Think Tank Thursday—Essence, Existence, and the Thomistic Proof for God
Episode 123
In this episode, we explore one of Thomas Aquinas’s most profound arguments for the existence of God—based on the distinction between essence and existence. Why do things exist at all, and what does it mean that their existence is not necessary? We unpack how Aquinas reasoned that only in God are essence and existence identical, making Him the necessary being that grounds all contingent reality. If you’re interested in classical theism or deep philosophical reasoning about God’s nature, this episode is for you.
5 Happy Birthday Versions | Terrible to Amazing: https://youtu.be/R2Eotw3IxN4
The Argument:
1. In all finite beings, there is a real distinction between essence (what a thing is) and existence (that a thing is).
2. Anything whose essence is distinct from its existence does not exist necessarily; it requires a cause to exist.
3. The collection of all such contingent beings (whose essence is not existence) cannot account for its own existence.
4. A series of caused beings, even an infinite one, cannot explain why existence itself is present rather than absent.
5. Therefore, there must exist a being whose essence is existence itself (ipsum esse subsistens)—a being that does not receive existence but is existence.
Conclusion: Such a being exists, and it is the necessary ground of all other beings—this is what we call God.
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/IC8oTquPEIE
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/
0:00 The Michael Zach saga continues. Relationship gets good and then it just gets. Soured like sour Patch Kids sour. But that's actually funny. We were talking about this girl, but we call, we called Jordan our sour patch kid. So sweet, so sour. Depends on the day. So is this first and second cousins 'cause you were talking about them? It might be more interesting than what I'm going with, but this will be I was at a birthday party yesterday. You. Were not there? Were you were kidding sports or something or you were doing stuff? Well, my so I think I told you a little bit off where yeah, they're, they're doing this cloud cut over and it's not going so great. We may have to roll back and try again next weekend.
0:43 It's kind of like a what's it called a cascade of error or cascade of issues that we're going through. So we'll learn from this one and maybe do it next week. You know, it's OK to fail, fail forward. You know I'm saying for that's. Great, as long as you learn. It's not good to just like just fail for. But yeah, you're taking from. It's OK to push it up. Yeah, and I'm not like the tech I'm, I'm, I'm a technical guy, but I'm not the technical guy in this respect. So I'm just kind of listening in to them, trying to solve the problems. And I see it's like, how do I encourage them? You know? I see. Yeah, You know, if I was like corporate America, I'd like send some pizzas their way or something, 'cause that's what people always do. But it's. Like more out pizza party. Yeah, that, that wins everything.
1:23 Where's our Christmas bonuses? Well, we got you a pizza party this year. Speaking of pizza, at this birthday party had some good pizza, you know, love it. But Speaking of failing, I feel like I failed. And what's what? I don't know if Jill probably didn't say anything, but I was standing near Jillian and I were when the, you know, happy birthday song is sang. And she says this wasn't directed to me as soon as we started singing it. I'm not the greatest singer. I think I was off key a little bit. She just starts laughing and I was like, are you laughing at me? She's like, she's like, oh, no, no, no, everyone's off key. But I think it was kind of targeted towards me. So Jill, you can be honest. You're not gonna hurt my feelings. It was it was rough out there. Happy happy birthday and kids were ever there's a lot. Of kids.
2:06 It's so funny. I will put this in the link below but there is this guy who does 5 versions of Happy birthday 5 levels happy. Birthday. And the first one is probably what you're describing. She's like happy birthday. And it's like everyone, it's like no one's you know. And then it goes on to this and it's like this over harmonized, you know, version. Oh yeah, it works its way up. So she instantly bursted into laughter but said it was not totally room. She said she was thinking also of like the Hawks and Kayla. She was thinking of something like that was really funny where, you know, they would someone would always sing something or interject at the wrong time. There's something funny. It was like really a funny thing. So I think she's trying to make me feel better. But anyway, failing for birthday song. I don't know if you've had any birthday, you know, mishaps. Yeah, yeah.
