...where we take theology 2 the next level
Oct. 30, 2024

The True Origins of Halloween

The True Origins of Halloween
The True Origins of Halloween
Take 2 Theology
The True Origins of Halloween

Episode 80


Where did Halloween and its activities originate? Should Christians celebrate or partake in Halloween?


Christian Origins of Halloween Pamphlet by Angie Mosteller: https://a.co/d/34GZAqc


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/48QjKzpssag


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com

0:00 Michael, Yeah. I don't know about you. This is coming out on Halloween. On Halloween. So yeah, this is the the Halloween episode. And if you're anything like me, I'm I'm not superstitious, but I am a little stitious. No, that's that's perfect. Does it mean anything to you? I, I mean it does I, I have seen contrary. So you you brought up The Office in one of our episodes. And you'll help me out to dry. You abandoned me in my darkest moment. I, I should say I had not seen all the offs episodes and some of them we both know some of them, they push the line a little. That's true sometimes. But you know, I've always been a fan of, of humor 'cause that's why it's so funny. You know what I'm?

0:45 Saying it checks, it checks out. And what a what a great quote for Halloween. You can't. You can't leave. That one off of the no, it's good. Halloween episode 'cause we're gonna try to just answer everything about. How everything all of your questions over Halloween? 'Cause I was, in my mind, I was like, man, should a Christian celebrate it? But I saw you, you got the Ouija board out and you're like getting the answer. So I'm ready for it. I thought that that's how we should get it or that or the the Magic 8 ball. Yeah, yeah. Looking doubtful, roll again type of thing. Yeah, yeah, Magic 8 ball. Man, that really when? When was its heyday? I mean. Has he just been around forever? For a long time there's I know someone who has 1 today and they you know that they don't seriously use it, but you know, they, they not, not in my house. Let me just make that not in my house. But oh man, a lot of a lot of fun things to talk about. So I'm, I'm excited for the notes. I think, I think it's pretty, you know, covered pretty well. Yeah, and because this is, you know, we're going to record 2 episodes tonight.

1:46 That's right. And this one will air the the soonest. And I'm wearing Pat's hat. I should. So I should at least mention, you know, Pat's. I think it's our first victory. I think it's hey, better late than never. Better late than never. And beating The Jets and Aaron Rodgers? Same game it was. I don't love Aaron Rodgers, but I like Aaron Rodgers a lot. You know, he's just a good guy. He's just a good guy. He's just down to earth, you know? I saw this meme like who's he going to blame this week? And then the the media were like asking him like here are some same issues. You haven't changed. What's your plan? He's like, stop listening to you guys for the for the to start. And then it's like, blame the media. Oh man.

2:30 Are we facing the Titans next week? I don't know. I I haven't really been keeping up with the entertainment. Yeah, this is center that NFL is these days. It's. It's all scripted. Is that what you're saying? I mean, oh man. You were pretty fired up yesterday night or a couple nights ago. Home groups talking about the the cause. Yeah. Are the Chiefs are still rolling. You're you're #2 team. It's like Pats for you, then the Chiefs. Right. The Chiefs, yeah. I mean, they're scripted to win. They they, I think I, I think what as a business, the NFL probably made a lot of money off the Pats. They're they're probably saw a huge fan base come in, a lot of merch sold. They want to repeat that. Where do you so you need to build like if everyone is kind of, you know, you have your ups and downs and you don't have this, what do we call it legacy, a dynasty then. But if you have a dynasty, yeah, you make more money. I I think that's what it is.

3:26 I think it's just, but it's so obvious to most fans. Most fans, some people can't see it, but you know. Oh man, I'm it's. Spooky, you know what I'm saying? So it's spooky scary, yeah, just like Halloween. Glad we could tie that back together. Yeah, join us as we talk about all things Halloween. And we're probably going to save the answer for the end. Right. Yeah, let's do it. Let's do it. All right, Let's take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. All right, Halloween.

4:09 Zach, did you celebrate Halloween as a youngster? Yeah, I, I don't know what what you mean by celebrate Halloween did. You participate in Halloween activities as a child. Just dress up. I did get to dress up as a I've got pictures as a young kid dressing up there. So as a kid we I've got I was a fireman one year. I was like a hobo one year, got a good picture of that. Then there was a time as I got older, we were in a church that end up doing like Harvest Day celebrations, which, let me be clear, way different just happens to be on the same day. You can still dress up, but it's way different. And then we participate that with our, with our church. And then when I got, you know, I, you know, I don't know what age you like stopped doing Halloween, probably 12 or 13. And then I went out with my friends or maybe 14 then. And you're kind of too old for it, but it's kind of fun with your own friends, I guess.

5:02 Yeah, so for us, we were kind of all in, like it didn't matter. It was all just fun and games. That's right. So your so your church didn't do any celebration. It was kind of like go, we're there's no. Like early 80s, you know, early 80s, like 8380 when I would have been just young enough to start participating and, you know, but which is ghost. I think we had this like spooky monster mask that that would get passed down year to year. I remember one year there we had some overalls and I was like trying to be a zombie type of thing, like what? Put some blood on there and stuff.

5:43 But I think maybe late 80s, early 90s, this guy came in and talked to our church. Yeah, Amen. Yeah, Amen. And talk was all of the really, really, really bad things about Halloween. And so did you ever have that talk? Probably at this? Harvest. Yeah. And, and. And at the church I grew up in, it was pretty what you would call independent fundamental Baptist. So you had people on all sides, some people who like really didn't care, some people that had strong convictions. You had like a pretty big mix where I would say some people had very strong. It wasn't like, do it. It was like, no, you shouldn't do it. But some people are like, yeah, fine, not that big a deal. And our church just decided to like Northwood, where our kids go to school, they do like a trunk or treat on a separate day. Like our church would do stuff on the same base. So you kind of had to pick, I think probably to accommodate people that kind of thing.

6:34 So it wasn't like across the board, but there were people like on all sides of the issue for sure. Yeah. So the, I think this guy came in and he really like pushed the church over to like, nothing that was dark at all, which I can get. But I think, you know, I think it all really depends on kind of the spirit that you're doing it in maybe. I mean, I don't want to hedge around that, but, you know, we talked about, you know, bonfires being bone fires and human sacrifice. Because that that's a good one. Because I think typically people are OK with bonfires. If it's not Halloween, it's like, OK, but it is. There's connections. Yeah, that's a good point. And then Jack O lanterns, we heard this, this tale about how they were like said to have captured people's souls.

7:18 I've I've heard that as well and I've also heard that they would, I was looking at something else that they would like ward off evil spirits too. So if you didn't have Jack O lanterns, you were like welcoming them. Right, like this soul has already been taken. Or something like that. Yeah, yeah, something like it. Was marked or something? And I heard the same thing with costumes, Like you dress up to like, you know, I don't know, ward off you dress funny and all this stuff. I don't know. I was looking, I asked Jill and I saw in the some of the notes that you wrote. I I had never heard this before, but that it was Satan's birthday. Yeah, it's a tricky 1 because Santa can also be scrambled to be Satan for Christmas. So you got it. There's a couple of different fronts. Yeah, well, Oct 31 is Deck 25 if you're doing number systems. So that's a math joke, but it's it. Works out, but I'm sure all the math fans are like do another one that was great.

8:11 But yeah, I've I've heard things like I don't know if I've heard maybe people in ignorance be like it's Satan's birthday or something like that. I was looking up some stuff and in the most popular Satanic religions, you know what? What like Satan, like the the Satan's day is or like the that the most important day to a Satanist? June 1st. Yeah, no, no, I'm just kidding. It's, it's, I guess there's a bunch of different kind of cults, but the most popular one I read was It's your own birthday, because it's all about like yourself. It's like your birthday. My own birthday is the day that it's. It's like the most celebrated in place. It's so yesterday for me, right? Yeah. Yesterday. That's that's great. And I love, I love this Pagan holiday. Sam Hayne.

8:51 Samhain Well, that's what it looks like, but it's apparently pronounced Sowin. Sowin Yeah. But yeah, so we were told, you know, this is basically you are celebrating a Pagan holiday. Sowin. But they probably pronounced it Samhain back then. 'Cause they did. No, that's like such an American like. Samhain and that, you know, the demons were more active. So I think those were probably things that we've all heard. So then the I think the bottom line question, Zach, is should Christians celebrate or partake? Cool. That's the $1,000,000 question and probably what makes it most challenging. Probably it depends. Yeah, probably. It does depend on, I guess a number of things, you know, what your thought process is behind it.

