together.
7:20 So we're we're in Part 2 of this not the problem. So let's go ahead and take it to the next level from the hearts of the low country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. Well, last time we, we gathered Michael put forth the Matthew first hypothesis made made a compelling case because and what I liked about your case is that, and I'm a church history guy, like I like, I'm not like I don't have the church history, but I, I don't think we throw it to the wind. I think that's sometimes, sometimes those of the Baptist persuasion can be like everything. Let's get these Catholics out of here because it's been so corrupt.
8:08 It's like we don't, we don't like church history almost at all sometimes. But I have an appreciation like I think things didn't happen for no reason, especially, you know, when it comes some of this. So, you know, some of this stuff makes some sense. Yeah, Speaking of Baptist, I grew up in the church and, and this was said from the pulpit, and this is what was taught, was that we were not Protestant because in order to be Protestant, it means you must have protested out of the Catholic Church. We were never part of the Catholic Church, just Baptist because, and I guess there were some. There's this book called Roarin that is based, it's historical fiction. It's like as historical as you can. And then they fill in some gaps.
8:51 It's really good. But it is about these people who stayed separate from the Catholic Church back in the day. But I saw this meme that had like, had these, like, different, you know, those different meme faces. Yeah. And it had like, Catholic and Ethernorthodox and you know, Yeah. And Protestants over here. And then it just had, and it had like, all these, they're like arguing. It's like, showed church history. And then it had this guy, like, the smirk on his face and said Baptist. And it had just like a straight line down to him. What's that? The troll blood or whatever, like straight from John the Baptist. Baby, that's right, I. Love it that that is like, that's the best. You just sidestep all that. Stuff. They didn't call him John the Baptist for no reason.
9:33 Checkmate. It's done so today. Or you want to talk about chess? I'm sorry, sorry. Keep going. Keep going. Today we'll make I'll I'll make the argument for Mark in priority versus Matthew priority that that Michael was was making. And so to recap briefly, this is not the problem is looking at these synoptic gospels, you know, that that are so similar, Matthew, Mark and Luke and trying to grapple with which came first, which one came last? You know, why are they the same? Why are they different? There's got to be some some reason for for this. And so as we get to Mark in priority in my notes, I have really until around the 1800s, most Christians believed Matthew was the first Gospel written. So that's some some creeds there where it's like over the course, not just of, you know, the first of thousand years, but it's like for a long time that was kind of a default. It is the first book listed got Matthew's first revelation listed.
10:30 The last. You kind of feel like there's Genesis as the first of the Old Testament is probably a reason it's the IT is the official position of Roman Catholic Church. And I wrote down, Oh yeah, evidence based on some 2nd century quotes by Papius as cited by Eusebius later on. Matthew also only apostle among the synoptic authors. And you were making the case kind of, you know, Mark got that Peter influence. So maybe you know, that's why it was bumped to #2. Yeah. And then some people would say that Luke has was commissioned by Paul. So they they give Paul and Peter the the links for Mark and Luke.
11:13 And so they they tie it to that Apostolic. Yeah. You can, you can tie all of these back to to some sort and but, but the thinking was, I guess it was coming from those Irenatus quotes. It wasn't that they were ranking Peter ahead of Paul. It was just they were just putting it in that order essentially. Well, if if what we think happened or what this book proposes happened was that Paul wasn't wanting to supplant Matthew's gospel and then Peter was teaching from both of them, then his teaching, which later became the gospel of Mark, would have gotten to the public ahead of Luke. So even though Luke was probably written first, it was maybe released, I say written second.
12:00 It was released 3rd. And so Mark gets put in second, even though it was a, you know, a reading of both of them. I see. I see. OK. Based on that theory. And I'll say most of the stuff I'm looking at is just I'm reading. I can't, I should try to find the book. It's a introduction of the New Testament book and. Is it he Bear? What is it The last name of the author Hebert. No, the last name of this of these authors are are you I can't I can't ever talk you about to make a pun or that's not the. Actual author No, no, I'm. I'm pretty. Sure. No. No, no, no, no. The one I'm talking about was Co written by DA Carson and Douglas Moo, who we've talked a little bit about with Roman's commentator. And so they kind of proposed this mark and priority. I think, you know, I don't think this is a pro to it, but I think some of that's a little bit trendier the last, you know, 50 years or so to kind of jump on that bandwagon. I think there's some good, good rationale from it. I'm, I'm, I'm just waiting in suspense as Michael there's finds.
