The True Story of Christmas Part 2
Episode 92
Michael and Zach discuss details of the Christmas story about the wise men, Joseph's occupation, "XMAS", and Jesus actual date of birth.
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/kd88OsRYidI
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com
0:00 All right, so we had home groups tonight, so we're recording a little bit later than we normally do during the day and had a visitor during a prayer meeting. Wow, it was you know who opened your eyes. You know, the people who opened their eyes during prayer 'cause they all knew, and the people who didn't, didn't. But apparently there was a rather large raccoon who was sauntering over to the food table underneath the Hawks and I, I mean Publix chicken. It tastes good to humans, and I guess it smells good to raccoons, dude. Thankfully, he didn't get to taste it because. Close call. Chris Hawk was over there on the on the. He was on the moot. Yeah, yeah. I Caleb, I think, saw it.
0:42 I was in the middle of it, but as a good Christian, eyes were closed. Of course, of course. I heard some rustling but I said no keeping those eyes closed. Right, right. And then, and then and then, you know, it was just a lot was going on. So yeah, yeah, you know, saw the old raccoon and then my wife seemingly like she said she dropped her phone. It sounded like she threw her phone at the Concord as hard as she cancels. Like, yeah. So there's a lot going on in that corner of the Home group. Yeah, Speaking of Home group, we currently use Slack for communications and it's been a little bit like trying to get people on there. And then I hear a lot like from my mom, not from my mom. She's in, in, in heaven with Jesus. So she doesn't talk to me directly, but from my wife, but from other people too.
1:27 Like, oh, I got kicked out of Slack. I got to renew my stuff. And I was thinking, you know, we've started using GroupMe for more things. So there's like the Bible studies on GroupMe kind of and. That's a very big maybe, but yeah, right, right. And then that group that Jonathan White and Clay and I are on, and we don't have to talk about specifics, but we use GroupMe too. And I'm starting to be won over by GroupMe because I used. To be nice. Yeah, so do you throw? A pole on there and do whatever you want. I like it. Yeah. So what do you think the appetite is for our small group? Do you think they would be willing to move to a different app?
2:07 I, I think if we were in a Home group and we just did it for people like let's just do this right now. We go, honestly, I think we should like recommend it to all of church leadership. If you're in a group and you're thinking about something, just push people towards group because once you're on one, it's easy to add, you know what I mean? And that's, and I wish, I don't care what we do, but it would be nice for like every little side group to be something. Side things that confuses people like the random or like the it's. Yeah, I, I think Slack is like, awesome. I actually really like Slack, but I think if you're not used to it, you're like a hashtag or you're like this, the way it presents looks weird. Right. Yeah, I think if like you're in a, a, a business group, like you're doing like Agile software development or something and you have like, hey, we want the development team or we want the UI interface team or, you know, whatever.
2:57 And you like can hashtag stuff, but that's that's more than what you know, grandma needs in order to find out she needs to bring something to to pot pot Providence. That that's right for the raccoons to to get. Yeah, no, that that's a good point, GroupMe, man, I'm you don't have to tell me twice. Also, some other side notes on home groups tonight. Really tough day for coming up with hems off the cuff. I mean Christmas carols. I thought you were about to say really tough day for toddlers and and it. Was tough. We're going down and half of the toddlers are my kids. And mine. So Phoebe went down. Jay and Jax did go down as Joshua did.
3:37 Joshua did, and Jay Jackson also. Well, yeah, Jackson and Jay, similar event. Jay was a collision. On his head, you might not know because Jackson screams like his life is ending and then 30 seconds later he's like, I'm fine. We're like, you don't. You don't need to scream if it doesn't hurt. Everything's a screaming situation with him. Jane was actually hurt so that I mean it was like the one to carry over, but you would think Jackson was hurt by his initial scream, but that's why you noticed later on. Yeah, but tough time getting, you know, it. It was a tough crowd tonight. You know, sometimes the crowd's warm and they're lively. Tough crowd. And I was trying to just get people like, what's your favorite? In I I think you need to treat home groups like stand up comedy and just like warm us up with a few jokes, you know, get us going, you know, like. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, probably so, so. That's that's I did this is one last tangent that we can get it get it rolling.
4:32 I I'm trying to prep for this doing us upcoming central class on the wisdom literature in the Old Testament and I found I I this is bad 'cause I don't have it like pulled up now, but I found what is known as probably the oldest one of the oldest jokes, oldest proverb, but it should be It seems like it's humorous that is dated to like 4000 BC 4000 BCI. It's some. The earth was just being created and. It's, it's pretty, you know, it's pretty anticlimactic because, you know, I don't have this joke off the top of my head and ancient Neary salutatrix. I was looking up. So here it is.
5:13 OK, 'cause it it. It's dated to be around 4500 BC 40. 500 BC This. Is what it says well. This is probably even before before if you use the the dating that that one guy uses so. Ancient summer, Summer. And it's supposed to be humorous. We don't know the humor 'cause we don't know that culture. But translated what we think it says. A dog walked into a Tavern and said, I can't see a thing. I'll open this one. Like no one knows what the joke is, but that's what? And people are like, it's probably a joke in the ancient culture and we just don't know it in our culture. But that's like the oldest. There's probably some play on words there that. Like maybe the way it sounds or the rhythm, but. No, that's good. That is good because, you know, there it's hard if there are words in languages that you can make plays on and then those don't translate over to your language because we don't have we, you know, we don't have one word in our language that can mean ruler and a type and a way of measuring. I think a way of like to measure against. But in Greek, you know arque.
6:13 Yeah, Arque is that word. So, and in that same vein, you know, you try to teach your Spanish kid about Peter Piper picked a pep. This is not gonna it's not gonna sound the same, right? You're like, no, I don't get it. Yeah, that's why people like laughing. Which is how like a marvel like when maybe English and German are close enough, when we like translated a mighty fortress is our God like that has a rhyming scheme and it's in a verse and stuff and it fits the same music, but it went from German to English. But maybe it's maybe it's close enough. I like it. I, I feel like we, we did full circle. We, I mean, we covered the gamut and this banter. We were all covered the place, but I think it was all good. That's right. All right. Well, we are going to continue our series on giving you the truth that we know you want, right?
6:57 You know, there's, you can handle it. You know, now breaking live, we're, we're giving you the, the breaking news on things that happened 2000 years ago 'cause we want you to know what really happened. So some have titled this Michael's Ruins Christmas, but I think ruins is probably the bad. A bad, you know, probably restores Christmas. There you go. I like it. All right, let's take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. All right, we 3 kings of Orient are bearing gifts we traversed so far. So yesterday we talked about, you know, the wise men, the Gentiles bringing gifts.
7:47 Kind of alluded to the fact that we're going to talk about this today, but popular culture, I bet every nativity is. Do you have any nativities up in your house? I do. OK, are there 3 wise men there? No, Yeah, yeah. It would be weird for them not to have three. I mean, and it just, yeah, I guess it just, you know, rolls off the tongue. The you know, gold, frankincense, and myrrh if if you need one person per one gift. Right, right. And there could have been three, there could have been three, there could have been two, there could have been 12. We just know it's plural. And we know tradition around the 6th century gave these three guys names. But that's like the earliest we have this written down. Did you know any of these names before these notes? Mel Cure we.
8:33 Talk about them. But yeah, Caspar and Balthasar, so no. Clue. Yeah. And so those have worked their those names have worked their way, you know, into other tradition literature. But we from 6th century, so around in the 500. So that's his, you know, maybe it was passed on, maybe that was their name, maybe not. It's hard to know. I I can't wait. I've made this kind of joke before. It's a popular go to joke, I guess in my joke vernacular. But get to heaven, that 4th, 5th, 6th wiseman's gonna be like, what the heck guys? Like you think these guys just travelled by themselves? You know what's going on? So anyway. Yeah.
9:13 So and then more probably more consequential than the number is when and where did they visit? This is I think this is this is a good question because the timeline, how old, how much after, what's going on? Right. And so maybe you heard stuff like this like, well, Matthew says they entered into the house and we know that Matt, Joseph and Mary were looking for a Motel 6 and they ended up in a barn or a cave. So and then so time had to have moved on. And then also we'll talk a little bit later. Herod kills all the boys who are two years old and younger. So these two things together have often LED people to say, Oh, well, it was there was some time, some large amount of time that had passed between the birth of Jesus and the wise men's visit.
10:07 No, that's good, 'cause you're like you're saying it's all kind of wrapped up together in this account. I might just read a few verses, maybe even verse 7 through 12 of Matthew 2, 'cause I think a lot of this is touched on. Then Herod summoned the wise men secretly and ascertained from them what time the star had appeared, and he sent them to Bethlehem, saying, Go and search diligently for the Child, and when you found him, bring me word that I too may come and worship Him. After listening to the King, they went on their way, and behold, the star that they had seen when it rose went before them until it came to rest over the place where the child was. When they saw the star, they've rejoiced exceedingly with great joy. And like you were saying, Michael, I'm going into the house. They saw the child with Mary his mother, and they fell down and worshipped him.
10:51 Then opening their treasures, they offered him gifts, gold and frankincense and myrrh. And being warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed to their own country by another way. Then a few verses later, if we skipped on the verse 16, then Herod, when he saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, became furious. And he sent and killed all the male children in Bethlehem and in all that region who were two years old or under, according to the time that he had ascertained from the wise men. So a lot to think about. And so you can see why these all these thoughts kind of. Right, right. And so if we're just gonna start untangling some of this, they enter a house, that's fine, because Jesus would have been born in a house. Joseph and Mary would have been staying with relatives. He would have been born on the bottom level of a house in the Manger.
11:37 That would have been on that bottom level. And so the fact that the wise men are showing up, maybe not the night that he was born, probably not, but maybe a month or two in. So that alone just aligns with what we learned from Luke. So no, no big, no big deal there. Well, she's just two years old. This this is the question because we do see at the end there he kind of was ascertaining. So I'm going to kill everyone two years or older. A lot of things think about Herod was a crazy person and not just so he's he'd probably be taking exceptional measures. Right. Yeah. So it it, you know, Herod wasn't known to be, you know, protective, like, he's the one that he killed, you know, a lot of his family members who he thought was trying to usurp his throne. And so probably, it's more than likely he would say, well, and the wise men didn't come back to him. So it wasn't like the wise men could say, oh, yeah, he was six months old.
12:37 All he knows is that the star appeared. They went down to Bethlehem and. Maybe he's waiting. Yeah, a few months late. I mean, he's like, yeah, just guessing. He's like, yeah, let's add an extra year to be safe. I don't know. And so he gives this two years young, 2 years old and younger. But what's also with that is how people counted back then. So like if you know Emily and Christopher, you know, if everything's on track, they'll give birth around January 21st. They would say, we would, if we were in this culture, we'd say he's in his first year because he's building up to his first year. Although for us, we would say, oh, he's two months, he's three months.
13:19 And then a year from now we would say he's one years old. But that's, that's not how folks would count. They would think of it, Oh, you're in your first year, You're in your second year. This was the third day, even though it had only been two days since you know. So you think you're like the resurrection or something like that? It's like, was it 72 hours or you? Sometimes we think more precisely than that culture did about a lot of things. That's a good point. Right. So, so saying two years of the second year and younger could have been anywhere arranged, you know, 1218 months or younger. So it, it would still it this would not be decisive to say, Oh, he they were there. And also it would be weird for Joseph and Mary to be just camped out in Bethlehem for two years. That would be weird.
14:05 Like they're like, hey, we got a free place to stay. We're milking this for all it's worth. Now. That's pretty crazy 'cause I think it's a good lesson in hermeneutics because you want to be literal and accurate. So you might be saying 02 years, I need to, but you need to be thinking about ancient Near Eastern civilizations. It's like, you got to get in their minds. And what standards were they held to? And I think that that helps out a lot because I, I grew up and it was always, Jesus is a toddler, you know? Right. Yeah. And so that makes better sense. And then you wonder how long they were down in Egypt. Matthew's the only one that reports that they go down to Egypt, But you know, that's an unanswered question. Yeah, that's a, that's a good, good question too.
14:45 I guess they at least remain there until the death of Herod. So right. If we and I think we know Herod died and four BC I mean, so I don't know when Jesus was born, but you know. Ohh. And four BC. I I think that's why people say Jesus was born from six to four BC because we, we actually know when Herod died. OK, so that's like what we get. We guesstimate off of that. I think maybe I should back check before I just start saying stuff, but yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll talk about Rachel's lament while you when you see him when he died. All right, so another thing is, and not to downplay this because it was a horrible thing to have these kids killed. Boom, 4 BC got it right. All right, So very good. But I think often times, like as a kid, I had in my mind like hundreds and hundreds of kids that would have been killed. By.
15:35 Harrods, and it probably was somewhere between 10 and 20 based on the population of Bethlehem. I never. Thought about that. The birth rate, the survival rate of birth. So there's the high mortality of infants. So taking all that into account, probably 10 or 20 young males who would have died. Tragic, sad, evil. Not downplaying it, but the picture that I always had in my mind growing up was like hundreds and hundreds of kids and that's that would would not have been historically accurate. Yeah, To me, this goes to the prophecy kind of thing. You know, being born in Bethlehem, it's not like there's millions of people to pick from. It's not Manhattan. You know, it's like, you know, it's like that pool gets dramatically lowered. So all all of this, I think what I like about this uncovering the truth or really trying to understand the actual context is that it just makes things so much more accurate versus like, oh, you know how I think in my mind. Yeah, yeah.
16:32 All right. So that was the three wise men. We should also talk about Jesus's and Joseph's occupation. Woodworkers, baby. Yeah, and I mean, you've all probably at least heard of, if not read more than a Carpenter. And you know, King James has Joseph being a Carpenter, Matthew 1355 says, is this not the carpenter's son? Is not mother his mother called Mary? And then in a parallel Mark 63, is this not the carpenter's son? And so, and what was very common in those days was that sons took up the same job as their their fathers.
