...where we take theology 2 the next level
Jan. 15, 2025

Cartesian vs Hylomorphic Dualism

Cartesian vs Hylomorphic Dualism
Cartesian vs Hylomorphic Dualism
Take 2 Theology
Cartesian vs Hylomorphic Dualism

Episode 99


Listen up! Either Michael and Zach are giving away a new car...or they are discussing the differences between Cartesian and Hylomorphic Dualism.


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/VYc5d5EVTL4


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com

0:00 All right, New Year and I happen to be the worship leader. This the first I think that we were back and I think it happens every year because we go away, we celebrate Christmas in Arkansas with our family there and then I come back and you all have just celebrated Christmas at CBC. But it's like I just need a little bit of closure. So I, I kind of talked a little bit about Christmas and then the new year in there. But say all that to say, we're kind of away, you know, by the time this is going to air, this will come away from Christmas. A little bit, yeah, But I was thinking, what do you, what do you think? We don't never mind. I was like, what are you doing right now? You're probably in the blinds. I'm just kidding. No, no, no. So this will be a week after. So the one that will hit while we're in the blinds will be the new year, the actual New Year's.

0:47 Yeah, yeah. So a week, Yeah. Yeah, 'cause we're leaving soon, yeah. Soon, yeah. We're recording this, Yeah. The Tuesday before we're about to head out in the cold weather, Yeah. Anyway, so. You wanted to, so you kind of got some Christmas gifts, but you also have maybe a not so Christmas gift. If this was not a Christmas gift, my Prius died. I actually really my Prius was a gift for my parents. I don't think he ever would have bought one. But then once I had one for free, I was like this is pretty nice. Got great gas mileage 50 miles a gallon. That thing was I did not make it to 200,000 miles. I was like at 198. I was gonna ride that thing, drive that thing forever. It still. Looked like it was in pretty good condition other than the little the flappy thing that you hit on a bumper but. Honestly the battery was still good. It was like the brakes, some ABS controller, whatever it was like gonna be expensive based on what it was worth. It was a 2013 high mileage.

1:42 So I hear you're like, so we've started playing D&D and some people think that's a cult, but it's not really. But I hear you joined an actual cult. So it's about a cult. Yeah, well, I went car shopping and everything's expensive and I was like, man, I could really splurge and get a Civic or I could just get a, or I could get a Tesla for cheaper. So I, I got, I got a little Model 3 Tesla courtesy of some government tax credits, which was nice, you know, knocking the price down by 4 grand. But it's just, you know, I was just, I was in, I was just in shock. Honda, Honda's retained their value, man. And I was actually going to get a Prius. And then I was like, oh, those are way too expensive. And so I was like, I can get a Corolla or a Model 3 Tesla. I'll try the Tesla.

2:30 Mainly if you talk to Clay Thrower for more than 6 seconds, I just had a million reasons like it'd be dumb not to get a Tesla. He was very, very helpful. I kind of drove his around and he actually went with me to the dealership and we, he was with me. He was, he's the man. Yeah, way better friend than you. He it is super helpful because I do, I do nothing. And then I happened to mention one Wednesday night impact and Steven Bostick's like, you should get a Tesla. And I was like, OK, yeah, he's like, no, it's actually very affordable. And then so I talked to Clay and then that was that was it. So that was big for me. So yeah, the cult of tests. Have like the callback like you can make it come to. See because mine is is inexpensive, it's not full self driving. Honestly the like the auto steer is futuristic enough for me, but it does not do the full and I can't summon it. I can pay for those things, but then it makes it more expensive, right?

3:22 You know, but so. So is that just a service that they turn on remotely? Yeah, they can. I can either subscribe to at $100 a month or you can pay $8000 and get it. But it's something I can buy whenever I want to. And it's if you buy it for $8000, it stays with the car, not with me. So or if I can subscribe to it and then I think. It stays with you. Correct. So yeah, yeah. So it's and they can also. It's crazy. I could honestly, it goes zero to 60 very fast. I mean a lot faster than my Prius and my Honda Odyssey. So it was what I'm comparing it to. But I could like, you could pay for an accelerator for 2000 bucks. They'll just unlock the software. You can accelerate even faster. So they've got like these things locked up, you know, isn't it crazy? I mean, and that makes honestly, that makes sense, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Because you know, instead of they build 1 car, they build it well Yep.

4:05 And then you pay for more features. I mean, that's how software works. Honestly, I've been pleasantly surprised. I'm a little bit too dumb to. But one thing I do appreciate, when you're driving a Prius, no matter how fast you're going, I'm going 10 miles over the speed limit, 10 mph. If they went, we're gonna pass. Everyone's like, oh, it's a Prius and cut you off. People don't cut me off in the Tesla. And you can accelerate a lot faster than Prius. So you can kind of like get where you need to go if it's like an iffy situation. So that's on my end. I heard that you know you're going to be Hibachi Mott in the future here. Yeah, so my, my mother-in-law got my father-in-law, a Blackstone Grill quite a few, quite a while ago. Because I mean, last time we were there duck hunting, I was like, hey, Tommy, you, you want to get it out?

4:50 I'll work with you. And I kind of show you how it works and stuff because I had used some a little bit at our school, you know, for football. And Jill's cousin's husband, Aaron, who lives pretty close. Like you can see their house. From Wow, that's pretty close. Has one and like he was still on it, but he just was not very comfortable with it. So we got it out over Christmas break and I did what was the first thing I did on an I cooked something for US one night. I'm I'm blanking. I'm sure it was oh, it's hamburgers and hamburgers and smash burgers. It's just normal hamburgers. And then a couple days later we did. I did breakfast for everyone. 'S nice. That's so cool. That's nice to do. That yeah, so the fried eggs, you know, the sausage, the bacon, the hash Browns, the works and you know and it's. I need a little bit more not cooking area, but like prep area like something like.

5:40 Because especially if you're cooking for that many people and you know, everything's big, but and then, you know, it's pretty easy to clean up, you know, just. That's like the dream. Yeah, you just spray some water on it, you know, scrape it into that little hole, wipe it down, let it heat back up, put a little oil to season it, let that cook off I need. To get when you're done, man. So we I can't, we came down the day that we were leaving like kind of look, you know, we're always a little bit behind what we want to be. That's just, that's just the Mott way. And they're like, Hey, we're going to give you that grill if if you want it. I was like, yeah, I just want to. And I was like thinking like we're, you know, we had to like figure out how to. Pack you made it work. Stuff, but we made it work so yeah. So now we've been home 4 days and I cooked on it half the time, half the. Day that there's something yeah, I my my girl is like seeing better days I'm I'm like need to be in the market soon but you know maybe maybe I'll get one of those but I'm trying not to spend money.

6:33 So, but yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Just get get get Leann's father to give you 1. I mean, that's your. Honestly, great idea. William's birthday is Friday. Get her a grill. That's right. That's right. That's right. All right. So Thursday episode. Thursday episode, a topic that I think most people are just they're dying to learn more. About this topic, what's funny about it is that well, we'll get we'll get into it. I'll, I'll, I'll intro it. This is my take on it that you I did not run by you. So this will be good. So let's go ahead and take it to the next level from the hearts of the low country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level.

7:26 Michael, I got some bad news, man. Let's hit me with it. I couldn't sleep last night. I it's, it is just heart wrenching. William Lane Craig, man, he has, he's gone over to the dark side. He was a hylomorphic duelist, and now he's a Cartesian duelist. I don't know if he was ever a pure hylomorphic duelist, but he has come out and showed his cards to be a Cartesian duelist. Wow. Yeah, and if you're anything like me, this means nothing to you in the same way it meant nothing when Michael's like. Here's the notes for the next 1. So explain yourself, Michael. Yeah, so I'll just preface all this by saying when I was getting my masters in philosophy, I took a class by Doctor Bridges called Philosophy of the Mind where we delved into these types of things. And it was towards the end of the class. And he actually said people in your churches are not going to be concerned about hylomorphic dualism. Like he said that like they're not going to know what it is, but you know about it and you should be concerned. And you are the watchdogs for these topics that are going to infiltrate the church and and kind of slowly get them off track.

8:40 And they don't know it. And so, yeah, I recognize that this is this is at least especially those words are not going to resonate. So I thought maybe I would give a illustration of kind of the three broad categories of thought when it comes to how a human is composed. So there's straight materialism and that just means just a body. Similar to monism like we talked about along, I mean like if you're thinking in those categories. Right. And so there is nothing spiritual, there's nothing non physical. Your consciousness is an illusion. And there there are some minor, you know, nuanced views in there, but we'll just we'll kind of lump all those together into materialism. And then the other broad category is dualism. And so it means there is a body and a spirit, a body and a mind, a body and a soul.

9:36 But you count these trichotomists can be in there 'cause they would say there is a body and a soul, but and a spirit. Well, so so yeah, a trichotomist could say I'm a duelist and we they think that there are three different non physical things and then a. Oh, there's a physical, I mean 2, two different. Yeah, I see, I see. The body the. Dividing line is through the. Body they'd still be duelist because they'd still say, you know, non physical and physical, but they would just chop the physical in in half. You know, they'd they'd put spirit and soul separately. OK. I'm I'm tracking with that and from our previous podcast, like that's where my comfort level ends, where my take away is, you know, I think scripture generally talks about the person.

10:20 Like I think that unity is good, but it does talk about immaterial part body divorced from soul or spirit in, in certain instances. And so I'm, I'm intrigued to see how you know these labels Cartesian hyomorphic fit into the case with 'cause they're both dualism, just different ways to look at it. Right. And so I thought maybe the best way to explain this would be through an analogy. So for the materialistic version, let's just say rock, you know, just rock, nothing else. And maybe it's complex rock, it moves around or whatever, or group of rocks, but just a rock. And then for the dualistic ones, we'll say it's rock and water.

11:04 So there's the body and the water will kind of represent the the mind, the non physical self. So in Cartesian dualism, the water and the rock are not mixed at all. And the water kind of, you know, just kind of animates the rock separately. Whereas hylomorphic dualism. Think of it like a clay statue where there's definitely solids in the clay, but the solids are mixed with water and the water is you know, it is animating the the solids from within, not from without. So they're and they're like more, you would almost think they're more connected than not totally separate, but it seems like they're more separated.

11:50 Right. And so that is the big deal and it's not a huge deal. I mean, this is not going to have earth shattering things for people in the Pew if we're Cartesian duelists, but I think it does give us a lower view of the body. You know, why do we close our eyes when we pray or most of us close our eyes when we pray or why do we like sometimes get down to pray, you know, and kneel or, you know, bow our head. That's, you know, spiritually there doesn't make really that big of a difference. But because we are mind body composites, which is what hylomorphic dualism would say, like we're, we are, we're a composite.

12:31 We, our nature is to have our body when you know, we die. If, if William Lane Craig is right, when we die, no big deal. We don't necessarily need our body. We're souls that had a body. But now we're just souls. And that's fine, because that is really our true self. Wow, so the yeah the body is just not an afterthought, but it's less significant. It's almost like modern day Gnosticism in some. Maybe not exactly, but it's like spiritual's good body. Not body's bad, but body is less. Right, yeah, I wouldn't want to put Gnostic type ideas into, but it's it's not important. Like he would say, matter is fine. Matter is good, but the true your true self is just spirit.

13:15 But I, I think the from philosophy and from scripture, and obviously you're not going to see Paul say and highomorphic dualism is, is correct, but I think the overall tone of Scripture is that there is a judgement when we die in our body. You know, think of a statue where the water and the clay are like stripped apart. And at some point in time, you know, God's going to join those back together and it's going to be working again, you know, in a perfect way. That seems to be more of the case like that. It is a judgement. And, you know, for this time, you know, that my mom, my dad, you know, are without their body. They're, they're not, they're full selves that they're, that God intended them to be. And they will be their full selves upon the resurrection. And when they get their bodies back, they're they're, they're good to go.

14:03 I think we sense that even in Revelation, it's like these martyrs are they're long. It seems like there's like this longing, right? Like it's like things are good but it's not perfect yet. So we have some notes here. Just seeing I'm looking over our primer on hylomorphic dualism. We probably covered most of this. I'll read this, the basics of hylomorphic dualism. It's a unified personhood. A person's not merely a body or a soul, but a composite of both. The soul animates and organizes the body, giving it life and purpose. The soul integrates and transcends the physical, shaping the person's life and identity. You know, so the difference would be like a living tree versus a dead log.

14:49 What's the difference? Well, one of them is alive, one of them's not. And you know, DNA plays a role in this. So in my mind, you know, you got these different schools of thought. So hylomorphic duralism started with Aristotle was kind of sanctified by Thomas Aquinas, you know, and, and that scholastic era, you know, 12:11, 12/13/14 hundreds. And then with the Enlightenment, you know, it was kind of thrown out and that in really people either were typically Cartesian duelist or so. That's an enlightenment idea. Yeah, or materialist. So you had these kind of, you know, and then you had some people kind of carry it on and so. Is William Lane Craig like pretty favorable of the Enlightenment just with like reason and stuff, or is it just like, you know well?

15:36 He would. So there's different aspects. He would definitely be a Kantian philosopher. And and so Kant comes out of this struggle between like a human as a cart or in a, in a Spinoza and a lock. You know, you have those folks that are, you know, imperialist versus idealist and they're, and they're fighting. So, and I put I put for those philosophy people, I put the two opposites together on each side unintentionally, but you know, Descartes, Spinoza on one side, human lock on the other side. And Kant kind of tried to tries to bridge those together. And and William Lane Craig would definitely be in that vein.

16:19 You know, there have been offspurts of that, but that is the type of philosophy he does, and it's very different than a termistic philosopher. Yeah, yeah, it seems like a lot, a lot different. And I feel like you just grow up and it's like, man, enlightenment's good because it's modern and you learn, but then like the more you think about it and read about it, it's like, man, medieval stuff that's a good stuff. They weren't just all dark and dreary and they we lost everything. Yeah. And we, yeah, we probably, you know, you had the Dark Ages and then you had the medieval era and then you have the Enlightenment and the medieval, we think maybe because it has that sound of evil on the end of it. I always thought, man, this must have been a bad time. And it wasn't roses either, but it wasn't as bad as I think the wrath that it gets.

17:03 There were some good things that that came out of that. So that that's hylomorphic kind of get into some of the nuts, nuts and bolts there. What else you got on that? So maybe just some why it matters. Humans are neither just physical as a materialism nor merely just spirits trapped in a body. You know, your body is important. We talked about last week, you know that verse that I think it's in Second Timothy. That's like, you know, discipline now. Physical discipline now. It's worth it's worth something, but you know, godliness is worth even more. And so I think sometimes if we as if we over spiritualize and say, well, you know, my body doesn't really matter.

17:47 Your body is important. You know, your body infects affects your mind, your mind affects your body. There is this relationship here. And so you treat the whole person you know, and when you're trying to, you know, sanctify and be all that you can be. Yeah, that is interesting to me. I mean, I don't know anything about philosophy, so this, I'm probably missing the boat, but just with this emphasis on Jesus bodily, resurrection bodily, I know he's not saying body is like evil, but it's like just this emphasis like carry over. It seems like their significance. He's eating at, you know, he's doing these very human things. And it's like, you know, you see that that seems like a good thing. Yeah. And I guess for a pure Cartesian doulas, you'd have to say, well, those are bonuses, but they're not required.

18:29 But the the Bible seems to make a big deal. Like like this is really it. So why would he? What's the prose? Or is it? Is it more or less you're taking this philosophical route or like what's I don't know. To me, hyomorphic has a lot more upside because it has this balanced view of like the new heavens, new earth to be a very physical place. And that's a good thing. Instead of it saying like, oh, it is a it's a good thing, but like not totally necessary or it's a bonus. I don't know, like what's the I? Think some, I think what's I, you know, I, some have accused Craig of just trying to go after Thomistic because, you know, there's lots of points of disagreement with Thomism, you know, divine simplicity, divine impassability.

19:14 I don't, I don't get the sense, you know, I want to be charitable for I don't think he's like just trying to go after tomistic ideals. But I think what probably leads him astray from Tomism, some of those foundational ways he views things, those just tend to lead to you. Know those things. I could see that to where it's like I can get on board with what an Armenian says a lot of times, but sometimes it just seems like certain things go together or they make sense more. And if there's like a maybe one, I might just by default side on more of like church history and reformation or something like that. Or I don't know. I could see how you're not maybe attacking the other side, but it seems like it's out of place a little bit.

19:56 So the reason this came up is because in the question of the week, so William Lane Craig at reasonable faith, I mean, I'm, you know, I encourage, I listen to his podcast weekly and, and they do the each week they'll go over the the question of the week. So this would have been last week's question of the week since we're recording on on Monday. So I think they come out every Monday or so, but it's really recent. He answers this question and you can see his answer there. But in in the answer he gives this argument and so this is his argument why he is a Cartesian doula. So it says the person before physical death is identical to the person after physical death. The person after physical death is identical to the soul after physical.

20:47 Death, so he's equating person and soul. Seems good. It may be the soul after physical death is equal to the soul before physical death. Therefore the person before physical death is identical to the soul before physical death. So hopefully all that did you follow that? I'm trying to so I get confused because a lot of times I'll refer to a soul as a person, but that's not good. If I'm saying like, hey, do this with your heart, it's like, well, that's separate than your body. So yeah, So what what we what if you're hylomorphic, you would say the person is that you are that mind body composite, right? And so, you know, I could lose a few pounds. My body impacts how I think, you know, my body probably impacts my mental stamina.

21:38 A joyful heart is good medicine, but a crushed spirit dries up the bones. Right, right. So my mind body composite is who I am as as a whole. And so like, you know, I think my parents are a good example for this because they've they've both passed away. You know, Chuck is not fully Chuck right now because he's not with, you know, his soul is there, his mind is there, but he's not all that God made him to be in the fullest of his nature right now. So his person is somehow diminished right now. Gotcha. So you would say person because sometimes I think and I get confused with colloquial terms because a lot of times I'll be like when I think of a soul, I just think of a person.

22:20 But I guess I should say a person. 'Cause you're thinking Cartesian. Gotcha. Yeah, probably. So 'cause I would be like, if I'm there with my heart, I'm doing it with my person, but I'll say hearts or you know what I'm saying, but I shouldn't say that. I should be like. Well, 'cause you're supposed to love God without your heart, soul, mind and strength, 'cause it's like all those the bodies there too. Yeah, so when I say soul, yeah. So I should always say soul and body don't say like the soul today got saved. It should be like that person got saved. Yeah, yeah. To be really. Precise. Not that. People know like we can talk looser, but when you're do when you're when you know, philosophy is basically the science of all these details and nuances and making small, you know, small different, you know, small distinctions between things you.

23:03 Know no I gotcha. So I'm making a decision in my heart. It just that might not be a it's not a physical thing. It's like it's it's I always connect them all so I guess I just have a hard time thinking. Yeah, I mean, there you have different like your finger is not making a decision, right? Right. But Zach made a decision and Zach's decision could affect his finger. Like if your mind did something dumb and you know your finger got burned or. Or I give my mind too much credits? Or I should I should extend it more to the body and not just keep it as like my mind? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Your body is important. Now we we want to overemphasize our body, you know, but yeah, so you know, Atomus would say that the body is the matter and the soul or the spirit, the mind is the form. So it's like your non physical self is animating your physical self and making decisions for your physical self and kind of giving shape to it.

24:04 Now I think that's why I that would be like AA14 hundreds person Traducianism. You know what that. Is correct an origin of a soul? Kind of. Right, so there's this. They also believed your first hyomorphic duelist thought that God, you know, created a soul. Like all the souls are like in a bank somewhere. Yeah, yeah. And he, well, he, no, he, he created them on the spot. Oh, you say on the spot. And then there is the in the bank somewhere that they just kind of get married up 'cause they were 'cause they're trying to avoid God creating something evil. But then the trans trdusianism says no, A mom is a spirit body complex. A dad is a spirit body complex.

24:48 You. Know their gametes come together, they make a spirit body complex that's right there so that I think the DNA that's carried in there, you know, in there and I said, you know, I think you're going to inherit soul traits and tendencies from your parents. You know that that's going to come come through as well. So, and that's more of that all mind and body are kind of working together. OK, Yeah. So I thought maybe we'd take each one of his premises. The person before physical death is equal to the person after physical death. I think we would basically concur with that. The person persists, but they've gone through some significant change.

25:32 They're incomplete right now. So the person is the same, but it's like, you know, if I, you know, we could say, you know, Brian had an accident in Arkansas, lost his lower leg. It's still Brian, but he's not as full of Brian as he used to because the Brian that I grew up with played a lot of basketball. Brian right now is not playing basketball. So there's a a decrement to him. Is it still Brian? Yes. And I think we could kind of say, you know, lesser to the greater. You know, when you die, you've lost your body. There's you're still the same person, but are you exactly the same or has there been some type of change that's happened to that person? 'Cause you would be even, I mean 5 versus 75 not. I mean, yeah, it's like you're different, but the same. Right.

26:17 Yep, Premise 2. The person after physical death is equal to the soul after their physical death. And this is where we we would strongly disagree because we would say the soul is not the whole person, it's the substantial part. But after and after the soul, after death, the soul subsists. It carries on without the body. But they're not fully realized at this point. They're not all that their form was meant to be, you know? And he's like, you are what you're meant to because the body, you're like the essence of what you'd be. The body's just like extra. Right, right. Premise 3, the soul after death is equal to the soul before death. Yeah, we wouldn't hyomorphic wouldn't disagree with that. Yeah, we would say that's the same. But then the conclusion, it really kind of rests on premise 2IN which we would disagree with. So if premise 2 is not true, then we would, you know, the argument would fall apart.

27:07 The person before physical death is equal to the soul before physical death. And so we would say, you know, the soul alone constitutes the person. We would disagree with that. We would emphasize the body's a central role in your personhood. It's a lesser role, but it's still it's still part of who you are. That's interesting. Yeah. I'm trying to think about all this terminology and stuff and I feel like I assume Cartesian language, but high a little more. I just think of a person mostly when I talk about someone, I think about body and soul and I'd assume that. So I would say soul as shorthand for a body. And I mean like when I can, that's what I speak in those terms. Because when I've read scripture, I feel like most of the time the unity of a person is emphasized versus all these separate parts. So I'm, I'm kind of with you where I feel like it sounds interesting to, you know, have the emphasis on the, it's like being so separate and it's like totally fine. This is great.

28:02 Not maybe not great, but it's good. This is how it's supposed to be. Yeah, so implications, you already mentioned one of these, resurrection theology, holomorphic dualism underscores the resurrection's importance for restoring the person to complete lists. You know we have all of First Corinthians 15. Talking about yeah, it's a lot of a huge chapter, right? Where Cartesian dualism. It wouldn't say that that's not gonna happen, it's just kind of. It wouldn't be as important in that system. Yeah, Why? It seems like there's a lot of emphasis on that in Scripture for it to be like, cool, it's like dessert, but it's not like you know, you know, it's not like a, the main, a main event. Right. And so you know hylomorphic would say that you are a body soul composite where Cartesian would say you Zach have a body so slightly different and Genesis 2 seven First Corinthians 15 both would kind would would tend to lean in the hylomorphic role.

29:03 And then some philosophical challenges here. Cartesian dualism faces challenges in explaining the intimate connection between the body and soul. When Descartes came up with this, so he just discovered the pineal gland in the brain, he's like, oh, I bet that's what what happens. That's what the soul uses to animate the body. Doesn't really make sense of that. Hylomorphic dualism offers a more coherent account of human nature, emphasizes the emphasizing the unity. Of I just just like you feel. I feel like the unity is there when I think think about, even if I speak in wrong terms. I'm just assuming unity, right? Right. So is this something that we need to go out and boycott William Lane Craig?

29:45 Make a tract about it. What's that I'll? Pick a tract, go door to door. Sorry. Yeah, I love morphic dualism. Yeah, yeah. But I think it it is, it could be, it could lead to other wrong thing. I don't know what that wrong thinking is, but I just found an interesting thought thought that we maybe we should talk about it if anyone else is listening, William Lane Craig and hey. William Lane Craig, I'm looking straight into the camera. I want you sitting in this seat. I'll put anyone against my guy and maybe if you debate him and you win, you will no longer be Michael Mott between Michael. Michael Harrison Mott That's right, there have been little podcasts from time to time that have picked got picked up by his show. So so I have all the respect for him even though I do disagree with him on some things.

30:33 So. You know, I'm gonna say it. No respect. No, I'm just saying I told him, yeah, a lot of great work. I'm not, I'm not, as I don't listen to everything he does, but I think he's a very smart guy. Oh yeah, very smart and obviously has read and studied more than than probably the both of us together, but. That's not saying much because you've read a lot. And then like throw on the little bit and a a philosophy that I have. So, you know, yeah. Yeah. All right. Well, hopefully that was enjoyable. Hopefully we, I was able to, you know, help explain it to you, Zach and then and then therefore our audience also be able to get it as well. So. I like it, yeah. If you are, you know, apologetic extraordinaire, you should, you know, type in other of these, you know, things.

31:13 That's probably good that you listen to these podcasts where, you know, these things kind of pop up and see things. But that's good. You know, it's good to have this wide array of of podcasts, you know, to Yeah, to get. On the title of this, so people don't look at that and go, Nah, not going to listen to that one. We'll say like, win a free car and if they might click on it, they're like hylomorphic dualism. Come on. But it'll be like win a free car or hylomorphic dualism. You got to listen to find out. That's pretty funny. Well, if you made it this far, you did not win a free car. All right. Anything else? I got nothing. OK, that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take 2. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.