...where we take theology 2 the next level
Sept. 25, 2024

Pneumatology Part 1 | Who is the Holy Spirit?

Pneumatology Part 1 | Who is the Holy Spirit?
Pneumatology Part 1 | Who is the Holy Spirit?
Take 2 Theology
Pneumatology Part 1 | Who is the Holy Spirit?

Episode 70


Who is the Holy Spirit? What roles does He play?


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/5t_xR0xkiig


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com

0:00 Well, last podcast we talked about what a disaster I think the disaster is. My boom stand is is breaking. Well, well, I went I I don't want to like Colin went out, but about twice a podcast Michael will smack a boom stand. Actually, it's been better. There was there was a time I like hit it every time. So I tried to you just heard me clearing my throat. We were talking about what a disaster. Berkeley County is pollen. It must be crazy high. So I'm it's bad. I was sniffing some in the last podcast that you would have heard on Tuesday if you're keeping up and I I probably will sniff a couple times this podcast. I was I was victorious and holding off a sneeze one time.

0:41 You're more than conqueror. I was more than conqueror. That's right, man. And all those things. I, I, I, I've been having a hard time, like sleeping at night. I think I'm like the pollen and stuff. I'm a little cranky. Michael's like evaluating my wardrobe. I'm just going to, I want to, I want to throw float this out to all the listeners out there. Is Navy blue that much different than black? Basically the same, Michael. They're completely different colors. Well, so I'm the one that has to produce this and remove this green screen. And there there was one. You can go back and find it where the green screen's here because he's wearing a blue shirt. But not Navy. But for some reason, the blue and the green is enough because, you know, this green screen, maybe I should take green skin off a little bit. It's not perfectly flat.

1:29 So with these little shadows, I have to kind of increase the tolerance of the, the video editing so it can get all of it away. And so sometimes, you know, our boom stands will slightly disappear because it's trying to remove that. My headphones good enough for you too, Michael the. Headphones are good. Yeah, Yeah. But I will say, I will say to your credit, you know, I was in the Navy. I was in the Navy and you know, there were things that we would call Navy blue that were just straight up black. Like, no, that's Navy blue. Like it's literally black. And they would call it Navy blue. So you're like, you need to put on your Navy Blues. Now, I was an officer, so I didn't have that particular uniform, but yeah, the, the list of guys did. And they they their dress Blues were black.

2:10 This is. Yeah. Relativism creeping into the military, huh? I'm just kidding. Well, I I think I'm just kidding. You have to delay which. Somewhere drifts over time and it becomes tradition type of thing. Well, I'll tell you on a positive note to get away from all this pollen and Navy blue talk. And me sniffing again. And the sniffling I I got a text not too long ago I want to give a shout out. While we were in the middle of the of the recording, the last one, right? Yeah, great, Great time. I checked my phone right right there and the the Texas dude. I've been listening to y'all's podcast. Big fan from none other than my guy Adam Angus. We go way back. Sounds like he knows beef to me. Adam Angus, that's good.

2:54 He that, yeah, he from Memphis. Haven't talked to him in a little bit but always, always a good time. Does he cheer for the Memphis Tigers or the ASU Indian slash Red Wolves? I should I should ask him. I'm trying to think who his. For some reason he's like a Texas Longhorns fan or something. I'm Angus. It goes with the IT goes with the I. I might be totally butchering this, Adam. You'll have to text me. I'm like blanking on your college. Football. You could literally text him right now. I can text him right now. While he's texting you, you do the texting 'cause we need to know. Viewers want to know how a a Memphonian? Is that what y'all wear?

3:37 What's what is it? I don't even know Memphian. Memphian became a Longhorns or you know, probably, probably raise it back. LSU Tigers. You could have really anything in there. Yeah, we'll see. We'll see what he says it. I think his dad is a Bama fan, so we'll see. Yeah, I'm talking. I'm talking to you, Lee Angus. I want to, I want to say that's because there's always like, trash talking to everyone. But you know, you know, you know how those Bama fans are. Oh, I mean just the worst. I mean the worst. Absolute worst. So while you're looking up that, you know, just revisit this banter's all over the place. It's just, it's just us thinking out loud. You asked about chess club interviews. Oh yeah, on the last.

4:22 You need to interview for chess club. Yeah, 'cause last so. What do you wear to a chess club interview? I I I have so many questions. Wear a school uniform. That's what you do. Yeah, 'cause 'cause our school has uniforms. But last year, a talented group of 5th graders, I don't want to take anything away from them, but very rambunctious. And it was just a a pool of guys. And it's like, I think even if I had done interviews with them last year and kind of had been able to set the tone instead of just been saying these are the guys who are, you know, it was guys and some gals who are going to be in chess club like, 'cause if you feel like, man, there's something on the line, yeah, that makes it. But regardless, they, they were 20 people who were interested. And I just can't take 20 man.

5:05 Cuts to the tournament. Yeah, the, there's a tournament. The bus only seats 14 + a chaperone. We end up taking two buses cause it's lower school and middle school. One day, sorry, I'm gonna have to cough here in a second, clear my throat. But so they played and I was evaluating, you know, I played against them. Headley beat all of them. I just, that's right. I mean. Hopefully. I mean, if I'm. Getting beat by a lower school guy should be Hopefully it's, you know, someone that's like studied with Magnus. This is probably more than what you want to know. No, I, I. More than what? Than what the listers I want. I have so many questions. Is there like an equipment manager for like the chess team? Like, you know, like take stats and like you know. Yeah. So you know, very simply I would say I, I would always, I would purposely like leave the board kind of just right. Hey can you help me set up the board? So knowing how the pieces are set up doesn't make you a good player but but not knowing how the piece is set up means you've not played a lot that.

6:01 Knight bishops. Tricky King. Queen is, yeah, the, the church is next to the power. That's all I tell them. Yeah, the bishops right next to the power of the king and queen in there. And the Queens, you know, ladies are fastidious about color. Queens always go on their own color, so. Yeah, I like. I'll give them those hints and stuff, but then I, you know, I, I, I love to watch them and like, 'cause you know, a player who's played, you know, I, I don't know what I am 11112 hundred 1300 somewhere around there on the fee day. But you know, the better you get, you can kind of see in advance. And I love like making a move and then seeing their like, because some people don't know and then then they're going, some of them with their eyes get big and they're like, and those are people like, OK, they could have probably, you know, a better player would have seen this coming, but now they recognized it and now they're problem solving to get out of it. And then, then I'm taking notes on that person and, and, you know, putting them up to the top, 'cause that's what I'm looking for.

6:55 Like how do they respond? You know, I forked one person and they were like, I don't think I have a good move. And I put one person in checkmate. And it took them a while and they were just studying it, studying it, studying it. And he's like, I don't think my king can move anywhere. I'm like, you can't, you can't. You're checking, but you know, it's good that like I'm evaluating, you know how thoughtful and and really behavior because you know they there. Was chess club kids? You're right, they're always out of control. Well, they're. Just. So it's good and we had our first official chess club today and it was good. I set the tone early, got them to be quiet.

7:36 Man. We went over openings 'cause you know, this is way more than people want to know. But I will say one more thing, then I'll then I'll shut up. I'm trying to give you time to get this text back from your friend, but I know I don't know what it is about this age group. They always want to open up with their A and their H. Those are your side pawns. Open those up, get your rooks out immediately and then try to start doing stuff with your rooks. I'm like, no, don't do that. And I would always do the London opening. So my white Bishop is just lined up on what would it be like A 6A6 or A5? I'd have to look at the board.

8:17 I'm not Magnus or Hikaru but and they would bring like 3 different players. My Bishop just sniped their Rook away. I'm like you're gonna, you're not gonna like this. Boom. Boom and never gonna learn. I like it. Well, you really stalled a lot and Adam has not gotten back. To me. So sorry to disappoint everyone out there. No, everyone's like, what's his favorite football team? Maybe, maybe yeah, we'll we'll mention briefly next podcast or something just for those trying to bridge the gap. But this morning or evening or afternoon, I don't know, when you're listening to this podcast, you're gonna hear a little bit about the Holy Spirit. And man, I'm coaching K through 12 soccer and talk about rambunctious.

8:59 We had a great first practice today, not as good, a little bit out there. So we need a I'm trying to connect it somehow, Holy Spirit. You need the Holy Spirit come in and sanctify those kids some. Sanctification. I like it. So join us as we take it to the next level from the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. Well, Michael, if you are following along, I'm sure you are. We're going through this foundations class at our church, hitting these pivotal essential topics, things like bibliology and theology proper and Christology and anthropology, and we find ourself at pneumatology and all these fancy.

9:50 Words. It's about your lungs. It's the study of the lungs, right? You would, you could think you could make that. That's a good, good connection. You're. You're getting good word play there. Yeah. Yeah. Now that that's good. But I mean, you really, I think Pastor Joel said that too. Like, you know, it could be the study of wind or breath or or whatever this context we're thinking the study of the Holy Spirits. When I, when I, when you think about the etymology, there is in Scripture some intentional word play going on with the Holy. You see your Holy Spirit associated with wind from time to time. Yeah, and one of those is Nicodemus. Jack would preach on Nicodemus and it was always Nick at night. I don't know if you've.

10:33 So what a great title. But you know he's asking Jesus questions. You like that? I. Forgot but I've I've heard. This before, Yeah, he's asking Jesus these questions and he's like, you're ruler of Israel and you don't know these things. And he makes this word play about the spirit and the, you know, the wind blows and you don't know where where it is, but you see the effects of it. So too is the spirit. And he's kind of, you know, using that same word and doing that word play. And then in Acts 2, Pentecost, there's this mighty rushing wind with with the Spirit. So a little bit, a little bit behind the scenes with the etymology, like, you know, where, where, where is it? Where do we get this word from? And Holy Spirit is coming on the heels of theology proper and Christology where, you know, we think of the Trinity. I don't think it's a common misconception, but I think people do mistake the Holy Spirit for a force or an impersonal, you know thing rather than a person. Yeah, and he is a a.

11:29 He is God equal codivine with the Father, the Son Co eternal. All the things that are about the of the nature of the Spirit that are true of the Father and the Son are true of the Spirit. It's really the relationships they have between each other. And then some people will call it the the economic Trinity, like their roles, like what, what they've chosen to do in, in all that they're doing. So they they take on different roles and they have different relationships. But as far as the nature of the essence it's got, He's God now. That that is good. Pastor Joel mentioned the Athanasian Creed. You did. You did it as well. And yours, right? Yeah. So something that is important, you know, be familiar with Reed. That kind of helps give us some guardrails to stay within. And I read a lot of it during when I was on theology proper. Why would I have read it for theology proper? What was I reading it for?

12:25 I'm just trying to think back. I, I don't know if you were, I feel like all of y'all kind of talked about the Trinity in some aspects. Oh yes, yes, because we did talk about the Trinity at the end of theology proper because God in in his proper, because I wasn't necessarily talking about the Father, although we, you know. But oh, I see. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, but we and read it and it's like, how many ways can they say the same thing a different way? But they really want to draw a tight box around this so that there can be no confusion on the Father, Son, the Holy Spirit, their Trinity, three in one, one being 3 persons. Go go read it. I you know, you can look at that. That's right. It it does draw that box where you know, if you're inbounds out of bounds, you can you can figure figure that. And I'll say one more thing.

13:10 I don't think Pastor Joel developed this at length, but it's a good study to just, you know, write outlook up all the ways Holy spirits mentioned that kind of point to his personhood with his actions. He can be grieved. He loves, he speaks, he gives, you know, he's a counselor and a comforter and a helper and these things you would, you know, attribute to a a person and the reason going back to the Trinity specifically, you know, you would think it's outlined there pretty clearly curly, but but people get get this. Wrong. There are people who get it wrong, you know, Mormons get it wrong. I talked to a guy I graduated with and they would say that the spirit, you know, all, all of us were spirit children of Father God and some of those were better than others.

14:01 And Jesus was a spirit child who got a body and then came back and, you know, did perfectly did what Father God wanted. And the Spirit is also God because he perfectly does it. But in their theology, in order to be purified and really go to that next level, you have to go through the process of getting a body and coming back. And I asked him, the Spirit never got a body right? And he said, no, I'm like, how does that line up with this idea? And I gave him the passage of the doctrine that in order to really be the best, you have to like, how could that? How could that person be God? And you know it, They really are. Try try theists.

14:42 Yeah, when it when it comes down. Or more. Or more 'cause everyone, I mean, like eventually that's the goal, right? Like become, become a God. So that that's why this kind of thing is important. And I would say, you know, creeds, confessions, these things, not the end all be all, but they do give us a good box to check yourself that way. So, and I'm not saying they can't be wrong, you know, but I think they've been tried and tested for it for the most part. It's a good place at least to compare your note till you're close. Are we saying something totally different than you? Might want to do some further reflection in scripture. Yeah, and, and Scripture does give support for the the Spirit being a person and, and the Spirit being different than the Father or the Son in the 1st place. You'd run into it.

15:25 You know, in the beginning, God created the heavens of earth. The earth was wooden, without form. Dark was on the face of the deep, and the spirit of was on of God was on the face of the water. Yeah, you don't have to. You don't have to read very long before you like Holy Spirit's a New Testament thing. It's like, well no, just open your Bible. Right. Yeah, yeah, Open to the very beginning. The spirits moved there. You know, I think Genesis 127 let us make man in our own image. You know, if you're following Hyzer exactly, he's going to say that's the Elohim, the the Divine Council. But there's a lot of people who say, no, that's the Trinity. Yeah, I don't have to. I don't know the way I had to weigh in on that or. Or yeah, I don't. Yeah, that verse doesn't make a brick. Like my whole theology's like change because we see the spirit active all over the place in the Old Testament. I mean, you know, maybe.

16:14 It's not super expensive, but it's like he's, you know, slaying those people, comes on Saul, leaves Saul, comes on David, from what we can tell, never leaves David. These these skilled people in the Tabernacle, it's like, oh, I don't know their they got, they got, I should have looked up their names, but it's like man, spirits not just coming on, you know, King David, but some of these these builders, you know, you. Wouldn't have been able to pronounce those builders names anyway so. It's fair, fair points. And then what what's interesting, I think this is subject to a little debate as well. In what capacity? But we look at the New Testament and the Holy Spirit's much more explicit, much, much more defined.

16:55 And we see, you know, every believer much more explicitly receives the Holy Spirit versus the Old Testament. You see, like comes, goes or it's on this person, meaning it wasn't at some point. Yeah, I would say, you know, probably David was the closest example of what a New Testament believer might, what we might experience. I wonder if his experience was different than our experience of the believer. We we just don't have those types of details. But I mean this part of the new covenant, I mean that that the Holy Spirit is given in a new way, you know, in the upper upper room discourse, you know, he says, you know, I got to go away so the helper can come to you and. That's a good thing too, right?

17:36 Like it's like I'm going away. But this is good 'cause you will get get the Holy Spirit. Pastor Jill, he took some time to develop this passage in Second Corinthians chapter 3 that talks about what you're talking about, Old Covenant, new Covenant, if you want to lay it down for us. Yeah, so it might chapter 3 and 2nd Corinthians, not too long, but it's probably too long for us to read all of it. But you should go read it. But I'll read 7 through 11, then I'll end with 18. So 7 says. But if the ministry of death and letters engraved on stones is talking about the the old covenant came with glory, so that the sons of Israel could not look intently at the face of Moses because of the glory of his face fading as it was, how will the ministry of the Spirit fell to be even more with glory?

18:22 For if the ministry of condemnation has glory, much more does the ministry of righteousness abound in glory. For indeed, what had glory in this case has no glory because of the glory that surpasses it. For if that which fades away was the glory, much more that which remains is in glory. And he goes on talking about our hope, you know, you know, talking about the Old Testament and the Old Covenant and the veil being torn in two. He ends in verse 18, it says, but we all with unveiled face, beholding as in a mirror the glory of the Lord are being transformed into the same image from glory to glory, just as from the Lord, the Spirit.

19:05 So it ends with his emphasis on the Spirit. Yeah, that that is so good. And it what I think is noteworthy about the passage is that old covenant had some glory. Like like it's not you just don't push it. And I think we've been seeing that in Romans as well and the role the Spirit plays in that. We'll see the same kind of idea in Ezekiel 36, the little heading and the ESP for this whole section, which just like Second Corinthians 3, can't read the whole thing. It it's a lot. You should read the whole thing. It's titled I will put my Spirit within you. And starting in verse 25, Ezekiel writes, I will sprinkle clean water on you and you shall be clean from all your uncleanness and from all your idols.

19:46 I will cleanse you and I will give you a new hearts and a new spirit I will put within you. And I will remove the heart of stone from your flesh and give you a heart of flesh. And I will put my spirit within you and cause you to walk in my statutes and be careful to obey my rules. So we see the spirit that that that's one of distinguishing features of the new covenant, that you'll have this new heart. And that that comes along with the Holy Spirit and his work. Yeah. And and so all throughout the covenants, you see this kind of future looking forward to the new covenant, you know, talks about, you know, Abraham, I'm going to make a great nation through you. All the nations through you're going to be blessed. Talks about David, you're going to have a son that sits on the throne forever. He's going to reign forever in peace. And then, you know, we see Jeremiah 3131, you know, talking about this new covenant, Ezekiel 36 talking about this new covenant.

20:37 Isaiah talks about, you know, there's going to be a prophet who's going to come and he's going to like make make straight the path for the Messiah. And he's going to like bring up the lowlands, bring down the Highlands. Great song. And Handel's Messiah should go listen to it. Get ready for for Christmas. But John the Baptist is that guy who's really starting to usher in that transition. And it's kind of a already not yet. And we're kind of still in some sense, and it's already not yet. But John the Baptist is that prophet that Isaiah talked about coming on the scene, going to start proclaiming the Kingdom of God is at hand. And then, of course, you know, Jesus, come, God the Son comes on the scene and he's going to, you know, live his life, build a ministry, fulfill the law, dies of sacrifice.

21:30 And as he's dying, we do it all, all the, all the time We do the Lord's Supper. He's like, you know, says this is my bread, it's broken for you. Take and eat it. Then he says, this is no, the cup, this is my blood poured out for you, a sign of the new covenant. And so he's really instantiating, Oh, I'm, I'm ushering in the new covenant that these other prophets have talked about. Wow. And you know, if we keep going along in this story we read in the New Testament, we get Pentecost, Acts chapter 2 and we see the Spirit poured out in a pretty remarkable way. We'll probably talk about a little later a lot of debate about, hey, is this prescriptive for every Christian or this just descriptive?

22:12 Or is it maybe maybe not necessary. A lot of a lot of good questions surrounded. Fire on your head. Am I am IA real Christian? Yeah. And what is mighty rushing? When is the the fire and and the speaking in tongues that just works in a substantial just amaze amazing way Happens in Acts 2 and Joe kind of zooms out and in light of all these great passages, we really take it for granted this new covenant's like do we really understand the magnificence and marvelousness of what we've got? Yeah, 'cause I I don't know that your Old Testament believer had the help to be sanctified in the same way that we do. So it's hard to imagine what that looked like it but we know it's different and grander and but this is all we know. So it's hard to like compare the two. I I wonder if there was an Old Testament believer around the time of Pentecost who would be like, oh, this is how it was and now this is what it was like and difference. We need to interview that guy.

23:12 Or, Oh yeah, we'll get him on the pod. That'd be great. But we take it for granted. You know who doesn't take it for granted? Pentecostals. They are leaning. They're taking a lot of they, they weren't taking that for granted, but they're taking a lot and claiming it. Yeah, yeah. They are. They are. Yeah. So I think, I think we would disagree slightly with some of their theological stances. You know, no disrespect, Bradley and Brandon, hopefully y'all are still tuning in. But it's central to to their way of thinking about church. They want the Spirit to be there with them and and they want to live in the Spirit and have the spirit manifest in in, in good works and perhaps miraculous things.

23:58 Joel threw out a bunch of stats. I'm going to butcher the history so I won't won't get into it. But his point was Pentecostals it it's relatively new, kind of started the turn of the after the 1900s, nineteen 01 started gaining some steam. And, and really, if you look across across the world, it's just growing rapidly, you know, in places like Africa and, you know, South America and you really see this movement growing in a, in a real remarkable way where it resonates with people and, and some level, and maybe some of that's tied up to some of the prosperity stuff a little bit, maybe probably a lot of it's not it's, it's, it's really a broad term, especially charismatic is much more broad than Pentecostal, where I don't really know what it means if Benny Hinn and John Piper are the same. I don't know that means everyone. So I understand why these.

24:45 Numbers can be so large. Yeah, there's a lot of people. I mean, in some sense that we, you know, we would say, I don't, it'd be hard to classify us as charismatic. But we are not closed to the possibility that someone could speak in tongues. We're not close the possibility that God could use someone to heal. So someone may say, oh, you 2, you're charismatic. No, I yeah, that's your definition, I think. I think MacArthur's by himself over there in California. I'm just kidding. There's a lot with him, but that, I mean, never really that actually makes sense with some of these stats that I'm seeing like if that, if that's the you're open to this possibility. So let's talk a little more about Acts 2. This gift of the Holy Spirit may be tied in with it. Talk about baptism in the Spirit. What's this mean?

25:29 We hear it a lot. It is. Is it associated with I feel like I'm in the Spirit? Is it manifested by I speak in tongues? So I've had the baptism in the Spirit. Is it a term that applies to all believers? I think there's a lot of confusion around that term specifically and what it means. Yeah, and we, we did a whole podcast on baptism. So go back and listen 'cause we, we'll, we'll hit some of this. And I was just thinking, should I try to pull up some of those notes 'cause I kind of detailed a lot of them. But, you know, I don't have instant recall, especially on today while I'm fighting allergies. But yeah, so we we do see these ideas of being baptized in the Spirit. There's, you know, we talked about being baptized and being immersed in and changed by. Pickling.

26:13 Pickling Dying. Dying. Dying cloth. So hopefully, you know, hopefully we're all being baptized in spirit. I want to be changed by the Spirit. I want to be changed by Christ, you know, And so, yeah. So I don't know if you wanted to go through some of the the different examples that that he gave. Yeah, so and what's interesting about this term, 'cause I think it's thrown around a lot, It's not like it's on every page of Scripture. It's like it's never mentioned. But this phrase, baptism in the Spirit or a close rendering of that phrase, it's really only mentioned 7 times in all of the New Testament. So small sample size, you probably need to be a little bit careful. And I think the question is if you're talking to, you know, someone that's full-fledged Pentecostal. 2nd Baptism.

26:59 Yeah, yeah. They would basically say, yeah, this is like a special class of Christian that you got, you know, your average Christian then like you're super out of, they would say it that way, but you're super Christian. They're speaking in tongues. They're they're in the spirit in a different way than someone who is saved is. There's this delineation in some capacity. Yep, Yep. And this is what I had referenced. You know, the Pastor Stelling I never met the met the man, but Jack did and what and said that pastor stunning related to him when he was young. He was, you know, with, you know, he was getting kind of hyped up when all this was hitting the scenes when your Pentecostalism was and he's like, I went to my apartment and like prayed and fasted for three days for baptism spirit.

27:41 And then he said I experienced something that was not the spirit of the Holy Spirit and not and he's like, I was trying to open myself up and and he's like, so I never went that way again. Again, anecdotal. Yep. We wouldn't want to base anything off that. But I know that there have been good people who have had, you know, made bad experiences with this. No, that that that's a good word of caution. And so if you're kind of going through these areas where in Scripture where the baptism spirit have mentioned it's affiliated associated with John the Baptist four times also we have 4 gospels. So so so maybe. It's one event that's getting recorded four times. One times mentioned in reference to Christ, which is also kind of closely such which on the Baptist deal. So so some of these things are are you know it it kind of even reduces in in some way mentioned by Peter once and one one in Paul and this is where Joel spends some time. I think I think it's a good place to at least read and this is First Corinthians chapter 12, this famous passage about gifts. And we're going to 0 when Michael will read for us verses 12 and 13.

28:51 Yeah, it says, For even as the body is 1 and yet has many members, and all the members of the body, though they are many, are one body, so also is Christ. For by 1 Spirit, we were baptized into one body, whether Jews or Greeks, whether slaves or free, and we were all made to drink of 1 spirit. So really this idea that through the Spirit we were baptized, we were immersed, we were grafted into this body of Christ that Paul talks about many members, different gifts 1 spirit over and over again. You know, you're here talk, talk about the bride of Christ, the body of Christ, the church, his body. So it seems, at least Paul's emphasis here is that we through the Spirit, through regeneration, we are pushed into the body of Christ.

29:47 Yeah, we're all baptized into one body by the Spirit, which I don't know, I I haven't looked at what they would say about this passage, but I'm sure they wouldn't say only like the Super Christians are part of the body of Christ too. So there's, there's something they they need but that. But I think that's a real thing they should wrestle with a little bit because I think, I think it's it's pretty clear that the the spirits involved in regeneration in this way that we would say is the baptism of the spirits. That brings us to John Johnny Mack. Johnny Mack. Strange Fire. Not, not a fan of the old charismatic label, right, right.

30:27 And, and and I think he's coming from a, from a good place where he's really looking at the abuses. And I don't think, I think he would say, hey, Wayne Grudem, hey, John Piper, I think you're wrong. But I think he would recognize. I don't think. There's a difference between them and the you know, the name it claim it, televangelists who are abusing this type of stuff. That that's such a good point 'cause it's so it's so easy and sometimes I sinfully enjoy ostracizing MacArthur a little bit because he's like one of the few guys that's more strict than me on stuff. So but but I actually love MacArthur and it's like, man, if I need to look up something in Scripture, it's like, man, I want to read one of his commentaries just because he exegetes the word so well, even if I don't agree with him on everything.

31:09 He takes scripture seriously. And so he's really guarding against totally one side. Like you mentioned the book Strange fire had a conference strength. Strange fire where he he he also has some conviction with how he speaks and he's like all charismatics are terrible, but you know, different, different spectrums and that charismatic term, I think is so is so loose it to me it's not really helpful because it's so broad. If, if you and I get counted in as a charismatic, probably it's not I, I mean, I don't know if I don't know who's counting or how they're defining it. But yeah, it is a it could be a broad swap. All, all of these labels are hard, like even evangelical.

31:50 I don't know what that means. I mean, I know what it means, but it's like, what's that mean? Fundamentalist, who knows what that means? That's why. Everyone needs a creed. That's what so that that that really is where where we spent most of the time this morning in this first lesson on the Holy Spirit. I think, you know, as we've been in Roman, it's good to ask yourself, you know, what's it mean to walk in the Spirit? How you know how we demonstrate the fruit, fruit of the Spirit? How's the Spirit working? You know, do you see it? I think Pastor Jewel's going to hit on that a little bit next week. But what other thoughts you got about the Holy Spirit? I just want to say one thing. Yeah, it was Saint Patrick's Day. Oh, this has. Write it down and Danny had a message that had a a Sunday school on the Trinity and did not play this Richard and satire.

32:46 You know, Patrick's bad, bad analogies of the Trinity. And then I, I, you know, I'm, I, if there's a one of us who's teaching that's going to joke a little more, it's probably me. I don't, I don't know, that joke may be like a, a loose term, you know, make jokes that people don't laugh at. And I shows I was like, you know what, I probably shouldn't show this video. I don't, I don't know. It kind of goes off the rails at the end with with Voltron and, you know, righteously puking green righteously into the, the the Chicago River. I was like, I don't know. So I I won't play it. I'll just kind of mention it. Joel. No, no, no, no, no holds barred on this. He plays it yesterday, which I thought was. Great.

33:27 So great move. It's funny. And it it, it exposed people to the Athanasian Creed in a good way where people they're not threatened by it. It's like, oh, this is great. Yeah, it's good, So good. And it really drives him to the point, right? Don't mess around with these analogies. Right. The the analogies are bad, yeah. Not going to work. Get in trouble. Well, I look forward to talking more about the Holy Spirit next week. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.