17:13 So Jesus, probably a Carpenter. Oh yeah, easily. I think you're setting this up good where it's like, OK, let's think what? Let's think what that would mean in his day. And maybe even let's look at the Greek and see if we can figure out, you know, what that would refer to 'cause I think, I think there might be a, you know, half a percent chance maybe he, his niche was woodworking and that was like a specialty. Yeah. Yeah, probably not. Right. Yeah, because if you recall David building the temple, they had to go to Lebanon to get Cedars. Import a lot of that stuff. Yeah, yeah, they had to import all that wood because in this area, while you're going to have some trees, they're not normally, they're not quite those tall, you know, straight trees that you can build with.
17:56 They're like the bindi, deserty trees and stuff. And So what they have around here mostly is stone. It's what the temple is, pulled out of stone. And if you go and you look at ancient Israel, you everyone's home is stone and they're adding on rooms and they're building with stone. You go and you're like, wow, stone is everywhere. I mean, it's like you come around Goose Creek or Somerville, all these houses got the wood framing. It's like that's not what you see in in that area when you're looking at ancient Israel. It's it's pretty, you walk in there, you're like, there's, there's no, there's no wood anywhere. So what I hear you saying is can't trust our Bible cause the Bible says Carpenter but you're saying there weren't carpenters back in the day So what gives? My, my, my world's been rocked there. I can't.
18:41 There's no, no comeback. I like that. Now you're you're, you're great. Alluding to going to the Greek word under underneath. This is tecton, which is really a broad word that that really could be better understood as builder, which you go in a lot of directions. Right. Yeah, just like Bob the Builder. Yes, he can. Jesus was a builder and yes, he can. Jesus can do what he wants. And so what's probably the better understanding is that Jesus What? And Joseph were stone Masons. Makes a lot more sense, yeah. Not not. I mean, I love carpenters. I'm not trying to, but I. Think music a stone. Mason I think someone who's like, you know, got jacks biceps and they're burly because that's that's tough manual work and and well, there's a lot of measuring and laying out and stuff. Same.
19:28 But that's also in carpentry. So I don't want to take any away from carpenters. Carpenters, we're not. We're not coming at you. We're we're everyone's everyone's friend. I think wood may be a little more forgiving than stone because it's like. That's true. You can't like like over. Yeah, it's it's you don't want to over chisel something. It's hard to glue. That like you can glue those back together or like put a, you know, like a, you know, some type of joiner on on pieces of rock. Maybe you can maybe I'm Speaking of them. I. Can maybe you can. Well, Speaking of Herod and crazy, crazy antics, Herod Antipus in the 1st century was doing this major building project. 1st century BC. 1st century 80 is it BC?
20:09 I think it's BC. BC So this is Herod the Great or is Herod Antipus is different than Herod the Great? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So Herod died and then Herod or this Herod's a different tetrarch. I need to I need to Fact Check some of this, right? Right. Well, I just know that there was a building project at Caesarea Maritime, was it? Somewhere in that area Maritime was roam away from home or something like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then there was this other smaller building village he was building up, Sephorus. Yes, this was going to be, I think I should, I should look this up, but it was going to be like a major, like some sort of, you know, capital city in the area that was just three miles from Nazareth.
20:51 So a lot of people in Nazareth probably picked this, picked up this work 'cause it would be an easy way to be guaranteed work for a long time. The government, you know, back in this, I mean, there there's a lot of a lot of money to be made where probably, you know, a lot of people in the town would would be able to do this pretty easily. Yeah, and between Nazareth and Sephora, there was a rock quarry. And so it's like calling all, you know, stone Masons. We got work for you. Which probably would have explained because it seems like Joseph and Mary came from religiously conservative backgrounds. Joseph, his hometown was Bethlehem. And so like, what would have brought him out? Well, if he was a builder in Bethlehem, then he, you know, would've moved up to find this work. So more circumstantial evidence that why would Joseph even been living in Nazareth?
21:42 Well, because there was work there and it was rock related. That that is great to conclusion. It is likely these two were stone Masons. You can't totally rule out the woodworking, but it'd be very, very narrow niche. And when you think about that in the context of biblical theology, you know, I think it brings some of these passages to life a little more, gives a little more meaning to this building we see all throughout Scripture. Yeah. And maybe I want to turn to the the first Peter passage because when Joel was preaching through this two or three years ago, four years ago, and we got to this passage and he didn't really make this point. But to me, having known this like it made the passage come alive to me more.
22:31 So first Peter, as you know, talking about some trials and stuff that you go through. And so let me just find my and then he says IN25 it says you also so I'll start in two four it says and coming to him as to a living stone which has been rejected by men. So calling back to was at Psalm 118. Yes, yes, that's right, but his choice and precious in the sight of God, you also as living stones are being built up as a spiritual house for holy priesthood to OfferUp spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ. And so this idea of, you know, him being the living stone and him building us up as precious stones and knowing his earthly job would have been a stone Mason, I think it makes the context much more rich.
23:38 He's got the resume, he's got that previous work experience where man, yeah, it just, it just all goes, all goes, goes together so much more. So I think that's a good way to to think about things. Jesus the master builder, Jesus the stone Mason, That's probably what he did. That's just the reality. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right, next one moving right along. We got to keep Christ in Christmas, which I agree. There's a lot of secularization of Christmas. And you know the weird thing about this, this is like, it's not secularization. It's like anti. I don't know how to describe it, but I let me put it in words and you give me the label. Jill and I went to the Dock Street Street Theater last night and I'll just say it was a gay O time. Oh, staying in the Christmas tradition. Yeah.
24:31 So there were, you know, some guys there that clearly seemed, yeah, more on the effeminate side. And then there was one person who in the cast who was trans, and they even gave that person's pronouns in the cast list. That's good. So it's like, yeah, I, I struggle knowing, you know, in a secular setting like that, where to draw the line. But then they're singing these songs like God rest you merry gentlemen, let nothing you dismay for born this Christ's savior on this Christmas Day or something like that. And like they're singing all these very heavily, you know, theological songs.
25:12 But to them it's just, you know, whatever. So it was a little bit weird. Yeah, I don't know the right the right label for this, but I know what you're saying. It's like, and then, you know, on on the flip side, or maybe in a similarish vein, us Christians, we can get bent out of shape when if someone, if someone says, hey, someone at a store saying celebrating Xmas. Xmas. We're going to flip some tables because they're taking Christ out of Christmas. Right. Get your whip out. You're in. Because because Christ was there Christmas, Christmas and we're taking Christ out for that X, we're X ING them out. It's like a no, no smoking sign. Yeah, get them out. Of here, yeah, yeah. So I'm guessing you heard this grown up. Yeah.
25:54 I heard it, Yeah. I remember my family being a little miffed at the Monopoly. I think it's a community. It's a yellow one. Community Chest not chance card that says Xmas funds mature collect, you know, $150.00 or whatever it was. And they're like, I remember asking, what is Xmas? And like, well, that's the secular way of referring to Christmas without actually saying Christ, because some people don't like Christ. But really, you know, that's why it's good. Hey, take a semester of Greek, maybe 2, because that would have saved everyone a lot of trouble. Is that X in Greek? Is this letter chi? Which happens, you know, CHICH 1st 2:00 letters of, of Christ. So it's really a shorthand for Christmas, Christmas. Right, yeah.
26:46 So this this Xmas predates any of the secularization of. And it was just shorthand for, right, Christ real fast. In fact, X just became known, you know, as a symbol for Christ. Or if you had the X with the Roe, that would be in like the first 2 letters 'cause it was the chapter and the R sound Cora. And so some people, I mean, some people are crazy, like getting that stuff tattooed on their bodies and stuff like the Chi and the Roe, you know? And so this has been even known, this symbol as a Christogram. And you would see it in Scriptures, you know, if they were Old Testament texts that pointed to Christ, people might, you know, put a little mark in, in their Bible or, or write this.
27:30 You really see this going back at the even before this, but it became really popular, popularized in the 4th century under Emperor Constantine. You know, they would write stuff like this on their Shields and it became more like mainstream. But even before that you, you kind of see this in different, different areas on some like catacombs and and that kind of thing. And then Xmas. That goes pretty far back too, in its own right. Yeah, 10:21 that's going back where people scribes would write either Xmas or the XP because the row in Greek looks like AP for us, but it was their letter R, you know that was had the R sound, but they would do XP mess.
28:12 So. Ink ain't free. Paint free. Does grow on trees. But boy, you know it ain't, it ain't cheap, right? We don't have, we don't have all this printing press stuff, right? So you gotta save, save where you can and and so, you know, looking at that, that that you know, and maybe people today, maybe they are trying to take, you know, maybe you get that right person be like, hey, gotcha. Gotcha. Yeah, Like it's like you think you're taking Christ out, but really you just put them back in in a in a different way and. And so much so if you, if you look at, you know, Eastern Orthodoxy, Roman Catholicism, Church of England, Episcopalian services, like they'll, they'll incorporate this on purpose. So you're like, oh, OK, so you're, so you might be like God, they've really gone liberal.
28:53 But no, no, they're probably probably even that. So both Christmas and Xmas both have Christ in there. Yeah, yeah. All right. OK. And lastly, December 25th. Jesus, if it's not again, my faith will be shaken if it's not his actual birthday. We sang the song A Magical Song December 5 and 20. Boom boom boom. Do you know this song? I don't know this. Song shout out to the listeners if you know know the song, it's it's pretty, pretty cool. It's like a, a magical song. So a lot of our song, obviously we're celebrating on December 25th. Is it possible that Jesus was born on December 25th? Anything's possible. Is it likely it's? It's unlikely.
29:34 You think it's unlikely? That it was on this exact day, I think it's probably unlikely. Yeah. Well, I mean, yeah. Do you think it's around December 25th? I think, I think it definitely could have happened. I just don't think it's most likely December 25th. I think it's like just as likely could have been the 26th or the 24th, but you know what I'm saying? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So what I mean is, do you think it was December 25th plus or minus a month? Probably, yeah, yeah, probably. I, I think, I think, I think high likelihood that it happened. But you know, anything's possible, you know, when pregnancies terms all all of these things. So let's look at the at the mouth. What? How do we even, how do we even wrap our minds around this timing, Michael? Well, unfortunately the Bible doesn't give us any like clear dates.
30:16 Now we will look at some scripture at the very end that's probably our best resource for dating. But the Bible just does not all right, give us his birthday, which makes sense because people were not as concerned with birthdays as we are in our culture. That's your day. That's. A good point. So by the way, my kid was at a birthday party. They totally off subject and my wife felt like this thing was sweet. It was like they it had like they got like one of these like video game trailers. She was like, anyway, we are. Get some. Get it for the fellas. Is it for the for the adult guys? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, all right. She was like, So anyway, thinking about people of different, the way they view birthdays, some people, I mean, man, you can, you can really, it's a lot different than the hail birthdays. Like we we try to celebrate and have a good time, but man, people can drop a lot of out of cash. Yeah, alright, so we have some hints. We know that when Jesus was born there were shepherds tending flocks.
31:11 Now I've heard all over the place on this used both sides. Like. Though the shepherds wouldn't be out there 'cause it was too cold or, well, the shepherds could have been out there because, you know, they have mild winters and it would have been bad. It's all over. See, things change season to season. You could have an unusually warm season or unusually cold season. That might change all of that. Too. Yeah, Yeah. It could have been like, hey, it's too, it's too warm. We got to take the sheep out away from the houses because it's starting to be smelly or something. You know, we, we don't know. So I would not put a lot of, like, stock on this. Some have suggested that it's a date before October because after October it starts getting cooler, but like you said, it could even have been a unseasonably warm week.
32:03 I mean, I mean, here in Charleston, it's like every now and then Thanksgiving is very hot. It's very cold. It's like who, who knows? Who knows? We do have Mary and Elizabeth's pregnancies. So these are kind of based on our two scripture that would give us some evidence and we're going to talk in depth about marrying Elizabeth's pregnancies at the end of this. So we're going to we'll save that to later. So here are some just general arguments in favor. And and I guess around the 4th century AD tradition was set up that it was December 25th and so it became recognized then. I don't know that. I wonder if that was during, was that during Constantine as well, would you say? I mean, most likely, unless it was really, really early, 3 hundreds, I would guess 'cause I mean, and this is what you hear and this is what we've been.
32:56 I, I know this is tied to a holiday, but it seems like, you know, Constantine's mom or wife or whoever had free reign to like pick all of these things like this is where Christ was born and this is, this is the date for this and, you know, kind of call on some of the shots. Yeah. And I've also heard, and I, I didn't put it in here as an argument for, but I've heard that one of the reasons that this date came about was that Jewish folks believe that true prophets died on the date that they were conceived. So Christ died around March 25th and so he would be conceived around March 25th. 9 months plus three months is 1225. So then they put the date around 12:25. I I don't know.
33:47 I don't know what basis they have. But I, I, I, I've heard that same thing going back to the 4th century. It seems like there's this Roman festival, this soul Invictus. And, you know, things are changing Christians. So we're gonna, so maybe Christians are like, hey, we're gonna fight against this Pagan ritual and we got our own thing going on. And I think this is where, you know, you hear people say, hey, Christmas has Pagan origins or something like that. Might come from some stuff like this too, I don't know. What is the Annunciation? Is that when he is that when he was crucified? I'm not familiar with that term. Question. Good question. You wanna? You wanna?
34:28 I'll do a little quick Google. I talked about, 'cause that may be this point that we have in here, may be what I just made. Was that his crucifixion? Let's find out. It commemorates, oh, the visit of the Archangel Gabriel to the Virgin Mary. That's the feast of Enunciation. Is that what did this say? Enunciation. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So we have a note here. Hippolytus of Rome 170 to 235 AD calculated December 5th as Jesus birthday based on his conception. March 25th linked to the enunciation. That's right. So. So there I guess someone figured out that Gabriel would have come. He made some calculation where he determined Gabriel came on March 25th and therefore 9 months later, December 25th. Boom.
35:19 So there you go, Hippolytus. Another thing to keep in mind Roman census timing. Look at looking to that familiar passage, Luke 2 where the census required Joseph and Mary to travel. It could have occurred during a time of year feasible for travel, likely after harvest, before severe winter conditions. So you got plenty we can travel. That kind of thing wouldn't make as much sense. If it's like, oh, we're gonna go all this way and there's not nothing means to get there and people are dying for this census would wouldn't be great. Look for the for the empire there. Yeah, and I've also heard this used as the negative that, oh, he wouldn't have made them travel this time. But remember, they were there for a little bit and the days were accomplished for her to be married. So it could have been like, hey, they're going to travel September, October, right around the, you know, mild times when there's harvest that's coming in and then they just stay there. So so that she's not travelling when she's close to giving birth.
36:15 I like this next reason Jewish festivals because Jesus birth aligned with the piece of dedication AKA Hanukkah in late November to December celebrating light entering the temple. Symbolically, this linked to Christ being the light of the world. I was in my mind, I'm just trying to run through the different I am statements like bread of life. Yeah, maybe the this festival fits too, you know right. Right, I guess, yeah. You could link it to all the different ones that occurred different times. Yeah. Astronomical events. The star Bethlehem may correspond to an astronomical event. Scholar suggests a conjunction of Jupiter and Venus occurred in December of 2 BC. I'm not I'm not convinced that the star that led the wise men was astronomical because I know some people have said well that when he says that the star is over the house that it was a house like up there.
37:12 But my, I think the plain reading of Matthew is that somehow the wise men knew which house was like they just walked up to the house based on the star. But again, how did they, why couldn't they have just done that? Why did they have to go to Jerusalem to find out that it was in Bethlehem if the star was that pointed? So there's a lot of unanswered questions. And there's one more reason some symbolic theology. Early Christians associated Jesus birth with the Windsor solstice, December 21st and 25th, symbolizing the Sun of Righteousness from Malachi 4 as days begin to lengthen. So if you know anything, you know days are getting shorter and shorter and shorter than around that 21st, 22nd, whatever.
37:52 Then they start getting longer and longer and longer all. Right. So here are some arguments against and what you'll find, because I've already alluded to some of the same things that people point to as in favor they'll kind of flip it and try to use it as an argument against climatic conditions. Again, it may have been too cold for shepherds to be out at that time. Again, that thing's I wouldn't say yay or nay based on that alone. Yeah, you know doing the Roman since December, it's not practical cause the bad weather for travel conditions, but. They could have been there for a long for a while. Yeah, they're hanging out. Clement of Alexandria suggested a spring date, May 20 or late fall, November 18 for Jesus birth.
38:35 So. What we doing, Clement, just covering all your bases, it could be the fall or get this guys the spring, right, That's half the year. That's right and the sole Invictus that we just mentioned it may just be too good of a coincidence so maybe trying to rewrite that Pagan holiday they could have just said hey we're going to put Jesus birth here reclaim this day we're. Already taking that day off, you know, with the with the work schedules and stuff, might as well just keep it all intact. That's right. Symbolic date selection. Well, Speaking of the winter solstice just talked about that. That's soul Invictus. Maybe it was just chosen for the symbolic reason light of the world. They may have used this date to contrast Jesus, light of the word with the Pagan son God. So similar a little a little bit different. What you'll what you'll find here is there's a lack of early church consensus.
39:24 If you can imagine, not everyone was just like if. We could just find his original birth certificate, then we wouldn't know. That's a good question. That's a good. Point. Just show us the birth certificate and remember that from. Wouldn't it be great archaeological evidence We got this birth certificate? This is interesting. I don't know if we, you know, want anything dogmatic here, but to me, this is, like more. We're about to talk, you know, Alex gives me something to hang on to. Yeah. Yeah. So I think this is the most conclusive and there's three scenarios here. So I think the most conclusive thing that you can know is that John the Baptist was six months older than Jesus because Mary had just basically conceived. We're not given an exact time, but it was pretty early in her conception that she goes and visits Elizabeth and we know that she's six months along.
40:19 And presumably we're making some assumptions here. But that Zacharias after he had served his time the temple, he's told, you know, you're going to go home and you and your wife are going to conceive. We assume that that happened in fairly short order. So with those assumptions, I think this is the best evidence where you can try to and I think you kind of get three. Well, you'll see there's three different likely I like. I like this a lot. So if you kind of like get an idea of how the priests serve, what was the priestly courses order? There are 24 priestly courses. If you're reading First Chronicles 24/7 through 19, you can see some some of these at each course served in the temple for one week.
41:03 So I like that there's some sort of, you know, time tracking we can do starting on the Sabbath and this rotate it twice every year. All courses also served during major festivals, things like Passover, Pentecost, piece of Tabernacles. So you kind of start getting that there's a method to it. Madness. Zechariah as a priest. We can start trying to do a little bit of math here. Yeah. So Zach, yeah, it's like you said, he's a priest, he's in the lineage of Abijah. And so all of those who were of eligible of Abijah would get cast lots and the lot fell to Zacharias and so he Zechariah. I think, yeah, Zechariah.
41:45 And he would have been chosen for his time. And since it was of the Abijah, we would have known it wouldn't be Passover, Pentecostal Tabernacle. So we've been one of the two times that Abijah would have served. And so the first time is the first rotation is somewhere between late May in early June. So the third month is Sivan. Sivan. I'm not, I don't know how to pronounce that. Me either. And then the second rotation would have been late November to early December. So that would have been the 9th month in the Jewish calendar. And I'll let you say this one, Kislev. Kislev. Yeah, sounds great. I think it gets tricky because is there a late month thrown in there? Do you add this, do you shift the second rotation to mid-october to early November?
42:31 You know, if that happens, the fall, you know at that time. Right, Yeah. So that, so that's how you get your three different options the the two normal or if it was a leap month ADAR 2 was added that would have shifted it to early mid-october to early November. Great. So hopefully you're tracking all of that so far. Going back to Zechariah Elizabeth conception of John the Baptist, you'll look at Luke chapter 1, verses 5 through 7. Zechariah, a priest of the division of Abijah, was serving in the temple when the Angel Gabriel appeared to him, announcing that his wife Elizabeth, would bear a son, John the Baptist. A few verses later, verses 23 and 24, after Zechariah's service, he returned home and Elizabeth conceived. So we can put these things like pretty close together. Right, right.
43:19 And so once we know that, we can kind of time it out. So we know that Gabriel announces Mary's conception in Luke 126 through 36 and that Mary is going to visit Elizabeth. John is going to leap in her womb, and so Jesus would have been born approximately 9 months after Mary's conception. So that would have been six months after John's birth. So John's about six months older than Jesus. So we're looking at our options for timing. If we go with that first rotation, you know, late May, early June, John's conception early June, Gabriel visits Mary in December, that's six months later. Like we talked about placing Jesus birth September of the following year, which I don't hate. Yeah, maybe maybe Jesus and myself had the same birthday, right?
44:15 That's like option number one. Option number two things shift. Where John's conception would be in early December, Gabriel visits Mary in June and then Jesus birth March of the following year. Yep, that's an option. Or if it were a leap year then that would shift his rotation to mid-october to early November. John's conception would be late October, early November, Gabriel visiting Mary late March, Jesus's birth late December. Boom. Can we look up? I'd be curious to look up leap years going back to this idea that if we know Herod died in four BC, I wonder what what when the leap years were because you probably couldn't been born in 15 BC.
45:07 I mean, just based on you know what I mean? So like you can at least maybe narrow it down to like is a leap year right there or not? Really. Is is is there one? Yeah, yeah. That'd be interesting. Yeah, maybe we maybe we can do some homework because and our next one, we'll talk about the actual year that Jesus born, you know, the next. Week, so maybe we can tie in. And and and go from there. That's good. So I hope I hope you hung in there with the the different math in the year. I I think maybe. I can put something up here that kind of gives the three different options. And, and again, there's some assumptions here, you know, maybe something was delayed, you know, on that first September 1, maybe took three months for Elizabeth to get pregnant.
45:47 Seems unlikely, but could have been. And then that would have pushed it into December, you know. Other thing is, you know, two of my kids were born at, you know, 30-4 weeks or whatever. You know, some kids may be born at 42 weeks. So you get, you know, maybe, maybe some of that is that play too? Yeah. So bottom line is we don't know that it's December 25th. I I think some people are like Jesus was not born on December 25th, therefore we should not be celebrating Christmas. I don't. That's not the take away. Not. Not the take away. I'm pretty confident Jesus was born. Hang in there with me. Between January 1st and December 31st, yeah. Somewhere in there, I would, I would wager, yeah, I would bet on that one. So.
46:27 Just trying to get out the truth, you know, we want the truth. So thanks for, you know, staying with us for this Christmas episode. We've got more Christmas Truth episodes coming up. That's right. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take 2. Find us wherever you find podcast and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed