Did We Strawman the Atheist?
Episode 2.32
In this episode, Zach and Michael respond to a sharp critique of one of their recent videos on the moral argument for God’s existence. The comment accused them of misrepresenting atheist views—doing a “disservice” to their audience by not engaging with stronger opponents.
But this raises a crucial question: Why is it wrong to misrepresent someone in the first place? That kind of moral claim assumes the very thing under discussion—an objective moral standard. After answering that, we dive deeper into the moral argument:
Do objective moral values and duties exist?
If so, what foundation best explains them?
Why don't evolution, social contracts, or human consensus suffice?
And how do we respond when people say we're “not being fair”?
Let us know if we hit the mark!
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/esLR3Zm4kzA
Merch here: https://take-2-podcast.printify.me/
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at http://www.take2theology.com
0:00 Right, Zach? Yes. Have you ever operated a 3D printer? I've heard of them, yeah. That said, for those that don't know, that's a joke. I have a 3D printer that Michael now has and I religiously probably for a year, I probably like every day is an overstatement, but like at least weekly I would it's like one of those addictive things where I'm kind of glad I don't have it. Gotcha. I because I would, I would work over here and have like lost myself and I would just be like I would like every morning when I got, I had a time like I'd learn how to start a print. So it'd be done at night or the next day and I would go out so. You'd let it print overnight. I I did, yeah.
0:41 And I would. It was like really fun and really great. And you'd be like, oh, print messed up. You'd be bummed you do it again. It's like it was really fun. You're like watching the progress. I do miss it in that sense, but I don't miss it in right now is not a good time of my life for one. But man, if I, if I get it's, I'm glad you have it 'cause if I get it back, it's gonna be kind of crazy. So I'm excited where this is going. So Speaking of bad prints, this is 1 Silk does this. Silk look nice. It does look one. This is what so we gave your printer to Alex who got it working and he was using the white PLA for a long time, but when he gave it to me this was in here and I've been scared to change it out.
1:25 Oh yeah. Yeah. Just easier, yeah. To but I think I need to print some things not in this probably white I will tell you. Silk. To me silk is harder to print the normal PLA and if you ever get if you look at the PLA and PLA plus I usually recommend the PLA plus is a little bit more sturdy and those two like easy prints. Gotcha. So this is this is what this was supposed to be. So I did get a wolf out of. It oh, this looks, it looks really nice. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, wolves are reoccurring animal. It looks like art D&D Yeah, yeah, it does. And then I my.
2:08 Oh man. Purchased online SLT file 06 bucks of my character but so that is basically look at that our character that's a little bit larger because the first time I printed it, it had some problems I had to re change the. Structure. It's pretty amazing this. Is the right size, but you can see there's a little bit of webbing in there. But I'm not, I don't think I'm going to try to take that off because. It's such a. It's so delicate. It's like it's so a it's tedious and delicate, and then it's like you mess up one of the supports or the webbing or whatever and then it's like, oh, I just cracked off the head. Yeah, yeah, this guy has. So he's got a Cape.
2:50 He's supposed this is supposed to be a flute in his hand. He's a musician. He plays like, you know, like, not like a flute like you'd think here like a, a wooden recorder. And then? A recorder that's like what I did in 4th grade. I'm just kidding. This is very cool. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. He's got a rape here, so you can see that sword on his side. Yeah, yeah. And if you could see his hand, it's like there's a little smoke there because he's a, he's a cleric. So he does like healing spells and stuff like. That nice? Have you ever heard of the resin printer? Have I talked to you about this? Yeah, we had a resin printer at formerly Spayware, now Nywick. And so it's like this big vent of resin and there's three lasers boom and they hit, it's where they they have to hit all three of them to form this laser.
3:35 And it's very the resin to harden it. It's very precise. You can get that's, I know a lot of people use it for that exact thing for game figures. Also I think it's toxic. So you have to have like ventilation or you have to have better ventilation than a normal. I mean, I could have bought this. From the. Company printed. It out. And it's like 3540 bucks. I was like for 6 bucks if I can buy the file I'll just print Oh I should. I should show you if I can find it next time. I printed out like the little trains for like like like Mexican Domino's. Have you seen this? And it like it? I mean, you could. It looks really good. I mean, it's not perfect. I'll just say. Does Northwood have 30 printers? Not that I'm aware of, no. But it's a good technology to learn, that's what. I was going to say maybe they should, maybe there should be a 3D print club.
4:22 Yeah. That, you know, like my sister's school is like grade and it's. 5th grade looking for some clubs I'm. I'm just saying that 'cause that would be good, 'cause it's like problem solving and developing it is and you can, you know that's. It's not a science, it's an art 'cause I, I learned it is even doing this like, you know what type of feeling I want to make the because the first time I printed this, it was really, it just kind of crumbled. I was like, OK, I got to change my supports out. I'd made it the most the tiniest layers and stuff. So there's different things you can do to kind of hone in on something like this. But if you're doing something that's like a box, you don't need. That stuff you can save time, you can do like cool designs and it sounds silly, but there is a difference. If it's like like little like like silk PLA versus normal PLA, it's like not that big a difference, but you do want to maybe like 5 degrees, 8° on the temperature does make a difference.
5:15 Yeah, so your printer always wants to go to 200°? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I had to put it up to 210 because the the silk PLA is 210 ± 10. And you'll see the nozzle temperature like kind of flow in and around 2:10 go up like 214 and then like 204 or whatever. And it'll it'll. Yeah, they should. They should definitely do that. And then we could use three for like a really nice one, you know? Yeah. So anyway, nice. That is good. I'm glad it's being put to good use. It is so fun to do. It is a pain to change out the PLA, but that is like really, really cool. Yeah. Any tips on changing that out? Just it's actually really not there's like 2 if you look on YouTube, there's two there's like I can't remember which is better.
6:00 There's like a a hot, I don't know, a hot pool and a cold pool and I don't know which one is preferred. I usually have them on a kind of heat it up because it like is a little bit easier like 50. 60° or something. Yeah, I can't remember. There's a YouTube video and some people are very strong, like don't do the cold pool. You're going to mess something up, you know, when you pull, when you pull it. Out Alex was saying if you take the PLA and cut it at a point because there's a little bit of a. It's like a loop deal. Not a loop deal, but there's. You gotta get to go through and if it's just flat it doesn't want to make that angle. You have, yeah, that, no, that's really smart. You have to have the angle and it's still a little bit annoying. It's really not hard, but it might take you like 5. It's like, it's like not hard, but if it's something takes like 8 minutes, it's like very frustrating. It's like not that long of a time, but you're like, Oh yeah. But that's exciting.
6:45 I like the the print updates man, I love it. That was before I leveled it with the paper, 'cause I didn't realize I had to do that, 'cause I just used the auto leveling. Yeah. And I thought, oh, it should be good. Should be. And I came back and those things were like floating around while it was trying to print. Oh, you just like in midair doing? The Yeah man. Yeah, great. I as Alex, he has his new printer has. He got his own printer now so. I bet it's killer. Yeah. Has he showed you what he's printed? I no, I don't know what he's got. I don't know if he got one like yours or I I. I bet it's good because this my printer used to print better than it does now. I feel like I haven't printed it in years and he got like a like a next level up.
7:25 Like I bet it's I bet it's gonna be so good. I'm excited. That's like so fun to print. All of I print so many things, all of them useless, all of them like not super functional, but it's great. We have that ornament that you printed. Do you remember? That oh, I do that was like a that was a intensive print. I mean, it took a long time and I mean it looks pretty good when you go like a little bit bigger than this. It like has less blemishes. You know, it's so hard to get that small detail, but it is annoying. Nothing's ever like perfect. There's like a little bit, but that's it's so fun. You can just make it. I made like a gas cap for like my car. It wasn't it like Fit, but it wasn't it wasn't good. But you can do like little things like that you. Know and the gasoline won't eat at the resin. I, I I didn't use it.
8:08 I I stopped it. It wasn't. It was like, oh it fit. Almost like I probably should use the normal 1. OK, so you had. It wasn't like you didn't have one. You were just like trying to. Yeah, it was like. It was cool. I was trying to do like functional things. I was looking at all these functional, but I was like, yeah, most of my stuff is, are like containers. Yeah. And like shell like I'll, I'll have to show you some of this if I can, if I can find it, 'cause it was like so fun. But anyway, a lot of 3D print talk there. You just said something like nothing's ever perfect and that would, you know, people would say the same thing about our podcast. In fact, people have said such about. That's what's prompting this podcast. Michael had the great idea to respond to some comments, 'cause we're getting comments.
8:49 We are getting comments. We started putting out Moss Louis Moss shorts, so it's. So weird. 'Cause you look at them, you're like, why did this one? And is it like YouTube getting served up or is it like the first few people that see it how they react? To it. Does it make it either go or not go? So just a word of the wise, if you see one of our shorts just let it run for like 5 minutes. Like it comment that just. Watch it 6 times and like it because it it is bizarre. We're posting slightly more shorts and for the most part really gotten a lot of views, but it's so bizarre to be like, hey, here's 2000 views, then hey, here's like 15 views. Yeah, 4/4.
9:32 It's like very drastic. Yeah, there was one. I so I guess I'm learning also the art of that because there were, I'm taking like what I consider good little Nuggets out of a longer format, squashing us, you know, on one on top of the other. And then I named three of them very similar or maybe even the same. And I, the third one, it just was not doing well. And I changed the title. Boom, it went up like 1.6 K and it's like, OK, it's like, I don't, I don't know. We'll see. Man, well, that's what we're gonna talk about now. Some of these comments. I'm, I'm excited for that 'cause we got some good ones. Let's go ahead and take it to the next level.
10:18 From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. Quite a few comments. We're only going to get to 2 commenters. So if you commented something and we don't address it re comment or something. But these are the these are the two that I felt were kind of the most pointed. OK, yeah. And I wanted to address them. And the first one was on our longer format on the moral argument. So the moral argument for God's existence. And strange Pan said this is about 3 weeks ago said you all do your viewers A disservice by so poorly misrepresenting the counterpoints you bring up.
11:06 It does very little to strengthen your own position. It's like testing bulletproof armor with airsoft. Try discussing these things with an actual atheist who knows what they're talking about. First off, want to say thanks for commenting and fellow southerner y'all. So we got some common ground here. Yeah, I appreciate y'all. Have you heard about the Y'all Bible? No, I haven't. So we have often mentioned the fact that in most languages you can be singular plural. So this Bible puts in a Yaw for all the plural yous. So you clarify that is helpful. That is talking to multiple people on the second person or one person. It's one of the fewer.
11:51 One of the few pluses KJV brings to the table is the the, the and the and all this stuff. Yeah, that's great. But y'all, so I was, you know, trying to do clues. Strange. The name doesn't help me a ton. Strange Pan, you know, it could be anything but y'all. So anyway. Yeah, and I will try to comment or you know, maybe comment the name so it shows backed up because you may not be a all time follower. I understand that sometimes YouTube allows me to do that, sometimes it doesn't. And I wonder if it's like privacy settings for the individual account, whether you can tag someone. But all right, so my first comment like you said, thank you, appreciate the input. And it makes this be a little bit retrospective and.
12:34 It's and it's really, it's honestly really helpful like to your comments to get pushed back like that so we can think through things better or different or at least do something like this where we're probably kind of on your side with this one and the fact that we're not trying to, you know, Mantle dismantle a straw man, right? Right. Yeah, we don't want to do that. But my first question is yes, why is that wrong? Oh, why is it wrong to build up a poor argument and take it down? Yeah, I I see what you said. You're doing the moral argument like turning it around. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's good. Is there some standard that we should live by with our podcast?
13:14 And I'm just a little tongue in the cheek, but that's a good question because I appreciate the the input. Strange, Pan, but it's almost as if you think that we have a moral obligation or a duty to treat the opponent fairly. And I think we would both agree that we do have that. But that in and of itself is ironic because you could have said this maybe on like the theological argument or something like that. But your comment came in on the moral argument. And so it if something is like. A disservice if it's poorly done. Yeah, it's yeah. What's the big deal?
13:55 Yeah. So only you know, and there has to be objective moral arguments or objective moral duties and values for this to go through. Because if it's just subjective, it's like you're saying I don't like it when you do that, but that's be like, that's fine. And I don't like chocolate. I like bread. Yeah. Yeah. It's like, fine, yeah. Yeah, so I just thought it was ironic, you know, just taking a step back from the challenge itself. There is an applied duty that we have to represent our opponents fairly, and that speaks to the moral argument. And to say it again, we agree, we agree with you that there should be some objective like that.
14:40 We should represent things well. So I thought maybe we just go over the moral argument because I think we hit all these things and I don't. I mean, what, what's the I wish I I wish I knew what the specific pushback was or like, you know which which area part. Did we not? Did we not do so Just the moral argument in a nutshell was if God does not exist, then objective moral values and duties do not exist. Objective moral values and duties do exist. Therefore, God must exist. So that is how we phrased it here. And we are going to say that the best explanation for objective moral values and duties is a trans, a transcendent God.
15:33 And so when I read this, I was, I think I told you this like I just responded in like a little selfie video because I was just like, I was thinking about it. I was like, I want to say these things. So as I was responding, I was driving. I just had it on my little magnetic thing recording. So I kind of wanted to get the the the. You're in the moments. In the moment. Capture the language. And as I was driving a 55 mile an hour speed sign and that's a physical thing and it is informing me however of a non physical reality. Right. That's right. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. There is a physical reality of my velocity. That is a physical thing that we can measure, but the non physical reality is that there is a body of people in the state of South Carolina who have an authority over me. And we can and you can debate government authority, but we'll just say there that that authority is a non visible thing.
16:31 And so we're saying that they have they are a proper authority to make a law that passes. And that physical sign is informing me of that law, but it is not the. Law, it's not the law, but it it kind of you look at that and you're like, oh, there's there's something there. Right. And so I just use that to to reinforce this idea that laws, moral laws and duties are non physical. They're not physical. Yeah, if that's right. If we walked into someone's garage and picked up a garden hose and I gave you every possible physical description of that act, like anything you wanted to know, I could tell you. You still wouldn't know whether we broke a moral law or duty or not 'cause you'd have to know things like ownership or permission to borrow those types of things.
17:21 And those are non physical things. Yeah, I like that. That's good. The non physical side of things. Yeah, that I I'm I'm like trying to wrap my brain for like what's like the what would strange Pam like what would he say? You know what I'm saying? Like that's what I'm trying to think. Of yeah, So most of the time when folks. So there's 2. So there's two premises that basically first premise says that you can't have objective moral values and duties without God. You can have subjective, but you can't have objective. Second premise is saying that they actually exist. So in order to defeat the argument, you either have to somehow try to ground objective moral values and duties and something other than God. OK.
18:04 Which would be like. DNA Evolution. Social contract type of stuff. So you you might you might try to ground ground them in an abstract non physical object like a Platonian object. Sorry I'm getting wrapped up in my chords. So the problem is abstract objects are causally effete big words. They cannot stand in a causal relationship. So even if there are Platonic solids or Platonic ideals that do exist apart from God, you know, we could say that the idea of goodness is an abstract object, exists, but it only exists in my view, in the mind of God.
18:53 But even if I were to grant you, goodness exists outside of God, and it is its own thing, like a Platonic substance. It's 'causely A feat. There's nothing that would say I have to obey it. Right, it's just. Right. It's just out there. Just like the, the, the purest perfect nature of a chair is out there, the purest perfect nature of a triangle is out there. Doesn't mean I have to make a chair that conforms to that. In fact, I I can't make a chair that conforms to it. Yeah. So. That's good. Yeah. So I'm trying to think of what other things that you might try to ground objective moral values and duties. Most of the time what I have heard in talking with people on the street, it's evolution. OK.
19:38 So yeah, so we're talking DNA, we're talking evolution. It's like we're just made this way. It's how we've survived. It's like we're, we can keep like, you know, the human race going through observing these actions. Yeah. So lots of times they'll say it is in your survival nature to be cooperative. It's in your survival nature to love. So we have basically been naturally selected to have these these things. Well, first of all, that sounds like it's not objective. So it doesn't that language by itself, how I, at least how I'm phrasing it and how I best understand the argument, is not, is not objective. But there are four huge hurdles for evolution to be the grounding of objective moral values and duties. First one, did evolution even happen? Right.
20:36 Yes, yeah. And. If there's an atheist, they're going to roll their eyes. Yeah, that's. Like always a given, probably in their minds. But not so fast. And evolution really depends on even though it presupposes like if you read it, if you hear about it, they'll they'll go. Well, there was some RNA molecule, like even the starting of life. Yeah. And evolution, if you press someone who knows what they're talking about and they're like, yeah, evolution does not actually account for the start of life. It just accounts for natural selection. After life starts. But so that aside, if we grant that, let's say, let's just grant to you that evolution did happen, then how does consciousness arise from that?
21:22 So you've got these molecules that. That's a big leap, yeah. Yeah, there's a huge leap there for consciousness. OK, well let's we could grant consciousness then you could ask how could evolution in principle even affect something that's non physical? Remember we talked about that, that speed sign physical thing, but how could our DNA, if we're talking about, you know, love and justice and, you know, not raping someone, not, you know, you know, probably that that board always gets bleeped out. So maybe I'll have to bleep that out. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Not assaulting someone, you know, all, all of those things. You know, those ideas are, you know, there's non physical elements to those.
22:03 Just because you see someone taking something or see someone mating with someone, you don't know from that whether something's been broken. But even if we could, let's say that we can grant that to you. The last bit is even if evolution could affect something non physical, evolution selects for survival, not truth, which is kind of what I was getting that before. So all we know is that our if if, if we're here as a product of blind evolutionary chance, neo Darwinian synthesis. All we know is is that our brains evolved to get our genes in the next generation.
22:44 Yeah. And it's like when you look at, you know, animals not behaving very morally, and you're like, oh, going back to some things, maybe you were just saying, it's like, oh, that seems like something we wouldn't do. Right. Yeah, that's that's. So, I mean, and I know we talked through it, but then the pushback's like, well, you know, someone, somewhere, some culture, somewhere don't have this standard or whatever. But but the broader point I think is. Well, even to that point, yeah. Yeah, when you die then into what's actually going on on those cultures that seem to be aberrant, the the main moral things are still there, even if it's like a culture where my tribe we believe we can do all these bad things to your. Tribe.
23:29 But inside our tribe we have the. Same exact. Values and stuff about not murdering and and you know, possession of property, you know. And with all of human history, even if there were like a handful of people, it's kind of like the exception proves the rule and like that you. Say strength of bad culture. Yeah, Yeah, that almost further strength. Yeah, I got you. Yeah. Yeah, so if it's not DNA and evolution, other possible things are social contract theory, kind of like house rules. So every. Culture maybe has different things and it's like, hey, get to spy. We just agree. I'm not going to punch you in the face. Don't punch me in the face. We'll be good on this podcast. But that's not objective, right? We just agreed to it. It's not something that is outside of our subjective agreement and then human authority alone, you know, so like some type of limited or you know, just because I say it or might makes right, you know, just trying to think of what other what are the things that might try to be grounded.
24:28 So if we if we missed some other way that. Let us know, yeah. Try to ground objective moral values and duties. Then then then let us know the other way around. This is to just say they don't exist. Yeah, right. Right, But by pointing out that you thought we straw man the argument, I think that shows that they do exist, right? Man. And it's not. I can't think of a real life situation where someone letters their entire life consistent with that anyway. Right, You can't because you always smuggle it in, especially when you feel like you've been wronged #1 you can't do that. That's wrong. Why can't I do that? Why can't I, you know, take your purse?
25:10 Why can't I take your wallet? Why can't I slap you? Why can't I call you ugly or fat or you know, all those things? You tell my 3 and 4 year old what's objective morality. They have no idea, but they do know Shane called me a baby or I don't know. It's like they, they're like, they're like, not about having this unfair treatment. Or whatever that's right. All right. So key takeaways. People naturally appeal to objective morality when claiming something is wrong. Objective moral laws point to an objective moral moral law giver. We call that person thing this God because it's got to be he's got to be non physical. It can't be made of this stuff, right? He's got to transcend this thing, but he has to be a person. It can't be like those platonic, you know, non physical things.
25:53 So so God is that best explanation? Nice. And you have this in here. I know we're running along on time a little bit, but man, it would be nice to do a five part series on the more argument, but audience isn't probably there slash. I mean, Michael probably would love to do it, you know, you know, but you know what I mean. It's not like maybe the the forum or the goal of this. That is good. I'm glad you where I I missed that I it's right. About the key take away. OK, Oh yeah yeah cuz what I what I what I was thinking is what I would consider ourself hopefully is this edutainment yeah yeah. So it's, it's educational entertainment. And so hopefully we're we're, you know, people are listening to us, they're doing a little banter. We're and we're giving you a accurate. That's right, yeah.
26:43 Thumbnail sketch of what's going on maybe? Without reading a textbook to you. Right, because you know there are channels who do. This, yeah. Alex. I think Alex. I can't remember his last name, but he's an atheist who seems to have had a really strong atheist but seems to be flirting with coming over to the other side. Very deep, inspiring philosophy, very deep. William Lane Craig's. You can find some of his videos of debates very deep and exacting. So those channels are out there. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's just not, we're trying to do this in like 30 minutes or so. So yeah, we're not trying to to get down to the academic level of some of these.
27:25 So I'm sure there are probably some academic responses, but you know, I've read Oxford Press's you know, thing on the problem of evil and the the argument for morality. I'm sure I've forgotten some of that stuff, but I think I'm trying to, I'm mostly accurately, you know, depicting that. So hopefully if there's something I've missed. Yep, honestly, that would be helpful and then we could get whether we agree or disagree, we're at least engaging with things accurately. That's right. And the talk show host, not Greg Kopel. What's He's the Jewish guy, Dennis Prager. Oh yeah. That's one of his mantras is clarity, not necessarily agreement. That's good.
28:07 So let's clarify what we mean and and if we're misrepresenting something, you know, we want to hear that. I love it. That's one comment. That's one comment. We probably I have a whole. The second one is even longer. Even longer. So that's I was going to say we're at kind of the 31 we're. At that that time frame, so we probably should do the next comment in another. Session. I think that sounds fantastic. We got this cool guy commenting on this too. This Kobe Forever, 08/2. Four. Yeah, Kobe forever. Who could? Who is that guy? I love it that that was good though, 'cause I, I, we do want to be fair and, you know, objective and do things we want to do things well. So I think that comes.
28:49 I'm hoping for more back and forth on this with Strange Pan for. Real yeah, strange pan obviously yeah drop a video type of some lines whatever, we'll listen to it because you know we want to make sure that we are being objective and not not straw manning so. I love it. Awesome. Well, anything else you want to leave the listeners with, Michael? No. All right, that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed