...where we take theology 2 the next level
Aug. 15, 2024

Is Mary the Mother of God?

Is Mary the Mother of God?
Is Mary the Mother of God?
Take 2 Theology
Is Mary the Mother of God?

Bonus Episode 1


Michael and Zach discuss whether or not it is proper to call Mary the mother of God.


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/xWm0HK2u0I4


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/

0:05 Bonus time. What's, what do you mean, Michael, what's going on? Bonus podcast. Mike, where are your heads at? I just learned about this bonus podcast about 30 seconds because I'm just as excited as you. So I asked that like we should do like a short 5 minute podcast on the topic that shows itself over and over again in this Facebook group that I'm in called Theology Matters. Is Mary the mother of God Zach? That is a loaded question, and it's hard to say yes or no without saying more than that 'cause you really need to qualify what you mean. Or you can, as you said at the last podcast, fall into a You can fall into at least one ditch, really.

0:46 Badly. Yeah. So I, I think we both agreed there's a sense in which we could say, yes, she's the son of the the mother of God. But there is also a sense we could say, no, she's not the mother of God. So we just recorded the podcast on theology proper. We went through a bunch of incommunicable attributes of God, things that he can't share with us because, you know, we can't ever have those. Did Mary pass any of those attributes on to the Son of God? Man, that seems like an obvious answer, but apparently. It's not, no. Yeah.

1:26 So like Jesus, we would say he's the God man, right? And you know this Calcedonian formula, and it's in the Caledonian creed that Mary the Mother of God. But we have to understand that so clearly somehow the Holy Spirit comes upon Mary and takes I guess I I guess if we took adna sample of Jesus, that'd be very interesting and like compared it 23andMe. I think Mary would show up as his mother if we. Did. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. So where did that other DNA come from? I I don't know. Clearly he got AY chromosome from some from some place. Yeah, and, and I'm, I'm looking at this Caledonian creed here and maybe the answer answers in here, 'cause every, this is like you were saying, this is where the problem comes from. Cause everyone loves the early creeds, at least up to a certain, up to a certain number.

2:21 And then maybe like, yeah, they're getting a little, a little wonky. But the verbiage here is that Jesus was born of the Virgin Mary, the mother of God. But then it says according to the manhood and that that that clarifies a lot to. Perfect, that's perfect. And that's what I that's what I said in this forum. Like, yes, she is the mother of his humanity and someone's like, well, you can't separate his humanity from his divinity. I'm like, and the person they're not separated like the person Jesus Christ, they are not separated fully God fully man. Mary didn't contribute to the God part. Like she only contributed to his humanity part. Yeah, I, I don't understand what, what the, what the trouble is here. I know some of these Facebook groups, I'm into some of these reformed ones where they really like holding on to these creeds, which I don't think there's anything wrong with it. But they'll they'll kind of rest and say they, they always go back to the Greek Theo tacos.

3:15 I guess they're like that, they want to qualify, but they're like don't, don't be afraid of saying that. Just know if you're talking to maybe a Catholic person, you need to you want to qualify. What you mean? Right. And I think that's a problem because if you just say she's the mother of God, it sounds like, like I'm, you know, Michael is the mother of Laura. I mean, pardon me, Laura is the mother of Michael. Hey. Laura is the mother of Michael and I derive, you know, a lot of my characteristics from my mom, but I also have a father and I derive some characteristics from him because they're both human. We don't get all a bound up like, well, you know, Laura is the mother of these parts of Michael and Charles is the father of these parts of Michael. But Jesus is a unique being like no other being is. Fully God, fully man.

4:02 So I think it deserves some care on our part when we like talk about who Mary is. Cause there would be. See if you agree with this, there'd be nothing wrong with you saying, and this would all be speculation, but there's a world where there are some physical characteristics where Jesus could favor Mary humanly, right. That's OK And that's what and that's what we're pushing it towards the to the humanity aspect. It's not like some of that immutability. I saw that, Mary. It's. Like, no, yeah, yeah. So yeah, I would think that maybe there are maybe even personality traits that yeah, that he would have shared with with Mary. Like what? What sense does it make to say that he is a descendant of David if he doesn't have some type of genetic lineage back to David and to Abraham and and eventually to Adam if you're tracing it in Luke?

4:51 Yeah. So to go back to this question, can you clarify 'cause I think I missed it, I know you just said it. They would be saying that. Oh man, some of Jesus, you know, fill in the blank XY or Z came from Mary. Like like literally like what kind of proper? What kind of attributes? Yeah, I would say, you know, clearly all of his humanity and some like you can't even say all of his humanity because he got AY chromosome from some way. So the Holy Spirit somehow miraculously, you know, I assume took an egg of Mary. We we're not told we're this is this is speculation. Took an egg of Mary and fertilized it somehow in a miraculous way. And that physical being is God man. And the man part had to develop and grow. The man part had to learn how to tie his shoes. The man part had to learn how to spell his name. And yet the God part of him is eternal God. And so Mary, you know, clearly gave birth to this person. This person is the God man.

5:53 She mothered Jesus and I'm 100% like I'm bored. Mary is the mother of Jesus. I don't think you have. Qualified that at all better a a a more clear way probably to say it. I think, I think that's good. And it's, you know, there's no, yeah, no problem physically, some of the trades, there's probably certain habits and customs and stuff. It's like those, those, all those all happen in families and stuff. But you do run some dicey territory because if you say that, then you have to say something else about Mary. And I think that makes a lot of sense when you when you think about, you know, the Catholic thought process, it's where they kind of have to go. Right. Yeah. Well, you know, they, they, they have a bunch of other stuff that, you know, that she was perpetually a virgin, she was sinless.

6:36 And that's, you know, that's not supported scripturally so. And yeah, yeah, not, not at all. Well, that, that what a what a delight. A bonus episode. Bonus. Wow man. You weren't even expecting this. You woke up the day I don't even know I wasn't. Expecting this. I don't even know when this will drop, but you weren't expecting it 'cause it won't be a Tuesday or Thursday. Oh, oh, I like that. Just Randra. Maybe we'll do a couple more of these. I I like this, Yeah. All right, that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.