13:05 This. Yeah, yeah, this is, this is what I had. This is the guy. I had. Yeah, Heibert, I guess. Heibert. Gotcha. Heibert. It's HIEBERTI thought that's yeah, so. Well, so this this is what this argument goes for. Mark in priority, if you're looking purely at word count, Matthew's 18,000 words, Luke's 19,000 words, Mark's only 11,000 words. And if you're looking at you, not that you follow the exact same rules, but textual criticism, sometimes you, you say the shorter, more difficult reading is original or comes first and people like add on to it. So, so that's some of the thinking in here like, OK, Mark is briefer. Maybe that's a foundation. 97 / 97% of Mark's words have a parallel in Matthew, and over 88 percents of Mark's words have a parallel in a Luke.
13:56 And so if you combine this with the brevity, you know, some of the proponents of this view would say that, you know, Matthew and Luke are actually borrowing from Mark and then they're kind of expanding on it. More likely. That's a more likely solution than Mark taking their material and saying, you know what, I'm just going to parse this down similar to what you're saying. John's filling in the gaps. Why would Mark say they got a lot of good stuff here? I'm just going to condense a lot kind of thing. But that's like, there's not a reason for that. There is reason. I mean, you can have a condensed copy, you know. So he also admits, omits, you know, birth narrative, serving on the mounts, you know, parents of the risen Christ. Those are like weird things they would say for Mark to be like, why aren't we talking about the birth or the sermon on the mounts or this appearance of the risen Christ? Like those things would be important if you were, you know, drawing from other things.
14:45 So if Matthew read Mark, it's easy to see there's a need for some more more of this info. If Mark read Matthew, it's less likely to see the need for That's how the reasoning kind of goes. And if you look at one of these charts that talk about where these gospels agree, Carson Moo have a good one that says that shows Matthew and Mark. They agree frequently. Mark and Luke agree frequently. Matthew and Luke agree but less often. And they would say that makes sense if Mark is the source used by both. It's almost like Luke, if you if you believe in Augustine's hypothesis with Matthew first, it's almost like Luke almost always chose Mark's wording rather than Matthew's with this two Gospel hypothesis.
15:31 Mark almost never introduced any wording of his own. If you believe Matthew was first with two gospel, which is all of this stuff is totally possible. It's just kind of like, where are you? What are you waiting? What's your, you know, presupposition going into it? So some things to keep in mind. Some of these arguments I think are stronger than others. Some other ones are, you know, the order of events similar to the verbal agreements where Matthew and Luke really don't agree against Mark like you were saying, Michael, some of this is like, how are you raised things topical, you know, not chronological. So I don't think that's a super strong argument. That's just something they they throw in there and I don't know where they're grading this, but they they would say that Mark has more of an awkward, more primitive style.
16:19 It's probably convenient to say it's a primitive style, but it's more grammatically irregular. It reads more awkwardly. It seems like Matthew and Luke are a little bit smoothed out. Same thing with that textual criticism argument. Like maybe another author would like make things read a little bit more easily. Mark preserves more Aramaic expressions than Matthew or a Luke. It's more likely that it's more likely that Matthew and Luke removed removed this for their Greek speaking audiences than Mark adding in the Aramaic expressions. And then you know, some scholars will say some of the theology and Mark is a little more have some difficult statements. I've got a couple examples if you want to read the first one.
16:59 Mark should have grabbed my. Actual Bible which is like 6 feet away it's. Not that far. But yeah, I'll just use my app so I'm reading Mark 6. Yes, read Mark 6 verse 5. And what I'm going to do is I'm going to look up Matthew 13 verse 50. And I'm, I'm assuming you were reading from the good old NASB. Yeah, I can. I can change to whichever because it's it's an app. OK, I'm, I'm, I'm here. I'm, I'm an NASB as well. So we're we're good. So this is Mark 65 and it says, and he could do no miracle there, except that he laid his hands on a few sick people and healed them. Versus Matthew, which says, and he did not do many miracles there because of their unbelief.
17:43 What they would say is you find some of these expressions where he couldn't do miracles. Sounds we're not saying that Jesus couldn't wear. Like maybe Matthew's coming in and says, oh, he just didn't do miracles, not that he couldn't do it. I think we would say, you know, you're ready, Mark. Mark's not saying like Jesus's hands were tied, but it's like some of these like awkward things. It seems like maybe they would be smoothed out by a later author. So just a few if you're using any, any any comments on that, that you're just like, man now. Yeah. Yeah, I would say, and I think this is the point that not to keep going back, but the point that Dee and Black would make in this book is that you like different proponents of this, they look at this evidence and this evidence can definitely support. Your reverse engineering.
18:29 Yeah, it can. It can support either one because I'm thinking, you know, if Peter is there, Peter was a fisherman and he's teaching. We know that Mark acted as a translator. So if Peter's teaching and Mark wants to preserve what Peter's teaching, you're going to get more of those Aramaic statements in. There. Because Peter probably was less cosmopolitan than maybe than a Paul or a Matthew. And so I everything that you said there, I'm like, yeah, I think that either one that evidence. Whichever way you want to. Read it fits either one of those theories. And then so then what tips you over, you know, what makes the most sense?
19:10 And you just have to make you have to make the call. Yeah, make what? What that call is? And and so in your view too, you do affirm Q was a thing that was used. No, no, no. So Q so that's not that's something you're like KQ is not necessary kind of thing. So Mark in priority view, you're going to you kind of need Q to to make it work. That's the second source of these two sources and this two source hypothesis that the argument would go that both Matthew and Luke, they would be using Q and they would be using Mark separately. So here here's a little bit, you know, that would point to to that being a possibility. You'll get the sayings of Jesus that there are 250 versus common to Matthew and to Luke that you just don't find in Mark.
19:57 And these are parallel with each other, hinting that maybe they were they had, they probably were using some of the same source, Matthew and Luke. They're not in agreement on many things, but they they are parallel. And some of some of the some of these events, there's these doublets that you find and Matthew and Luke and doublets that their accounts that appear more than once in a single Gospel. And so the thinking is Luke may have followed Mark at one point and Q at another. So just for example, if you want to turn to Michael to Luke 18 verse 17. 18 or 8. Eight, I'm glad you're watching the notes, and I'll turn to Luke 12, verse 2.
20:37 I think this will be an example of one of these doublets. All right, it says. For nothing is hidden that will not become evident, nor anything secret that will not be known and come to light. OK, very similar and Luke 12/2 it says, but there's nothing covered up that will not be revealed and hidden that will not be known. The first one of these that that Michael read parallels like almost word for word with Mark 4/22 and the second one is almost word for word with Matthew 1026. So the assumption is, you know, the first might be for Mark and the second one might be from this cue source that that they're using the same cue source because they're so, so similar. And then what we see is that they they place this, you know, hypothetical cue material in different places. The the non marking material of Matthew and the Luke, they're kind of put in different context that, you know, we see Matthew preserves this in discourses and Luke scatters them a little bit more.
21:39 Kind of makes sense if it if Hugh was used as an independent source versus like I'm going to take copy and paste Mark into my gospel, using it a little bit differently where that Greek in those cases are not word for word. So if you deny Q like we kind of talked about, you're going to deny yeah, Michael, you're going to deny this Mark in priority. There are minor agreements between Matthew and Luke. So that's, you know, that's there and they stand against Mark. You can't totally be sure because this really is a complex process. And it's not saying that like, you know, it's not like Matthew would be like, well, Peter said something one time, blah, blah, blah, blah. I'm not going to listen to this or Mark. It's like they all like ran in circles that probably talked with each other a little bit.
22:24 And so you're like, OK, you just don't know how much they heard. Or maybe there were written things or oral traditions. And so because you can't put a percent or no, a lot of it is it's so much reverse engineering. You only, you don't have all the evidence. It's it's hard to to figure out the eyewitness accounts, oral traditions and that kind of thing. Yeah, it really is a forensic science. Like we are looking back and we have our evidences and we can't, it's not like it's a we can't go interview the people. It's it's so and we can't. It's not like it's something we can do again, again and like try it out. So we just we, so it's like we have this historical evidence. We're trying to, like, piece together what makes the most sense of all of the evidence that's there.
23:10 And, and I think, you know, even some of the things that, like I said, you know, for each one of these, I think you could go. We could go either way. Yeah. Oh, this is a point for me. And you're like, no, actually that's a point. For me, right, right. So I think I think that both there's probably some really bad theories out there that can explain it, but I think the the marking and cue makes sense of the text. I think the Matthew with Peter using both of them makes sense of the text. I, I think I have the church fathers on my side too. So maybe that would, would sway you. OK, this is the, this is the way to agree, But I think both, I think it's, I think it's very understandable, especially if you say, man, we found some errors in the church fathers. We're not going to count them at all. Let's just look at the text and come up with our. I think this makes a lot of sense. Here's some theories that I think are not as as likely. Some people have proposed that maybe there was like an earlier edition of Mark, like a first edition Mark or a pre a preview of Mark.
24:12 It's like, it's like a rough draft, like it's not done. I'm still working on it. Homework's not due for a couple weeks but you know, haven't checked. This out with the Holy Spirit yet? It's just me writing down. I'm going to pray about this and then give you a draft too. And so if you had like these pre drafts floating around, then you could borrow from each other before. I don't love that. Probably not likely. We talked about this, Matthew's first gospel. Maybe there, you know, it wasn't Hebrew and Aramaic, or maybe there was. Most people say, you know, it wasn't translated from that, but he wrote some notes down in Hebrew, Aramaic and then related wrote in Greek and there's something floating around. You know, Peter used Matthew and composing, you know, the Greek mark and then Greek Matthew used Greek mark.
24:56 But you know, problem with that. Matthew doesn't read like a like a translation, right, right. That's and we have enough, you know, science where you can like know that almost for you know, just how it how it reads. There's also this. Proto Luke Proto. I've never heard of a Proto Luke theory. Let's hear this well. Let's let's hear it out. There's more amount there. There's more special material in a Luke that's unique compared with unique material in Matthew and Mark. Luke kind of goes his own way. Even in material that's shared by Matthew, Mark, he'll expand on it in more ways than they do. Luke included material from Mark and blocks. When Luke talks about Mark, it's usually blocked out rather than evenly scattered. With Matthew, it's more evenly scattered or with this queue. So, you know, maybe Luke composed the 1st edition with Q and with this hypothetical source L, which is separate from Q that he had, and then later integrated Mark into his work. And I think, you know, you start getting into these things. There's like no end to the theories that you could surmise. Maybe someone's working on their PhD and they're like, all these topics have been taken.
25:57 I'm going proto Luke. Yeah. And I'm trying to make sense. So, yeah. So it says Luke concluded material from Mark, but I think it it could also be that Mark it's just borrowing straight from Luke, you know? And so you have those. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So it's AII kind of like this. So you know, we kind of talked about, you know, there's form criticism that that focuses I think more on the oral tradition. You've got source criticism that focuses on that written tradition. I like just to add to the complexity and and you can even know less about this because a lot of this I think is based on your source criticism view. So it gets like, you know, you're building upon, you know, supposition, but there's this field of study called redaction criticism.
26:42 And it really takes the focus off of oral tradition, more off of the sources, But it looks at, you know, it, it puts the focus on the author, which I think is good because sometimes source criticism is just and they copy and pasted, copy and pasted. But it's like, no, Luke was a person. He had a theology, not, you know, not that he had his own agenda, but he was looking at the world from a different perspective as Matthew, you know, Matthew's Jewish audience compared to to Luke. And, you know, maybe some of this accounts for some of their, you know, differences too. Certainly, right. And so they, they're authors and they can read, they, they can under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, you know, use sources and come to different things too. So it's a little bit different than the Synoptic problem, but I think it's worth mentioning why these might be different as well, that they take these sources and they're going to make their own work.
27:31 They bring a particular emphasis to an objective historical accounts of Jesus. So, so part of this problem is it's going to depend on the sources and then they might make some of their editorial changes as well. So I didn't write down everything. So I'm sure you've got some stuff you might want to add, Michael, but some things, you know, you look at Matthew, everyone knows the Sermon on the Mount, Matthew 5 through 7. And you read a Luke and some people are like, well, this is the Sermon on the Mount in the same way the Sermon on the Plains, it's on a mountain. But maybe for the, you know. Well, it's scattered all over and. And that that's what what's unique is that Luke's is much shorter. I guess if it's not you're looking at it doesn't contain nearly the Old Testament references of the law like Matthew does.
28:15 Matthew talks a lot about Jesus relationship to the Jewish law a lot more than Luke does. Luke talks about Jesus praying a lot more than Matthew does. Mark doesn't either. So maybe people are like, well, Luke talks about prayer. It's a special priority. But you could look at a lot of these a lot of these different emphases you even I have this written down later. But while we're talking about some of the mountain, you know, Matthew says, you know, blessed are the poor in spirit, Luke says. Blessed are the poor. So some people are like, he's totally socio economic. Not for, you know, it's like, I don't know how much we read into all of those things 'cause you can read too much and be like, oh, I know what Luke was thinking. It's like, no, he was just, he's telling it. He's writing down an account, you know. Yeah. And I've often wondered, like, did Luke get that wrong?
28:59 And is that even heretical for me to think that or say that, you know, to. But I, I, yeah, I think it's preserved. I think, you know, that's what Luke wrote. And there are places where Jesus said it's, you know, it's easier for a rich man to enter through the, it's easier for a camel to go through the Avenido than rich man in heaven. So I think it may, there may have been a place where Jesus was talking to and this was like Jesus for a little bit was kind of an itinerant preacher, itinerant. Rally. And so he may be saying the same thing and like bend it slightly because he knows this area is. Very affluent and so could have picked up on. So he may have interviewed someone where he says blessed are the poor, where Matthew, you know, remembers the time where he says blessed are the poor in spirit and you know, so he probably said both of those at different time, but trying to get to the same point, you know.
29:56 That, that, that I think that's, that's a great, great point. We'll look at how these authors arrange their materials, You know, topical for chronological. We talked about that a little bit. You'll get miracles. They're kind of put in different orders. Matthew probably has a different emphasis because he's using these topics compared to someone like Luke. This is an interesting one. I know you've ever looked at this, Matthew 4 and Luke 4, temptation of Jesus in the wilderness. Of course, there are temptations in different order. And is it saying like, OK, there's some significance here versus chronological? A lot of people, I think, point to that is like, the Gospels aren't true because they're different. It's like, well, no, no, you know what I mean? Like those kind of things. This one's to me and that's that's what gets gets me is like some people try to use this to discount the Gospels and it's like you both you have both of these books that one it's anachronistic to go back and assume that their requirement of specificity and precision was equal to ours because we have a much higher standard for precision than what they did back then.
31:01 Because you could quote someone back in the day and no one expected it to be word for word what the person said. But if you were accurate in what they you know, if you caught the spirit of what they said, then they that was fine you. Know, yeah. And even furthermore, it's like when it comes to things like spelling and that kind of thing, it's like you read stuff from like the 1800s and people spelled things however they. It's like, it's not that long ago spelling was like arbitrary, not arbitrary, but it's like you can do whatever you want. And so it's like it's silly to say, oh, we're going back 2000 years. We got to do it the way we do it today. Sorry, I got to say this. You can tell. So there's the English teacher, not Jonathan at Northwood, who had these posters up on, well, I guess there were other English teachers, female, so I can say on her wall.
31:51 And they were just talking about different aspects. And they had, like, different pictures of these literary persons. And they had one spelling. And the picture they had there was William Shakespeare. And I'm like during William Shakespeare's day, there was no standard spelling. So it was just crazy. Yeah. Man, a couple other things and we'll, we'll wrap this up. You know, you can look at these different gospels. They have different stylistic variances where, you know, Matthew uses this phrase when Jesus had finished saying these things at like 5 different, you can break up, you know, the Gospel Matthew into 5 sections based on his authorial style that he's doing this on purpose to give you a flow of the book that's, you know, different authors. In the morning or the first day?
32:37 Yeah, yeah, OK. You. Just broke him up into thematic sections, right? And so that that is so, yeah, yeah, that there's a lot in that. You have these little seams to break things up. That'll be a different podcast. Yeah, we talked about poor and spirit versus poor. So I think that's fascinating. And you can kind of see the different emphasis, their audiences at the same time, you can read a lot into this and it might just be a style thing and you're reading all this theology. And so like, that's just their personality. They're not trying to send a message, even though, you know, every word of scripture. I think it is important. So it's kind of, you know, you want to take all these things together and not just run, run off because because some people, I think you might agree. Look at, you know, Luke talks about the poor and it's written after Matthew.
33:21 That's our whole theology or you know what I'm saying? Like you're kind of, you're kind of missing some points, you know? If that was a huge point, it would have been made. It would have been majorly focused on not just one little, little thing. Yeah, so And he said blessed are the poor. So. Right, it's good. So take so take people's money away. Is that how they're using it right? But that's like that's really funny. So that's the synoptic problem in in two podcast. I'm sure 2 is plenty. People are probably like, you know, maybe people are like, hey, let's do an 8 part series. Let's keep our. Series let's I want to dig into. Let's show us the graphs. Yeah, I don't know what what it occurred to me that it's, it might be good to point out that we know Luke wrote the gospel, Luke and Acts.
34:06 So Luke writes, if you just look at number of words, the majority of the New Testament, I know that's the case if you don't attribute Hebrews to Paul. If you attribute Hebrews to Paul, it may get close. I'd have to, I'd have to look at that. But we know that Acts just ends with, you know, Paul in Rome under house arrest. We think that it was his first house arrest. We're not sure. But that would have been around 62 or so, 63 ish. And he would have written Luke before that. Right, right, right, right. Yeah, yeah. And no matter whether you're marking or Matthew, Yeah, right, right, right.
34:52 Priority. Those would have been written before that. Yeah, it's good. And so you get the gospels very early man, at most like 1520 years after the events. Some people would put certain sayings very early, like in Corinthians, like when Paul tells them in Corinthians 5I pass on to you of utmost important what was passed on to me that Christ, he wrote that. We know he wrote that like in the early 50s and then he would, but he was referencing an earlier time when he preached that to them and that was passed on to him.
35:35 So it hadn't even been before then. So there's lots of good arguments that put all this material early and that put this, you know what, around when people were there to say, no, this is not what really happened. Yeah. That, that's pretty striking. Yeah, when you take all of that and that, that that's incredibly, incredibly early. And it really just lends to the credibility. It's pretty pretty amazing. And, and as much as we read through our gospels and we see different facets, it's like a, a, a diamond with different facets like so. And they're, they are in agreement. So I would what I wouldn't want anyone to walk away is like, oh, can I trust gospels? Yeah, you can trust them.
36:16 They're early. We're just trying to figure out, you know, how they came about. Yeah, it's, it's, it's amazing how how similar, similar they are and the dating and all that kind of stuff, man, that, that, that's really cool. Well, there you go. Apologetics kind of from a different different angle. Any any final words besides the final words you just said? No, no, I think that's good. Go read. Go read your gospels. Boom, that, that is great. A great, great word. Well, that is our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed