...where we take theology 2 the next level
May 14, 2025

Yom Pt 2 – Which Interpretation Is Best?

Yom Pt 2 – Which Interpretation Is Best?
Yom Pt 2 – Which Interpretation Is Best?
Take 2 Theology
Yom Pt 2 – Which Interpretation Is Best?

Episode 2.4


Episode Description:

In Part 2 of our deep dive into Genesis 1, we ask the big question: Which creation view best fits both the Bible and the observable universe? Building on our discussion of yom in Part 1, we compare major views—Young Earth, Old Earth, Theistic Evolution, and more—and examine how broader creation passages across Scripture (Job, Psalms, Romans, etc.) shape our understanding of Genesis.


Michael makes the case that Old Earth Creationism aligns best with the text’s linguistic structure, theological depth, and scientific evidence—from radiometric dating to starlight travel to the Big Bang. Along the way, we answer common objections and emphasize that the goal isn’t to compromise Scripture, but to read it faithfully while recognizing God's revelation in both Word and world.


Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/fZX1nZbaJIU


Merch here: https://take-2-podcast.printify.me/


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):

⁠https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone⁠

License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8


Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://www.take2theology.com/

0:00 Well, you ever made a bad decision, Michael? No, never. Sorry. Silly question to ask you you made a bad decision about an hour and a half ago. Ada. I do this thing where we talked before. I feel like I'm being healthy because I don't eat all day. Then I'm just like so hungry. And so got home a little early from work and waiters like, oh, you're probably podcasting will do something different for dinner with the boys. And so just so hungry. Put in a I I started out kind of healthy. I I fried up three eggs. OK, Yeah. We're tracking. This is where it goes terribly. Wrong. Let me just say the the recent literature on eggs has come out like in rave support. I guess I saw something about people who ate so many eggs a week had.

0:44 Oh the yeah. Less mental health issues as they got older, less cardiovascular issues like so eat your eggs. So I'm starting up good. I didn't I I left out a little bit worse thing that I did. I put in, got one of those like Pillsbury, like grand biscuits, like the 8 count thing, put it in the oven and so I made. And you ate all 8 of them. I only ate 6. But boy 6. Are there carbs in those things? Yeah. I can't, can't be good for you. But I I was doing this thing where I was like, I got one biscuit and I put an egg on it. It was like a little egg sandwich. Then I did it again. Then I did it again and then I just say 2 just normal biscuits and I was like I want dessert. So I put you on it right now and. Then I put like Jelly on one of them for my, you know, and my kids were like, dad, are you just eating all of these? Like I was like, well, you're eating dinner and and, and they're like, do you really need that mini sale? It's probably aggressive, but I haven't that's my meal for the day.

1:41 Doesn't make it doesn't doesn't make it good. So you've been you were fasting up until that. Correct. Yeah, Yeah. Yeah. So I mean, that's that counts for something. Yeah. But this is what I do when I fast. I am like, ridiculously sometimes if you wait long enough, it's like it goes like it goes away better, you know, when I'm hungry, man. Yeah. It came back, came back to bite me. So my typical, you know, we were talking about finances last, last, and I thought about mentioning this, you were talking about eating now on, on lunch a lot. But what I have done is bought some like bulk stuff from Sam's. I have them in my cube at work. And then like I just had the same thing over and over again. So it's like some protein bars, a protein shake, that fair life thing, Slim Jim, that's protein and some fat. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

2:28 And I got some pistachios. Nice. So you're like really crushing that high protein. Yeah, yeah. That's. Good and pop Tarts. You have one. Vice in there, I know and like. I love them. What kind of pop tarts? So it's there's it's a big box from Sam's and they have two smaller boxes of strawberry and then one blueberry. 1 cherry. Let me tell you. Yeah, yeah, tell me. I would not have told you this before 'cause I hadn't eaten a lot of cherry. But Cherry is where it. Is don't sleep don't sleep on cherry flavor. Oh, it was good. So I, you know, I have one of those packages a day and I, I'm a bigger guy and I feel like people are always looking at me and I want to say like, this is the only carb that I'm eating for all of my lunch. It's gonna be OK.

3:15 It's. Gonna be OK. You know, I haven't done pop tarts in a while. My this is, you know, this is a little insight to the Hale household and nutrition like Friday's pop tart day for the hell kids for breakfast. You know, they love it. I never like love pop Tarts. I do see this is my problem. I like pop tarts. I just like peel up the crust and just eat all the inside, you know what I'm saying? I. Mean the the inside is the. Best. It's so good. But do you toast them? Always. Oh, yeah, 'cause if you toast them, it's just like, Oh yeah, it's two different things. That's right. Yeah, yeah. That's right. And that's probably my problem is that, you know, take a pop tour on the go. Didn't have time to toast it. Yeah, it it is. It's way different. Right. It's like it crisps up the crust and it makes it, you know, 'cause if you don't toast them, the crust is just the. Crust.

3:59 That's what gets you the crust. You gotta toast to get over the crust. It's just like like Krispy Kreme is good all the time, but man not but it's good on by the when it's hot and ready. Boom. Honestly you buy Krispy Kreme from like Walmart or something. I don't care for it. Like it just, it's like. Doesn't have the same. It's. Like I mean I hate it, don't get me wrong, like I'm not crazy, but it's just not the same. Yeah. Yeah, I don't think, I don't think get back in the Pop Tart game. How do you feel about the They have the what kind of brown sugar, the cinnamon brown sugar, you know? Cinnamon brown sugar, that was my go to. Yeah, I like. That a lot, but I don't know I I saw those again when I went to re buy. So I'm on my second box after like a month or you know, finally made it.

4:42 Try to be healthy, get strawberries and get the fruits. In there, right yeah, yeah, fruits, fruits and veg, you know what I'm saying? But I saw it and I was like, you know what, I maybe next time I'll get the because they had one that was like the brown sugar and I think maybe s'mores and chocolate. And it's like, Oh yeah. So it's a whole different vibe. Like I. Yeah, it is a different. Yeah, I wish you could get like the best of both worlds, kinda. It makes I think I prefer I like the fruit ones, but I do like the brown some brown sugar. This pumped sugar just good. Yeah, they are good. Man, some bad decisions, but very, we made this pun the last time. It's not even really a pun. It's very yummy. Very yummy, Yeah? Yeah, yeah, Pop talks or Yammy. So everyone at home is probably like they talked a lot about YAM but not enough.

5:23 I would another Yam episode. Yeah, yeah. So we did talk about yam. And so we're going to, you know, kind of do this is Part 2. We won't be spending as much time on the word yam, but it is like, you know, the the old earth, you know, discussion. Ken Ham is rolling over in his bed because he's not dead. Not. Yet. Well, let's go ahead and take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Lowcountry in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next. Level real quick Michael 32nd recap of of last week's episode. Yom is a word that can be used more than one way. Yes, 4 literal definitions to the word Yom can be when it's light, a calendar day, a 24 hour period or a longer, you know, unspecified amount of time.

6:24 And so hopefully, you know, hopefully the goal of last episode was just to answer, not necessarily persuade you. You could listen to that episode and go, yeah, OK, not persuaded, but hopefully you came away going. All right. Maybe it's not a closed, clear cut case that I thought it was. Maybe there is some room to be faithful to the text and still, you know, maybe not take it as 24 consecutive, 24 hour consecutive days. Yeah, maybe this would help our listeners, too. Do you have good examples of old Earth creationists other than yourself, who you would say, hey, these people are faithful to Scripture? Like just to get some work gets people in your mind because, you know, Ken Ham, you got like John MacArthur you. I mean, it's like a lot of people, because I think even I got to look this up, it's like even some of the fundamentalism issues in like the early to mid 1900s, we're kind of based around this indirectly.

7:22 Like they would wrap up inspiration of scripture because I think it was pushing back against evolution in the school system and that, you know, trial and it was like missing, missing what you're saying, but it was like kind of funny. And some of some of these like drafts, they were like mentions like a literal 6 day, like in the same sentence as a inspiration of scripture, right? So anyway, yeah, are there people we can like? Greg Coco. I should have known. We should have known. Wayne Lane, Craig. OK. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, Hugh Ross. Yeah, Fuzz Rana, you may or may not know that. Name but the fuzz. Mr. Z, He's Fuzz, and Mr. Z and Hugh Ross are all from Reasons to Believe. OK, Yeah. I may be mistaken on this, but your your guy Piper. I was going to mention he he's the one guy you can look, you can Google John Piper desiring God and old Earth creationism and he's got a bajillion articles, but not very if you can find a couple times he like alludes to it. He he'll say like my I'm persuaded old Earth. There's like one or two articles. Don't talk about it a lot, but in there. And I was like, and I think I could be wrong because I was like trying to look into this maybe a couple years ago. I think he's a gap theory guy.

8:30 I think OK. So created long period of time where like the stars and galaxies were doing stuff and then boom boom boom on the earth. I, I think so it's just hard to say 'cause he does not develop his, I guess he's got a few things, but he kind of like stays out of that conversation. Maybe he feels like that's a not a specialty and like more to like that's like not where he's going to focus and maybe not. Stephen Meyer, Michael B. He is Grudem. I, I don't know that for sure. It just when you asked me that question, I think he is. Grudem is, I think you're right. Yeah. Yeah, I think you were right about that because he took like in his, he does like a Sunday school with his systematic theology and he gets a lot of pushback in his class.

9:11 And he's just like, hey, these are my reasons. I don't know if you mentioned this. Because I know Augustine. Yeah, yeah, you're like Peter, Apostle Peter. You're like, that's great because in this podcast you're going to get broader to like objections or like. Yeah, we'll cover some of the same objections we had last time just to recount because this you may have missed the first one, but and then we'll also talk to some objections that aren't necessarily text based because all of our ones last time were texts of the Bible based. Great, I love it. Well, give me the overview. What? Give me a lay of the land. Right. So we've got our already talked about. Oh yeah, we kind.

9:54 Of young earthers. Yeah. And we're defining that as somewhere in that six to seven. I think it's 6 and some change. I don't know the exact number, but it's like 6700 years old I believe. Really there are some young earthers who would push back against Uzak might say that you're a compromiser because you're like a 1220 thousand year guy. I've. Lost the way. Yeah, yeah. And then there are old earth creationists like myself, and there are many different types of old earth creationists. I think like a Michael B, he believes that God zapped. I know that's not probably not the best word, but but he miraculously changed DNA inside, you know, an embryo or something and created new kinds.

10:47 I'm not for sure on that, but you might have someone like that to someone who believes that God created the different kinds, you know, as full grown animals. Like you mentioned gap theory, there's day age theory, there's I remember. I remember as a kid in like a very conservative Christian high school, I remember very visually science class, we would have like like course on creation, like matching about all these like terrible theory, like gap theory, like gap theory is bad. Like these things. It's so funny, you know what I mean? Like it's like that was, I think that it was just such a thing maybe like in the 50s and I went to a school, although in like the 2000s, we were like, we always just say we're 50 years behind. So whenever the culture was going through 50 years in the past, it's probably what we're dealing.

11:30 Yeah, so I just want to take a moment to say all of the the different categories that I just named new, young and old earth creationists all believe that God miraculously brought about life on earth and that he is the one who created the heavens and the earth, you know, so. These were in the bounds of orthodoxy, Adam and Eve, literally. Literally Adam. And Eve. Yeah, I was in. Even William Lane Craig would hold to a literal Adam and Eve. I don't think Josh Swami Das holds to a literal Adam and Eve. But these are these are like most people. Swami Das is not a household name, you know, So you got to be like in this.

12:16 Swami. You got to be in this topic a little bit in order to have that name be be. Got should be like familiar with that and then you're about to go off the ledge where? So the next category still believes that God created the physical universe and that God upholds. It's hard to nail them down the the process of life coming about, but they would be your theistic evolutionist. That's a bad word. It is a bad word. And and I'm sure they were like, you know, to me, I just want to say, young earthers, we don't have to agree, but we we're we're in this together. And I'm sure that the theistic evolution would say to me, you know, we don't have to agree, but we're in it together.

13:00 But I'm like, no, you're too far. But that is how I feel. Because you know, if you hold to a neo Darwinian atheistic, you know, evolution model, you asked what did God do? And they don't really have an answer. I went down to they had a symposium downtown maybe 10 years ago along and there was a theistic evolutionist there. And, and some, some of them just like to be called evolutionary creationist, evolutionary creationist. But I'm going to we'll for ease of we'll just continue to call them theistic evolution. And I asked what God do and like, well, God upheld it.

13:40 God was, but he didn't like actually do anything. Like all the mutations, I think on their view are still random and that if God were to do it again it could come out to a different. And that's really how we got Adam and Eve. It's not like God created directly Adam and Eve. That came through the series of evolution. And Adam and Eve might even be like like a framework or it's like, not necessarily Adam was a person, but it's like that's the humanity or you know. Yeah. And it's very difficult for me to say, like, here's a book that God basically between maybe some of his oral tradition that was passed down to Moses when he wrote it down. But, you know, I think for the most part, God is giving Moses this revelation while he's on Mount Sinai. And you know, what's the purpose of saying, you know, here is how everything started.

14:31 It was good, and here's how it went bad. If the very thing of explaining how it went bad is metaphorical or, you know, figurative, like, OK, well, then where did sin come from? If Adam and Eve aren't literal, there wasn't a literal fall. If they evolved into consciousness, then how, how did they sin? How are they, you know, are they just acting according to their DNA? And how could that be bad, you know? Yeah. And then you run into real problems when you get into Romans and Paul's appealing to Adam and he's like, are we appealing to a metaphor? Like that's weird and not an actual person? Yeah, that's a really good point. But they still believe that there is a God who created everything.

15:12 So then there are some other finer tooth categories like deistic evolutionists. So not at the. Eric was founded on baby. Yeah, yeah. That's. What we love that's right. And then you're agnostic atheist evolutionists. So you know you're Richard Dawkins would be in this area type of. Quick, quick quiz question. I don't want to belabor it too much, but in the United States, do you know what percent of people would consider themselves atheists? It's it used to be like around .8%. I would probably say it's up to 6% these. Days, that's a really good guess. ChatGPT says 4% about 10 million people. Agnostics would be about 5% and then people that say nothing in particular, there's probably got, but they're like more like maybe there's not a guy like I have no, no hard feeling that's like 17 percents with like 70 plus percents playing some. So I think that's good for him too. Because I feel like you feel like science is against you or I don't know, you know what I mean, But it's really not bad, the average.

16:20 Person and science, I know. I just want to push back on what you said there. Science. It's like the people in the news and. Science is never against you. It's scientists. Right. But I might say pharma, I don't really mean like pharmacology doesn't make yeah, yeah, yeah, people pushing medications and stuff. But yeah, yeah, I see. Yeah, yeah, I just want to because sometimes people will say that science and faith are against each other and like, they're not really. Right, right. I see what you're saying. I think they'd be like, well, Fauci doesn't agree and he's like the representative of science, but I you're saying actual science. Or I might say like, you know, evangelicals. I don't. I mean, just like, you know, I don't really mean the actual people, but it seems like there's like a movement and a lot of people push a certain thing or whatever.

17:05 But yeah, yeah. So I think the difference of the evangelicals, just to kind of hone in what the points, yeah, 'cause it it the thing, the parallel would be like evangelism, evangelism, evangelicalism. Or you could, some people will say like big Eva things this or big pharma wants this. And I would be like, well, I would say I agree with that. But I mean, yeah, pharmacy, yeah, yeah, yeah. All right, so last time we spent a lot of time on Genesis. Yeah. And talking about YAM specifically, we went over different verbs that were in Genesis. We didn't spend a lot of time, but we we covered it. But there are other passages that speak to the creation and we're not going to go, maybe we can list these.

17:47 So if people want to go find them, if you go to Reasons to believe, I believe they have this here. And I'll just plug Hugh Ross. He has a book. It's something like Unimaginable Planet or something like that. That's not the title, but it's something like that. But yeah, I would be listening to this and it would be going over all the you're going to look it up for me real quick. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, Hugh Ross, Something Planet. Oh, yeah. Like, yeah, yeah, yeah. Hugh Ross. Let's see what it is. Oh, improbable. Planet, improbable planet, improbable planet. And I would be listening to this and I'd be like, oh, this is this is so good. I would like crying on my way to work, you know, talking about how God you know's handiwork was used. But he's an old Arthur.

18:33 He's he's an old Earther, so. He's OK, yeah, Yeah. But if you go to his website, he'll have these different passages. But, you know, Genesis 2 through 5, they kind of give us the some of these archetypal, you know, that just to to, you know, Genesis probably 3 through 5. Well, 4 through 5 is more confusing to me than one through 3. You know, where it's like Tubal was the first person to play instrument. Yeah, it's a little bit odd. Yeah. Job 934 through 42, you're going to see snippets where it talks about God's power and creating Psalms 819-3310, four one, 39147 and 148 going to speak different aspects of poetry.

19:20 And there's some places in here that give you things that say something like he set a boundary for the waters and it'll never go past. He set the laws in motion and they'll never change type of thing. So there are like, do you take those poetically or are they really trying to tell us stuff? You're going to talk, you see some stuff in Ecclesiastes one through 3, Isaiah 40 through 51, Romans one through 8, you're going to see some mentions there a different creation. You, you know, he alludes to Adam there and, and stuff. Colossians 1, Hebrews 1 and 4, Revelation 20 through 22. So if you read, if you're reading all of your Bible, you're going to see different places where the creation is assumed, where Adam and Eve are assumed to exist. And so I think very easily that we can discount theories that don't hold to a literal Adam and Eve, and I think we can discount theories that that hold to evolution. You're not going to see this, you know, on your latest, you know, popular thing.

20:25 But there's a lot of concern amongst evolutionists, evolutionary scientists right now about the evolutionary paradigm, you know, neo neo Darwinian evolution. So I say that because evolution, we have a lot of different definitions. So when I'm talking about a Finch be getting bigger or smaller with the rainy seasons, we're talking about, you know, the common descent from a single ancestor. You know, macro evolution is what some people might call that, but there's a lot of concern. The time span for evolution to happen is very, very small. Even on the old Earth, there's not a lot of time there was a you can't really have life until we get our ionosphere because our ionosphere stops a lot of radiation from the UV light and, and, and stuff from the sun.

21:20 And between the ionosphere forming and the Cambrian explosion is like, it's pretty small. And we see in, you know, our first hints of life and the Cambrian explosion is even smaller in our fossil record. And at the Cambrian explosion we have every single phyla of animal body type present there. Yeah. So it's like, oh, what what happened here where we have all of these body types immediately? Maybe there was a creation event there? Yeah, no, that, that's interesting that there's, you're saying there's been like they're doing the math and they're like, well, if you have billions, billions of years for like every little thing, it's hard to make that happen when you start really extrapolating.

22:08 Yeah, and you can dig into it. There's a recent paper that was written, you know, because there's a famous like you give monkeys long enough on a typewriter, they can write the works of Shakespeare and and a guy actually was like that actually is not true. You can give them a a very, very, very long, like infinite time doesn't exist, right? Yeah. Yeah. So we can't give an even. If you made that like 10 trillion years, that changes things dramatically. Yeah, yeah. Right. Yeah. So 10 trillion years is a finite time. They're still not typing out the. So any finite time period of time, the monkeys are not typing out Shakespeare's works. So we maybe we have a separate episode if we need to, to really, you know, bomb evolution some more.

22:52 But I think from merits, you know, basically theistic evolution, theistic evolution, atheist, agnostic evolution, they, they just don't stand. And so really you're left with God created stuff and we're all on I, I think that's the bigger picture here, that we're all on the same team. And So what you know, what's the best way to understand, you know, the, the textual stuff? Nice. I like that we're on the same team. Get those evolutionist out of here and let's, let's, let's have our, you know, intramural debate. Yeah. So I got a question for you, Zach. When do you think that the Earth is the center of the the solar system?

23:41 Of course. Me, me and, you know, way back in the Middle Ages, we we all think. That Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you probably don't. Yeah, right. And but you know that the Roman Catholic Church for a while taught that. And their reasoning was part of their reasoning was most of it was based on Aristotle's bad physics. But then they came along and they strengthened that with some verses like from the rising of the sun to the going down of the same in the name of the Lord shall be praised like, well, it's, it's clear right there. The The sun is what's rising. Wouldn't lie. That's right. And and, and so I mentioned that to say that if you have two options that are both faithful to the text, I it's OK to say, all right, which one is better supported from our physical outside the text observations? OK.

24:38 So choice A&B are both fine. There's, you know, there's a way to be faithful to the text, interpret the text. B has a lot of scientific support. A doesn't have a lot of scientific support. Which is the better read of of that Bible verse? Gotcha. Yeah, yeah, you can go with the scientific support. It's it's. It's within bounds. Right. And so based on that, I do want to give some scientific support because assuming that last time we, you know, I did my job and, and demonstrated how you could be faithful, then OK, let's give some evidence that might sway in that The Big Bang theory itself. I've said this before. I know Christians don't like the term Big Bang. We've been told that's bad billions of years and Big Bang, that Big Bang, that's bad.

25:26 You know, scientists don't like the word Big Bang, at least the ones who came up with it. It was a derogatory term that the scientists came up with because The Big Bang meant that there was a beginning of the universe. And we covered this in the Kalam cosmological argument. But if the universe had a beginning, then and to have A and to have a cause for it's coming into existence, cosmic background radiation. We've observed that it agrees with the, you know, expansion theory of our universe. We've done a lot of radioactive decay and radiometric dating. There is a book out there called Rate that tries to undermine this and I've read through it again open minded.

26:18 I was AI taught nuclear power so I feel like I understand isotopes probably better than your average person and was unconvinced. So yeah, their main argument is finding helium in places that it shouldn't be, but he then gets into everything but all the other daughter isotopes are exactly where they're supposed to be. In school, that's what we were always taught in like the Christian School I went to was like this, this the dating is like suspect or you know, they're always changing that. This year they said it was this much, but then 20 years later it's this much, or that's what they would say. Yeah, but they never said 7000. What do you say the never said 7000 years old for the for the earth?

27:00 Yeah, right, right. It was always like, why is it like 13 million and now it's 2 billion or I don't know. There's always, there are always big numbers that I. Know, right, right, yeah, yeah. So I think radioactive decay is fairly reliable and some people have said well we have no, we have no evidence that the half lives have been stable over this full time. And I would say that's true but all science works on this principle. So if you're going to throw all those out, you got to basically throw all your other your other stuff out too. I think this is one of the best arguments here. Starlight and distance. Yeah, I think, I think going back to your Wayne Grunden point, he's like, does God set up the universe to make him look like a liar? Or he's like, dude, is God trying to lie to you and deceive you? Or you know what?

27:42 I mean, and I hate saying that, but that's how I feel. Oh yeah, I'm glad you said it and not me though, because you're the you're the new Arthur. Yeah, yeah. So you would say like Adam and Eve, no belly buttons because that would be lying, right? Right. Like or you know, I. I don't have a firm position on Adam and Eve and belly buttons. Do belly buttons serve a purpose once you're an adult? I don't think so. I don't know. So they, because they were obviously they're not, you know, born and they don't need the belly button, you know, I don't know. Yeah. And yeah. And so we can riff on Adam and Eve a little bit, a little bit, because some people say, well, Adam and Eve were created an immature state.

28:25 Correct. Yeah, Yeah. Is that lying? Yeah. Yeah, and so, you know, maybe the universe was created in a mature state and you know who Ross does a good job, better than what I'll be able to do in these 3 minutes. But I'll try to be faithful what he'll say, but he'll say there's a difference between maturity and age. So like, you could have a mature car versus an aged car and you could tell the difference between, you know, age and maturity. For Adam and Eve, the difference between age and maturity might be lack of scars, lack of calluses, lack of certain, you know, he mentioned, you know, things that happen, that build up in your bloodstream and your veins as you metabolize, you know, stuff that that wouldn't be there necessarily, you know, right, when they were created because they didn't have any age to account for those things.

29:15 But then, you know, would God put in, you know, those waste products? Oh yeah, yeah. That would show, you know, metabolic processes and stuff, those types of things. And so I think Starlight happens to be one of those 'cause we observe supernova that are further, thankfully further than 7000 light years away, right. And so if you have a supernova that occurs more than 7000 light years away, that in order for at the young on a young earth view, that star never actually ever ever existed. His only thing that ever existed was the light that came to us and the the in the stream and then the explode the light that shows the explosion because it would have had exploded.

30:07 So before, right, Right. Yeah. And Greg Hall has a good article where he explains that you know better than than I do. So I think Starlight and distance is a really good, you know, there's some folks like Lyle, I can't think of his first name, maybe Eric Lyer, Dr. just say Doctor Lyle, Doctor Lyle who thinks that, you know, that the speed of light is like 2 times the speed of light going away from us, but instantaneous coming to us. And that's how he tries to get around with it. 1 is very ad hoc. You know, ad hoc just means it's for this. It's just like that doesn't make sense. But our Earth is like constantly moving. So, you know, there's be no way for that light to be, you know, coming towards us and stuff.

30:54 But yeah, geological record. We see layered fossils, we see evidence of old, you know, impact craters and stuff. And we see them 'cause I 'cause other side. I feel like sometimes younger creationists really like the the fossils though, too, 'cause they're like that. That's like their whole thing with like the flood and all this kind of stuff. But I feel like they embrace it. But you're saying they like a certain aspect of it, but then the other aspect they don't like. Yeah, So Deltaket recently did a series. It's probably available on Amazon Prime, maybe Netflix. I don't know. Remember where I saw it, where he. I think they go to the Grand Canyon and they look at stuff and he's saying, you know, we have evidence that catastrophe can make the Grand Canyon in, you know, 502 hundred. You know, I don't remember what the date was. Not like the slow, slow erosion.

31:50 I'm like that's I don't disagree with that catastrophe can can bring about some quick changes, but that doesn't that doesn't that maybe that maybe cuts off a defeater for young earth, but it doesn't disprove older, you know. What I'm saying I only the reason I brought that up is wow, we would be like gap theory so bad. We would spend a lot of time saying grand Canyon's great. This is so good for, you know, specifically connecting it with the flood and that kind of thing. Yeah, and I think maybe, you know, I don't have strong opinions on whether Grand Canyon is very old or very young.

32:32 To me, it doesn't like I haven't invested in there. I think the fossil record shows like no transitions. So OK, we don't see the transitions that you would you would sit, you would hope to see. And Darwin said if we don't find transitional fossils, then you know, and you know, one body form and then millions and millions of years later another body form, and millions and millions of years later a separate body form that is not. How do? You Yeah, yeah, you're just saying a, a what if story. And here's sorry to to to rich, because there's a lot of you know, you've probably heard of Archaeopteryx, right? Archaeoptic Archaeopteryx.

33:13 Yeah, have you heard of this? It's the fossil that they claim is a transitional fossil between a reptile and a bird. I'm. Missing link of sorts. And they always like, they draw it like in this line, that fossil is older than the thing that you would naturally think would have preceded it. So it's like you're not, you're not telling the the truth here. So yeah, that that that's pretty crazy. So geological record. Oh yeah, more plate tectonics. Yeah, all this fun stuff. Yeah, because you can measure 1/2 a millimeter every year or whatever. Like that's measurable, right? Yeah, yeah, You can see like how fast things are moving. We have really good evidence based on matching of rocks. Like you can see South America and Africa like they should go together picture, you know, pictorially.

33:57 But then, you know, you start doing the things and you know, our magnetic poles flip every now and then and actually we could be coming up on a flip. But you know, you can use that to line up rocks to and to see that. And yeah, that we can tell that those land masses were once together like based on everything that we. Know I was somewhere in Iceland where this phenomenon has happened and they're like, yeah, we just measure it every year. And every year we get like 1/4 of a millimeter apart and it's like, here's a picture from 100 years ago. It's not that much closer, but we're, you know what I mean? It's like, and they can just measure. It's just like right there, easy to, you know, do the math. Astronomical observances, we can see pulsars, quasar supernova, we already talked about that magnet, magnetic pole reversals and ice cores. So we can, you know, we see these, you know, lots and lots of years of magnetic reversals in the history. We see lots and lots of years in our ice cores. And so, again, could God have created that? Yeah.

34:59 But like, why would he Like, I'll, I'll, I'll, you know, Champion Grudem. Like it seems like if he went through all this trouble to make the earth have these marks of age and the universe these marks of age, seems like he'd be like deceiving us. And I don't think that's in God's nature. Yeah, I think I don't know where a lot of these people went to went to school, but I feel like, you know, it's like almost tribal in the camps where if you were like at Dallas Theological Seminary, you're like almost always going to air on the younger side. And then, like, if you're gruedom, you know, you know, conservative in the fact where his undergrad, what's that school? He went like Fuller Theo.

35:44 It's like liberal now, like Fuller, but then he would like get his PhD at Harvard and Cambridge and you know, like run around. And I feel like those people tend more to really maybe even just understand some of the scientific stuff a little bit better and kind of fall out on that side. Kind of same thing, you know, with with the anyway, I don't know if that there's a correlation there or not, but for for what it's worth. And you got a bonus on here. Oh, yeah, So addressing objections. Oh, the bonus, oh, these aren't in conflict with Scripture, but could they can be seen as part of God's overall plan in Revelation. So Hugh Ross will talk about the Book of Revelation, the book of nature. Those should align. And I appreciate if you get Grudem's biblical doctrine or his systematic theology, he'll basically say if we perceive some inconsistency or some conflict between Scripture and the world around us, we're misunderstanding one of them because God's the author of both of those.

36:43 So we should we should evaluate those. Let's address some objections. All right, you want to read these? Yeah, You know, I feel like we're just a slave to science. And I even want to say maybe the scientist, too, Not just science. Yeah. Yeah. Because you know what? You know our conversation earlier. But yeah, aren't you just like giving over to big science? And I do hear this a lot. Like I've heard someone say, Michael, no one believed in the old Earth until Charles Darwin came around and proposed evolution. And you're just, you're just giving, you're just doing this because of, you know, you're compromising with the evolutionists. But it's not true. A lot of people thought that the universe was eternal. Like Aquinas said, really there's no way to know that the that it's not eternal other than God revealed it to us. But it could have, you know, so there are a lot of theologians throughout the years that thought that the earth was much older than, you know, the 7000 years. So it's not capitulating a science and but you know, science can help inform us.

37:52 It sounds like scientists got you right where they want you now. Romans 5 talks about death coming through sin. You know, if sin, Adam and Eve, there's no sin, you know, death, that that's a problem. Right. And we, we talked about this last time, Romans 5 has in scope, I think just human spiritual death. You could broaden it to human physical death. And I still think that it, it doesn't expand. There's lots of plant and microorganisms that have to die even on a young earth view of things. If amoebas did not die, they grow unchecked. Like within three days they outweigh the earth. You know what I'm saying?

38:38 That they don't die 'cause they, it's exponential. It's like 1 becomes 22 becomes 4/4 becomes 88 becomes 16, you know, And if you know your powers are two, that that gets really big. So there had to be some some type of cellular death and Organism death before the fall. How about this one, Exodus 2011? It says God made everything in six days. We think Moses, just like loves. Every book is not going to lie in there. Genesis. Exodus. Whatever. Yeah, so addressed this last podcast more detail, but pattern matching. So God worked 6 yams took and he's resting in the yam. That 7th yam is still going on. And so we are to follow that same pattern working 6 yams taking a 7th yam off.

39:22 So it I don't think that's a big defeater for for us. But clearly you don't believe God's all powerful because he was powerful. He would just create everything instantly. Yeah, and I have heard this too. Like this was spoken to me by person you may know they're not at our church anymore and not recently departed either. Just put that out there. But and I was and it this one really got me for a while because I thought you will. But then I was thinking a young Arthur doesn't believe that God just snapped his fingers and it was all there. That's not what and that's not what scripture tells us. It says he created and then there was some time period, I won't call it a rest because I don't want to evoke the 7th day, but there was some time period, morning and evening and then he created again. And then there was morning, evening. So all we're talking about is the the length of that that time.

40:15 Well, when you think about a long creation, that's just not efficient. You're not getting work done. God is like a productivity, you know? Yeah. Well, God doesn't like for resources. He's outside of time. He's all powerful. So the process doesn't have to be efficient necessarily. But I will refer you again to Improbable Planet. And you know, the watch that you have on your wrist and the phone that you have and the gold and the metal and the uranium and all these heavy elements. And to get us to where we are in a safe place where we can observe everything by natural processes.

40:59 You know, there's a theory called fully gifted creation where it talks about basically God created the physical aspect so that it would unpack in a way that was just how he wanted it to be, right? And our earth would set up in this place just where we need to be. Like there's, there's so much about where we're located. Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Even in these huge structures that if we were, you know, not in this exact right spot, life wouldn't be possible. We wouldn't be able to observe the universe, you know, all these things that God did. And so the fact that it potentially took 13.8 billion years, that's nothing to God.

41:43 You know, it's, it's a couple days. Nice, cool, someone needs to mute their phone then. That's me. Shout to me. Well, we're at the end here, some final thoughts. What you got? Well, I wouldn't want to say that we have some notes here, but I'm going to, I'm going to free roll this. I want to say that I have no animosity towards Young Earthers. I and I would. And as an old Earther, I appreciate not necessarily having. We can have debate, we can have discussion. You can tell me I'm wrong, I'll tell you you're wrong. But if we do it in a loving, gracious manner, like, hey, I don't think that's the right way to read this. And here's why I think that's good.

42:24 And I think it's not helpful if you know, we divide over things like this or if I'm telling. Your own church, that old Earth 13.8 church on the street, Yeah. Yeah, or for me to call you a a compromiser type of thing. There's a guy at Southern Evangelical Seminary where I went to school for my masters, Richard Howe Howe. How do you say that? How? Do you spell that? How, How? I'm kidding. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I got. You. Oh, OK. Funny guy. Funny guy. But he's a young Arthur.

43:05 OK, OK. But he argues against how Ken Ham and Hovind and some other people argue. He's like, you're not making good arguments here, you know, So 'cause Ken Ham would say, if basically I don't accept the authority of the Bible, I'm like, I definitely accept the authority of the Bible. We just disagree on what the Bible is saying, you know, and that's a hermeneutical question. It's not a, you know, am I going to subject myself to the Bible question. Have you have you been to the Ark Encounter? Are you scared? Are you scared? Are you scared to go? I've not been to the Ark Encounter, but Jessica Petters is like, hey, I would like for you to go to the Ark Encounter with me sometime because like I'd like to hear, you know, you're, you know, they say this. How would an old author respond?

43:55 They say this. How do others respond? But yeah, yeah. So, yeah. So I think it's a like it, like you said, an intramural discussion. It's a good discussion. I don't think that there has to be vitriol with it. And at the end of the day, I don't think a lot theologically rides on it. Now, I know someone else might say, oh, everything rides on it, but I don't think you know the age. And I think like I've talked to people that'll say, well, I can't be a Christian because the Bible says the earth is 7006 thousand years old. I'm like, the Bible does not say that.

44:35 Yeah, some people interpret the Bible to say that, but there's you're not going to find that in there. So. Yeah, but if you count the genealogies it. Adds up, yeah, yeah, so. I don't know. Yeah, I will say I said this last time that, you know, people will say, you know what, you know, they'll, you know, Romans 5 or whatever, they'll say this is Exodus. I'll say I think the verse that most in vase, I guess my view, you know, I'll say the weakest thing I think is the verses that surround eating patterns in the garden. And so I'm like, is that just what they ate in the garden? You know, 'cause God will say I've given you every green leaf to eat and it almost sounds like inside the garden there were no carnivores or or omnivores kind of sounds like. That, yeah.

45:26 And then you don't really eat a lot of meats right until later on anyway. Yeah, it's after the flood. Where? You know, yeah. Humans are told specifically they can eat meat. So like those verses on like there's, you know, there's ways of not breaking those verses, but bending, you know, I understand this verse this way, but I would say that's the strongest verse that I know of that I'm like, yeah, that doesn't sit well with me. I've got to understand it this way. I've kind of got to force it into my paradigm. That's strong. But I think all the other verses are more in my favor. Like I'd rather take that one that I don't necessarily understand than than the other ones.

46:07 So but. I think that's good kind of balancing said it a lot, the science with scripture, not letting science override scripture. But you know, if if it can fit, if it's like permissible, it doesn't, you know, it's a it's a loud. You don't have to like just reject science because it's science, right. Yeah. I mean, people do you know what I mean? Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I don't want science. Yeah, Yeah. So. Yeah. No, that's good. Any final word for wrap up yon Part 2? Yeah. Any questions you have, Zach, any any did? Were you convinced? I think some good arguments I should I should look at it a little bit closer. I just I'm always like, man, I, I, I lean, I lean probably new Earth.

46:53 It's just based on reading, but I, I see good, good things on older side. So I don't know. It's just one. It's one of those things like, yeah, I wish we did have more and more info. And I wish, I wish John Piper wrote a book on it, man. I should, I should pick up if John Piper would write a book on it. You'd be. You'd be. I would. I would read it. I would. Understand, I would understand it better. I would be more more apt to read it. We just need a, you know, some of these it's like we just need a heavy, a heavy hitter. I feel like people just don't. A heavy theological. Hitter, that's what I mean. Most people, it's like in the science realm or something. It's not, it's not like like. Steven Meyer is a scientist, and he's writing on this, but he's not like a theologian.

47:34 Yeah, it'd be interesting to get like someone in pop culture who's like a big name that would write it. And, you know, I think that's probably hard to wishful wishful thinking, you know. So I'm I'm trying to think who would be that? William Lane Craig has written a book on Adam and Eve. Now he's going to take the 1st 10 verse 10 chapters, 9 chapters of Genesis, say they're mytho history. And he's like, that doesn't mean myth like you think it means myth. It just means that it is telling a history in a narrative style where not everything is expected to be. But it's they're not lying either.

48:14 It's not like, so he's gotten some pushback on that. And I think his timeline is wrong because he'll put, he puts Adam and Eve like a million years ago. And I'm like, I don't think that's right. I would, yeah. I I'd actually be come from putting Adam and Eve very recently. Oh yeah, with everything else taking a long time to develop. Right. Yeah, yeah. So like I would probably put Adam and Eve where you put the Adam and Eve 10,000. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. 20,000 years ago, yeah. Yeah, because that's funny too. It's kind of like different like John Piper arriving at like, you know, created some things, took a big break or I don't remember how his is. Or some people are like, well, Eden is something special or, you know, like everything else created. And then maybe like, I don't know. But so all these genealogies not literal or I mean, there's gaps just like in every genealogy in Scripture, like we read in Matthew.

49:05 It's not like we're nailing down everyone. I've looked closely at the genealogies and I'll say that our view of genealogies and how they're supposed to be, you know, so you could say grandfather begat grandson skipped the father skipped that, and that was fine in a Jewish. The problem with that is the Genesis genealogies are pretty exacting 'cause they say Adam lived this long and then he begat this person. So I, I, I literally, I'll just be transparent. I have some cognitive dissonance there because it by the genealogies, Adam is 7000 years ago, but I think that the like there's overwhelming evidence that civilizations have been here longer than that.

49:54 So I'm like, I think like I'm like, I must be not understanding Genesis right. You know, there must be something that we're, you know, I, I don't know what the answer to that is, 'cause I like how do these two fit together? Yeah, it's pretty amazing. Like you read those genealogies and you're like when you're doing the math, you're like, oh, like Shim might have been alive when Adam was at the end of his or it's like these people how they line up. Maybe not Shim, but it's like, no, it's like these the. I think. Shim so long. Sham was supposed to be would have been live potentially when Abraham was on the scene. Oh yeah, And then if you go the other way, it's like, it's like everyone knows each.

50:34 Other some people thought Sham was Melchizedek. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Yeah. So I mean, it's like, you know, all these people, you know, not that far, far removed. Yeah, yeah. So that's that is where I I struggle the most is how far back Adam and Eve cause the the physical and the and the animals. Like. That can be pretty far. It's like, but when did when, how far back did human civilization? And I could probably be convinced that our understanding of civilization timeline line is wrong. And AB and Eve were really 7000 years ago. I'm probably more like because I feel the weight of yeah, yeah, that's those Genesis texts, Liam, like, OK, yeah, yeah, yeah.

51:19 So like you have some people will like look at me and be like, you're a compromiser because you think the age that the universe is 13.8 billion years ago. And then that same person will say I believe Adam was 20 or 40,000 years ago and I'm like whoa. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Right. You know, I, I'm not as comfortable being dogmatic when when they were, you know, I don't know so. Well, there you go. Should we expect to yawn? Part 3 We wrapped up pretty good. I think we should have six of these in a row and then take a break. You know what I'm saying? I will say add your questions. I can see questions from both sides, maybe some atheists coming in or maybe some theistic evolutionists coming in and saying here's something you missed. Or if you got questions, if you think we didn't address something enough, I think you're, we're open. I'm open minded.

52:16 You know, if there's something I haven't considered, I'm, I'm happy to, to look at it. So. I love it. Well, thanks for hanging in there with us. That's our take. Thanks for listening to Take 2. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.