9:37 I, I guess in how you do it, what you do and you know, so, so maybe we should talk about the true origins of Halloween, kind of maybe clear away some of the fanciful stuff and we should start by talking about Saint Patrick's Day. Nice, I like it 'cause every good Halloween conversation goes back to Saint Patty. 'S Day, Saint Patrick's Day, Saint Valentine's Day a. Lot of Saints. A lot of St. And if you take my definition of a St. it really starts getting to a lot of Saints. The calendar fills up fast. Very fast, yeah. So as you know, the early church, they put certain Christians in this category of Saint where we wouldn't do that today. But those who were like, like apostles, those who were martyrs, those who, you know, live some great life or something, or there was some miracle done through them, they kind of got venerated to this higher level of St. And you should celebrate that person. So March 17th, St.

10:36 Patrick's Day, February 14th, Saint Valentine's Day, And there's, you know, Saint Luke's Day, St. John's Day, Saint Paul's Day. Man, but Valentine and Patrick get all the love. Yeah, yeah. So eventually you run out of days. Yeah. And so we put them all together. Just give one day to all you guys. One day, call it All Saints Day. I I like this too. Apparently it goes back to the three hundreds, like in an unofficial capacity. Yeah, yeah. And, and it's not in the in the fall, it's not October 31st. No, it was, it was first celebrated in the spring and there, you know, the church kind of split into East and West.

11:18 So one of them celebrated it and I should have brought that pamphlet. We're getting a lot of this information from a pamphlet. I will link it and maybe put a picture up here for you. But you know, one of the the East celebrated it like maybe a week after Pentecost, like the Sunday after Pentecost. The West celebrated it the Friday after Easter or I have those reversed but it was early on like this can. You imagine I can't even get my mind around like the Friday after Easter. Tom, the drug, it's so hot. It's it's better that it's still can be pretty hot October 31st. So yeah. And so then around 16 O nine, it was established as an actual day. Wow. That was May 13th. We don't say.

11:58 Did you say 6? O9. I said 16. OK, Yeah, thanks for the correction. It was yeah, six O 9. Didn't want another Ephesians 289 situation on our hands, if you know what I mean. Yes. Clear clearly, yes. So six O 9 or 610. This, so this goes back, back, back, back, back All Saints Day. All Saints Day goes way back and it was officially like this. May 13th day was Pope Boniface. The 4th set it up and so then it was rolling good until around somewhere, we don't know, Somewhere between 7:31 and 7:41 it got pushed to November 1st. Gotcha, now it's making more sense. Yeah, yeah. So the idea, we don't know for sure, some of the when you read the suggestion is you have all these people making these pilgrimages.

12:50 OK, Yeah. To Rome to celebrate All Saints Day, and you've just come out of winter, you don't have a lot of food. But if we move it to the fall when we just had the harvest, we can be a little more crazy. Party time. We don't have to worry about not having enough. Food. It's hard to have a celebration when you're scrounging for stuff that makes a lot of sense. And so it seems like that was part of it. So by 7:31 somewhere, 730-1741, it was moved to November 1st. And so then I thought it might be good because, and you may be like, OK, I thought we were talking about Halloween. What's going on? Why are we talking about All Saints Day and why are we talking about, we're about to talk about Rome's conquest of the British Isles. But just hang in there with us.

13:36 We're going to wrap it all up. So I was surprised to know this that Caesar Augustus back in like 55 AD made the first invasion into the British Isles. Man, learning a lot. Yeah, but the the Empire of Rome actually kind of conquered those Isles under Claudius in 4380. So about 100 years later, that's. Crazy cause Claudius emperor like we were talking about that in Roman series. So this is all. This is all interesting. And so they were under Roman rule through that time. We know Constantine converted in 312. So Christianity would have hit on those shores around 3-12, maybe a few years later. By 400 AD, Christianity was well established. Now we don't know if they're really Christians. Are they just nominal Christians? Are they bend in the knee?

14:28 Because yeah, we don't know all of that, but we know that least the practice, the name, the the ideas of Christianity had gone to the the islands by 400 AD. And then I guess when the Gauls were invading and stuff and the the empire's collapsing. Rome withdraws in 410 and Christianity declines. But in 597, the Pope sends Saint Augustine of Canterbury, not the other one, to London to kind of really reconstitute Christianity. So it's really starts to flourish by then. So by 597 it's like completely Christian Halloween or me, pardon me, All Saints Day, not to not to reveal anything too soon.

15:19 All Saints Day is still being held in the spring right now, right? We've got 200 years or more of like full on Christianity, Christianity before it moves to November 1st. Wow. And so this this makes a lot of a lot of sense. This is going to be a lesson in contractions and Eves and all this stuff too, right? So All Saints Day Saints Holy equals All Hallows Day. Yeah, so just like in the Lord's Prayer, the KJV hallowed be thy name, it's the same word. Hallowed Holy St. It's it's just a different word from a different language family. And in the day before something is the eve, like Christmas Eve and Christmas. So we have All Saints Day to All Hallows Day, All Hallows Eve. Yeah.

16:07 That's a lot to say. That's a mouthful. No one wants to say All Hallows Eve I. Just want to say Hallows Eve. And even that, yeah is just a mouthful too. So I'm just gonna say Halloween. Halloween Halloween. Boom. So that's how we we get Halloween on October 31st because All Saints Day or All Hallows Day is on November 1st. And then it's it's bad news from here in the, in the Celtic, Celtic English kind of area. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So there was this holiday that they celebrated Salwin. It's spelled like Samhain S AM Hain, and that was basically all that was destroyed when Rome comes in, you know, there are people who lamented the loss of the British culture and wrote, you know, epic stories to kind of replace the loss of those stories. Jr.

16:57 Tolkien did that. Oh boy. But so all of a lot of that was lost. So our earliest record of sow in dates from late 10th century by this guy who is in Northern Ireland, Northern Scotland, he's a Northern Celtic guy and he's telling what they used to do. Gotcha. So there's that's our earliest record and it's years and years and years and years after all that we've talked about. Well, that, that, that's pretty amazing. Yeah, hundreds of years afterwards. And so I guess what would be helpful is we're talking about this holiday, Like what, what goes on? What, what do we know? What did they write about? And from what I'm reading, harvest was celebrated, fires were made, give some lights.

17:41 People gathered around, told stories. People were celebrating this change of season. It's getting darker, it's getting colder, Summer's past. And then there's, you know, like you're, you've dropped your, your boy's name. You know, some of the storytelling is a little bit, you know, maybe some of this fanciful stuff is in there. Yeah. So what we can tell is, yeah, that's a really good, accurate description. They told some supernatural, preternatural, mythical stories during this time. In, in, in your notes, you say doesn't sound that bad. Lord of the Rings. That sounds a little rough, but I know what you're saying. It didn't. It didn't sound like malicious or mischievous or like it didn't sound evil. Right, 'cause I love, I mean, I have a fire pit out behind my house this time of year.

18:21 Like I've already had a couple fires. I love just sitting out there looking at the fire, maybe roasting some marshmallows. Like, like, I'm just kidding. Halloween. Yeah, Yeah. But I like you're drawing this distinction where even that Pagan holiday was not necessarily Satan, like Satan 'cause that's, I think it gets a bad rap. I don't know a lot about this holiday, but that's just where my mind goes. Yeah, well, 'cause a guy in the late 1800s wrote about Sao in Gotcha and ascribed the practices that were associated with Halloween to be present in in Samhain, Sao Inn and. It's one of those like I'm just keep saying Samhain, one of those things too. You probably couldn't say. I know for sure no one ever had some dark evil story about witches.

19:05 Sure you like, maybe there was some, but it wasn't like the theme of it or the spirit. Like, if you go on a camping trip and you tell stories around the campfire, someone's probably going to tell a story about, you know, a hand that's left, you know, holding on to a rear view mirror or something like that. A scary story. Yeah. So I'm sure there were some things in there. That doesn't mean that all the dark elements of Halloween are OK. Exactly. Yeah, that's not you. Might ask, OK, if they didn't come from this Pagan holiday, where did they come from? Yeah, that's a good question because I think a lot of thinking out there is All Saints Day basically was made to like this terrible holiday. Let's like Christianize it. We're going to throw that over there and start afresh. Right, yeah. And honestly, I don't have a problem with that practice in general when that happens, like let's redeem this thing, let's take it out of this culture, let's re Christianize this so that we, you know, is we take off and we put on. I mean, but that's not what happened here at all, even if you were concerned about that.

20:07 Because the dark elements come in through none other than our dear old Catholic Church. Sorry to throw a jail about our Kathleen brought. Everything from that, so Halloween, you know, has a Christian origin partially because like we're saying, Christianity ruled the world at one point. So everything, I mean, from a time period had that Christian origin and then corrupted in certain places from there. So let's talk about some of those maybe darker elements. Yeah, So around I was just, I know it's 1049, this someone wrote about having these days set aside to pray for the dead, to pray for those who he had lost. And that was like put into some liturgical form. And then by 1274, so a little over 200 years later, it became dogma in the Catholic Church that when someone dies and they're not, they're not so bad that they're going to hell, but they weren't clean clean when they died. Then you go into purgatory.

21:07 And, and how long that could be, could be a little bit a lot of it we don't, we don't really, there's not a definitive timeline given. It's all dependence on how bad you were maybe, or how good you were, how close you are. Or if people pray for you here. You know what I was thinking? I was thinking, what would Craig Cockel think about the situation? Greg Cockel was born Catholic, or was. Raised, I'd not know this. So yeah, yeah. So he remembers, he will retell being being told and taught about purgatory and like one of his nuns or priests or someone said you could be there for a million years burning away your sins. And he's like, this is not good news. This is not like the gospel is good news. This is not it. So it was a very worrisome thing to note. You know, how long are we going to be there? And he always makes this point.

21:52 Either sin overcomes the blood of Jesus or the blood of Jesus overcomes sin. Like what? What do we see in the Bible? Yeah, that that's good. And we can kind of start fuse. You start getting some Reformation vibes as we're talking about purgatory, maybe you're thinking indulgences. You're thinking of our guy, a Luther that had, you know, 95 problems and nailed those suckers to a wall. So here's a quote from that pamphlet. Though the Roman Catholic Church was careful not to define the nature of purgatory, wild and terrible descriptions developed among Christians. Furthermore, over the next several centuries, a tremendous amount of energy when the understanding purgatory, teaching people about it, and in particular arranging life in the present in relation to it. All Saints and All Souls Day were both intimately tied to remembering the Christian dead and considering their state. It became standard practice during these days for Christians to call on the Saints for help in relieving loved ones from their punishments of purgatory.

22:54 Well, that's pretty amazing. Just the cultural significance, you know, new theological development and all that energy. Probably papers are written and then your whole way you live life shifts because of this. That's pretty fascinating, you know? So Luther is not a fan. Not loving. It he's not loving it. So you're you already alluded to it. He hammered the 95 theses to the door on Halloween on purpose. It wasn't a coincidence because Halloween had been so closely associated with purgatory and therefore indulgences. He's trying to say something like this is not how it should be. We need to have a conversation.

23:35 We need to fix ourselves that that that was his goal. Yeah, no, that, that's great. We've got a few of these theses there because I, I think most people just have, are familiar with 95 theses. They don't know what any of them said. So here's the thesis. 35 indulgences were giving people a false assurance of salvation, wanting them to overlook true repentance and contrition. So here's the actual thesis. It's not in accordance with Christian doctrine to preach and teach that those who buy off souls or purchase confessional licenses have no need to repent of their own sins. So kind of bypassed repentance 'cause you can do that. You've ever read the Bible? Yeah, that's just some money and it's God counts that as the same, right? Cause part of me can understand that I don't really understand, but I can understand that you're going to live a holy life and do these holy things on top of stuff. But it's like, hey, I can do a little exchange that's like, wow, totally.

24:28 Yeah, there's famously this story of this guy that was come in and was selling indulgences and this guy said, can I buy an indulgence for a future sinful act? And the guy and this guy was was rich and he was like, sure, it'll cost you this much money. So he gives them the indulgence and then he stat, he stages some bandits and robs that guy of all his money. It's like, here's my indulgence. Gotcha. Wow, that that is something. Yeah, indulgences are clearly being sold for financial gain. Here's Thesis 28 When the money clinks in the bottom of the chest, avarice and greed and crease.

25:10 I love that and I I don't I can't remember what's like the the slogans. It's like when a coin of the copper clinks a soul and I don't know what. It is as. Released. Yeah. It's great. They had, like, all these, like, little phrases or whatever. Then we got one more thesis. 27 There is no divine authority for preaching that the soul flies out of purgatory immediately. Immediately when the money clinks in the bottom of the chest. Yeah. You can't find a chapter in verse for that. One, no, no, no. And, and just to be true, I think, well, I've heard some present day Catholics talk about purgatory and they would say, yes, we still believe in purgatory, but we don't. But we do not paint it in this picture. Adult indulgences were done away with and there were Catholics, even Pope Pius the 5th in 1567, who had some criticisms of this. So just to be fair that there are. That's true.

26:00 Don't want to totally it might have taken a few 100 years there, but they eventually like shut it down, which bring brings to a big point. We've kind of talked about it, but the myth is that Halloween and and October 31st just and and Reformation day. You know happenstance. Yeah, no, this, this was purposeful because it was so tied with these beliefs about purgatory, the dead, the afterlife that that were in connection with this holiday that we are trying to get better. And this is the perfect segue to witches. Yeah, I mean, from there into witches. So there are some elements that you might wonder how did we get there? How did witches, how did ghosts kind of become part of Halloween?

26:43 And in general, they thought that because they're praying for the dead and this was All Saints Day in an All Souls Day, that that veil between the living and the dead was thinned or pulled back or stretched so that you might, you might have these, you know, trapped human souls wandering around and stuff. So you kind of get all these dark elements in there because of purgatory and and Catholicism. Well, and you and you see things, if we're going to scripture about necromancy and communicating with the dead that that's not, that's not no bueno, not good to do. Yeah, yeah. So, yeah, Scripture, as you alluded to, strictly forbades it. Deuteronomy 1810 says let no one be found among you who practices definition or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft or cast spells, or who's a medium or spiritualist, or who consults the dead. Anyone who does these things is detestable to the Lord. Yeah.

27:35 Pretty clear, pretty clear there. Have you met anyone who who is a witch or practices in this? You know, seems. Like I have been told by someone that they were Wiccan but I don't. It's no one in my, it's no one that it was like a year and gone. I had AI had a patient one time who practiced this and I don't know if this happened today or not, but she had like 3 cats. I don't I'm always a cats with that. And she was like super friendly, super nice, but she always had things all over her house. You know, I was like, but very, very kind, very like our notes here say good. I was very positive. It wasn't like I'm going to curse you, but still not great, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

28:20 Because when you open yourself up to those preternatural elements, we know that it's God that can do stuff. Or. Demons, you know, and so you know, you and I don't think God works those ways. So if you see stuff happen scary, it's it's, you know, through demons. So this this leads us to to ghost, ghost big part of Halloween people hanging sheets everywhere and saying Boo. And you know, what are ghosts? Are they real? Do we have, you know, you know, people are ghost hunters and these kind of things, you know, and they're going to these old houses. So I guess a good place to start is what what do you mean when you say ghost? Because I think people mean. Different things, yeah. I remember watching so at my college we, they would run a movie on the college channel like every Wednesday night or something or every Thursday, whatever it was. And so I saw that The Exorcist was going to run one night and I was like, I've never seen that I'll check this out. Scariest movie I've seen in my life. Scariest movie I have seen in my life because I took it as probably real or very close to what could be real. And so, you know, if by ghost you mean some type of demonic activity, Yeah.

29:33 I mean, it seems like that has maybe gone down since Jesus's time here. We don't, you know. Some people surmise that there were further constraints put on them after Jesus rose from the dead. Oh yeah, yeah, right. Yeah. I don't know. We're not told. Explicitly. You know what's interesting too, after I was like watching a a scare movement time about it was not the exorcist, but something like there were exorcisms in there. And I don't know if you know this like you can look up how many like exorcism experts, the Catholic Church, like employees like to the same. They, they send them out like all the time to these places to. I mean, I don't think most of the time they're performing exorcism, but they're, you know, blessing the play or whatever and, and for that, but they're like, I don't know if they're called exorcism specials, but it's something like very close.

30:16 It's like that's their job and they just go place to. Place. Blessing. Yeah, yeah. And it's a decent amount of people they employ in there. I was looking at us like, oh, that's interesting. So if by ghost you mean something like that, yeah, it probably could be something like that. If by ghost you mean some stranded human soul that's been trapped. Cause a lot of people, that's what they mean, that it's like, yeah, floating around there trapped someone didn't they weren't buried in peace or they're not resting in peace. Or that, you know, that, yeah, something was done wrong to them while they were here on Earth, and until that gets paid for, they're going to, you know, you know, haunt over that area or something. And that's clearly not biblical. Yeah, and and really only time we see a soul separate from the body. An Elohim is the word used of of Samuel when Saul's going to this lady, for you know the the summon him from the dead. And it wigs her out.

31:06 And it, yeah, she, it's, it's like, whoa, this is, this is bad news. I normally just fake this part, and here this guy is talking. So yeah. Yeah. And that God allowed that for that one time. It was judging Saul. You know, Saul and his sons died the next day. So not a good, not a good thing. Not like and like we you've already said like, yeah, don't open yourself up to this bad, bad stuff. Now we get to trick or treat. I can you sing a song for me? Trick or treat? Smell my feet, Give me something. To eat, Yeah, yeah, yeah. Did you say that? Is there another did we used? To there's more to that too. I I we just did for our work, we did like a trunk or treat out at one of the assisted livings and there's like a little girl who was she was like having the time of her life like saying that to everyone. She was great, but she probably didn't know what what she was saying between What's the trick?

31:52 What's the treat she. Didn't know, she didn't know. So both of the the trick and the treat have their origins on the British Isles. And this is good. Yeah, so the treat was these poor people would go around and they would beg for food or some drink or whatever. And in exchange they would say, we will, you know, be sure to pray for your loved ones to help them get out of purgatory for, you know, whatever ever meantime. And so that was this exchange. So please treat us and we will. We'll pray for your loved ones, which I mean, on the surface, if that theology is correct, that's there's nothing bad in that, you know? Yeah, if you're, you're trying to help someone out there helping you out and it's like really, you know, help How about some of these poor people that don't, don't have means like, and it's you're not giving them a Snickers, you're probably giving them like something substantial. Sure, hey, I'll give you a pot of porridge and if you pray for my mom, get her out of purgatory sooner. It's all good.

32:44 But The thing is, you never know. Like your mom could already be out of purgatory. Where do those prayers go? That that's true. It's like, man, that's very, very crazy and on their side. That's the treat. The trick really spoke more to some maybe practical jokes. You know you can, you know, those crazy kids that are just like going to have some, have some fun, you know? Yeah, some of. Them turn up attacks. Turn up attacks, some of them recorded, were like parking a cart in front of a house door. So they couldn't open the door, you know, had to figure out how to get out. So yeah. Wow. And so if we look over to Ireland just just across the way, yeah, yeah. Halloween bagging always involved a masquerade and some sort of good-natured bribe. So you're kind of playing off of that tradition. And such traditions were easily imported over here to the good US of A.

33:28 And it appears, you know, that term trick or treat just kind of grew out of that. And if someone's not going to give you candy, you might be like, hey, I might, I might prank you. Yeah, Yeah. You might end up with your plow, you know, 50 feet from where where it was it it. And I think those kind of, you know, if you don't add in the dark type of things, those type of things happen all the time. I remember we were at issues college campus for bot to bytes. It was a how to do use MIDI in a soft computer software to write code and they were doing some construction. There was this lamp pole that they had laying down that they were going to install. And it was like me and four other guys and we just picked the lamp pole up and maybe walked it 100 yards away and put it down. And is it like it's not a big deal, but if you're the only guy there that.

34:16 Might then it then it could be. Yeah, that's true. I didn't think about that. Yeah, you know, But you know, it's just a harmless little prank, you know? Well, I like this too. You've got going back to Jack O lanterns. You know, in the British Isles that that term referred to someone who's keeping watch at night or a man that has a maybe a guy named Jack who has a Lantern and he's just keeping watch. Yeah, yeah. So just a watchman with a Lantern, this kind of patrol in the cities, it came to mean also those bog lights. So the swamp lights. So they, you know, they, they don't know what's going on. You look out in the middle of this swamp or this marsh or the bog or the, you know, whatever, where they have this peat and stuff that's decomposing and you see this like little bright light. You're like, whoa, what? Is that yeah. And, and, and what is fascinating is that like what we think about Jack O Lantern and even I, I was reading like maybe gourds were the not even pumpkin. Some of the stuff, you know, the 1830s like it's, it's not like this is going back to, you know, Pope Boniface in the 600. It's not like going all the way, you know, crazy back. It's relatively that's relatively, you know, recent there of of kind of using these turnip speeds, pumpkins, whatever and, and using that tradition and kind of updating it a little.

35:23 Bit yeah. And so they would they carve these different types of gourds or melons and they'd call it the Jack O Lantern. It was the guy keeping watch. You know, I like it with. Light just on the front porch it. Wasn't it wasn't soul stealing or or anything. I mean, there could always have been someone who said this guy's keeping watch over our house. But it's like, you know, where do you, where do you go with that? So man, so big picture, circling back around what's let's start with the easy one. Reformation Day. Is it OK? I've I've known people to dress up like Martin Luther in the past. Maybe we link a picture? There have dressed up as Martin Luther in the past and yeah, yeah, I say definitely celebrate Reformation Day in some way that's fitting for your family. Talk about Reformation Day, if you're a teacher or you know, if you home school, it's a great, it's a great opportunity. Yeah, that's good.

36:13 So now, now the question of the hour. Halloween. What? What do you say? Do we participate in this evil thing? Is it OK? Is it not OK? Where? Where do we land? Maybe. I mean, if your conscience is stirred against it, then definitely don't, Paul would say. Don't sin against your conscience. Maybe, yeah, maybe inform your conscience, but don't violate your conscience. Yeah, like maybe you'll look into it some more because I think some of this background stuff is is helpful. And so on one hand, I get that if you grew up in some environment and in your mind you're going to be worshipping Satan, you should not do it. Correct. Yeah. If you're not, maybe there's some more wiggle or to me, to me, the worst part, there's two sides of it. There's I don't know how many events are so family friendly and community friendly as Halloween.

36:58 It's like, what opportunity is there? That's like every all your neighbors are like opening their doors. And then on the other side, I do think some of the worst parts of it are people use it to trust really inappropriately. That's like probably on the bad side, not not even like a scary thing, like just not dressing right. And then some people do really lean into like the gore. Maybe that's a little bit much for, you know, to be just really idle light or putting a spotlight on that kind of. Stuff it would be tough for me to live in a neighborhood that had like a 20 foot skeleton with red eyes, right? You know, I'm saying I don't know if I'd had probably sell my house and move. It's if I had a neighborhood light. It's hard for my 7 year old too. Can't he? He has a he has a hard time and so so, but I think I think there probably is some some middle ground depending on, you know, are you saying, hey, I'm going to hang out with with family and friends and I'm going to be a firefighter and this is fun or I'm actively worshipping Satan, Probably I'll do.

37:51 That and if you're handing stuff out, throw a track in there. I mean, the worst that's going to happen is it gets thrown away. Yeah, this is this is just a I'm always like very sensitive to this. If I ever we have a track somewhere, I'm like, I got a tip big If I ever am giving out tracks, you got to give the good candy. You can't give, you can't give erasers. You can't give those orange circus peanuts. You got to give some Reese's or something to give out tracks, you know? That's good. That's good apples. That's great potatoes. Have you seen the guy who gives out? Potatoes. That's actually pretty funny. Yeah, he just puts them in a bucket and like the kids chews it over the candy and it's like crazy. That that is that that's pretty good. I think that those are good, some good parameters maybe to keep in mind.

38:33 And I think, you know, I look out at my neighborhood. I don't think anyone's actively worshipping sake. Maybe there are some people, there are some people who maybe lean into it a little harder than I would. It's not my thing. And and like, you know going that. Hard. We don't ever decorate for Halloween. We decorate for the fall, you know, put out some pumpkins and scarecrows and orange and stuff, but we don't ever put up like spooky stuff. And I know some people going back to your conscience, it's like, like, you know, maybe if they're coming out of an environment, we're a kind of, it kind of was dark and demonic. And maybe it wasn't explicitly demonic, but it was dark. They might be like, hey, I want to distance myself. And that's probably a good call. That's your. Yeah, yeah. That's. Good, that's great. Halloween. Halloween, it is upon us.

39:13 We got it, we got it. We got it covered. Thanks. Thanks, Michael, for doing the legwork and that pamphlet for helping us out. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take 2. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.