...where we take theology 2 the next level
Aug. 21, 2024

Theology Proper | Immanence

Theology Proper | Immanence
Theology Proper | Immanence
Take 2 Theology
Theology Proper | Immanence

Episode 60


Michael and Zach discuss the immanent attributes of God.


Class resources/Google Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1elcFkj-2PhHpY3fPbbKC4l60HrV9XbraE0VwQT-h9mk


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/f6X4ycR0kp8


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com/

0:00 OK, Zach, so a couple episodes ago you introduced to me some moxie. Oh yeah. Have you gotten that's aired right? Yeah, that's. Aired button that's aired. Yeah. And any of the family give you any feedback on it? Lot, lot of feedback. They are. So it's going Moxie. Moxie reached out to me. Sales are just going through the roof, yeah. Yeah, so I thought maybe, you know, we had just gotten some of these and they may not be available everywhere. They're called poppies. I see. And it is a soda if if you're, you know some of my Arkansas family Coke. That's right, yeah. Or some of my Michigan family soda pop. Oh yeah, you cover the gamut.

0:44 Man, Yeah, yeah. But it's a probiotic soda, so there's a little bit less sugar, and it's supposed to have, you know, Have you drank kombucha? I have, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So it's supposed to have some of those. Those things you like? Kombucha. I do like kombucha, yeah. I I like kombucha too, like the taste is fine. I it's more of a mental thing with things floating around in my drink. I don't like that, but I know that's like. I really like the ones that are like in this this sorry, I keep hitting these boom stands, but it's like that really dark black brown glass. Oh, yeah, yes, yeah. And you can see like there's a layer on the bottom. And I really think you have two options.

1:24 Don't shake it at all, and then don't drink the very end of it or shake it up so you get a little bit with either drink. Yeah, but you don't want to leave that stuff and then drink it all at the very end. Well, I'm, I'm excited. We got a watermelon flavor here. So I thought maybe we could, you know, we're gonna try watermelon and lemon lime first. Lemon lime, that's. That's a little bit, yeah, mild. That's good. All right, So we'll just give you some of the lemon lime. Give me some of the lemon lime. By the way, behind the scenes, a lot of drama about which which cups everyone got. So I, I, I, I was like, I have to have the dad. You can have the mom one. Oh yeah, the it's got notes of I don't know.

2:08 Yeah, maybe I poured too much to to drink all this and get to the the watermelon. I don't know. You got to chug. It it's that kind of podcast we're chugging all right, and it's not bad. It's not bad. Is it like it's like, is it less carbonated I. Think it's less sugary? Less sugary. Yeah. So they're they're trying to make it healthier. They're trying to make it something that you would enjoy and drink, but you know it's it's good for you as a a calorie drink can be other than milk there. You go I, I. 25 calories is not bad. Not bad at all. Let's try watermelon.

2:50 Oh yeah, we should. Audience can really hear the poor. Yeah, right up to. The right up to the mic, all right. OK, I think my family prefers watermelon. I like the watermelon. It goes away pretty fast. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And and watermelon, I feel like it's one of those flavors it's hard to it's. Hard to be be wrong on it, yeah? Yeah, it is good. Well, you know, look, I might, I don't drink a lot of Coke or soda, but it's good to be, good to be. Are these reasonably priced or are these about the same? Are they expensive? I think they're maybe $1.25 a can. I don't. Know what but everything's. Expensive. So it's like it's more expensive than buying a case of soda, but less expensive than buying 1 soda at a time from a vending machine? That makes sense.

3:37 There you go. That's a good way, good way to think about it. There we go. So maybe, maybe there's more stuff for us. The Taste Test Future Podcast Send to send. Yes, if you if you want it like the send in some something that's going to be good, not you know. People are like watching them eat this. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. What is that? There's a type of fish over in Norway that's like that that is supposed to be really, really bad. Yes, Yeah, don't. Send us that. I'm blinking on what that what that is, Yeah. Or or the stuff from Australia, the Vegemite. Oh, that, that we'll. We'll skip out on those. Yeah, no, thank you. We're good. Send send us the good stuff. And yeah, cheers. It's good all. Right. So probably should actually talk about some type of podcasting stuff too.

4:20 We should somehow segue into we're gonna be talking about theology proper. This is the second class really. I mean second class on theology proper. I mean just really an outstanding class. Overall, great, great class. A lot, a lot to take in. And yeah, we've got the didn't catch the hints behind the choker. This is this is the teacher, Michael Mott. We got the person who who brought it to us these last couple weeks. So let's go ahead and take it to the next level from the hearts of the low country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. All right, Part 2 on theology proper. And before I forget, I, I will try to remember to put a link to the Google form.

5:14 And I'm not, I mean, it's not really necessarily looking for a response. If you want to put a response in there, I I'll probably see it. But really there's a list of resources that went along with this class that if you're interested. And it has my list of attributes kind of like whether they're communicable or not, whether we know them by via Negativa or by analogy, which we're going to go over and then some subscriptional support for that attribute. So that is out there. So, all right, so with that out of the way, just kind of review the first class we talked about transcendent properties, fact that God is transcendent, he is other. Sometimes we call that holiness and some people will attribute righteousness and holiness together.

5:58 And and I think that's because we are called as people to be righteous and that sets us apart from the world around us. But holiness in and of itself, it means sanctify means to be set apart, means to be different. So. That's a good good distinction. Like what's its primary use and and? They are related, but that's definitely different. Yeah, yeah. And so we talked about there being like two different ditches here. We don't want to be any ditch, so we don't want to be to the point where we are so stressing God's transcendence that we say we can't know Him, or so stressing His eminence where we would say, oh, you know, we can fully understand him.

6:40 But we got to have that tension between them 'cause He has revealed himself to us in a way that we can understand him, but we're never going to fully understand Him. I, I like how you've got, if you, if you look at last week and this week and you've got these attributes side by side, it just great to be in both of those. So you do get that balance because you look at these different religions and it's like for the most part, they either air I, I don't know if another religion that has both of these things, right. And that's you can see where being out of balance has major implications. And so just to review real quick, one of those that we talked about last week was impassability. This one, for some reason, it's weird to me that people are OK with go, oh God, can't change. Oh yeah, right.

7:26 Yeah, that. One's easy. That one's. Easy, Intuitive. I get it. Yeah, I understand it. God doesn't have emotions. God doesn't have passions. Well, to me those are almost bound together because God can't have changing emotions if God is immutable. Right, right. And when you think of it that way, to me it makes a lot more sense because what I think the average person reads it is going to say, well, in Scripture, I, I feel like I read that God is joyful or God pities this person or is grieving or is angry. And I think that's the crux of it. And so of course he has passions. Of course he has emotions. And so I did get asked like, can we believe those scriptures that say God repented or that God was angry?

8:12 And I I my answer to that yes, and you and they tell us about how to understand God as he interacts with his creation. It the same way you could believe if I had penned you know Jill is a ray of sunshine in my life. You could believe that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I hope you wouldn't believe that. Like she's has fusion in the middle of her and she's like beaming out these photons. You know you. Need sunglasses? Right. It is a way of understanding. Now probably that metaphor of Jill or that figurative language of Jill is a bigger contrast than what we're talking about here. But it's still, we have to kind of understand that when the Scripture is being written that way, it's being written so that we can understand, you know, God.

8:56 It's kind of help us see him anthropomorphically or anthropopathically like that, so we can understand him really in his transcendence. Yeah, that, that, that's really good. And I'm glad, you know, when you think of impossibility, it's good to in your mind be like, this is the transcendent side. And that's why he is different. And I like when you when you talk about him being outside of time, it's, it's really the only way he can kind of operate with that fixed disposition towards different things. And it is confusing because he can almost have, You can correct me if I'm wrong with how I'm saying this, what can seem like conflicting dispositions towards the same person at relatively different times. And that that's confusing.

9:37 But it's because we are experiencing unfolding of events and sequencing. He's not. Yeah, Let me maybe give one more example. You could say, Jay, there's no way to go into the park today. And then he goes and cleans his his room and you go, OK, you can go to the park. You could, you know, taken literally, you're contradicting yourself, but maybe in your mind you're like Jay, I told you earlier today, your room has to be clean. There's no way you're going to the to the park with your rooms like it is. But then the circumstances change. And so you had a fixed disposition towards Jay going to the park with a dirty room. But now that the circumstance changed, you're you saw the fixed disposition circumstance changed. Now his room is clean.

10:21 Now he's free to go to the park. I don't know if that helps, but you you. I I think some of these are really good and God, God is I just your theology, just the implications if your God is, you know, hot and cold one second to the next or unpredictable or capricious in any way that that's just a we would say that's not the God of the Bible. I think most people get along with that. So hopefully, hopefully that was helpful. I appreciate you taking time because probably the number one attribute that and it's just so not intuitive, but when you start talking about it, I think it makes more sense. That's good. And so I started off the class with this wrapped gift wrapped box.

11:01 Did you wrap it yourself? I. Did wrap it myself. Nice, nice, yeah. I've been I don't wanna say I pride myself. Wow, that's I've been, I would say other people have complimented my, you know, rapping abilities. I should have looked closer. It looked, it looked really nice from I I was really hoping at the beginning you're like, I'm I've known to do some magic. I was waiting for you to like just talk to someone and it and something was in there like you would set them up and they didn't know that would be, I don't know how you would have done it, but that would have been amazing. Yeah, so you know, he mentioned that because I have done magic tricks before, but not illusions, not pure magic. Sorcery. Witchcraft. Yeah, but but I set this up by, you know, passing around like asking people questions about it. I was like, OK, what if I told you that magically whoever is holding this gift, the thing that would be most valuable from that person, like the best thing that person could give appears in that box.

11:57 And we kind of pass it around the audience and it's like, yeah, what would appear if this person was holding any etcetera, etcetera. And then I was like, OK, what would, what would, what would be in there if, if God were holding this box? And CBC came through. That came through. I don't think I even heard one wrong. I heard, I heard a couple and they all were saying himself next time, next time we just need someone in there just saying something just just ridiculous. Like $1,000,000. That's great, 'cause I also want to shout out to Alex. Always got something great to say. Is he the one who said vote time? I don't know. He said he he's always saying hilarious things, Yeah. Yeah, he, he, Yeah. Anyway, it's good stuff. Sorry but but but your your greater point is God gives himself to us.

12:41 I mean these attributes we can relate to him. Yeah, so he gives himself and there's there's lots of different ways he's given himself to us. He created us, you know, he made himself known to us, you know, so by by doing that alone, he has given himself to us. But when he created us, he created us with the image of God. And so the things that we talked about last week, he can't give to us, but these things we can share in with him. We're not going to have them to the same measure or the same degree. And then, of course, on the cross, he gave himself to us so that we could be reconciled with him. And so that biggest gift that he can give is himself. And so we're going to be talking about these different attributes and these attributes are different than the ones as we talked about last week, last week, we're all negative in some sense this week going to be positive.

13:27 And when we talk about positive attributes of God, we we say that we're calling them by analogy or we're ascribing to God by analogy. And we always kind of use this thing to set up, you know, if I were to say, you know, man, this, this dog is a good dog, we can kind of have an idea what that would mean. Even on the screen, I showed you kind of a generic dog and I showed a duck hunting dog. Like now you know, you know, your, your attributes of a good dog might change if you know that it's supposed to be a duck hunting dog, which kind of plays into this because now I'm going to say, what's a good father? Will the attribute change it again, because the attributes are based on the creature or the being that we're ascribing this predicate of good.

14:13 So then if I were to say God is good, well, we wouldn't mean what we mean by a a good dog or a good father. It's a different. But we kind of have something there, but we're not like, oh, he shows up on time to work. And you know, that would be absurd, right? I like that. It's a good way to set up these communicable attributes. And I don't know if we, we think of these, you probably have some good definitions ready. I think as we talk about maybe later on the Trinity, later on talking about the hypostatic union, some of these words are hard for us to grasp words like I think we know what a person is, but what's like a good definitions or conscience or will some of these things, I think they're important to know.

14:56 And it might be this might be over just making a super simple and maybe we don't need to do this. But I think when we when I think of things like that, it helps make other stuff a little bit more more clear. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So the first one you mentioned was person. And he is a person, He's not a force. And kind of the things that follow directly behind that would be what we would say. What makes a person a person? They're they're conscious, they're self aware. They have some type of intelligence. Sometimes we would say God is omniscient. Well, we would say that or his wisdom kind of all those are different aspects of his intelligence. He has a will, He decides things, he decides them from eternity. But so it's not like he's discursively deciding things, but he decides things. And so and you hopefully you can see, oh, I'm a person, I'm self aware.

15:46 I've got some limited intelligence. I can decide things. And so those attributes he shared with us and really kind of when you pair all those together, you have this other quality of moral. I, you know, I, if a lion goes out and, you know, kills another lion and kills all the Cubs and like puts the lionesses in the heat so that he can mate with them and have his own Cubs, we don't go, man, that's an immoral monster. Yeah, cuz, cuz even the most, maybe not the most, but some God hating person would hold humanity to some sort of standard and on some level, right. Maybe not, maybe there's, there's people out there, but it's there's a clear difference with animal behavior and human behavior. And people want to compare us so much to animals. But at some level, yeah, people aren't freaking out. They're like, well, that's just the circle of life or that's nature or whatever.

16:40 Yeah. Yeah. And so we would say God is moral. Now this is by analogy. So how I am moral is different than how God is moral, because I am moral by trying to live up to God's standards. God is moral by being God himself, like he. It is in his nature, you know the good. Our standards of good are defined by God's nature, Himself. That that's a good way to put it. And you alluded to this when you talked about intelligence and wisdom and omniscience. But part of the challenge with these communicable attributes is that you're a list could could be endless. It could it's like, how do you and you look at different confessions or different systematic theologies? Everyone lumps them in slightly different. And so don't feel like Michael's we've left out one. It's because they're all kind of, you know, it's impossible, really.

17:24 I'm trying to hit the big ones and I didn't even like, I have more on my list here that we're looking off of than I actually even had on the PowerPoint. But so He is love. You would see this in Scripture. God is love. He is goodness. Sometimes we would countenance that as Omni benevolence or righteous because of his love. He is just, he's a just God. He wants to have what's right out of his justice. With would come wrath and jealousy. And you can see, again, I just want to keep as we go through kind of a group of these, hopefully you can see, oh, I can see that God has those attributes and I can see that he has shared some of that with me.

18:07 Hopefully I can be loving. Hopefully I am good to extent. You're not going to be Omni benevolent like he is. Hopefully you love justice. And you know not that you want to see someone, you don't rejoice in the punishment, but you rejoice in justice when it happens. So hopefully you can see those types of things. Yeah, I think just going through through this list and reflecting on it, it I think you can learn a lot about ourselves and where we kind of missed the mark two and and we see how how great God is. And and really this list spans the gamut from things like being conscious and having a will to being creative. And it's it's it's a very broad list in in that sense too. And I think one that I think people might struggle with, two at the outset is when you read things in line with justice God, God's a jealous, God sounds, sounds a little bit. When I'm jealous it's not good, but when God jealous it is good. It it could be good if you're jealous in a non sinful way. So like if Leanne was spending time, it wouldn't even have to be like with another man, but maybe she was just really wrapped up in something that wasn't good for your covenant relationship as a husband and wife. You know, you could be in a good sense jealous for her to return to that covenant relationship that you have with her. And so and that and we would say that God has a covenant relationship with us as his

19:37 people, but he also has a relationship to us as, you know, creator creation. And so he can be jealous of that rightful relationship that we should have with him. And so it's, you know, but you could the badge you all see is like when you see someone that has something that you just want, you kind of that's we got a synonym for that would be like coveting. Yeah. I. Think that's good? I point out that one because I think that one's maybe the most stark way we can see that. But we can have, you know, along those same lines, when we're angry, it can be good, but it cannot be good. But the same token. Our grace can be good and not good too. Like I was trying. You know, you start jealousy is weird, but then we can let things off the hook that we shouldn't in some capacity, right? Right. Yeah, yeah.

20:18 I think that's great because all of these we're not going to exhibit perfectly. And so we could be too gracious with someone where we should really kind of toe the line with them sometimes. But yeah, that so the next one's kind of His mercy, His grace, his faithfulness, Providence kind of goes underneath intelligence. Here's another one, the omnis. We wouldn't want to leave off omnipotent. So he has all power. We you go, how do we share that? Well, he has given us a measure of power. We don't have the Omni part of it, but we have the ability to affect things and people around us. So. Now that that that that's great alluded to it, creativity, the ability to, you know, problem solve and build things.

21:00 We can't build things out of nothing, but we can still build things and have solutions to to this world and use this world engineer it for for different purposes. Patience that that that's a good one and joy and peace. Really, really we can. Do it's hard. To keep. Going on, because I saw people like Will all the fruit of spirit you could list there, you know, all, you know, So all of the things that you could, you know all of these things like you said it, we could keep going on because we're describing discursively all the attributes of a transcendent holy God. It's really hard, hard to describe. And in some sense, because God is simple, God's love is just, I mean, not it is in that sense.

21:44 So God's love is wrath. God's love is mercy. It's, you know, we kind of compartmentalize things so much, but all of these really express another attribute. It just, you know, maybe a different emphasis or something like that. They're not totally separate. Yeah. And. Like this love and wrath and justice kind of being wrapped up together. Like if you saw someone, an innocent kid, you know, being harmed, your love for that kid would be tied to your wrath towards the the person who's harming them. And so you can see how they would flow out together. That's great 'cause I think it is easy to just be like, well, God's merciful here. And it's like really, these are all very connected. And when they are connected, that's why God is God. And we missed the boat 'cause we're doing a wrong kind of wrath or whatever, whatever it it may be.

22:30 What else we want to talk about, about these, about God's eminence? Well. We did. I'll just touch on it 'cause we have talked about it before, but we have talked about his knowledge, his way of knowing. And we've said, you know, he talked about his natural knowledge being knowledge of all possibilities, his free knowledge being his knowledge of what he's freely chose to do. We said there might be some knowledge in between that of things that creatures might do, of the way things would be if, you know, things were different. We call those count. Oh, I've lost the word. Or it's about counter or counterfactuals.

23:11 OK, yeah, yeah, I thought I knew it, but I'm like, not the philosophy guy. So yeah, I got you. So counterfactual, so like things of what would have happened if something had been different. So we call that middle knowledge. Some people have used that to support Mullen ISM. I don't think neither one of us subscribed to Mullen ISM. Get out of here. And I'm not even sure you subscribe to Middle Knowledge. I don't know if. I'm conventionally I, I, I've come around. At first I kind of rejected it, but I think after thinking it through, I think there's a way where it can be done, done right, right. Yeah, I think what I think what when we were talking about before, 'cause we were talking about like the deck of cards that he has dealt. Like yes, but he has an infinite number of cards.

23:51 Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's different. And I think it just presented so poorly or in that Molinism framework that's I'm like, don't love that 'cause I think a lot of these people, their different systems influence their thought. And it's, you know, I don't like this part, but I like this part. And so I think I think that that helps out a lot because that's something we probably don't think about a lot, but it does point to how great our God is and how his decrees come to pass and how he knows everything. All right, So we did talk about the Trinity, but I think we're going to save that for a future podcast, maybe give it its own little spot because. Trinity Pride deserves its own. I like that.

24:31 That's good. Yeah. All right. So I don't have anything else to say about theology proper. Hey, second time around maybe, maybe we did a little better, I don't know. Hopefully, hopefully, thankfully we found it like halfway through so. Thank you, Michael. So, so glad for that. Well, thanks for hanging in there with us. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.