...where we take theology 2 the next level
March 12, 2025

Who is Michael the Arch Angel?

Who is Michael the Arch Angel?
Who is Michael the Arch Angel?
Take 2 Theology
Who is Michael the Arch Angel?

Episode 115


Michael and Zach reinvite Clay Thrower to the show to discuss an interesting theory about the real identity of Michael of Arch Angel. What a great name.


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/I-PLcUXODqI


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/

0:00 All right, you're looking a little sleepy there. Dude, Zach, I'm so sleepy. I just got back from camping for two nights, not sleeping well. I'm I'm I'm dragging. Yeah, well, ever, whether you we're camping or not, we just entered a new phase of our existence. GMT -4 for those who are Greenwich meantime -4 instead of -5 and we call that when you live here Daylight Saving Time. That sounds so wrong. It sounds so. I don't think I've heard anyone say that in my life. I think I've only heard daylight savings this weekend. Yeah, well, that's because everyone gets it wrong.

0:42 So to me. It's easier to put the S on it. Honestly. I think. It probably it just rolls off the tongue. To me this is. My savings time. This is a mature, mature situation where when people say mature, I say maybe that's technically right, but I don't like the way you're talking. I'm going to say mature and then. I've never heard, I've never heard anybody say that seriously. Mature. Like, yeah, you have. You have. Oh, I have. It's usually an older person who is just trying to be like, they're not, you know, there's doing that. They posh, they're trying. Yeah. And I'm just like, man, daylight savings time is what I say to that. Yeah. Because you posted this on Facebook. I did. I did last night. I was like hey it's because I saw someone else post and it was a meme so they didn't type it out but it said it was written out daylight savings time and it's just as like fingernails on a chalkboard for me. I'm like it's it's not savings time it is daylight saving time. My favorite part time that saves daylight. I, I, you know, I.

1:43 Constant time is the. Technicality, I get it. This is my favorite part though. Michaels Lake at dinner, I guess with my mind. Your chicken, you know, fettuccine and you're like, scroll and be like, hey, what's up, Lydia? And you're like, Oh my goodness, you flipped the posse. You're like daylight saving time people. And I can appreciate that. I like that 'cause I think, I think I was trying to think of some things like that that bother me And there are a lot. They're not coming to me right now. Like things like that, where it's like, oh man, you're not, you're not saying it correctly. And, and a lot of people, I don't know if you probably don't deal with this, but maybe do, people will just put EST at the end of like, you know, for me, 'cause I work in a world of. Different.

2:27 Of 24 hour clocks, people will be like 1400 EST and they'll put that in the summer and I'm like we're not in EST right now, we're in EDT, we're in Eastern Daylight Time. So you can't you just be rolling out the EST and don't? Don't just let's PSA, don't just roll out the EST. I'm talking to you. Well, we were working with a contractor in Arizona and you may or may not know the whole state of Arizona does not abide by daylight saving time. So they stay on what would it be Mountain Standard Time the whole time. And so we get this, this e-mail setting up and it and it wasn't. And it was like, hey, we're going to have this meeting at 1100 EST.

3:08 And I was like, did he really mean EST? The people in Arizona need to know whether it's standard Daylight Time because we're in Daylight Time. And I was had to go back was like, hey, John, you said EST. And I hate to be pedantic, I hate to be that person, but we got people who are in Arizona. Did you mean Eastern Daylight Time? He's like, what do you mean there's a difference? I was like, yes, there's a difference. That's the same. That's why Trump just needs the executive Order it all the way. Yeah, yeah, I'm fine. Let's just take a whole one the. Whole country needs to get away. With just like as long as we don't swap like, yeah, I prefer this one, but I'm fine with standard. Just put us. In one and leave. Well, isn't it? And there's more than one state that does it differently. Right? There is.

3:49 There is a state that does it, like halfway down the middle. Yeah, dude, that's tricky. Honestly, I'm going the other way. Let's have more changes at the times. I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding. I've never met someone. Who likes? I don't think it was a state, it was a city that because it's like half of the city is on I. Heard this. And one side and half the city is on the other side. And Brent Hanson, do you know who Brent Hanson is? He had a jig in one place and it crossed the time, the dateline, maybe it was in Indianapolis or some, I don't know, and he didn't realize he was losing an hour going that direction and he was almost late. So anyways. Wow, yeah, I got, I got fired up. You, you look so tired that I decided to bring. Whoa, we got another.

4:31 I mean, that has to be my thing, right when I come on the podcast. I love it. Can you further everyone at home? What what number podcast? What number energy are you on? Like for you personally, like cataloging? I'm I need to double check but I'm pretty sure I'm over 750 now. Wow, you're almost to 1000. Yeah, I'm not. So it's going to take a while when I buy some from my like since I drink 1A day like the I try to save as much money by buying a bulk. So I'll buy those from Amazon, but when I go try to find the new ones I'll have to buy them individually. OK, so there's just 750 different energy drinks floating all around there's. More than that, those are the ones I found. Yeah, Can I give you some caffeine, Michael? I know you.

5:13 I'll. Take a little bit and. This one has the extra little an extra. Little ingredient for you. What's the extra ingredient? This has beta alanine. What is that? So this will make you tingle potentially a little bit. It's great. Homo Cardiologist doesn't watch this podcast. I mean, I think, I think you'll be fine because I think, I think the beta alanine is supposed to increase blood vessel dilation. I think increase blood flow to muscles to help them sustain later. All I know is it tastes really good. And. Doesn't it? It tastes like a Jolly Rancher. It tastes like a jolly. Just like a jolly. Sport and fitness can't be bad for you. I mean, yeah, honestly. Sport and fitness has got to be good. We talked about this last podcast briefly, but we were like churches should test, you know, pastors for like PEDs performance, dancing, drugs in case they had like a great.

5:58 Surge that, yeah. Maybe they need to test us after this podcast. Be like that beta out. It was unfair how great Clay was on that podcast, 'cause he was, you know? Can we say this like with, with with with Tim's clicker performance we give it was a pass. It was all your fault there, Michael. You should have. You should have fixed it. I know, I know. And he said Michael over and over and over again. I like it. Segway. Segway. Can before you Segway it. OK, OK, in his defense, I don't know what happens in these times. It seemed like. I mean I don't know what he did but it's like one time he clicked a button and it was like 15 slides later. Press in hell. Or is there is there a skip to end button maybe? I don't know. But then Ethan was trying to help him in the back.

6:38 I was like, don't, don't do that. Like just he yeah, you're going to make it worse because you're all going to be fighting against each other. I was like, just let him find it where he wants to be. I think it because when Pastor holds it up, like he will hold up because it is just an RF signal from there. And he was like trying to do it, you know, behind the TV screen or something like that. You know, I believe he's getting blocked. I was going to say, I appreciate someone getting up there in a little flair. We should do more like behind the back clicker points up top. We just need a better technology because I think that adds something to the sermon. There's something there. Think about the the one on the chin was was good though, doing it for a good He did it for a good 60 seconds. It was on. It was on the chin for a good 60 seconds. But back to your segue.

7:21 Oh yeah, yeah. So every time it didn't, he said. Michael I wasn't even sitting at the you know, there's three spots in the booth, sound person, video Switcher in the slides. And I do occasionally pick up slides, but normally it's sound. I hate doing video. I will always put clay there if I can put someone there other than me. I don't play your nature. But yeah, so every time you didn't click, you'd be like, oh, Michael, Michael. So yeah, good segue to our our podcast today. We're going to be talking about Michael, who is like God statement or question. Wow. Yeah, hang on to your seats as we get on the podcast. Clay, start us off. Let's take it to the next level.

8:09 From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next. Level Michael the Archangel. There's a a ton of biblical text on on him. Yeah, I like my favorite 1 is where he rows the boat ashore. Hallelujah. The classic, the classic. I I just say that because it's something we were talking about a little bit before the podcast, but it's something everyone knows. Michael the Archangel, no one doesn't know him, but people don't know a whole lot beyond that, myself included, Really have not thought more deeply until our good friend, my Tesla brother Clay brought it to brought to attention, talked about more and I and like I'm, I'll, I'll just say right now I'm like undecided, but I just haven't thought that deeply about Michael before and seen some of these connections, which are pretty cool. Yeah, I I listen to a podcast again by my favorite guys, Blurry Creatures and I Whoa.

9:11 Whoa, whoa, whoa. Second guy, sorry, second favorite podcast. I apologize. I want to get asked back on, so I'm going to, Yeah, I want to make a correction, but I thought it was super interesting and I sent it to Michael and I. Thought it was interesting too. Yeah, I, I, it's not, it's just, that's something that I just love about that podcast is they bring up topics that aren't really ever discussed or I had never really heard of before. And I think it's, I think it's neat kind of looking through the scripture and looking at Michael and how he's described and, and what he could potentially be and, and the, and the, and the scripture. So. Yeah, I'm right there with you. Pretty, pretty amazing. And so the the question that we're going to pose or the question we're going to ask is Michael the Archangel, the angelic representation of Christ.

9:59 And that kind of sounds pretty strong. It's it kind of sounds on its face. Yeah, So what we're not asking is what the Jehovah's Witnesses believe. We're not saying is Jesus a mere creation, AKA Michael the Archangel, the first of creation, the highest of creation, but still creative being. That's not what's on the table here. What we're what's on the table is, is does God the Son have another title? Did he make himself known in another way, possibly through the the the manifestation of Michael the Archangel?

10:41 Sorry, I was thinking my mind glitched because I was thinking I do remember Harold camping. Do you all know Harold Camping? Unfortunately, I knew, yeah. He believed that both Gabriel and Michael were Theophanes. Christophanes. I don't know that that helps us are. They in the. Are they in the same scene at the same time though? So that would be kind of weird. Are they? I think Gabriel just was a messenger to We only know of Gabriel because he brought the word to Mary for sure, and then we suspect it was him for Joseph. Is that right? I thought that one of the verses talks about Michael going to save Gabriel or from something or somebody. OK, well, we should read, I mean, there are only a handful of verses that talk about about Michael the Archangel.

11:25 Three of them are in Daniel, one's in Jude, one's in Revelation. Maybe we should start out by reading those verses. Quick kind of comes around to your first question about, you know, there's a whole, it's not like we get chapters and chapters on Michael. So that is one of the dangers here like, you know, at the end of this. Yeah. You know, we, I don't, I don't know that you could be very firm on on where you stand. Maybe Clay could be I I don't know that I could be very firm on this. But because I, I guess it has something to do with owning a, a Tesla. These these verses are in from the ESV, not the NASB and we'll just, we'll just roll with it.

12:06 I. Like it? You're speaking my language. I like ESV. Do you like ESV? I love you. Do you like Teslas? Another high 5. I love it, well I do. You guys might already have your bibles turned to this first reference as well, but maybe talk about Michael as the Prince of Israel. Yes, yeah. So Daniel 1013 says the Prince of the Kingdom of Persia withstood me 21 days. Now you may be asking, who is the Prince of the Kingdom of Persia? But Michael, one of the chief Princess, came to help me, for I was left there with the kings of Persia. To me, this is a good starting verse because I think this is where most people, myself included, I'm like alarm bells are going off.

12:56 If Michael's the guy, if Michael is if Christophany, it's weird that he's one of the chief Princess, but there's there's another way. What I'm obviously this has been addressed, is this like a translation issue or like that could that could mean or I guess we were talking it could factually. Is the chief, then he's also one of the chief. It's what you or maybe it's a way of speaking. Like, I think if you were to come down hard, you might say, you know, sometimes there's an understatement in Hebrew, in hyperbole. I don't know. I don't. I don't remember Doug Van Dorn addressing this. I don't think he specifically addressed this, no. I think he talks about how there's other verses in the Bible that call Jesus the Prince of Princess and the King of kings. So it it could be something like that. The chief Prince is the Prince of Princess. And I was trying to think, you know, you read in a place like Colossians or something to say Christ is the first born of all creations.

13:51 It's like a weird phrase, but it really speaks to preeminence. It's it's not it's not saying he was So I don't know the, you know, Hebrew or anything like that. So that's to me, that's like the one thing I kind of want to work with and understand better. But anyway, first, first place we we see and then a couple chapters later Daniel 12 verse one we read at that time shall arise Michael the great Prince who is charge of your people. And there shall be a time of trouble such as never has been since there was a nation till that time. But at that point your people shall be delivered. This is a long first, first everyone whose name should become written in the book. But the point is, looking to this time, at the end, Michael, this great Prince will will be there.

14:33 Well, and there's another one in in chapter 10 as well. 10. 21 But let's let's stick with 12 one that you just read because some people would say this links Michael with the resurrection, which would give you some clues that it is Yeah, well, who would call Christ today Jesus the Messiah? So that that would be, you know, 1021 says. But I will tell you what is inscribed in the book of truth. There is none who contends by my side against these except Michael your Prince. So. So Daniel, Daniel sitting, Michael Heavy.

15:15 That's a big you know, one of these big books where you see Michael Michael a lot. Any any other commentary on these Daniel passages that sees great chief Prince, Obviously, you know, big deal, a lot going on protecting doing these kind of things. But anything else before I keep moving on? Well, I don't know, this might be further on in the notes, but I think that one of the things I liked about that aspect of Michael, the physicality of Michael as the Prince of Israel is that is that there's a physicality. Other times where there's a Christophan, he is I think we talked about is the Angel of the Lord. You know, the Angel of the Lord led and protected the Exodus, you know, and that I think that's a clear Christophany because it accept he accepted worship from the Israelites and so.

16:06 So he's either the Angel of the Lord or a bad Angel. He can't be a good Angel. Except worship, yeah. And so I think that I think that if you know, there's, there's other places in the, in the Bible that there's many names of God, there's many names of Jesus. So Michael could be one of the names, just another name of Jesus like the Angel of the Lord was. Michael could have been as well. Yeah, that's really interesting. You see all these different different names and most people are not divided on an Angel of the word. Like we were saying it's Angel don't like mentioned like 60 plus times like explicitly and probably pronouns that would. So that's probably the issue with Michael. It's like, oh, I wish there was like a few more things, but it's not out of the realm of possibilities.

16:48 Yeah, because what? Say it again, what? What's Michael mean? Who is like God? Who is like God? So I mean, it's like a name. And it's also like, who is like God, you know, So like some of that kind. Yeah, when I was young girl, I was all about that because I was like, Oh yeah, Oh my God. But then I was like, well, probably it should be a question for me, you know, like, like, you know, question like, is there anyone like that? Clearly, there's not anyone. Like, it's like a rhetorical question. But, you know, like you said, Daniel could be referring to this Prince who is like God, who is like God, like, you know, it's hard. It's hard to be dogmatic for me. But it seems like the hints are there. Well, also I think another point, you know, you know, based on based on I guess how I'm speaking, I'm pro, I think Michael is a Christophany. Is that the Prince of Israel?

17:38 There's there was probably 1 like why you know, if, if if Jesus the, the inheritance was given to Jesus and Israel was his and you know Israel's gods like I don't think there would be multiple Princess over Israel. Yeah, because it sucks that Michael's one of the chief Princess, but you would go back to that passage and Deuteronomy or something like that that talks about all of these Princess. Yeah, I was just looking that up. It's like. 32. 32, yeah. Yeah. But yeah, so maybe we should briefly talk about the watchers the the word that is used. Is that an Enoch? That's an Enoch, but it's also in the Bible one time. I think it's also in in Daniel.

18:23 I think it is. Daniel, Yeah. But and this wasn't, this was how I grew up. Like it wasn't like it was like Thunder dawn. But you know that when we went through Daniel, we talked about it. Basically we were taught that it seems clear that different geographical regions of the earth have maybe a good Angel and a bad Angel. That's we just call them angels. Maybe, you know, if you want to get specific, because there are orders of non physical beings, we might use the term the Enoch or the Bible uses watchers kind of like a higher level non visible being. I'll try to not because Angel just means messenger.

19:05 So we know like Gabriel was an Angel, he was a messenger. And we sometimes people think of Gabriel as an Archangel, but it might be that he's one of the lower level angels and it is just a messenger. And so the idea is, you know, if you had the Prince of Persia where Daniel was, who was like, who was like holding Daniel, like not not allowing this other messenger to send this message. Michael has to come in and like, say, Prince Persia. No, we're going to let this message. In are there alternate views on like what the Prince of Persia is there like another like oh, it's just like a a demon that was like trying to help Persia or is it pretty universally like geographically Prince here I I haven't heard like other explanations.

19:50 Before, yeah, I would. Assume there are other explanations, but I haven't heard them. I mean, I think that there's I think they just is it. I think it's in Daniel too. They describe like in great detail, like some of the attributes of the of this being or other beings like this, and it seems very angelic and and type like not. I don't know how you would describe it as like a person or, you know, you know, and not to go against something that you said. I think, I think Angel, I think we a lot of people just use Angel to describe spiritual beings. Any and I think that even saying spiritual being. I don't know if that's also a good representation because I think that there's a physicality to what we deem as a spiritual realm. You know it. I don't. I think saying non physical also might not be 100% accurate because because there's there's plenty of times in the Bible where the angels did physical things. They were physical places.

20:39 They went, they went places. I think this one was even hindered by the Prince of Persia or whatever. Like there's physicalities are going on. I just think we, I think that sometimes, like you hear Angel, you always think the same thing. But you know, I think there's a hierarchy that we don't know. Like I think in the Bible talks about seraphim and cherubim and angels and demons. And like, I think there's a lot more potential hierarchy in the spiritual realm than than what we we hear about or think about. You get just that hint too, with like rulers authority or like you like you like don't know what the hierarchy is, but sometimes it's like, it's like. Principalities. Principalities and powers. Like a principality means ruler, a ruler over over something physical like.

21:20 So yeah, there's that too. I just feel like the Prince of Persia in this, you know, got like the the whoever is supposed to be coming to Daniel, like in an armbar or something, you know, and it's like wrestling. Yeah, I do. I do like what you said, Clay, about the physical nature of it because yeah, there it's like it is very confusing to talk about. We don't have great categories for it. Yeah, I, I don't know, like maybe and maybe that is anthropomorphous. It will. For us to understand but there is something that we don't understand about how they. Work. Sorry. I think. I think you're right too. I was just trying to think like, I don't know, it's like, yeah, the Angel of the Lord is like sitting under a Myrtle tree or something, or you know what I mean? It's like.

22:02 We wrestled with Jacob. And we wrestled and so it's like some of that and but then this not so. But I know what you're saying. This could be, this might not be like, oh, it was like WWE and we're jumping from the top rope. It's like it might be like different than that. Right. Well, yeah, just to be clear from what I'm saying, when we see angels like the three angels that show up to Abraham and Sarah, one of them is the Angel of the Lord and he cooks for them. Clearly they have taken on a physical manifestation for our world. And I'm not discounting that at all. Clearly physical. When the Angel of the Lord wrestles with Jacob, then to soon to become Israel physical. So yeah, definitely I'm just saying, and I don't know, like it seems like we don't fully understand that spiritual realm. Do they use physical language so that we can kind of understand it or is it truly fit some type of different phys physicality? I don't know, maybe we don't know yet. So I think it's maybe a.

22:57 Nice question. We could get into like a more scientific discussion about I've heard I've heard it discussed like there another, it's another dimensional dimension. Like if you I've heard the analogy, like if you if you look at a 2D object and you know S3D beings, we know what that is. But if you look at, you know if it's. A 3D doesn't understand 3D. Right. And it's kind of it could be the same thing. They could be a 4th, 5th so. There's a tesseract dimension. Multi multidimensional. OK, alright. He's now he's tracking. That's good. But Dad, you said words. I don't know what they mean. Let's keep moving along on the outline where I'm, I'm, I'm, I don't know. I don't skip over anything. Where were we at? Well, we read through, well, we read through the Old Testament passages of Michael and we probably should read through the New Testament and then maybe go for the arguments to pro and against.

23:46 Does that sound good? I love it so that we have one reference in Jude and I think this one kind of cuts a little bit against it being Christ. But it says, but Michael the Archangel, when he disputed with the devil and argued about the body of Moses, did not dare pronounce against him a railing judgment, but said the Lord rebuke you. I mean, I think if you were, you know, strong that it is Christ, you'd be like, well, he's just saying, you know, my father rebuke you. It does seem odd that you know, if he is God the son that he would have to say the Lord rebuke you. But you know, there's that, that passage. And then lastly, Revelation 712, seven through 9 says now war arose in heaven, Michael and his angels fighting against the dragon, and the dragon and his angels fought back, but he was defeated, and there was no longer any place for them in heaven.

24:43 And the great dragon was thrown down, the that ancient serpent who is called the devil, and Satan the deceiver of the whole world, he was thrown down to the earth, and his angels were thrown down with him. Perfect I am. I think I'm on. I think I have the wrong outline of them. I'm trying to find this. Here do you have the one that says Michael Mechazdeck in Christ? Let's see. I do. I'm just I'm missing. We're are we? I'm at the. I'm at the top. We're not at the. Top anymore. Yeah, yeah, we're at the top. I was on another. I was on the one that Clay gave us that just had all the verses. Gotcha. Sorry, sorry. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

25:24 All right. So given those verses, what I did, what any self respecting Bible scholar would do, he would have a long drawn out argument with you at GPT club it and then have ChatGPT summarize an argument. So that's that's is the outline that we we have here. I do. I do that often. So here we go. So these were some of the things that ChatGPT and I discussed, and they're going to fall in line with what was on the podcast, clearly. So the question is, is Michael the Archangel, the angelical representation of Christ? Like is it Christ by a different title where I read those key verses?

26:05 Daniel 1013, Daniel 12 one. That's why you skipped Daniel 10. 21 Oh yeah. Yeah, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. So so we could consider this, is Michael protecting Israel also aligning with Christ's role as the King of Israel? One place calls him the Prince of Princess and the Shepherd of Israel. So all kind of sharing that same role that Michael the Archangel had that we saw there. That's good. Also I see here when you I think he made this pointless guy, whatever his name was in the podcast was like sons inherit things like that was the the sonship was an important part of his argument too, which I thought was a pretty pretty interesting argument. On the other side of things, Michael is called a Prince whenever a king.

26:54 I don't I don't think that's a good opposing argument. Whereas Christ is explicitly cling. I guess that explicit connection, I don't know, I'm not to me, I'm like that. That's not a good. Opposing argument. I mean, the Princess eventually become kings, right? Yeah. So I, I don't, I don't know what chat's what chat was thinking there. I guess he was looking for that one to one connection. The word Prince in Hebrew often refers to high-ranking angels, not divine beings. Again, I don't think that's a great, great one because this is a a unique situation. You know what I mean? And then I think this is a good one to to talk about Hebrews one separate. The whole point is really pushing back against Christ being an ordinary Angel that obviously we're not saying Michael be an ordinary Angel, making it unlikely that he would be called one of the cheap Princess. Even that might be technically right. It'd be weird to say Michael's in the top 10. Why wouldn't you say, oh, this, you know, he's better than that, but.

27:48 But that could also go against kind of what we were saying earlier, is the hierarchy of things like he's not an Angel, he's not a messenger, but the Prince is the angelic or the spiritual Princess. These beings are higher than the. Angels there. It's like one of these 10 kings of the earth or something is what they. Say the 70, the 70 that were put over the nations in Deuteronomy. And just for reference, here's that Hebrews passage. It says for to which of the angels did he ever say, you are my son today I have begotten you and again I will be a father to him and he shall be a son to me. So that those that's that's clearly no mere Angel rises the level as Christ. So I think that's a strong verse, but I think Chet kind of misunderstands Clay because we're not saying he's a mere Angel.

28:38 We're saying that maybe he manifested himself in an angelic form as one of these supreme watchers over Israel. Yeah, I think because what you're saying to Clay is like it, it it, it easily could have said the Prince of Persia, one of the chief Princess. It would just be the same kind of disclaimer for everyone who's in that in that certain role. All right, moving on. Christ as king of Israel probably don't have to look too far or that's probably not sounding like a weird, a weird claim. You know, John one talks about this. Nathaniel calling out to Jesus, calls Jesus the son of God, the king of Israel. We see something very similar in Matthew 21, that Jesus is the heir of Israel.

29:21 And I guess the argument goes like this. If Jesus inherits Israel, Michael's the Prince of Israel. Like you were saying, Clay, this suggests that you know there's same thing, maybe different rules. Principle I think multiple Princess would be weird, like over the same place like. Well, then we do have Prince Henry and Prince William, right? Both of those. And you have the artist formerly known as Prince Different. Prince and of Bel Air. So that guy was fresh. So that's well done. So then opposing arguments. This again, these were chats opposing arguments. So these this is not what I came up with myself.

30:02 It would be nice. And I'm assuming Chad is pulling from other sources. So maybe there's some theologian who wrote something like this, but maybe chats thinking on his own, I don't know. A Prince serves a king. Michael is Israel's garden, but Christ is its ruler. So this idea that there's this hierarchy and we're talking, we're talking about a Prince or a SAR being a high Angel, but not necessarily a Prince like a Prince graduating to a king is one way to look at that. And if Christ is the unseated son of the uncreated Son of God, not one of many angelic principles. Kind of going back to what you were saying as one of many. Yeah, and that that Prince King argument, I don't think I think that's a super strong argument.

30:49 I think I think some of this is confusing too, just like, you know, if there's God the Father, God the Son, I think you can read into that and be like, well, there's a father son, so there's less authority with the Son or something like that. You know what I mean? I think you could erroneously kind of think that way. It's a different category than we're used to sometimes. Yeah, the the Trinity with the Father, Son, Holy Spirit, like all being the same, all being different. Like the Prince of Israel, the king of, you know, Israel, like all being the same but different. Potentially there could be some parallels there too. That, that, that's interesting. Next point, Christ's return and the archangel's voice. Again. If you're in Christendom almost at all, you know, there's gonna be the voice of an Archangel.

31:32 It's gonna be like booming like a, it's like, I don't think that is very, that's not something that people are like, well, I've never heard that before. Very, very common. First Thessalonians 416 says the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the Archangel and with the trumpet of God. So this would fit very nicely. You know, if these were the same things that that would kind of work itself out. Yeah, it almost seems like, you know, chat wanted in my conversation, wanted to push that these were three separate things. But it almost sounds like it's 3 descriptions of the same thing. You know, it's a shout, it's a voice of an Archangel, it's a trumpet. It's like all those things. Like it's a call to battle. And the trumpets were known for, you know, marshaling troops in on into battle.

32:20 So to me, this sounds like this is all the same thing. Now, is it Christ himself shouting or is it Michael shouting on behalf? That would be the the the back and forth. Yeah, I think you want to say there, Clay. Yeah, I, I think that, you know, and this and this scene also, what we read earlier is that Michael is fighting against Satan. Michael. And you know, I know a lot of people necessarily don't believe the Book of Enoch, but the Book of Enoch also talks about Michael is the one that goes and binds all the watchers that cast them in the shield like this. This is the the. Is that Enoch one or Enoch 2 Enoch? I I believe it's Enoch one, it might be two, but I think it's one when the 200 watchers are bound and thrown in the shield like there, it only takes one arcange. It only takes Michael to go do it. So it's a pretty powerful hierarchy hierarchical. Being always knew, if you got the name Michael, you're pretty. You're pretty high up there.

33:17 You thought that? I always thought the opposite. No, I'm just, I'm just kidding. Obviously very high up there. He was like, great. Name. That's right. Yeah, that's great, Great name. Do we want to hit somebody affirming opposing what house we? Want to talk through those? That's unless you see anything there that's that's new. Now, I think that that makes a lot of sense. Moving on. This is a good test because, again, if you're a Christian, you know, angels say don't worship. No, no, get up, get up. That's like a common thing too, right? John Man had a bad record twice. I think he fell down and angels like, no, get up, get up. Yeah, cool. So let's look at some some of these verses. If you were in Revelation, I just happened to be here Revelation 19 verse 10, like you were saying Michael, then I, John fell down at his feet to worship him.

34:05 But he said to me, you must not do that. I'm a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold to the testimony of Jesus, worship God for the testimony of Jesus. Is the spirit of prophecy something similar later on, later on where angels, if they're good angels, if they're serving the serving Yahweh, they're going to refuse worship. We all know Christ accepts worship as well in the gospels. That's also not a super big surprise and. We know that the Angel of the Lord accepted worship. And and that's big. And so I think a lot of it's Angel of the Lord God the sun. We see this perils clearly because of that too. So the question is, do we see anyone ever bowing down and those versions we read and worshipping Michael? It's just we don't have a lot of text. So it's not saying right, you know, but it's like, man, be nice if like one of those verses that snuck it in there, right? Like Dan is like, oh, and then I worshipped Michael and he accepted it and great, problem solved. That'd be awesome.

34:55 Or I worship Michael and he's like no, give up, I'm a fellow servant either. Wait, it would clear. Either clear it up. But we it's just we don't have anyone trying to worship Michael recorded. So we we just don't know. So all right, divine counsel in Deuteronomy 32 eight. This is the passage we were referring to earlier, talking about the sons of God. Or is it the sons of Israel? Don't know. We don't know. Yeah, well. Please. Like, no, we know. Tell us. Tell us how we know, Clay. Well, the I think the best argument is the Dead Sea Scrolls that were found had had that, you know that scripture that they found it had that part. And it says sons of God, not sons of. Israel and the Septuagint also says sons of God, right? And the Septuagint also does.

35:48 So what was up with those first and 2nd century rabbis change in scripture on us? Do you think it was because they were trying to write out anything spiritual about and and and disclaim Christ? I think Doug brings us up in the podcast and I think it's AI think it's a good point. I think it's it makes sense if they if they were regretful of crucifying God, they're like, OK, we got to cover up this huge wrong that we just did. We accidentally killed the Messiah. We got to fix it like we got to erase everything that that shows that we did the wrong thing. And I think that that I think that this might have just got caught up in that aspect of it. Because Christ references this, right? Doesn't he say and all says you're sons of God, why are you picking up stones?

36:39 He makes some comment. Maybe it's not this first, it's exactly maybe because it's like he calls you gods. Maybe I'm maybe I'm thinking of a different reference, but regardless, so we have this the sons of God and Israel's garden, Deuteronomy 32 eight. Do you return in there? I, I, I am hammering from the ESV so I will read how the ESV reads it. Deuteronomy 32 eight says when the Most High gave to the nations their inheritance, when he divided mankind, he fixed the borders of the peoples according to the numbers of the sons of God. A little footnote. The Dead Sea Scroll compared with that compared Septuagint Masoretic Text.

37:21 Sons of Israel. Yeah. So NASB, this is I think a fault of NASB. They just, they just hold that Masoretic text. They don't look at Septuagint or. I think the NIV might say Sons of Israel too. I think the ESV was one of the few. There's not too many that changed. It changed. It we're not saying that your Old Testament is riddled with errors. Like there's just a handful of these places where they made maybe one, one word changes and you can, you can look them up. They're known to scholars. So you can trust your Bible and it and it's like these obscure things that that they change here and there. I think there's a couple in the Psalms as well that they change. But reading, if you don't mind, let's read verse 9 too, says, but the Lord's portion of his people, Jacob, has a lot of inheritance.

38:07 So that kind of goes to the Michael, the Prince of Israel kind of thing. Like Doug was saying that a lot of people gloss over #9 you know, when it says that there was one given to it, Israel. No, I I am glad that you mentioned that because I remember him saying that but then I did. I never found. And then he glossed over it. And then I glossed over it. No, I never found it's. Because the sons of God in verse 8 is so shocking to so many people, they just don't even think about verse 9. But yeah. So for the Lord's OK, so let's just read it all together. When the Most High give the nation's their inheritance, when he separated the sons of man, he set boundaries of the peoples according to the number of the sons of of God for the Lord's portion is his people. Jacob is the allotment of his inheritance. So I think what you're saying, the argument is these were all separated.

39:05 They're given out to different watchers and Israel was given to Yahweh because that's the, it's the proper name of God there. And so and, and then I would read in Daniel that Michael is the Prince of Israel. So what does it mean for Michael to be the watcher, who's the Prince of Israel and for Israel to be given to Yahweh? Are those the same being with different names that I think it's a compelling? Argument yeah, I think it makes sense. I wish there was like more, but that that when you synthesize some of that there's there's it's not like I think on its face it could sound really weird.

39:46 Michael. Yeah, it's like, no, no, he there are connections here in Scripture where someone says that it's not. It's it's based in, in some really, really strong, strong evidence. I think, I think it's the throwing, I think it's the it's, it's a proper name as it's throwing people off. You know, we, you know, cause 'cause when we with the other places in the Bible of Christophanes or where it's Jesus, like Angel of the Lord, the name of the Lord, like different things like that. It's not a name. I think that us as English Americans, like we, we see this name, we think of individual beings, you know, But when you're when, when it's referred to him as as God, like has multiple names for the same being, when we see the proper name, I think it throws us off. All right, next argument, Christ's superiority over the angels.

40:35 So we see a distinction between Christ and the angels in Hebrews 1. So we already read this one. God never calls any of his angels my Son. No Angel is invited to sit at God's right hand. So if Michael is a title for Christ, then this would not contradict Hebrews 1 because Christ would not be a created Angel, but simply acting in an angelical role or in that realm that the the that the watchers are acting. And this was one of the key opposing things that that Chad just couldn't get over when we were talking. He's like, OK, all right, Chad, but he he's like, I don't think that Michael could be Christ because it says to none of the angels have I, but we recognize Angel of the Lord.

41:23 So I think it cuts against this. Argument that I think that's probably the best one where it's like people see that connection and so it's like a clearly that's a different category. So let's that's a good segue too. Let's talk about the Angel of the Lord and its implication for Michael the Archangel because like I said, there's like 60 verses to talk about Angel Lord that that's all over the place. Like you mentioned some of them Angel Lord appears to Hagar Angel Lord speaks from the burning Bush. I think some people miss miss that Manoa and his wife Samson encounter talks Samson's family talks about the Angel of the Lord and all these times you see this connection when this is God, not a. Mere Angel, Yeah. Yeah. So it's really weird, you know, when the first time I remember hearing this, oh, the Angel of the Lord is Christ. But then you could look at it.

42:10 I think it's overly abundant. That Angel of the Lord is Yahweh, is Christophany. So then it makes this transition to Michael the Arc Angel, and he's the only one that ever has that title. There's no other Angel that has Arc with it, right? Is that right? That's a great question. I think that's right. I think he's the only one. Yeah, so again, you know, like if we had fifty other angels and he was the only one that had that title, then we could be like, Oh yeah, there's clearly something different about Michael. It would, but scripture just does not have a lot of those references. Yeah, yeah.

42:53 I just just back checking us there only place in Scripture so that that does give a little more credibility to the argument too. Yeah, anything else you want to add for this one? Clay I'll, I'll plug Doctor Michael Hyzer's book The Unseen Realms that that was one of my favorite parts of the book is he he spends a lot of time going through the Angel of the Lord, the different names found in the Old Testament, like proving God being the trinitarian or other, you know, shown in different places in physical form or non physical form at the same time in it throughout Scripture. It was it was one of my favorite parts of the book. So. Very cool, very cool. Awesome implications. So like, where does this matter?

43:35 Where is this take us? What's what's the point? What you know, what's all of this mean if in fact the Angel of the Lord is the preincarnate Christ. Like what do we, what do we do with this kind of stuff when it as it relates to Michael? Yeah, this is a good question. There are some angels that are called the chosen angels. We could, you could translate that as the elect angels. I don't know that I subscribe to this. I know that Michael Van Dorn and there was another guest that was on Blurry Creatures. He I think he was all about angels having a redemption plan. So I what I've told my kids in the past is I don't think there's a redemption plan because Christ didn't show up as an Angel.

44:21 This might Yeah, I you know, I struggle for words like because you're just it's really like you kind of get further and further out on supposition like if this is Christ and somehow at the cross or another time he, you know, paid the penalty for angels, then there may be, but we don't have any record of that in the Bible, right. So I wouldn't and I don't know how it affects how I live on a day-to-day basis. And even if Michael is Christ did that fact, although I don't know how it affects me on a day-to-day basis. It's just maybe it helps me understand a little bit more of how God ordered things and how. That's good.

45:05 How things are coming around to, OK, here is this Prince of Israel, he was strong and now not only does he inherit maybe on the physical realm, but he also inherits on the spiritual realm. Maybe there's that going on. I don't know. Anything else that you thought of as practical implications for us, Clay? No, I think that maybe we talked about that once before. Is, is the, you know, some kind of redemption plan for angels? I think that, like you said, that's kind of we're getting really out there, you know, suppositions. Yeah, yeah. And and that doesn't really affect us. Like there could be something. There could not be something. But Jesus coming to save us is what's the most important thing, right? And, you know, it's seeing. I think, I think it's neat seeing him as Michael in other places because Michael's the one that bound Satan or fight Satan. Michael's the one that bound the Watchers, like Michael 5, the Prince of Persia.

45:58 Like that, to me just makes the story more full and more, you know, more detailed, I think. Yeah, that. That's cool. Anything else you have to say? No, I I think you nailed it both you all. Right, so the final conclusion, so this these were chat's highest ranked arguments before and against. So we you get your take from him. So Chad thinks that the best arguments for what we're talking about is Michael is the guardian of Israel. Christ is the king and inheritor of Israel, potentially different roles of the same being. Christ ascends with the voice of an Archangel, which could suggest he speaks as Michael. Daniel 12/1 links Michael's rise with the resurrection, aligning with Christ's role in John 5828 and other places.

46:41 I think maybe Deuteronomy 32 nine would also go up here as one of those the the better arguments for this going on there. Anything to add to those statements? I, I think that I think there's a really good, I'm trying to trying to reflect for me. I'm like, I don't, I would not stake my life on this, but I think there are some good foundational points for what we have. And and then on the other side of it, on the I mean, my biggest concerns were man, that one of the chief Princess just weird reads weird to me. But we discussed there there. That's not like a end all be all Hebrews one, but you know, Angel, the Lord stuff. Those are like my push backs that I originally, but you know, that's not dogmatic either. I think it's very, very plausible. It's just something with there's not a lot of text on it. So we don't spend a lot of time talking about it, but I think I think there's some good stuff there. Are you going to start praying to Michael? That's a no no bueno, no no.

47:39 Yes, I don't think I would reorder my worship or how I'm thinking of Christ based on this. I think it's like, oh, that maybe there's something that we missed there, but like you said, I don't know how huge it impacts. I would say one of my strongest arguments against is the Jude verse where it says, but Michael wouldn't raise a railing accusation against Satan, but instead the Lord rebuke you. That seems odd if if he is God the son and if and if Enoch is right that Michael bound all the other watchers like why wouldn't he bound bind Satan? You know, so I don't know. I don't know. Well, yeah, there's there's speculation that Satan is the one that convinced all the Watchers to do what they did.

48:22 And so he he didn't really do it. He got them to agree to a covenant amongst themselves to to go down and mess and mess with humanity. And so he kind of was like the deceiver to them as well. So he wasn't, he didn't directly do anything, so that's why he didn't. Get bound. Do you know what I just heard? I heard another podcast is coming down the down the Pike. Well, you know, and even. I would love the Book of Enoch I. That's a. That's a fun one. Yeah, and the probably another podcast on Satan. Yeah, that would be. Good. There was some, there was some episodes there that talked about, you know, Satan really isn't a name. It's a title. The accuser. And Serpent has some various meanings to.

49:06 Like tear, like kill every serpent or something. I think it makes her bad. I'm just kidding. Michael likes. Me, I could be wrong, but the Hebrew word is nakash, which I think is more I I, you know, we can get into this more in the future, but it's more of a, a seraphim, a serpent like dragon being not not necessarily a snake, right? Yeah, snakes get a bad rap, right? I don't. Think they get a bad enough rap? And so, you know, there, there are some people, godly people, I think they're godly people who suppose that this title has been occupied by more than one watcher. It's not, it's not the same one. Like there was one and then Baal took his place.

49:46 And so then maybe Baal went and became Zeus or Jupiter. So something like that. That is an interesting discussion. Again, at the end of the day, it's not not going to hugely impact your walk with Christ on a day-to-day basis, but it's but it may be helping you see some things that are hinted at in the Scripture that we don't get all the full fullness of. So. I love it, my clay. Any last things about this topic? Thanks for bringing this to lights. I think it's very, very fascinating. Yeah, no, I appreciate you guys discussing it. I think it's just it was neat to to study and look at so. Awesome. Well, without further ado, close this out my friend. I think that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.