...where we take theology 2 the next level
March 19, 2025

Think Tank Thursday—The Kalam Cosmological Argument: Does the Universe Have a Cause?

Think Tank Thursday—The Kalam Cosmological Argument: Does the Universe Have a Cause?
Think Tank Thursday—The Kalam Cosmological Argument: Does the Universe Have a Cause?
Take 2 Theology
Think Tank Thursday—The Kalam Cosmological Argument: Does the Universe Have a Cause?

Episode 117


Does the universe have a beginning? If so, does it require a cause? In this episode, we explore the Kalam Cosmological Argument, a powerful philosophical and theological case for the existence of God. Originating in Islamic philosophy and championed in modern times by thinkers like William Lane Craig, this argument follows a simple yet profound structure: (1) Whatever begins to exist has a cause, (2) The universe began to exist, (3) Therefore, the universe has a cause.


We’ll break down each premise, discuss objections from skeptics, and examine how contemporary science—like Big Bang cosmology and thermodynamics—intersects with this ancient argument. Whether you’re a believer, skeptic, or just curious, this episode will challenge your thinking on the origins of everything.


The Argument:

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause.

2. The universe began to exist.

3. Therefore, the universe has a cause

Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/4olNCURgX94


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/

0:00 Zach, I've got some concerns. Oh, let me have it. I got some I I found out that baby, you're not as caring of a supervisor manager that some might some might think that you are. What's what's your exact title? I am regional director of. Operations The regional director. Thank goodness I'm not assistant regional director. I work for a therapy company of operations for Berkeley County and then for our Myrtle Beach area. And I guess nothing is really going on in Myrtle Beach right now, right? Well, I just learned that there's fires. You told me you're like, man, how about all these fires in South Carolina? And I said, that's news to me.

0:42 And really, it's punishment fits the crime. It's what I deserve because I've not been on social media in two days. And what that's telling me is I need to be more, more, more on social. Media, that's what. That's what your take away is. I'm gonna tell Jonathan. Zach's take away is he needs me on social media more. I I literally I took Facebook off of my phone 'cause I get on it too much and now I'm a bad boss. I need Facebook to do my. Job. So we're recording this on the one second. I don't think it's going to air until not even this Thursday, but next Thursday. So this might be a little dated. Hopefully the fires get put out. We don't. We don't know. That's like scary. And fires are happening everywhere because Michael was telling me it's because of global warming, which I was like, you know what? I didn't think that, but I trust your judgements.

1:22 Oh, man, yeah, there are weird things with, you know, I was telling you we don't have to go into all the conspiracy theories that I'm starting to believe, but there are some weird things about the fires in LA and the ones that were in Hawaii that that. It's. Weird, they don't have very good explanations for. And if you hear like some things, you know, former or current governors of some of these places have said about things, it's it's very concerning. Yeah. Yeah. It's very strange. And this is going way off topic, but I think it was my 12th birthday, maybe my 13th birthday. My house caught on fire as a. Kid. Oh, for real? It did. Like burned down or?

2:04 It did not burn down, thank goodness. But my mom picked me up from school. I was bringing a couple of friends over. I think it was 13, maybe I was 12. And one of those and she. Was actually on your birthday you're gonna have. A birthday party, my birthday. It was like yeah and she like got the grill going, put some like ribs or something on the grill and then she went to pick me up for school. Don't leave a girl intended, but it's actually good. She did propane tank exploded. It was right outside, but my like whole kitchen was demolished like smoked. We had to live like in an apartment for like 4 months while they like remodeled our house and there was a lot of smoke damage. That's when I realized like how bad, you know all of this stuff. It was like terrible but it really just blew out like probably like this side over like a a decent amount for a kitchen. Everything else was like needed repair but it wasn't like the whole house burned down.

2:52 But my neighbor came over and like stopped it from getting worse. He made sure like no one was in there. It's like pretty amazing. Wow, I've never heard the story. Never heard. This happy birthday to me. I don't, I Yeah. It's why I don't celebrate birthdays. Yeah, we, I I make a point of shutting all of our doors at night when we go to bed. One, because most people die not from heat but from toxic inhalation. Shutting doors can help that, but it also helps slow the spread of fire and smoke damage. It's like there's videos of like, you know, these houses that it's like all black on one side, you open the door, it looks like nothing happened on the other side. So yeah, so fires. Fires is crazy. It reminded me of we don't have to go into detail too classic, classic quote by Dwight Schrute.

3:34 He says like today smoke is going to save some lives. He does like the fire drill is great. So a lot of fire talk, anything, anything else in the fire world that you can pull up through your past or what's going on today? Well, not, I mean nothing that's kind of banter worthy. I mean, we had a fire on my block when I was in 3rd grade. Tragedy took three kids lives in there. It was it was crazy. So my mom was always pretty fire safety after that. She didn't want to leave any of us sleeping, you know, like she would leave at 7 and school didn't start to like at 8:15. And I live like a block away. So I could get up at 8:30 or 7:35 and, you know, throw in some clothes and make it.

4:15 But she was like, I'm leaving and you need to be awake and which? Was good. There was a fire like off of 17 a on like some some building or something recently. Do you know what I'm saying? Maybe College Park area like there was something like a a fires have been happening a lot. There was a fire at Taco boy, a kitchen fire. I think they put it wasn't like detrimental 'cause I called for some take out and they were like, they're like, oh, sorry, we're busy right now. And I was like, or there's like, we're not open right now. And I was like, well, you guys should be open. It's like 6:00 on a Saturday. And they're like, sorry, Sir, we have a kitchen fire. It's like, OK, sorry, I didn't mean to be that aggressive person. I was like, I was like, why are you talking to me if you're not open? Like I was a little snarky and she was like, I was like, you should lead with the kitchens on fire. I would totally understand that.

5:01 There's AI was going to say. There's another fire around. We pronounced that Maggie for forever, but if you look at it, it's before I knew how it was spelled Magi Rd. In along Henry Brown that they had to shut down Henry Brown in between like Gay Men's Mall and Red Bank. So. That's crazy fires. Like there was a family recently at Northwood, that house come on fire thing, right? Or something. Like maybe not recent, maybe a couple years ago or something, but it's like fires happen because part of me was like, I've seen these things online. Like I feel like I spent a lot of my childhood learning about stop, drop and roll. Never had to use it, but I guess it's good to know because it happens enough. Right, right. Yeah. It's not stop and stop, drop and roll anymore. What is it?

5:43 You know this? I did not notice. It's stop, drop, cover your eyes and roll. That mean it makes sense, but it doesn't. It doesn't roll. It's telling quite as good. It's not as easy to say to cover the eyes part because I feel like in elementary school it was like we spent a lot of time on that. Oh, this is so funny, Chloe so literal, especially when she was younger. She's gotten better. We've just abused her some. I'll give you some examples. Like one time we were in Arkansas. We were going from Jill's parents' house to my parents' house, And we're going to stop by this restaurant that's in Bald Mob called the Bulldog. And we're like, and Jill's like, hey, do you want to eat there or eat on the road? Go ahead. And and I'm like, we can eat on the road. And she starts bawling, like we can't eat on the road, get hit by a car, That's great. So stuff like that.

6:31 But this was when her and Anna, I got pictures of this night. Diana Globker was teaching and they had some hot chocolate. It was Christmas, it was winter. They went outside. They are dressed like shepherds and stuff. And they had like some candles there and Diana's little sleeve, she got caught in the candle fire and caught on fire. And Chloe was told her about it and she just got some hot chocolate and I'll sit and put it out. But Chloe was really concerned because she came in like that night. She was like, mom, dad, miss Diana's clothes caught on fire. She stopped.

7:12 She was already dropped because they were sitting on the ground. She's like, but she didn't roll. That's hey, they drill it into you so much. I was like in elementary school, instead of doing that, we should say like W twos tax dependent, like just teach me things I can use, you know, start that at a young age. Well, a lot of fire bans are worked out. Oh, yeah, that's good. We didn't. We didn't really know what we're going to talk about. But fireworks, Well, you know what? Fireworks. Oh. What? What When I I always get fired up like everyone else about apologetics. Who doesn't love? Apologetics. I mean, now you're speaking my language well. Let's go ahead and let's take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level.

8:04 Well, I was, I was thinking the other day, Michael, I'm just happy that we all just appeared. Yeah, just popped out enough I'm. I'm just glad that I can rest, rest in that. Does apologetics have anything to say about that kind of thing? Yeah, it just popped out of existence from nowhere. Yeah. So I thought that maybe I had mentioned to you maybe like once a month we would maybe take up one of these apologetic arguments. I'm a classical apologist. Sorry, Cordell, we've not talked about the difference really between classical and presuppositional. I know that was a request. By what standard? That's all you have to. Say by what standard? You win, you win the argument every time. We also, if you're listening, feel free to chime in.

8:45 We should have some word that's like we should have something that's like Thursday apologetics, but it's like a that they're worth a tea. I don't know how you do that, like a Thursday something. It might not. It might be. Impossible, but we can figure it out. Maybe crowd sources. So that's right, Yeah. Come up with a name for our. Apologetics month. Thursday Tomists. Yeah, there we go. There we go. So, you know, I thought maybe, you know, I have a master's degree in philosophy with an emphasis in apologetics. It was really important to me. So maybe we would spend, you know, we didn't want to do a whole series on apologic street, but we could maybe pick up some topics. And so as a classical apologist, you know, one of the main things, you know, we kind of see things broadly in two steps.

9:28 First step, establish that God exists. Broad second step, you know, establish who Jesus Christ is along with the authority and the reliability of the New Testament, because those things kind of go in hand in hand. And so, you know, kind of one of the foundational arguments for God is existence is the cosmological argument. And there's different forms of that. So cosmological arguments in general, they're a family of arguments that kind of really talk about, you know, basically we look around at the cosmos and there's some splaining to do because how did the cosmos get here, right? And so the particular version that's been most popularized of late is the Kalam cosmological argument.

10:14 Cool. Cool word. It's. I'm so glad it didn't have, like, some stupid name. Wouldn't that be terrible? Yeah. Well, so that it's named after this Muslim philosopher from a long time ago who I don't know if it's his name or if just that's how they that how they spoke about it, but it's been really popularized by William Lane Craig. There are other cosmological arguments out there. There's the tomistic arguments that are kind of all cosmological. Your boy. Yeah. Your other boy, Greg, Coco and. Yeah. And Thomas Aquinas, he'll argue from motion, he'll argue from causation, argue from contingency. And then probably we should, I wouldn't want to spend necessarily a whole podcast on any of those 3, but he does take an Aristotelian argument about potential and pure existence, and he argues from that back to a creator.

11:08 And that is an argument that we should probably look at at some point on. These Thursdays, let's let's hit it. Leibnitz also had a, I mean a cosmological argument. It was based on contingency as well. And Leibniz would basically grant to you that, OK, let's say the universe is eternal. Even if you had an eternal chain of of contingent links in that chain, that whole chain still has to have an explanation. That's how he's basically going to argue. Makes sense. Yeah. So. But the Kalam does not assume an internal universe. He's actually going to suppose that there's a beginning. And so maybe we should just get into the, we already talked about the origins, Al Kindi and Al Jazali, and then as I mentioned, kind of revived by William Lane Craig. William Lane Craig and his studies saw this and was really intrigued by it and then wrote a book about it. All right, So any argument that we're going to make, we could sit here and talk about reasons and we could kind of just have a conversation about it.

12:17 But any good, you know, argument that's philosophically sound, you should be able to put into, you know, Step 1, premise 1, premise 2, premise 3IN and then come to a conclusion. Now, I think all the ones that we're going to do are syllogisms, which is a special type. It just really has two premises and then one conclusion. But the first premise is whatever begins to exist has a cause. Second premise is the universe began to exist, therefore the universe has a cause. Yeah, that that's, that's a good question for you. Maybe we'll get into it a little more. It seems like, I don't know if this is more recent or not, but it seems like everyone basically says the universe had a cause through science or whatever. Like there was a starting point and it expands outward. Yeah.

13:06 And so that, that is a good, a good thought there because the scientists are going to say the universe had a beginning and they're going to call that The Big Bang. And, and some of your scientists, when they're just talking by themselves, they'll, they'll use those terms. But when they're kind of guarding turf because they know what that might lead to, then they'll start hedging on that somewhat. They'll say, well, our equations get us back to like so many trillionths of a second before the beginning and then they breakdown. But really, you know, if we look at all our science and we kind of rewind the clock because we see things expanding and it's like, well, if we rewind the clock, things contract, contract, contract. Contract at some.

13:56 Point. At some point there has to be a beginning. In fact, the term Big Bang was a derisive term at first. I believe it by Hoyle, one of the astronomers, when they found the blue shifts redshifts. Yeah. And he was like, and it was like, oh, what was it, a Big Bang that caught on? Oh yeah, yeah. Because he didn't like it, because up to that point, before we observe the expansion of the universe, it was just commonly assumed that the universe was eternal, that it always existed. And so then that led to this beginning. Now, why have I spent a lot of time? And I know probably some of our listeners are young Earthers. I'm an old Earther. But we can. We don't have to agree on how old the universe is, to agree to say the universe began to exist.

14:40 And we should use that as a tool in our toolbox when we're talking to people. I I like that. So if we're starting at premise one, kind of looking at these different premises, whatever begins to exist has a 'cause you know, if I look around my everyday life, it makes sense for a lot of things even, you know, if I'm looking at this kitchen wasn't always here, someone built it. I look at my siblings, they weren't always there. You know, it, it kind of that kind of tracks in my mind. Yeah, and I think it does track with an everyday experience. So it's kind of the raw assumption. Now some people will say, OK, well then, what's God's cause?

15:21 Yeah, 'cause some people might be like, OK, we'll grant that, but we got to keep infinitely granting that. But then what I would say to that is to someone who said that, well, maybe depending on who they are, but if it was like a an atheist in a debate or something, I would say something like neither one of us believe that God began to exist. You don't believe God exists at all. And I believe God was eternal. So that's the question. Like God does not fall prey to this premise because this premise specifically says things that begin to exist. So if you have something that's eternal, that's always there, it doesn't. It can be its own explanation for its cause, like it is a necessary thing.

16:05 Yeah, you have to grant. You have to grant it that. Yeah, eternality or something like that. Because things, you know, don't generally just pop into existence normally. Even something that might be hard to see, like a storm or something. It's like there's pressure and there's like there are things there. It's not just out of nowhere. Yeah. And there can be natural things like like you mentioned a storm that or there can be a man made things like a bench or something, you know. And so maybe there are some natural processes that made metal or metal ore and we fashioned nails from there. And that had a cause. And we could talk about, you know, we've talked about in the past the four efficient causes or the four types of causes. But, you know, the table at one point in time there was, it could, OK, now it's a table.

16:51 It began to exist. And then we could talk about it's a material 'cause it's efficient, 'cause it's, you know, final cause and formal cause, all those types of things. Yeah. OK, so I, I feel pretty good. Premise one seems like it resonate with that. Whatever begins to exist has a cause. Premise 2, the universe began to exist. We touched on it. It seems like if you do the equations and expanding, you can kind of come back to a starting point. At least you know theoretically. Yeah. And so if if you talk to William and Craig, he would say that since like the 1920s or 1930s, because the universe having a beginning, an absolute beginning is so distasteful to science.

17:31 Cosmology has spent 100 years trying to get around the beginning. And so we've had, you know, the expanding and contracting universes. We've had universes that rebound or now we're into the multiverse. Yeah. And they're, they're trying to get around this beginning. Have they found like those models just don't work like can? I mean, I know, I don't know if they have enough data to like make like look at it, but they they're like, oh, the math just doesn't math with the rebounding stuff. That, yes, there's not enough like you can make a lot of rebounds, but eventually that's that's there has to be a beginning. And William Lane Craig will often quote this bored Gutha Lankan theorem.

18:12 Is is sorry, I was just thinking it's so funny. This is not Greg Cochle. So sorry to derail us. Be great if like Greg Cochle has like a cochle guy that he always it's like the the uncaused. It's like the IT keeps. There's a cause behind the cause. Anyway, carry on. Sorry. Yeah. So William and Craig will talk about the Borguth, the Lancome theorem. And this gets a lot of, you know, atheists will accuse him of misusing it. But if you look at it, he's not misusing it. It basically says that any universe that on average expands over its existence cannot be past complete. So that means that that scientists speak of saying it can't go on for forever.

18:53 It has to have a stop. And so then it has to have beginning. Now Kraus has recently said, well, you could have it go back to the beginning and then another universe shoot off and time is going in the opposite direction. But really, really that is, is just two universes coming from the same standpoint, time going both. You know, it's it's it's not a model that works the other way. The only way to get around that is if you have a boundary condition. Now I know that math is probably not. I mean, you had to take some math. Had to take some math. I'm not not not a whole lot. I think I topped out. I did take some, you know, calc classes but not but not nothing past that. Really. So you've seen like piecewise functions like where you have a function that gets defined one way for this little bit, but then there's a boundary and it gets changed. Man, I hated all this.

19:42 Yeah, yeah, it's, I haven't PTSD, but I remember some I, I, I'm not totally tracking, but I know. Yeah, so so basically Borgwith Lincoln theorem is saying if you have a boundary you can get around this, but then you have to have an explanation for the boundary like why did? You got another problem. Why did it change? Right. So yeah, so there is a lot of scientific evidence. Special relativity, a general relativity, has been verified within, like everything we do just fully verifies it. And if it's true, then our universe had a beginning. Wow, yeah, a lot of good stuff there. Anything else on premise 2 we want to hit? There's a lot in there.

20:24 I don't know what you want to hit, what you don't want to hit. Well, second law of thermodynamics and entropy, it's like, you know, you have whenever we, you know. People don't dispute this either right? I feel like this is like everyone agree. Like the laws of thermodynamics are pretty like there where people generate. Like I went to a Christian School for college, but everyone was like, these are things that happen. Right. Yeah, No one disputes the laws of the second law, thermodynamics, the the slow increase of entropy. But you know, we have an amount of usable energy in our universe right now. That makes sense. If we had an infinite universe, we would already be to the point where we didn't have any usable energy.

21:08 Does that make sense? Yeah, at some point. Yeah, because it's winding down. It's like we have gas in our tank right now. There had to be a point in time when that gas was full. Like if we had, if this car had been going forever, we would not have gas in our car, right? Now no, that that makes sense. It's like every it's got a certain certain amounts. Philosophically, what do we think about this? Yeah, these are a little bit harder to explain, especially in a short period of time. But there's this Hilbert's Hotel that had an infinite number of rooms and you but all the rooms are full. So the question is, if someone shows up, could you add them to it? Could you give them a room?

21:51 This infinite number of rooms, but every single one of them is full? I'm thinking like Hotel California, you can check in. She can't leave. Yeah. Yeah, it turns out you could give someone a room. Like you just say, hey, go to room 1, everyone else go down a room. And so there's like this infinite shuffle, but you can fit someone in. In fact, you could fit if you had a line of infinite number of people, you could fit an infinite number of people into this room. You would just say, all right, first person in line, everyone in your room, just double your room number. So 1 go to 22, go to 343, go to six. And then everyone else, you send them to the odds, you go to 1356. And now I've I have it.

22:34 The the whole point of this is to show the absurdity of an actual infinite. Oh, gotcha that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We can kind of mind game these things, but it is absurd to have an actual infinite number of rooms. And in the same way it's an absurd to think that there's an actual infinite number of days. There has to be a starting point. So all these are kind of saying the same thing in different ways. And just like second law thermodynamics, you know, they're, you can't go past what you got, you can't go the other way either. And it's paradoxical in a. Way right, right. And the infinite regress problem is you can't get to Infinity by adding one. So you can't get to negative Infinity by tracking subtracting 1. So you can't subtract 1, subtract 1, subtract 1 and get just go go back for forever. So it's it's illogical to try to try to traverse an an infinite with single additions or subtractions. All right, so you look at that, you come to this conclusion, the universe then has a cause.

23:30 Then you got to think, you got to think about this cause. You've loses a little bit What what would this cause be like? What kind of properties? Right. And so, so far we have not really talked anything about the Bible or religion. I. Know this ain't precept, I can tell you that much. We have taken things that we can see with our own eyes and concluded to the fact that there must be you know our everyday experience. Things don't pop into existence throughout the cause and when we look at science it looks like our universe had a beginning. From those two things we can say universe has has cause and so we can reason from those like non religious things to some. Religious things, right?

24:12 I see. And a lot of times people will say, well, that's the God of philosophy or that's, that's Aristotle's God, but that's not the God of the Bible. Like one, we're not necessarily trying to get to Yahweh from this argument alone. Like we're just trying to to show that there is a theistic God who exists. But when you consider the implications of this argument, so the universe, it's got time, it's got matter, it's got energy. Like, you know, the potential energy, kinetic energy, you know, the entropy that's winding that useful energy down in order, None of that stuff could exist before this. So the God who created, you know, the cause of this universe would have to be spaceless, like no extensions. That's what we would consider a spirit. You know, we say God a spirit.

25:13 Well, that aligns with the Bible says that God is timeless because time came into existence with creation. And so the Bible tells us that God's eternal, that he's unchanging those those ideas of timelessness, He's immaterial. He's not made out of matter. Like he can't be made out of the stuff that is part of creation because he created that stuff. It's got to be powerful because he brought this into existence. Now, the one thing that the universe doesn't have is a material cause for its beginning. So if you think about that like if I make a. Table you. Have materials. I have materials that I went and got and I fashioned them into a table. But God made this ex nihilo out of nothing, right? Which is a little bit of a mind Bender. So how did God do that?

26:03 We we don't know. He's all powerful. He's got to be personal because this happened. God decided when it would happen, even from eternity, from from the eternal. Now he's like, OK, I decided that this is going to happen and it was a decision. So some of the things that well we got some objection. So unless you had questions about anything that we said there? No, no, I think I think you nailed it good. And I think you nailed the people that aren't fans of classical apologetics or whatever will be like, why don't you just go to Genesis 11 or, you know, it's like you're not necessarily because they would be like, Oh yeah, you can be a Catholic or Islam like, but you're you're if if someone's like, well, I'm, you know, a Muslim, you you would probably have a different set of apologetics to, you know, argue to get to a lot.

26:48 Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. Like you're it's a multi step process. And it's not saying, you're saying you're not saying I'm not allowed to talk about the Bible. You can do both of these at the same time. Yeah, yeah, that's absolutely right. And you can do both. But you know, David in Psalm 19 would say the glory of the Lord declares, you know, the the heavens declare the glory of the Lord day after night that pour forth speech. We don't hear them, but they're saying something. And then Paul in Romans, one would say that we can come to the conclusion that God exists from what he's made. So we are kind of in a sense, we're doing what both David and Paul say we should do.

27:28 Awesome. Yeah, take it away with some of these objections. Yeah, so objection one, maybe the universe caused itself that, you know, even when I was talking about God being eternal, I didn't say God caused himself, but I would say that his cause or his existence is bound up in his essence. And by his nature, He is something that exists, you know, eternally. But when you look at the universe, that does not seem to be one of those things, like one of the things in order to exist eternally, you can't change. Because if you do change, then you fall prey to all the stuff we talked about in infinite regress, right? And so it's good that our Bible says God doesn't change. You know there's no shadow of changing with him, so the universe doesn't seem to fit into something that could be eternal or cause itself.

28:23 I do. I do like the second objections. I'm talking about quantum mechanics because I know nothing about quantum mechanics, but things just pop up and you can't trace the all these corks exactly all over the place. And, you know, people always raise that kind of objection. Yes. So OK, this might be a little bit tougher, but when I've explained space, a lot of us think it's space. Let's think of an ultimate vacuum. Like there's no matter there. There is still a bowl to hold matter there, right? There's something that can hold matter. There's not nothing. Space is not nothing. And from a quantum physics perspective, we would say that's the vacuum energy of the universe.

29:09 So there is energy in the, if I can use the word fabric of space that can allow a proton or an atom or something to exist there. And so out of this vacuum energy, you can have particle pair production, which means I can produce 2 particles of the same nature of obstinate parity. So antimatter and matter, they can pop up and they can collide and go back down into that energy. There are, I think, 1317 different ways of interpreting the the quantum physics equations. Most people go with the ones that make it indeterminate.

29:52 The math is the same. It's like I look at an equation and I say, I think this is what's going on with this equation. You look at the same equation, you're like, oh, I agree with that math, but I think this is what the equation's telling me. There are views of those equations that are completely deterministic, that that's not happening randomly. In fact, there are group of folks who are chemists who have basically produced all the same effects. We see quantum physics using a carrier wave particle system, so that may be like whoo, this is all going overhead, but there are there and that is completely deterministic as well. So if you're interested in looking into those things, you could look into that.

30:40 Some people have also said that gravity caused the universe to come into existence. I think Neil deGrasse Tyson has said that like the laws of gravity, the laws of gravity are part of the universe. So that's just saying that's another way of saying that the universe caused itself. Well, I got one for you. I've watched a lot of Marvel recently, and so I think I found a loophole. The multiverse, that's the that's the secret to getting around all of. This SO multiverse gets brought up for this argument and fine tuning sometimes to try to get away around the fine tuning, but both the multiverse just pushes the question back a layer. The multiverse is still going to fall prey to the Borgoof Thalancum theorem.

31:22 So it OK, let's for the sake of argument grant there's a multiverse it it has to come into being at some point in time 'cause it's not eternal. And so maybe there is this mechanism that is producing these bubbles of universes. OK, we could grant that forsake of argument. I don't know how we could ever know that that's the case. Like how could we get outside of our universe to measure that? But doesn't get around the problem, it just pushes it back and stuff. Because whatever that multiverse generator is, it would also have to have a cause for it its existence. OK. All right. One more objection for you. Maybe like the math, the physics, I kind of understand it. You know, you said this is a personal creator. Why?

32:07 Why isn't it just arbitrary random, or why does it relate to people? Or why is it a personal creator? Well, let me reference one of your favorite movies, Star Wars. Remember, there's a force there. Oh, yeah. And it's just there. Yeah. And it takes a mind, a person to really get the Force to do something that you want. The Force doesn't do anything on its own. And so in the same way, if you just have a force like gravity or some other non natural, non personal thing, it's not you have to be a person to decide to do something. That's what we you know, we talked about a person having intellect, a will and emotions.

32:50 Well, that will is the thing that decides I want to do this now or I want this to be done now. And so since creation was a deliberate act because it couldn't have just popped in by some force deciding to act, then we say it has to be personal. All right, those are four big objections. What else we got on this argument? I don't think that in most of your conversations you may come across someone who has studied this a lot. But I wouldn't wouldn't want someone to walk away from this podcast and go. I just said a lot of things I didn't understand. And I don't know how I'd use that.

33:32 What I would want you to be able to to do is have a good idea of the thumbnail sketch of this and you could just say to someone, how do you think the universe came into existence? You know, everyone agrees that there was a Big Bang. What brought it into existence? You are, without going through premise 1, premise 2 premise in the conclusion, you are basically giving an informal version of the cosmological argument. And I'll say there was a time where I was like kind of doubting stuff. This is like when I was, you know, when I was really becoming, you know, saved around age 16 and 17.

34:14 And I wouldn't have been been able to articulate all that I said then because I've studied this since then. But this idea stuck with me. Like, there has to be an explanation for what is here. And that's all the cosmological, different types of cosmological arguments are saying. They're saying there's stuff here. There has to be an explanation for it. Evolution doesn't do it for you. And even if someone says well, The Big Bang, like well, what caused The Big Bang? Use that as a jumping off point. Like you don't have to run from that 'cause I feel like I grew up in a school that was like, don't say those words, Big Bang it. But it's like that's not a bad thing because you can, you know, justify that. Talk through it. That's good. Yep. So hopefully this has been beneficial to you, giving you a little bit of deep dive into cosmological, the Kalam version of the cosmological argument, maybe some to Mystic Thursday, I don't know. Yeah, there's something there.

35:09 I'm excited for it. Thanks for hanging in there with us. Any last apologetics words you want to impart to our audience? No, not that I can think of. That's all of them I have right now that. Was that was a lot of thoughts. That is our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.