2:56 What was your question? You know, if I had any. Well, I've got a lot of either. I've got a lot of first cousins. Yeah, yeah. You you you ended on a question that I over spoke on. So I was trying to get. I was now I. Was going to say any. Any birthday mishaps? Any we talked about. I had a birthday birthday mishap when I was 13. My house caught on fire. But yeah, any. Yeah, nothing like that. I remember, you know, my, my, my parents worked hard. We weren't, we were probably upper lower class or lower middle class in some like you don't really know that sometimes. But then as I got older, you know, they, they started being able to, you know, mom got several promotions.
3:36 So things got a little bit easier. But I remember for my 18th birthday, like, you know, you can just kind of think of like things you would get for your 18th birthday. I don't know what what would be some things you would think of? Like, in a perfect world, it'd be cool to get, like, a car is probably too big, but, you know, it's like you're 1618. That's like a big day. I'm trying to think of other big things. Yeah. Luggage is what I got. Hey, hey, a good a good pair, a good a good luggage thing is hard to come by. Yeah, and it did serve me well. So it was like one of those good practical gifts, But I opened it. I was like luggage on my 18th birthday. Like, by the way, leave the house. We want you to. You're on your own. But it did serve me well.
4:18 But that Jill still makes fun of me because she was there and she was like, you can see the look on my face, like, yeah. Presents are such a tricky thing when expectations are. It's always funny. I was on this joke with my sister, like on Christmas one time. She got like a sweater, but I don't know that well, I think she liked the sweater, but we were like four or five gifts in and she was like, oh, I actually like this or something. She's like actually in there like Tori, does that mean you you weren't a priest of your other gifts? But it's always, it's always, it's always, you know, tough, especially when it's like a like it's, it's like you get one or two gifts and it's like, even if it's luggage and it was like a lot of money or something, it's like, oh, it's like, oh, you know, it's, it's a tough thing. And I don't know what I expected. I did have a car.
5:00 OK, Yes, you're. Good. I had what people called the lanyard. It was a it was an old, it was a 1988 year, but Oldsmobile Delta 98, which was like the top of the line, had the Gray liner like. Man. Cassette player, electric seats, electric windows like it was it was tricked out for 1980. Eight. Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And this was or not maybe, yeah, 88, maybe it was 84. It was old, but yeah, so. And I had a pretty nice stereo that went to college with me. So I don't know what I was expecting. I was just not expecting luggage. That's. Great. Did you do the old you have like the old cassette player with the little connection to for?
5:43 Absolutely. Yeah, Yeah, yeah. Yeah, that's great for your CD player. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's classic that that came in big time before, like CD players were just like ubiquitous. Same thing as my first. My first cars I had were older cars, which were great. But it's like man. And now today it's like what's ACD? It's it's just you. Know it is crazy thinking about CDs, but they exist, you know? They do exist. And you kind of know what the nature of ACD is? Yeah, You know what it is? It's it's not the same as an 8 track. They're different. It's it's not the That's right, That's right. Yeah. Yeah, that's great. Things like like the floppy disk. We don't do a lot of floppy disk stuff now, but it survives because it's like the save symbol, like it just survives.
6:27 Yeah, there's some funny thing about, you know, someone had a floppy disk like you. You made the symbol you. Know no this is. This is what it was from. Boy, and those things cannot hold a lot of memory. I mean, I remember it's 1.44 megabytes. Wow. 1.44 megabytes And I remember in, you know, thinking that this is a lot of because you the old cause by the time we were around what we called a floppy disk, you know, there was the five and a quarter that was actually floppy and then there was the, you know, the hard, you know, thing that had the little slidy things. It wasn't as floppy, but I think the five and a quarter was like 512 kilobytes maybe.
7:08 So, you know, when you get the the, you know, 1.44 megabytes, you're like. Game changer. Yeah, 'cause even a little bit later than that maybe is like when, when MP3 players first started coming out, a lot of them were like 400 kilobytes or something, and you could like store like 40 something, maybe 100. It's like there's a finite number of songs that was on that thing. Yeah, they weren't the highest quality. I remember having like down, down qualities that could fit more on there. Yeah, you could. Put more on there. Great. And then you got limewired. Your computer crashed because we're like, you're downloading, dude. I'll tell you we're all over the place. We can wrap up this dancer. But man, when you first could like, burn CDs, that was the wild, Wild West, man, You could do anything.
7:49 I remember my sisters having a cassette player with a radio in it and waiting for a song to come on and then hit and record. And then you got to wait there. And like, if the DJ talked over it, you were upset. Like you don't like stop talking. Just let the music play. And then you would like, stop recording and you would make, you know, a, a tape. And then Napster came out, and while it was still questionably legal, yeah, yeah, yeah. You could make what? You could make whatever fave CD you wanted. To make anything you wanted. Game changer. So we started with birthdays, ended with Napster, and if you thought it couldn't get any better than this, it can. We're going to talk about Aquinas argument for God's existence.
8:31 So get hyped. Let's take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. All right, so this is our second installment and kind of our crowded hit every month. It may be a little longer than a month sometimes, a little shorter than a month sometimes, but installment on apologetics and apologetics arguments. Nice last one. Hopefully everyone remembers Cosmological Argument. Do we have a nice I know we didn't land on a neat name for like something Thursday. What's AT word we were talking about it was. Like anyway Theology Thursday.
9:17 Or theology Thursday is there is there apologetic adjacent word that starts with T? Like hmm. Anyway, something something something to ponder. Yeah, maybe ChatGPT can help that. That's. That's a good idea. Yeah, yeah. But he, he's good at those kind of things. But I, you know, so I thought we would kind of give another somewhat akin to the cosmological argument, but this one is more from a scholastic is the word I'm looking for scholastic point of view. So, you know, I don't want to give everyone the whole history, but, you know, you have these huge philosophers, Plato, Socrates and Aristotle, and then actually let me give them an order. Socrates, Plato, Aristotle.
10:13 Yeah. That's good. I always make stuff. I don't know the orders as well as I should. That's good. Yeah. So Socrates is first his student was Plato, and then Aristotle was his student. And then some of Aristotle's, you know, their writing was lost, you know, you know, through the the dark ages. And then it was rediscovered, translated. And he, Aristotle, became so ubiquitous with the way of Western thinking that people would just refer to him as the philosopher. That's it. He was just so the. Philosopher said this and so you see his huge impact and Thomas Aquinas takes a lot of what he writes because Aristotle had a lot of good things to say.
10:53 You know, we threw out the. The problem is let me interrupt my story. We. He had a bad physics, right? Yeah, the earth is the center, you know, and we threw out the physics. Then we also threw out the metaphysics. That was the bad thing. We threw the baby out with the bathwater. But Thomas Aquinas, you know, took what he had right in the philosophy and the metaphysics, but tweaked it so that, you know, he was believed in lots of different gods. And so like, OK, he's saying some right things, but let's let's, oh, yeah, let's just tweak it to make it right so that it is in line with reality. And so this really falls out of one of those things. And I don't think we talk a lot about essence. I think this is gonna be. Great, 'cause I, I personally am like, man, what is what's essence, what's substance like I don't understand, like what we're trying to say and I don't know if I'll ever be like satisfied totally.
11:44 But I think this is good and you know it. It's some of that that's classic period. A lot of rigor with like the philosophy. It's like really well done really. It's not just like we're throwing stuff at the wall. Not that we have to call it, call it this, but maybe at least for a couple times this. This is a Tomas Thursday. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Anyway, carry on. And so there's an argument for God's existence just from the fact that you exist, Zach, or this microphone exists. And really it has to do with this essence existence distinction. So you mentioned this word substance. A substance would be something that qualities could adhere in.
12:28 So you are a substance. Water is a substance. Can you abuse? Substances, yeah, you can abuse substances. You have substance abuse. And so then like, you know, when we were talking maybe 3 or 4 or 516 podcasts back, we talked about hylomorphic dualism versus who could forget Cartesian dualism. You know, really that's a debate about if the human is two different substances that kind of interact some way or are you one substance that is both physical and non physical? So those are the substance words. But really we could leave substance alone here because we're going to be talking about different substances, but we're going to be talking about the essences and the existence of those substance. And I think when we say essence, you kind of know like we're familiar with that term.
13:16 Maybe nature or form might be another word that you might be. They all kind of mean the same thing, and it just really defines what something is. Yeah. And I don't know why this is, but trees are always what philosophers immediately turn to. Trees. Yeah, I like it. But you know what a tree is? Yeah, yeah. If I held a rose to you and I was like, this is a tree. I would slap that thing on your hand saying no thank you Sir, not a. Tree. And then if I said why, you might shrug a little bit to go tell me why it's not a tree. Exactly. You just know. You know, like, well, it's shorter. There are some short trees, yeah. It's, you know, so you might struggle and but you kind of internally know it's not a tree.
13:58 And then you might, it might take you a while to kind of like define what makes a tree a tree and what makes a rose a rose. I will say this is probably not what you're going after either, but it's like those people that are like if someone came up to me, this is this is way off topic, but if they're like, Hey, you like what do you think about this tomato? But it's a fruit. I don't know. I'm trying to think of something where it's like, you know, those people that they're just like, it's like, well. Tomatoes. Fruit, not a vegetable. Exactly. Yeah, where like looks like a vegetable. It's like people might commonly associate with vegetable. It's a fruit. Yeah, that's because they're they're mixing up culinary words and botany words. Oh, is it? From a culinary perspective, it is a vegetable because it is.
14:39 All day long, it's a vegetable. Oh I never knew this. OK gotcha. I was just associated as a fruit. That's what I was taught. OK, there is no, there is no botanical definition of a vegetable. A vegetable can be a fruit, a leaf, a stalk, a root. Yeah. So at its essence. Biologically, it's a fruit. It's a OK, OK. Guess, but culinarily we use it as a vegetable. OK. So like your essence, depending on what perspective you're looking at, could be slightly different or something like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So we could define, yeah, you could define, you know, what is the essence of a fruit. And if your, if your viewpoint is culinary, you might say something that's sweet. Or if you're, you know, what is a vegetable, then you know, you might also have different ideas what that is.
15:20 So I one thing I like to when we're talking about essence is a Unicorn. Do you know what a Unicorn is? I I do yes. Could you describe it for our audience? It's got one horn coming out looks like a horse. What's there was a very famous there's like a girls Rosa Franklin Is this something like like girls like in elementary school, like girls like had this thing like that. All their folders, all their pens would be like something, and a lot of those would be unicorns. But it was like some sort of like phrase. But I'm. Not familiar with them, but you could, yeah. I showed you a picture that looked like a Baron and said this Unicorn. Oh yeah, I would say I don't think so, yeah. Which is odd 'cause it leads us into this next idea of existence.
16:06 So we talked about what the, we talked about essence, you know, the characteristics, what defines a thing to be a thing, but there's also existence and that Unicorn that we talked about it, we, we could describe its essence, but it has never existed. It's never had the quality of existing. Yeah, yeah. Or Stegosaurus T Rex. Unicorns in the Bible, right? Yeah. Is that like King James Version or something? Right. Yeah. That's always funny. One. Yeah. Stegosaurus. You would know what? Well, maybe you know what is? You know what? Stegosaurus. Is. How dare you? How dare you? Yeah, it's a dinosaur. Yeah, yeah. But I mean, do you know? I I could, if someone showed me a picture of it, I could get like with a tail with like the, you know, things, the rocky tail or whatever.
16:49 Differentiated Ankylosaurus. Tricerosaurus. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I bet I could. Yeah, OK. And so then we're we're, we are talking about their essences, but those things have not existed for a long time. So we're kind of going through this to help people get into these, their mind, this category of existence and essence. One of my professors used to say, you know, if you've ever had a balloon, you know, most of our balloons are kind of just straight. But there are some balloons that have like twists in them. And so the balloon with the twist kind of defines the essence, but it doesn't really exist until you blow air into it. So you can kind of differentiate existence itself, like the act of existing that gets paired up with an essence. OK, so I like that.
17:34 Everything good so far. Yeah, pretty pretty good I think. I think I at least could define essence and existence. So finite beings there's for all of finite beings, we have a distinction between our essence and our existence. So whether it's a horse, a tree, a person, we all have a specific nature of what it is, but our existence is not part of that nature. And what we mean by that is that those things could have not existed. You could not you. It's possible that you never existed. Oh, gotcha. You don't exist out. Of necessity, it's a simulation thing. No, I'm, I'm just. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. And let's take something that like, you know, like a horse that doesn't have an eternal soul, that thing will stop existing at some point in time.
18:18 Right came in. Existence came out of existence, so we can say we can clearly see its essence and existence are not the same thing. Gotcha. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so if it's is, if it's essence is not to exist, like if it's not part of its nature to exist. Then. It has to get its existence from someplace else. Gotcha. Yeah. Does that make sense? Yeah, I think so, yeah. So then the distinction is really critical because we need an explanation for the fact that something exists rather than nothing at all, right? OK, Yeah. 'Cause I exist, I have my essence, but it's clearly not my essence to exist. It's not part of my nature to exist 'cause it was part of my nature to exist, I'd exist necessarily. Yeah, and then if you were talking about a Unicorn, right, it doesn't exist, you know what I'm saying? Yeah.
19:07 Yeah. So yeah, I got you. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right, so here's where the argument comes in. He'll argue that everything in the world is contingent, meaning its essence does not necessitate its existence. This leads to some observation. So things exist, but do not have to exist. We kind of already covered this. They could fail to exist at some point in time. They could stop existing. Some examples, You didn't exist 200 years ago, yet you exist now. Same is true for stars, planets, civilizations, even species. Yeah, they come into existence, they go out of existence. Things have potential. You. Think I have potential? Oh man, you got some potential that that. Yeah, that's correct. Often times people use that in a good way and it is good for contingent beings, but God has no potential. That's right, because we have potential he could change. That's actually not.
19:56 That's a scary that you don't want him to change what he said, Yeah. Right. Because if you had potential, either he could get worse than what he is, or he's not as good as he could be and he could get better, you know? And he's not the greatest. Yeah, because and our gods pretty great. So there's not, yeah, not a good direction to go if you have potential to change that's. Right. But contingent things like us, we have potential. That means we are subject to change. A tree grows from a seed, lives for a few centuries, maybe eventually decays, civilizations rises of fall. This means their existence is not necessary, they're dependent on something. Else something else would be more steadfast. I gotcha. Yeah. So hopefully maybe you can see where this argument's going. Things must have an explanation for their existence. Even if there were an infinite regressive contingent causes. So cosmological argument that we talked about, we spend a lot of time showing that the past cannot go backwards forever. There has to be a beginning for contingent things, right? The universe had to come into existence. We talked about how you know physically, scientifically, that the past cannot be backwards, infinite. But we could even grant that to the skeptic. We could say, for the sake of argument, we'll grant to you that even if the universe was infinitely eternal in the past, it would still just be a long chain of dominoes. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
21:14 Of contingent things and even that thing would have to have at some point explanation for its existence, right, right. And this kind of is borrowing a little bit from Leibniz's cosmological argument, but. So, yeah, yeah. So things you know. Imagine chain of dominoes following it indefinitely. The series itself still needs an explanation. So even if the universe were eternal, it would still need a reason why exist now rather than not existing. So we must receive our existence from somewhere. Since things don't have the reasons for their own existence and their essence, their existence must be received from something else.
21:58 So the bottom line is, there must be something that exists whose essence is existence itself. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. It's like a similar argumentation. I mean, it's different, but it's like coming from the same point that there's just got to be something outside of all these things that ebb and flow, and the something is something that most likely does not. It can't be ebb and flowy as well. Yep. So if everything were contingent, then there would be nothing that exists. But since we do have something exists, it means that something there has to be something that exists. It's not contingent. Everything were contingent, but nothing would exist. That's what I'm saying.
22:40 Yeah. Yeah. So it's like, and stuff exists, right? Like logically, yeah. Yeah. Gotcha. Yeah. So that means there has to be something that's not contingent, something that's necessary. Parmenides was another Greek philosopher, and he had this to say. It kind of goes along with what Aquinas would say in in Aristotle, being itself cannot be created or destroyed, being itself, right? Essences can rise and fall, but existence itself, like, you know, trying to think separating that balloon, the the shape of the balloon from the air. And if the air is existence, like if that shape goes out of existence, that air still goes someplace else, right? I. Got. That it cannot be created destroyed. In order to create being, something must have had to 1st exist. In order to destroy being something, something is going to continue to exist.
23:26 Like whatever destroyed the being, you know would have to exist and then it would have being. And so he comes to this absolute nothing list can produce nothing. And it has this famous phrase ex nihilo nihil feet. Nice. Yeah. And most most people would know ex nihilo. You might not know the rest of it, but you're like, you should know that. One, yeah. So ex nihilo means out of nothing. So we say God created the cosmos ex nihilo out of nothing. We mean it had no material, 'cause right? But God was still there, He existed, right? And so he's saying out of nothing, nothing comes for The Sound of Music, folks. Yeah, this I know. This isn't you, so just bear with me. Yeah, I don't know anything about it. I just saw where I went to undergrad is doing a Sound of Music production, so I saw some a lot of Nazis running around. So apparently it's World War Two thing I'm learning. There are, there are.
24:17 It is that is crazy. Like you have to have Nazi uniforms to put some of these, yeah. These. Things on Yeah. It's like, why do you have all these Nazi flags? Well, because we're putting on Sound of Music. Big Julie Andrews fan. We just. That's what, yeah. But there's a song there where she sings Nothing comes from nothing. Nothing ever could. So yeah. So she's. Tracking. Yeah, so she's tracking Parmenides, you know what I'm saying? That's great. All right. So if that is the case, then we have to have at least one necessary being whose existence not depending on anything else right now you might say, well, if there's multiple things that whose essence is it is to exist.
25:05 Yeah, yeah, yeah. But there can't be logical, you're saying, because if so, you, we can distinguish between me and you a rose and a tree because of our different essences. But if my essence is existence itself and your essence is existence itself, then we would be identical, there'd be nothing to distinguish us. So that's how we can say that. That's how we can say there's really only one God, because of the indistinguishable nature, indiscernible nature of identicals so. This idea of this dualism where there's like an eternal good force, an eternal bad force, not, not not vibing with.
25:46 That it doesn't work and this is probably, you know, first year masters level of not back in the day, you know, back in the cars day this would have been maybe junior high, but today it's masters level. People just knew so much, so much more. It's crazy. But yeah, the what was the question? Sorry I got. Distracted dualism, eternal good, eternal bad being, or you know, Whether it's a being or not, you know. So we went through pains to show that existence, oneness, I think goodness. And maybe those are the three. Maybe there's a fourth one. All in one sense are the same thing.
26:26 Say that. Say it one more time. Existence, existence, goodness and the oneness. OK, OK, OK. Yeah, yeah. And how a being whose existence, whose essence is existence itself, has no other properties. That is a single property. And it it is good. And so it is one and it is existence. That's a. If you're interested in that, you can go find more. It's probably too much for this podcast to break out those details. That's good. Yeah, I like it. All right, so that being must be pure existence itself, and so on #4 the conclusion God is a subsistent being itself. So he's pure actuality, no potentiality. He cannot not exist.
27:10 And so some of the implications of this. God is uncaused because if he were caused then he would be necessary. God is eternal. If he ceased to exist he would not be necessary. God isn't changing. If he could change he would have potentiality rather than pure actuality. God is simple, not composite, because if you were composed parts he would depend on something up prior to himself. God is the explanation of existence itself. Without him nothing could exist. So the the Latin is God is ipsum essay subsistence, or he is existence itself. His essence is existence itself. No, I like that When I think of Aquinas Thomas thinking, the first thing that comes into my mind is God is simple. That's like the one thing that I just automatically associate for whatever reason.
27:59 I think it's been, people have talked about it in the last few years a little bit more and I think I think that's good at all, you know, logically comes out and I like we've got a couple of different arguments that say like not the same thing, but it points in the same direction in a different way, you know? Yeah. So if we were to talk about the cosmological argument, it would be like coming across something and going, why did, why did this thing exist? Like how did this thing come into existence, right? OK. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This argument is like you're hearing music and you're like, what is making that music? Because I not only did I come into existence, not only did the universe come into existence, but it continues to exist. So the fact that we still exist and it's not in our essence exist, it means that we are God is lending his essence, his existence, his essence to exist to us right now.
28:49 So there are verses that talk about, you know, he holds everything together. All things are summed up in Him. You know, all those ideas are true from a philosophical standpoint as well. And that's great. I think apologetic some of this philosophy, it's always been challenging for me where it's not, I don't think I think it is complicated. It's really not that it it on one level it's very complicated. You have to do a little bit of time and another way it's kind of like same. It's kind of a similar thing. I feel like with like economics, a lot of it is like common sense with terms. If you're gonna like just learn the terms and definitions, then it makes a lot more sense. But when you're throwing out terms and you don't know, you haven't been trained in like a definition, it can't seem overwhelming.
29:30 But it's like just, you know, some of these things like essence existence, just know what they mean and then you can talk with them a little bit more freely and it's not as overwhelming. Yeah, that's a good, good point. I remember being 17, having some doubts about God's existence, my salvation and stuff. And I remember thinking, there's the the Earth is here. How did it get here? There needs to be an explanation for it. OK. And really philosophy is just come alongside that and go, that's a good idea. Let's make that more bulletproof against attacks. Let's use some fancy words to to help round it out so that when people try to naysay it, you know, well, no, I formulated my argument so they can withstand what you're saying.
30:14 And that's good because all these are really, I think they are grounded in some other than maybe the ontological argument. It's all grounded in, you know, some common sense ideas. And so this idea that I don't exist on myself by myself, there has to be something that exists in and of itself. That's a pretty common sense notion. That's really what this argument is saying. That is great. I'm looking forward to some more, you know, whether it's Tomas Thursday or different apologetic. I know, I know Tomism is probably on your mind just because that was like integral in the school you went to. And we're really where a lot of this, you know, came from any ways, like like you're saying Aristotle, Plato and then this Renaissance.
30:56 And then so a lot of it he kind of like set the stage where all people borrow from this stuff anyway. Who's like the other? I guess you would just be more, you know, postmodern and if you're like rejecting Aquinas stuff or I could you know what I mean or like. What's the not postmodern? You'd be more Kantian. OK. Oh, gotcha. Yeah. Yeah. So you'd be Kantian. So like William Lane Craig is probably a a, you know, Kantian compared to that that, you know, a what's the guy that founded SES? Oh, Gersh. Scott Geisler. No. OK. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Gotcha. I thought I could help you out on your own model. I'm just kidding. Awesome. Well, yeah, Is there, can you tease out any other arguments, maybe on a future episode or we don't know?
31:37 Yeah. Oh, I mean, you're thinking. Would be like good. If we wanted, Aquinas has some other ones like from Motion, and we had to memorize them back in the day. This one I gave you, I think is the best one. And then so there's theological from the basically argument from design. There's a moral argument. There is the ontological argument. Those probably are your biggest arguments for God's existence. The moral argument falls into this family of arguments that even our presuppositionalists will buy into this family of arguments.
32:20 Yeah. So it's it's it's a good argument. So you could take the same argument we give for the moral argument and you can replace it with knowledge, you can replace it with beauty, you know, mathematics. So, you know, we'll, we'll go over that when we get there, you know. Because I feel like people that are critical of, and I'm not the expert in this space, like Tomism, maybe like some presuppers who are like, you know, all this, they're just like what I hear them saying are things like, we're just going to use what Aristotle? Like, why are we, Why are we starting with Aristotle? It's like, well, some of the things that if you're saying if things are true or not true, they're true or not true. But I think. All truth is God's truth. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
33:02 You hear some of that sometimes, and I can't remember other And then everyone's like, well, Aquinas was so Catholic. You hear that sometimes, too. Like nothing. You have to embrace everything. Aquinas says. You can, you know, you know, pick the good parts, you know if. If I'm honest and transparent with you, I didn't read every single book that I was assigned. OK. Wow. Yeah, yeah. However, there is one book that I read all of On Evil or De Malo by Thomas Aquinas. To me it is a masterpiece of talking about what evil is. And and you said he's Catholic. Like think about a Catholic who cannot controvert anything that has been said in the creeds or Pope has said ex Catherida or you know some cardinal who is very influential said because that's your life on the line, but you're still dedicated to the truth.
34:00 If you have that vision and then you read on evil, you'll go, wow, this guy was why is as a dove? Why is the serpent innocent as a dove? Because he would say, you've heard it was said. And sometimes he'll talk about Aristotle or you know, you've heard it said and he'll say, and this is true in this respect. Like there's, there's a way of thinking about this that's true. And here's another way that it's true. And here's another way true. And he'll give you all these different things he'll say, and here's the conclusion to that. And he does this over and over and over again. And so you do get some Catholic stuff in there. Like you might see some venial or mortal sins be mentioned in there, but most of the time he's just dealing with kind of your standard stuff. And everyone's a product of their own environment too, where it's like, man, it's just today's world is not that word where it's like OK to say whatever, or it's like, there's 800 different denominations.
34:54 It's like a different world and you know, you look at Irenaeus Norwich and it's like you can find, you can find find some bad stuff where you can look at, you know, even Agustin and be like, why would you say this? You know so. Even John Piper. What? Hey, hey, you bite your tongue. Yeah. So I think some of that's like uncharitable. It's easy to look back and I don't and I just I've never read a lot of Aquinas to make that. So when people talk, I never know how much like, you know, claims and I, I think it's more of like turf wars, like my way's better than their way. So I'm gonna try to undermine some of this stuff. But yeah, he's The Who. Who else was around Aquinas's time? I mean, I feel like that's like, that's the guy. Yeah, man, you're trying to.
35:34 Sorry. Yeah, I was trying. I was trying to think of people around. Not that I don't know, I mean. The I mean, I could pull out my my medieval philosophers there. There were some good Islamic medieval philosophers, I mean. 'Cause they had kind of a this is where. We're going to each the name for Kalam cosmological argument. There's a guy who's whose name starts with an A. That's the most I can remember from from the Islam who was a doctor and you know, he was doing a lot of good things. Unfortunately, you know, there was this revolution where they, that they kind of burned all that stuff and they went back to the arcade, the Dark Angels. They burned all of the, the stuff in Babylon, I believe.
36:15 And they kind of just set them backwards 'cause they were, they were doing some pretty, you know, good stuff, some good thinkers despite their, their false religious ideas. But then that they were overcame by that, overcome by that. Well, I think, I think this is great. We'll kind of keep maybe running through these once a month or something, but I love it. Any any parting words on apologetics? Yeah, apologetics are they're good for the people who are are running a mouse, you know, saying bad things, you know. Well, that's not actually true. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Because of this and this, you kind of stop the detractors. They're good for seekers. And then I was talking to a gentleman at our church today who said he's dealing with doubts. Well, apologetics can be good for, you know, your biggest critic sometime is yourself.
37:05 You know, you have your own doubts and you think about, you know, so that. That's what I like about apologetics, Like you should apply as long as you're applying the same rigor of testing to everything. Test everything. You know what I'm saying? I think the problem is when people are really harsh with Christianity and then they don't apply that to other things. But it's like, do do that. See what? See what comes out. Yeah, unfortunately, like if you applied the same standards, you're basically into a place where you can't know anything. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's why probably so many people are at that spot where they can't do anything 'cause they're like, well, that's what I'm looking at. Yeah. Well, that's good. Well, look forward to some more of these. That's our take.
37:45 Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed