...where we take theology 2 the next level
Aug. 13, 2025

From Chaos to Connection | A Teacher's Story Part 2

From Chaos to Connection | A Teacher's Story Part 2
From Chaos to Connection | A Teacher's Story Part 2
Take 2 Theology
From Chaos to Connection | A Teacher's Story Part 2

Episode 2.30


More Than Meets the Eye: Rivalry, Friendship, and the Heart of Teaching


In Part 2 of our conversation with Northwood Academy teacher Matthew Gilbert, the story takes a turn—from chaos to connection. Matthew opens up about his initial rivalry with fellow teacher Jonathan White, a man who, at first glance, seemed to be his complete opposite. But once the walls came down, an unexpected friendship formed—one forged in the classroom, grounded in grace, and focused on Christ.


Matthew also continues to reflect on his calling as a teacher: how God uses his past to shape his purpose, and how his mission now is to reach students not just academically, but eternally. This one is honest, hilarious, and filled with the kind of perspective that only comes when you’ve lived both sides of the desk.


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/uAMANj7Gz4w


Merch here: https://take-2-podcast.printify.me/


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at http://www.take2theology.com

0:00 You're actually. Being a true friend, this is perfect because I've become like this elusive creature. So like this one time I show up in your church and I'm sure you're like, you know, institutions of the place you bring, you know, 117 of when you show up, but like, I'm glad that in this particular case, I, I show up and you're not there. And so like I and there's no pictures. So there's no actual proof that I was like, maybe I was maybe I feel like it's like the Tasmanian tiger in Australia where they're like in remote villages, there's still like an occasional sighting and it was supposed to be extinct. I like to think that that's what that. Means well, I I do want to say thank you, Matt, for coming to my son's baptism. It's an honor. Michael. You're dead to me. You missed it. I will tell him that every night before bed. Michael didn't show up, but that's it. I was kidding, but I, I should say this. It was really cool.

0:44 Jay, my oldest, Jayden, his teacher last year was April, Matt's wife. And it was, it was really, I bet Jayden like had like loves your wife. It was really cool that she made the trip out, that y'all made the trip out that that was, that was very, very meaningful. Even though you know y'all go to a Presbyterian Church, you still still participate. So thank you for giving me some homework to do. When I got there talking with my son, I was like, hey, here's what's going on here. But in fairness, my wife was obviously the one that's doing most of the work in this case. She was honored to come. I was honored to be a part of it. Seeing, I'll be honest, seeing you as a dad, like kind of talk about your son, like how your, your vision for him, your, your pride in him was moving. It's just for me as an emotionally repressed meathead, like seeing you kind of listen, I'm like, I'm not, I'm not going to shed 1 tear.

1:34 I'm going to do it. But like, but I felt it in here man. And, and, and Jonathan's behind me. And I think he could kind of like, he can sense if I, if I'm going to crack it all. And I'm like, I can't, I can show nothing, just grip A determination because if he sees this, he'll never let me live it down. And I and there's nothing I hate, I hate more then for Jonathan White. Okay, that guy to have a one up. On that guy, all right. So welcome back honored guest Matt Gilbert. And one of your passions, I think is communication. Like you, I know that if you there's a subject that you are passionate about, you also like to communicate that.

2:15 And I know you're also passionate about football, correct? Yes. And I know that you like the challenge and maybe taking more than one side of a coin, maybe it's like seeing if you can argue. A particular. Position So I I think for the next two minutes you should argue Zack into being a Patriots fan. Oh, all the all the things that are good about being the Patriots. It hurts me that I'm going to do this, but but for some reason I'm willing to try this even though it disgusts me. So just know, here's where I got to start with this, OK? I am a long-suffering, self loathing Titans fan. And there's there's, there's dozens of us out there. I mean, dozens.

2:56 That's just what's out there, OK? And we're all cynical and we're all super salty about it. So here's the deal. Our coach, who is the one good thing the entire organization had, was fired because reasons. And so naturally, as soon as he was on the free agent market as a coach for like 5 minutes, that giant, glorious meathead Mike Vrabel, who like, listen, clearly I'm not of the athletic standard. You can take a look at the Zeke. I'm not exactly NFL ready. But but if that man was leading troops into like Kandahar or Fallujah or somewhere, I'd be right behind him. Like Mike Vrabel's my dude. And he's a man's man and he runs that team now. And So what I think you're going to get once again is like competence. And so here's what I understand as a sports fan, as a Titans fan, I don't know who your team is. I should know that, but I don't know. Pittsburgh Steelers.

3:44 OK, we'll see. But see, this is this is going to be hard for me because all I know is pain as a fan and those pain and then numbness and the numbness is what you just hope for. Because in the words, the Great American philosopher Ted laughs. So it's the hope that kills you. And so you have a little bit of hope. And here's the thing. It's going to be hard to, I'll be honest, root for Aaron Rodgers this year. That's a little. But Patriots, you had a couple year lag. They're the gold standard for a long period of time. They they make something out of nothing all the time. And I think good times are coming again. And if you don't want to hurt, it seems like now is the time to jump on the wagon here. And here's the thing, you can jump on the wagon. I can't believe I'm selling. I feel gross. I'm so dirty. Because if you jump now, you're not a band. You're not a bandwagon because it hadn't happened yet, but but good times are coming back to Foxboro. I hate it.

4:32 I hate it. But here's what I hate more Titans Phantom, because all I know, all I know is they'll hurt me. And so for my son, I'm like, listen, Simeon, I love you. Your dad's watching Titans games and it doesn't have to be this way. Don't do this to yourself. Roll far away from the tree. Pick a team, the Ravens, somebody, sorry, but it but it can't be the Titans. So I would say this, it's a chance to not be a bandwagon fans can't go to the competent organization and you've got probably the best coach in the league in my head right now. Well. First of all things, I thought that was well done. Second of all, I relate because my dad was a Detroit Lions fan and it was, you know, just Heartbreak City over and over and over again. I never, I never got on the train. I was like, I I can't.

5:16 You got off the best. When I think of the Titans, I think of like Eddie George, Steve McNair, I think Eddie George against the Rams, like out if he's like 3 yards away from that touchdown. I was watching that Super Bowl and I grew up in Tennessee. So like there's a lot of people and they were like relatively. They just got there from Houston and that's, I think Kevin Dyson's reaching out there and George's on that team, though, and Steve McNair was the quarterback. And because there's something wrong between the years for me, that's like my introduction to football. And I could have been like, let's go Rams, but I didn't. I'm like, you know what? I want pain and mediocrity. And so I just like, you know, let's just let's just make this burn the maximum possible. And I went with that. And so that image is forever burned in my brain. But like, that group of dudes is why I'm a Titan soap because something about just that was a a group of just tough dudes. Our quarterback was like his wife. Steven Air's wife became a nurse so she could mend his injuries at home because he's hurt so bad most of the time throughout the week.

6:13 He couldn't lift his arms above his head, which seems bad if you're a professional thrower of the ball. Say that's not ideal for the quarterback position. Eddie George was the toughest dude around. Keith Bullock. And I'm saying a bunch of ranch stuff, and I'm getting off track, but man, you just opened up some spot in my heart that is both joyous and full of unimaginable pain. So thank you. And also you're killing. Me and I do what you say this just in hate of the Patriots. This the one thing that sticks with me and I I wish I could get this out of my mind, but in all my Tom Brady, Tom Brady like kissed his like 14 year old son on the mouth and I just can't. I can't forget about it. It's so terrible. It was Tom Brady's this interesting character. And I forgive me, I'm going along now because Tom Brady's a dude who like in the offseason had like a ponytail and Capri pants.

7:01 And every like, dude in Boston, like every longshoreman is like, that's my guy. And I don't understand that. Like, what do you share other than like, he throws touchdown pass? That guy eats avocado ice cream and he's got Capri pants on. Like that's not he had like he's a different kind of. Dude, I was watching some of the shows on him and there's this guy who was playing with him and he wasn't even ready. And Tom Brady like head butts him and he ends up like chipping his tooth a little bit right before a game. He's like, I wasn't even ready for it. Like Tom Brady was like, so it's like the the dual nature of it because it's like you said, it's like I'm well was dating and then married to a model and I'm on a yacht and I've got, you know, capris and stuff and then total transformation the. Football Tom Brady, which is like just a but I will say this to get redemption and maybe wrap this thing up. I don't know my favorite memory, one of my favorite memories of the Titans.

7:56 There's not many that that drawer is pretty empty. Your boys not experienced a lot of elation as a fan of the Titans again. However, the Titans in that I think first round playoff game ended Tom Brady's time in New England by just smashing them one last time on the way up the door. And so that was one thing. We just. #22 we just couldn't stop them. Oh, oh, Derrick Henry, listen, that, that refrigerator with shoulder pads on, it's, it's one of the greatest things ever happened to us. And I wish him the best with the Ravens. He's finally gone to a competent organization, but seeing him leave was was rough. For short man and I think that Brady and Belichick were just not seeing eye to eye though that last season and they they could not get on the same page. It's weird though, because like, Belichick's been like, thinking so clearly, like with his dating life, and it just seems like he's like so on top.

8:44 Of it, he seems to be totally with it right now. It's it's got to be rough if you're Belichick and part of you thinks like, no matter what happens, I'm a genius, I'm going to take whatever this thing is and I'm going to make a winner out of it. And the minute Tom Brady's gone, he wins the Super Bowl in like 20 minutes with the Bucks. And then you're on a slowly sinking ship very quickly. We're like, everybody that works for you is like your son. And then you have like a guy that's. And his son, the look of his son is like hilarious. It's insane. And then if you know his defensive coordinator before it came back and was an offensive coordinator later on, and that guy kind of looks like he was trying to capture olive oil. He kind of looks like Brunus or whatever. Bruno.

9:24 Am I wrong about this? He's always got like a pencil on his ear. I'm like does the pencil work? Like are we on like a dry erase board with a pencil? Like you know that sheets laminate. Right bro? Like that She's laminate. You're not writing anything. I know this works, I'm not new. Yeah, that's the that's the Lions coming to bite me again, because if they had never hired him as a head coach, we would have never gotten him back as an offensive coordinator. But he would have hired just another son at that point in time or, or somebody he like who was like just in like an accounting or something with the organization. Because at that point in time, he's just like, I'm tired of meeting new people. I know all the guys I need to know. And the answer's going to be somewhere down this hall. And so that might have been the best you were going to get. Yeah, I love it. I love it. We got, I don't know a guy here, but I'm glad we made it. It's good.

10:08 All right, so should we for the second time, turn to our honored guests and have us get out of this banter You remember? I oh man, and y'all keep doing this to me and I keep watching it. Now you're great. Here we go. All right, here we go. It's time to take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. You know we want to make podcasts great again all. Right, all right, well, there we. Go red shirts, not red hats.

10:50 Today did. You see the back? I've not seen the back. I heard something about it 'cause you're OK. So, OK, so I heard y'all talking about like how this is kind of the churched up 1. And this is one of the things, and I hate saying this, I hate saying this. This is one of the areas where I would kind of lean toward Mr. White's sensibilities. I'm glad I call Mr. White because I'm so used to being in front of kids Jonathan's sensibilities because like without that on the back, I would struggle more with it on the front. And again, it's it hurts my soul to agree with that man, but here we are. Yeah, I clearly agree with him because I got it naturally because we were kind of joking about Give Hate a chance.

11:33 And there was another guy that I played D&D with. He's like, yeah, let's just have it that on there because, you know, you want to make merch that people are going to buy. I think he has one that just says give hate a chance. And he's like, no, to me it's a conversation starter because I want to provoke someone asking me a question and that I want to tell them about this. So I think his hearts there is just approach is different. Yeah, and it's a level of, and you would think from the time we've had that, like I would be more comfortable with the snark. But like me, I'm a little, I'm a little more careful this part part of me still like we got, we got, you know, yeah, we're going to fly right here. So speaking. Jonathan White. You you met him one day? Yeah. This. Is the reason we're here but to hear about you? And John of my of my long standing feud and friendship with Jonathan White.

12:23 Sweet mercy. OK, so let's do this. All right, so I was teaching for about 3 years at the point in time that Mister White, Jonathan White showed up to teach and he was put in the room next to me. He never taught middle school before. I think he wants to go by John. And I don't know what the obsession is with that like. Jonathan's fine. But. He's changed. I've noticed he's changed his his. I don't know this. Yeah, he wants to. He wants to go by John. He's changed his, his tag on, you know, like you can fill out what your name is that's associated with your e-mail to John. So it's like John White at northwoodacademy.com. Are there any?

13:04 Cool nicknames you have for Jonathan I. Mean there's plenty of things I mean it's usually insults obviously and it's usually me calling a pretentious or something because he constantly is OK like we again, we could not be more opposite human beings. The man shows up every day and he's, you know, he's dressed in this pristine ridiculous, you know, he's in a suit every day. I'm like, buddy, you work with middle schools, OK? Listen, it is what it is. Like we're, we're in the bowels of the ship together. You may be at the head of the bowels of the ship, but we're still in the bowels of the ship, OK. And so naturally, when I first met him, I, this is a problem in my soul. I'll say this. This is a sanctification process I had to go through. The person that that used to be in the room next to me in the middle school hallway over here was Miss Gibson, who Miss Gibson was an English teacher here for a long time. She taught 7th grade English.

13:56 I was a 7th and 8th grade history teacher. And so she functioned like, because I'm kind of a crazy person, in case we haven't figured this out from this microphone from my face yet, but I'm, I'm a little bit out there. And so she kind of was like the guardrails for me going through the beginning of teaching. She would like let me know like, Hey, definitely an important e-mail. You should take a look at that or hey, you know, whatever, like whatever, you know, all kinds of things. She was kind of like my, my, she, she was like a mentor for me here. Yeah. And so like, and she was my, my 7th grade teacher. She was my 7th grade English teacher. So like, I worked with her for a couple years and then all of a sudden she's gone. And I hate change so bad again. And so all of a sudden I know there's going to be change. And then the change that shows up the first day back to school is there's a guy in the room next to me and he's just got, you know, he's got the hipster glasses going.

14:41 He's got the full suit on. I'm dressed in like the coaches, like 1/4 zip that looks kind of like a trash bag that you cut sleeves into it. And I'm like this guy and and I'm like, I I'm going to hate him. I'm going to hate him and none of them I going to hate him. And this is wrong. It's wrong, but I want to. And so I'm like, OK, this is this is what it is. I'm like, so we go the first meetings I'm sitting with like at the time, I'm still coaching football. So I was going to sit with those guys. And then there's Mr. White. OK, Jonathan or John or whatever we're doing these days. Jay, Carl, there it is. There's another course, of course. Yeah, we got to go by. But yeah, we got to get an initial in there because we're we're we're artsy now. Sure. Yeah, he's got a Masters, don't you know, But anyway, so. All with love, All with love.

15:26 And yes, naturally, I hate saying this again. Let's clarify. He's a friend of mine, been a friend of mine a long time. So it's all friendly ribbon. And ultimately, at the end of the day, for dudes, I don't know who said this, but it's not my quote here. Insults are the language of friendship here. And so I insult him very, very aggressively here. But it is what it is. And he's Irving. He knows he's Irving. So I see him and I'm like, man, like this dude. And so when it started to change kind of by accident, because I, I automatically assume all the worse, whatever, I don't know about my fill in the details. I'm like this guy, look at that jacket. That's a prosperity gospel guy. If I ever saw it, I'm like, I'm not going to like. And then all of a sudden they're like, Hey, he's a middle school teacher. You're a middle school teacher. We have they think these like kind of small group things at the time they're called storm now that they call impact groups.

16:09 And it's like different kids from all throughout the campus. And the idea is get them all together and have like a small group thing instead of a regular Chapel settings. It's more intimate. You can talk and really get an old group of kids. And because he's a new teacher, they put him in there with me. And so I show up that time I'm like, I'm coming in hot on this thing. Like it's about like suffering and something like that. And like, I expected him to want some flowery nonsense back there. He's like sitting in the back and he's just kind of watching, figuring everything out. And so I come in top rope like pretty aggressively, you know, like, Hey, some kind of God will, you know, things to happen to you and that's for your good and trying to get this point across the kids. And I've got a video to kind of go with it and it feels it's heavy and it's in a way that I thought most people were going to be pretty upset about it. And so I, I keep looking back at him.

16:50 I'm like, I know, I know he's going to, he's going to lecture me when I get done because he looks like a guy that would lecture you. He definitely does. OK, So we go through and we get done and he kind of walks up and he was like complimentary. And I'm like, and I'm, you know, and my, my heart, I'm a little upset. So I'm like, I don't know if I'm going to hate him because he's with me now. He's with me. He's he's he's in the the canoe with me. We're rowing in the same direction theologically. And then he had a message at Chapel early on. And I'm like, so he gets up there and he does thing and it's an, it's an aggressive, you know, a message again on the topic of suffering and he doesn't from the Chapel. And it was, it was pointed. It was, it was difficult to kind of get in front of that group of kids and, you know, and, and so I was like, all right, I guess I do have to like this guy.

17:31 And I keep begrudgingly giving a little bit more respect. And then what kind of had to break. It was the ultimate proving ground for a middle school teacher, the overnight field trip. And so we're on a 7th grade field trip. I show up and I'm getting on the bus and I'm sitting there in the front and I'm like, let's see, let's you know, I'm, I'm pulling that book here. I'm reading, I'm reading some CS Lewis, I think it was till we all have faces like, you know, one of the CSL books. And I'm kind of going through and starting that off and I'm like, let's see what happens here. And so he starts chiming in on CS Lewis. And I'm like, if you like CS Lewis, I, the war's over. The war's over. I have to like, I, I don't have to love all that's going on there. But I think we're, I think we're friends here. And I think I got to call it Detente and we got to move forward.

18:14 CS Lewis, if you go to see us, there's a couple people. CS Lewis is 1. And I don't know how you're going to feel it. Tim Keller for me as a guy that wants to think through Christian a good deal, was a guy that just naturally just produced all these sort of resource stuff. So if you're in on either one of those, those guys, there's a level of respect that I have to go with. And he's been, in fairness, he's been a huge resource to him as a teacher, as a friend, you know, when things going on, he's a sounding board for me as as somebody I work next to and somebody's now principal here where we can kind of go through and I go, hey, like I was going to talk about this topic because I teach Bible now in this way. Like, what do you think? Or he said, well, that's great. Or he'd say, hey, why don't you look at it this way? And so he's been a big resource for me as a teacher and quite frankly, in a job like this. And forgive me if I talk too long here. Guys, no, you're good. It can be a lonely business.

18:57 And you think that sounds ridiculous because you're in front of people all day. And like for some of us, like I don't have a traditional planning period throughout the day. So it's just this army of children that comes through every of different ages that comes through me about 20 at a time every 50 minutes. And and you're, you're, you know, you see everybody in the morning before you start, you say hi and then you kind of go down the salt lines and you work all day and then you emerge at the end and you really don't know how you did because it's not a group of people who are going to be naturally responsive to what you're saying all the time. And that's partially developmental. It's partially just where their heads are. As you get in the older groups, sometimes it's like, Hey, I have these sins in my life and if I adopt some of the things you're talking about, that has ramifications for how I live.

19:40 And I don't want to do that yet. And so I have to understand where they're coming from. But that doesn't give you the, the, the feedback you always want. So for Mr., for Jonathan and others, it's it's good to have those people around to kind of help you out in. The circumstance no, I, I love that so much because it, it, it's such a travesty if you only hang around people that like totally echo everything you say to you say personality. It's like man. That that that's really cool to see that that connection how you guys balance like you guys feel very strongly about the things that matter and then, you know, can have that good back and forth and yeah, like you're saying, sanctification for each other. I'm sure I can't wait when I can't wait for his job and White back on the podcast and. Get a rebuttal, it'll be great Fairness to him. This is a complete and shameless blind side and I don't apologize for it.

20:27 I'm here to feel it. You know, You put the mic in front of my face, this is what you get. And so here we are. But in fairness, he has been a good friend and he's been helpful in this business and so definitely appreciate it. Now that that that, that's great. You got any comments on this specifically? Yeah, I was just going to say about the fashion I had this, this green. I even forgot what it's called, you know, little Irish wool kind. You. Know thing that kind of bends down that I wore a couple times and you know I wore it one time specifically because I wanted the green there and I was like yeah I don't think it really goes with this outfit as well so. There's like the kind of fluffy hat with the bill on it, like kind of the bagger fan special sort of deal. Yeah, yeah. It's called flat cap. OK, there we go. Like you're selling like newspapers. Like a news like you're like, you're like 9 years old. You're smoking cigarettes outside of New York City. Yeah, and I realized, like with my outfit, it's not the best jive, but, you know, I wore it for a particular reason that evening.

21:20 And he was like, yeah, what you need to get is a tweet, need a short coat with the elbow patches, have it all be like natural grain colors and stuff. And he's like, he was, he's talking me up. And I was like, yeah, I can see how that would go. Yeah, I haven't bought it yet, but I've. Gotten in his head now. So like sometimes he'll come by and he'll say, you know, like, because he's, he's, he's education through and through. He loves it, he lives it. That's one. And he'll come out, you know, and he'll start using terms or whatever and, and he'll start talking about, you know, in literature and transcendentalism. And I just like him on what are we doing? What are we doing right now? Like like he called down a little bit, but so he he talks about that sort of stuff the way I would talk about sports. And so I know what you're talking about. Usually that point in time where I kind of look at him and he understands what I'm saying here, which is like, bro, come on.

22:04 That, that, that's so good. And do you have anything else on this specifically I don't want? To move on too fast, I was. Going to say this, this is I, I like all these thoughts like so the different pieces complement each other so well. You mentioned, you know, Tim Keller a minute ago before we went on air, we were talking about baptism and you know, Tim Keller, Presbyterian, you go to Presbyterian Church. It's like I and I, I know from my own life, I feel like in a lot of ways I probably have benefited from Presbyterian authors a lot more than, you know, your Southern Baptist hyper dispensational. Careful admitting that on these mics. So it's like, I, I like, you know, so it's like Tim Keller's great, Kevin Deyoung, you got these people. It's like, man, they're just so clear. They write so well. The young as Presbyterian? What was that?

22:45 Deyoung as Presbyterian. I think so. I did not know that. I didn't know that. No, he, his church was actually, I think it used to be PCUSA and he recently brought them to the PCA one and maybe it needs to rethink the PCA now with everything going on there. I don't know, maybe it needs to go OPCI don't know, but it's some. Guy R something. RC Sprill Yeah, some ran weird guy, yeah, but it's like, I feel like all of the really well thought out books are written by a Presbyterian and then all the like. Not bad books, but they're not quite as they're maybe a lot more superficial or on the backside. It's a little it's a little less linear and quite fairness. It's a little less pedantic at times. There's a there's a stuffiness love the Presbyterian environment, but it could be a little little stuffy at times.

23:27 But certainly it's produced some good people who've influenced my life from the local level with our with my pastor Nathan Francis to, you know, big figures like Tim Keller, Sinclair Ferguson, people like that have impacted my life. And you know, like we were from it's off air earlier. Like, I don't know, like this comes down to an issue for me of like theologically what only matters because I, I did not grow up in a Presbyterian environment. I grew up going to church here. Honestly, theologically I probably am more Reformed Baptist, which I think maybe y'all don't admit it, but I think that's what we are. So we're. If we were trying to brush in broad strokes, we'd be Reformed Baptist, maybe with some asterisks. Because the Reform people will come at you and say, you got to be Calvinistic, creedal and confessional. And we'd be like, well, we're not confessional. I know we're not.

24:17 We're not saying the 1689 is our letter because I've said this before. And those Reformed people come at you hard and they're like, don't you say you're Reformed? You know what I mean? Typically our our senior pastor might say we're reformed in our soteriology. We are as a church dispensational, but we're not like that hard line dispensational craziness that first came out. In fact, my pastor and I, I mean, I guess in one sense all we're both pastors because we're both elders there, but our senior pastor and I are both what we would term progressive dispensationalist. So it's like it's close to being covenant theology that that you can be. But Israel still has a role and there will be a, a literal millennial reign.

25:00 But other than that, it's like a lot of the you might get there different ways, but where you end up is very similar to what some covenant theologians might might believe. And haven't been in different settings like there's so much overlap between the two. And so like the thing that we kind of discussed for a little bit here was like, what are the lines? What are kind of the things that are non negotiable as Christians? And then what are those things are kind of second tier close? Communion non negotiable. We would probably disagree on that. But I was, I'll just say I was raised close communion and I heard the man, the people at that church growing up, they believed it with all their hearts. And I'm not there today because I'm like, I think Paul probably took communion with the churches he planted, and he wasn't a member of that local body.

25:52 That seems like a pretty good argument. That's a guy that kind of has some sway in this community. I think that's like this is such a good topic to think through because I think previously you said in the on one level, in the context of your students coming from all walks of life, like what is essential, there's so much, you know, there's a billion different denominations within the denomination, there's different, you know, whatever. And then even on this level, you know, how does that flesh out practically, You know, how does that I would really maybe for different podcasts, like what I hear. Yeah. What's your life like at a Presbyterian Church? Because and at the same time, there are things about Charles the Bible church are not my favorite. I'm not like 100%, even though I would say very, very closely aligned. But let's talk. About those later and we'll we'll.

26:33 Very different things, yeah. So I think those are really good questions that have practical implications on all sorts of different levels, but it's, you know. In a school setting, it's, it's very different because it, you're not holding people to the same confession of faith that you would and in your church. And so trying to find out and, and draw clear lines of like we stand for this and we're very clear about certain lines and then other lines that are lower tier, you know, really kind of tier 3 kind of tertiary issues, old earth, young earth, those type of things, which I think clearly, I think we've all agreed kind of a tertiary story issue. Like we can disagree on that, but in in drawing as few hardcore lines as we can while also being fable to the message of the gospel in a setting where we know people are coming from all sorts of backgrounds.

27:20 And even amongst the Christians, there's going to be a lot of different opinions. So in a classroom setting, particularly as I'm teaching seniors, since they're really starting to, some of them are really taking ownership for this for the first time. Like clearly stating what I believe stating what is non negotiable, what's not is very important if that makes sense. That that makes a lot of sense that that sounds really good. What you got, Michael? What you thinking? Nothing, I would just echo what he was saying. I think the only time that because most of the questions that you get asked, at least that I experienced were some because I would occasionally have what we would call a question Friday where you know what, maybe we don't do trig today because y'all don't care about trig as seniors anyways, because this is not the this is not the honors class. So y'all are not going to go major in something that requires math.

28:07 So I could, I could see the bit like I want you to learn the skills of trig, but I can see there's a bigger picture. So we would just take a break sometime and just talk and you'd get some random stuff like do ghosts exist and stuff. So they're not asking about pedo baptism and and creedal baptism or anything like that. Not usually, no. Usually the questions are like you know about like the the truthfulness of the Gods word or the. Thing, what have you got? Like just a oddly hyper specific, like explained to me, super lapsarianism versus super lapsarianism. Like something like crazy. Like then you're like, what? How? What are you talking about? No. Oh. Geez, that's a great question. You get you get ones and this is an episode. I know you all have covered before and I believe you would have a shirt about this if I'm correct, but I'll occasionally like a kid will just come off the top rope with like a hey nepheline big fella, let's do this.

28:56 And and then I've learned this from the previous podcast, like maybe I'm not pronouncing it right 'cause this one of those words, like I always felt like I was good on it. And then y'all were like, you know, trying to. Just I think it is nepheline, right? I think I think it is. It's a word that you see all the time, but it's not like I'm going to hear that at Publix when I'm buying rutabagas. So there's no way for me to like, no, it's just a word you see. And so you say it, and then you're like, maybe I got that right, maybe I didn't. Yeah, I think we probably butchered it like the first episode we talked about like on it too. It's just so funny. But if we all butcher it together and we do it confidently, we're good to go. Yeah, I had one student at one time ask me, you know, what do you think about where I'm at spiritually, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, you want, you want the unvarnished truth? And I was like, he was like, yeah.

29:37 And I, like, laid it out for him. And I was like, I think, you know, And then another guy heard that. He's like, you tell me. And I'm like, well, you know, and I was like, my guess is you're struggling with porn right now. And I gave him. All these recent. And he was like, you know, you're, you're not wrong on that. So you can have some very serious conversations about about stuff. And those were like, sometimes I felt like, can I have this conversation with you? Can I be just no varnish What I think you're what's going on in your life right now? And but I think that those guys respected me because we had that conversation. Yeah. And like, it's they to some extent, they want to see a level of courage from you to be willing to say like, hey, I'm going to tell you the truth on any number of different issues.

30:21 And the fact that you're willing to like have deep conversation about big issues. There's a balance because it's like, I don't want to speak about a student with limited information if I'm not pretty certain about what I'm saying. But if you're asking me, here's where I think your heart is. Here's where I think whatever's going on in your life, here's what concerns me. And that's, you know, one of those things that like we're always looking for, we're looking for those opportunities. And if a student lays in front of you, it's got a fair game. But it's also the atmosphere of like, am I doing it in a public setting? Am I having in a private setting? Yeah, we can do that in front of in front of the whole class. But in like, honestly, you know, certain ones are definitely going to be in private, but there are other ones that like on a theological issue or something like that, it's like, OK, this is brought up in public.

31:02 This is the class setting. I think it's a big thing. And one of the things that I've really tried to model, especially with the seniors now is try to tell them like, hey, I want you're going to have to comport yourself in a Christian manner as we disagree. And so I have to remodel that. So like one of the things we've done, and this is kind of on the side tangent here is I do current events where like I have them bring in a topic they want to talk about and write out a article. You know, what happened, basically who wrote it? You know, what's the source kind of, and I'll analyze the source a little bit, but more so the big thing is like, OK, how do I fit this into a Christian worldview? What should a Christian think about this? And they have, you know, a couple sentences for five sentences on that paragraph. And so then talk about it and it brings up lots of things and occasionally it brings up disagreements with me over political issues, over social issues, whatever it is.

31:48 And so one of the things that is challenging is, and the kids are almost always very respectful. But even if it if it starts to elevate or if they talk to each other in a certain type of way, like I want to model like, hey, we don't get to stop being Christian because we disagree with someone on a political issue. And we have to comport ourselves differently regardless of how the world treats us. And certainly in a room where theoretically we're talking amongst Christians and friends, we need to disagree better. And so trying to teach kids to do that. And they're usually good at it, but occasionally like it's the world, they grow up and it's snarky 1 liners online. It's, it's things like that. It's it's pretty glib insults, which are always part of being a teenager. But it, I think when it's on your phone and it's in your pocket, it never leaves you in a way that we could kind of leave it alone for a little while. And so I think it hits different. Yeah, that that's great because we can't disagree, but it's like you always just want to dunk on someone with this like one liner, like got them, you know, it's like more about that than discourse.

32:44 It helps. No one, no, because like that instantly is going to make the person defensive. And so like what I like big questions I want to use in different environments and I don't always get to it. I'm certainly not perfect asking who's been in my class. You got a whole crew in your house that's been in my class is I want to ask you questions like, OK, what do you think? I mean when I say this and that like it puts them in my situation or ask them to define a term for me, that kind of thing. Just because those kind of open up conversation in a different type of way and hopefully create some level of empathy, some level of understanding for the other side because that's I alone am not wise and neither are you. So let's like see where the other person come from. We can still disagree. That's perfectly fine and good and healthy at times, but ultimately we have to disagree as Christians first and foremost with that. Does that make?

33:32 Sense. It's great. It's great. I love it. Where, where are we at on on our timing here? Well, overall, it's just hard to know because we're borrowing, but the counter is says 38. How? Sweet, this is good. I think it's like prime's the pump really well. I would next one of these podcasts is going to get crowded in here, but we got to get Jay Carl. Honestly, where the Jay Carl. I want to see you dressed to the Niners. I want you in the tweed you show up to your. Uniform And one last thing before I I'm sorry, I got to say this. We did one day at school. The kids asked us to do it one day and they said look, can you? Can you dress as each? Other. And so like, here's the part that's sad about this part. So he texted me that morning. He's like, hey, I need to know you're still doing this because he was going to get there for me. He's like, I need to know I'm not being left on an aisle with no explainer.

34:19 And the amazing thing is when I showed up, I usually I'm pretty like I'm about as Loki's. They get in the tire, as you can see from this moment here. But like, he usually shows up how to dress at every level in the hair and whatnot. He's like, OK, what's the quintessential Gilbert look? And I'm like, OK, so we gave like a football coaches shirt and gym shorts, which is quite a thing if you're not, you know, 'cause you used to Jonathan being dressed rigidly and starchy. So seeing him dressed in like my attire and not doing his hair, just kind of leaving it down. And here's the thing. He got there first and he's in there like getting coffee and making copies or doing whatever he does before he teaches the class, whatever. And so he's in there and like nobody wanted to ask him about it because I think it's like near the end of the year and we're having like AC trouble that day.

35:01 They're like just gave up. I think they're like, he just gave up. He just thought even he broke. And so nobody said anything till they saw me show up. And like the expectations I said were apparently so low because they see me show up and I'm dressed like him. I've got on the long sleeve shirt, I got on the hipster glasses. You know, I'm doing whatever here. I've got like a coffee mug just trying to get what if I was unfathomably pretentious? What would I what would I do? And so I'm like, here we are. And so I, you know, I showed that day and then at that point in time, it made sense. And I think he felt more comfortable, but it I was physically hurt that day. And I think he was emotionally hurt because he felt vulnerable. There was like, I don't usually dress like this, like, bro, what do you think? I do it over here. Or Bear. Yeah, it's great.

35:41 That's so funny. Do you have a picture of that? I would love to see that dress as. I will need to try to find that and my phone will look at the picture that yeah. We'll put it up. Love it. Now the real question is, do you remember what to say to close this out? See, I keep getting walked to this ledge every time, and you know I'm going to fall off the edge every single time. So I keep getting walked, walked, walked, walked. And then you just kind of give it that last push of the edge. And that's what this feels like here, I think. I think, and I'm going to get this wrong and I'm going to do it confidently. That's going to make it worse. And that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.