The Trinity
Episode 76
One God. Three Persons: The Father, The Son, and The Holy Spirit. Tune in to here us work through this often misunderstood doctrine.
Find our videocast here: https://youtu.be/YQxO_aHPi14
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
https://uppbeat.io/t/reakt-music/deep-stone
License code: 2QZOZ2YHZ5UTE7C8
Find more Take 2 Theology content at https://take2pod.wordpress.com
0:00 Michael, you seem like a pretty easygoing guy. I think I am most of the time, but I. Can see right through that exterior into the inner Michael Mattha gets frustrated from time to time. I was thinking maybe we could talk, talk some pet peeves. What really gets you going? What kind of things are you just like, man, why? Why do people do that? Well, you know, not that we discussed this, but now that you mention it. OK, yeah. One of my biggest pet peeves is you are in traffic, you've got a red light and oncoming traffic has that protected left turn.
0:40 You know where I'm going. Oh, I surely do. And they just keep going. They just keep going. Or they go and they stop right in front of you like they can't complete their turn. And I have been known, probably in my more or less sanctified times, to just take off as fast as I can and then narrowly miss them or slow down. And Jill always like, you know, I'm like, I want them to realize. It's never learn. How are they going to learn if if they get positive results from this they don't have any negative feedback? Like if their life flashes before their eyes for just a second, maybe that'll help them. You're welcome. Person who's life black before their eyes. Michael's doing you a huge favor.
1:21 Also on the traffic train, generally people are bad in traffic anyway when it comes to a there's like a double roundabout in Cane Bay that just throws everyone off when I'm going from 5:26 to 26. The merge merging areas. People don't know how to merge. Like you're a zipper merger, right? Only way to live your life and it and it's like, I think people think you're being selfish. We are. No, I'm actually obeying. I'm actually like going with traffic flow and it makes everyone's life easier. But if you're going from 5:26 to 26 in that lane that backs up, that is not zipper emerging. Like zipper emerging is when 2 lanes become one. But when you have one lane that's just going off and you want to drive up to the very end and then cut into that one lane, it's not 2 lanes merging that is zipper emerging.
2:09 Then that's wrong. Like you should just go get in that right hand lane so that left hand lane stays open because we're not merging, we're not merging. And so that also, that's another pet peeve of mine because because there's a difference, there's a difference. Traffic. That's a good one. What else just gets you gets you going? I try to use and no one's going to be perfect. So if if you, but I I appreciate it when I get called out like oh. Good, we'll be sure everyone take note. He appreciates being called out for this. Can't wait, Doctor Richard Hartnett, one of our musicians, calls me out 'cause I think I, so I, I like to pronounce words correctly and use the correct definition and use a correct grammar.
2:52 Yeah, I, I try to do that. So I think I said like, this song needs to be more contemplative. And he was like, you mean contemplative? And there is this guy. What's the there's a a guy's name that I can't think of from old times. Maybe I will will think of it. But also like definitions. So like a lot of people misuse words. Well, like the common one, like literally for when they mean figuratively. But I guess that's becoming a confronym. That's a thing. And if you go, I took a deep dive in the Sunday school thing I did about it and apparently, like, Emily Dickinson used it that way. And I mean, the people are like, so it's been around for a long time and you know.
3:38 That makes it right. And and that's what I'll, I'll tell you the pushback I get after I say this, but like the word nauseous, a lot of people use it like, man, I was so nauseous and I'm like, well, you weren't nauseous until you threw up on yourself. Then you became nauseous to other people because nauseous, that's an adjective for something that makes you become nauseated. So you were nauseated, not nauseous. And I was pointing this out. And then our English teacher extraordinaire, Mr. White, was like, you know, definitions, they change over time with usage. And so, you know, we update our our dictionaries to reflect current usage. So nauseous is starting to become that thing. I'm like, yeah, but it wasn't. That, but it was. So.
4:19 It's great. So if I'm like, just about to die, you're going to take time to correct me while I feel terrible. I appreciate it, Michael. I'll tell you the pet peeved, end all pet peeves. This is this is the one that this will get me. And and there's the right way to do it there. If you do this in all sincerity, it's fine. But you know, when someone maybe drinks a Coke or something and then goes afterwards, I'm just like, got to keep that in check. You know you hate that. I, I, I really don't hate it, but I give people a hard time. I'll be sure to be like, what are we doing here? You know, seems. Like there was some kid that was doing that. Was it one of our kids? Yeah, I'm calling you out specifically the no, I'm just kidding. But you know, I'm, I'm, I'm mind if a kid does it, but I'm just like, what are what are we doing here?
5:03 You know, that's one also a pet peeve of mine when people try to put an analogy on the Trinity. I'm like, come on. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you like that? Yeah. Yeah, I I like that. I like that. That's, that's where we're headed. I'm still trying to remember this guy's name that I misremembered. It's the guy Antiochus, Antiochus Epiphanes. And he's like, it's Antiochus Epiphanes, not Antiochus Epiphanes. But I grew up hearing Antiochus, but and Richard was like, no, it's Antiochus. Yeah, there you go. So you can always. Yeah, I feel like all of these, like old names can go. Yeah, Augustine. Augustine.
5:44 Yeah, Who knows? All right, who knows? But we do know about the Trinity as much a little bit, a little bit. That's right. I may not know everything, but we we do know about Trinity. So stay buckled up and we'll take it to the next level. From the hearts of the Low Country in South Carolina. It's the Take Two podcast where we take theology to the next level. You know what I love about the Trinity, Michael? It's easy to understand. So easy to understand and there are so many verses that spell it out explicitly and use the word. Yeah, yeah, You just go, you know, like go to your concordance, find all the places where it uses Trinity, turn to those verses.
6:27 It's easy. It's a easy day. So what what I mean, everyone makes such a big deal about the Trinity. You know, to be Orthodox you can believe the Trinity, but we don't find this word in Scripture. So how, how can it be such a big deal? How can we be certain in the way we define it? Well, I think there are some questions that that we have and you know, if we were to skip down a little bit, we would read that the early church, they kind of struggled a little bit with this Judaism, clearly a monotheistic, you know, religion and lots of you know, hear O Israel, the Lord your God is 1 and you should have no other God before me. You know, those types of things.
7:15 And but there were hints maybe depending on if you're Heiser or not 'cause they use this plural version of the word L Elohim. And you know, let us let us make man in sorry in our image. Sorry I got. He got this as a pet peeve in the name, so we got it done, yeah. So, so there were hints at this, but it wasn't explicit till you really get to the New Testament. Now they're that you've got these verses, they're trying to work out. How does this all work out together? Now that that that's really good because, you know, the Trinity is a foundational, essential aspect of Christianity. We would do well to, you know, be a little bit more familiar with early church creeds and and that kind of thing.
7:57 So maybe on the outset we can give basic definition should then then work towards it like what? What are we trying to keep in mind? What verbiage should we use? Because I think sometimes simple is better. You try to uncover all of the mystery and all of life you might. The more it's like the more you talk, the more you can run into trouble. Yeah, so you have one hell family. And how many members are in that family? Oh. And so we got 6. Six, so one family, six members. So I'm not saying that's analogous but to the Trinity, but it can help you see how there could be. If there's different categories, we count them differently. We're counting families versus members. So the category that we count for being, there's only one being or one what some people would say.
8:43 Some people find that offensive, like, you know, that's like what, 11 being God, but there's three who's there? Three persons there. So we're not, they're different categories, so they can have different numbers. But that's hard for us to comprehend because most of the time it's one to one for us. You know, there's one human, one person there. That's that's my normal experience. 11 dog 1, you know, you know, intelligence there or lack of intelligence there. Yeah, yeah. So that's what makes it difficult. Yeah. And it's like some of these terms, philosophy, Greek words, all of that gets confusing because I my understanding is, I mean, at some level persons is kind of an analogy for us to understand in a way to that we don't totally. If you look at some of the East versus the West, like you go way back, it's like they're arguing over the definition of persons. You look at these, you know, like Carl Bart and these, you know, people come from Germany.
9:42 They're like, well, persons is to find this. It's very, a lot of it's tied up in the semantics of what's a person and where, how that's evolved. And some of that gets confusing to me when I'm like trying to look into that a little bit. Yeah, I think you could argue over how we define a person, but hopefully that we know what 1 is when we run into it, it's probably that thing like, you know, I don't know how to define it, but I know it when I see it type of thing and so. Like if you because, like, because some of the computers are like, oh, I do I when I run into an essence or a nature versus a person versus a relationship or trying to nail this down because I was trying to read some of this stuff and it's like, it's really fascinating to read. Like if you look at the Eastern church, they're like wow, you you guys totally missed the boat because you basic you you're basically modalist, which you or it's you look at these verse West and it's like they have all these criticisms of each other and a lot of it revolves around what do you mean by person? Agustin really just talked about relationships and not about person.
10:45 Aquinas I was reading was like, I really prefer a different term a little bit, but I'll go with persons or you know what I'm saying? Like it's like some of the if. You want a deep dive into Aquinas? I can cause of how Aquinas thinks about it. He thinks it is all relation and emanation. So he would say, you know how you can think about yourself, and if you were a omnipotent eternal being, that would be so strong it would create a second person when you think about yourself. And then when you realize that you're think, 'cause you can think about yourself without realizing you're thinking about yourself.
11:30 And then when you real basically, Thomas, come on here and correct me, 'cause this is not an easy thing to to explain. But basically when you realize that you are thinking about yourself, like you have that third level, then that is strong enough to create. So he would make the distinctions all in those relationships. And I think that's because for someone who's gonna hold to divine simplicity as strong as Aquinas and I do, you're like, well, it can't be the differences, it can't be part. So what distinguishes, and it's only the only thing that distinguishes them are the relationships they have to each other so that, you know, the Father is eternal, the Son is eternally begotten, and the Spirit is eternally spyrated or produced. What's the word that they use emanates from them? Yeah, overseeing Spyrates, I think. Yeah, that to me, at the end of the day, it's like hanging on to those words.
12:24 That's where the creeds are really, really important. So we've got here in our notes, you know, we, we worship one God in Trinity and the Trinity in Unity. And then it looks like you've got a lot of creedal statements here that help us understand. This better opening of the Athanasian Creed. OK, great. I'm neither blending their persons nor dividing their essence. For the person of the Father is a distinct person, the person of the Son is another, and that of the Holy Spirit still another. But the divinity of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is 1. Their glory equal, their majesty Co eternal. And it it goes on, that's the opening paragraph. There's probably 17,000 paragraphs. It's.
13:07 A lot it goes on and on and on. And so we, we try to understand that. Like to me that's helpful. When you try to get into a little more, try to, you know, bring these analogies along for the ride, you start running into run into a little bit of problems. Yeah, and the problem is there's really nothing analogous to God. The only analogy I've heard that somewhat fits the bill is by Greg Coppol, the one and only and, and he talks about a three-dimensional Cartesian plane like XYZ and how, you know, if you're thinking about X, it is fully subsumed in the Y and the Z and the Y is fully subsumed in the X and the Z and the Z is fully assumed in the X and the Y and they are identical in nature. So he's like, that's how, that's the only analogy that I think kind of works.
14:03 But even that you know it probably fails some way. This this is Augustine's analogy way back when, where he's like, so I, I was coming across this, I thought it was interesting. Still, I don't think it it fits the bill, he explains. The Trinity is like the mind and the mind's ability to remember versus understanding versus to will are different aspects of the So he he's kind of trying to take it a different with things kind of like proceed. Sounds great. And so that that that's essentially, if you get down to like the E 1st West, a lot of people are like very critical of Augustine and then, you know, on that kind of thing. But it is interesting. Everyone's been trying to do analogies and no one, no, no one's, no one's nailed it.
14:43 So you probably, we should probably go over some of these analogies and kind of point out why they're wrong. The first kind of broad category, you've heard me say the word modalistic or modalism, it just means it's the same thing that's in a different mode. And so the problem with this is there's really no distinction in the person. It's a, you know, it's God the Father is God the Son is God the spirit, just kind of different aspects of it. So 1 you might have heard is water can be a liquid, a vapor or a solid when it becomes ice. And that's really the same thing, just in in different substances or different forms. Second one that you might hear is, well, I am a father, but I'm also a son and I'm also a husband. I have different modes, but it's all one person doing all of those things I so that's where it fells down because it fails to keep the distinction between the persons. Yeah, no, that, that's really good. And I think we modalism man, and, and, and I think a common theme we're going to see is a lot of these analogies, you can kind of like keep modalism in your mind 'cause you can like pull that out for several things, just like partialism. You can just, you can just hit this. This was, you know, condemned, condemned as heresy. I can't remember the guy's name.
15:58 If it was Sibelian Sibelius, I don't know. Sibelianism I think sometimes is equivalent to modalism by some people. Maybe it's a little different, but what? In a different vein, you can get some of these Arianistic analogies where Arianism is that Christ, God the Son, is lesser created, being maybe still deity, but not on the same plane as God the Father. Right. Like maybe a demigod or something like that. Yeah, the best of all creation. So it's the not elevated over human sizes, but it's still missing, missing the boat and Arianism. You might see in some of these some of these analogies too. We've got one here where there's sun light and heat where those things are very related. But there's a source, and things proceed from that source in a different.
16:45 Kind of way, yeah, the light is created from the sun and the and the essence of light is different than the essence of sun, which is different than the essence of heat. So they don't share the same nature either, Yeah. That that's a problem. And then and then we've got a dot dot dot. Was that just in case you think of a different one? Yeah. Yeah, in case you hadn't had any more. And the the ellipse itself. No, I'm just yeah. And then so also partialism, this is really where there's parts like God could be divided into three parts and three parts combined to make a whole. One of those one might be Voltron, which is what the the two Irish showbillies reference in in the but you might have heard of like a three leaf Clover. You know, there's three different leaves. They all come together to be one or like the shell, the yolk, the albumin, albumin albumin, the egg white. Yeah, all three parts come together to equal 1 egg. So all of those fail because it has to be 1 thing that has the same nature but is presented or represented or indwelled personified by three persons.
17:59 It's you know the the word trying. Trying to find the word to is difficult. Yeah. And I and I think if you go through different analogies, most of your analogies are going to fall in one of these three categories. Maybe not every single one, but but these are the common ones that that you can kind of call out and and I've led to some heretical views and you can you can tie these right, right in with with these analogies we we use. So we have unit Unitarianism that one God, one person. We see this this is yeah, Oneness Pentecostal kind of embrace this modalism of sorts kind of thing. Islam Scott, you know. They're not Christian, but they do. They don't.
18:39 They believe that we're wrong. And they would look at us and they would say, oh, you guys are polytheists is kind of what they would. Think, yeah, yeah, yeah. So Unitarianism, Poly or try tritheism depend on, you know, exactly. And really, LDS Mormons fall into this. They would claim different, but it's like, oh, yeah, yeah, they define it how they define it. They are three different beings who all share define divinity, godhood. And so I don't know how you get around calling that polytheism. You know, I have friends who are Mormon and I love you, but your your definitions are the same as polytheism and. Then we have Arianism, the popular cult that you'll see today, Jehovah's Witness, where I've talked to Jehovah, Jehovah's Witness, Job's Witnesses are very prevalent in the older adult community.
19:34 They do a really good job of converting people either online or whatever. So run to people and they're in all these online Bible says like I just came across this. It's so great on my patients and I've like talked them through what I feel like are very clear claims to deity. So. You can have these kind of conversations with your patients. Oh, it's not all of them, but a lot of them. It's one of my favorite things about my job is that I see people for like 3 hours a week for like 120 days. Like you, you get very comfortable with people. You know, you can ask and it's hilarious. There's a huge, there's like a few 55 and older communities where in this is different. A little off topic, but got a lot of people from like Long Island and they they're they're Jewish culturally and it's like they'll have like the 10 commandments hanging up and you ask them about it.
20:15 They're like 10 commandments. I think I can name like four of them. It's just like the cultural Jewish. It's not like they went to Jewish school and all this, all this stuff, but man, things that I would think. With Jehovah's Witnesses that are clear attestation of Christ's divinity, there's like all these talking points around that they they are not convincing. But I, I'm trying to think of the one that was put toward me recently, but it's it's almost like ridiculous that, Oh no, Jesus was just saying this because I don't know. It's like very, very straight you. Tried Jesus the Divinity for Christ's. Case closed. I get that title from. Cocol. But it's 1st chapter John, not the first verse but like the third verse. I'll keep going down.
20:58 Where it says he created all things that came into being and nothing came into being apart from. Him. And so then you're like, OK, if nothing came into being apart from him, he created all things that came into being, then Christ has to be something that didn't come into being. And if you don't come into being, we call that God if you've always existed. So yeah, that's maybe that's a tack you can take with them. Yeah, I'll, I'll, I'll try it. Win them over. Win them over. Yeah. It's it's crazy. The it's just like, man, boom. They've been indoctrinated so much. So you know what? What's the big deal? What? Why do we believe in the Trinity, Michael? Well, the Trinity, like we were saying alluding to at the beginning, it you're not going to find that word in the Bible, but you're going to find a lot of verses that present a trinitarian view.
21:51 So we have some verses here that first kind of I thought we'll just take this in in order. So are they separate persons? You know, is it clear that the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit are persons and that and that they're separate. So we just have we don't have to read all of these, but here's some Matthew 316 through 17 kind of a your common one that gets brought up after being baptized. Jesus came up immediately from the water and behold, the heavens were open and he Jesus saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove and lighting on him. And behold, a voice came out of the heavens said, this is my beloved son, in whom well, please.
22:31 So you see, Father, Son, Holy Spirit, three different manifestations of those different doesn't really make sense for those to be the same. Yeah, three kind of different, different things going on there. John 1426 But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, He will teach you all things and bring you to your remembrance. All that I said to you. This is Jesus talking. He's talking about the Holy Spirit being sent by the Father. This is probably a different, different podcast, but the whole debate where the East is like, hey, I don't like this Council of Nicaea or this, you know, Nicene crew that's been adapted to include from the Father and the Son that the Spirit spyrates. That's it's only the Father.
23:14 They would look at something like this, Yeah, Later on in that same thing, he's talking about the helper again. 1526 of John says, when the helper comes, whom I will send to you, so there you go East Church, whom I will send to you from the Father. That is the spirit of truth who proceeds from the Father. He will testify about me so similar but a whole chapter later got got basically the same pieces there. Great if we keep moving along. 2nd Corinthians 13 Paul writes the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all. So these three separate persons to be be with these people in Corinth.
23:55 Matthew 2819 the everyday Commission go therefore make disciples of all nations baptized him in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. So talking about them out like they're three different people. Yeah, and and the beautiful thing about this there, and there's just verse after verse after verse. Matthew 2639 says he went a little beyond him and fell on his face and prayed. This is Jesus praying, saying, My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me yet. Not as I will, but as you will. Yeah. And so it doesn't make sense to pray to yourself, right? Yeah. So yeah, John 17 one Jesus spoke these things and lifting up his eyes to heaven, he said, Father, the hour has come, glorify your son, that your son may glorify you. So clearly different relationships there. And we see similar thing.
24:44 John 11. So they removed the stone. Then Jesus raised his eyes and said, Father, I thank you that you've heard me. I knew that you always hear me. But because of the people sitting around, I said it so that they may believe that you sent me again. Strange thing to be talking to yourself. Yeah, and there's probably more. I got these pull these from a quick search that had compiled some so any any other examples you have off hand? No, I, I, I, I think that's good. And I think it just proves the point that this is just, it's pretty ubiquitous with. So the New Testament authors did not see a need to explicitly define the Trinity because it was assumed, you know what I mean? Like that that that should speak for itself a little bit, right All.
25:28 Right. So then on the other side, if they are different persons, are we guaranteed that they are all divine? Maybe, you know, maybe the Jehovah's Witness has have it. So you could ask, is the Father divine? Is the Son divine? Is the Holy Spirit divine? I think, Father, most people who are in the faith, they don't. It's a weird if you were like, Holy Spirit's the only one. You don't see that? Yeah. Yeah. So is the Father divine? Well, of course He is. John 627 Do not work for the food which perishes, but for the food which endures to eternal life, which the Son of man will give to you, for on him the Father God has set His seal. So just a very explicit verse calling the Father as God.
26:11 First, Peter one says, according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, by the sanctifying work of the Spirit, to obey Jesus Christ and be sprinkled with his blood. May grace and peace be yours in the fullest measure. Talking about, you know, God the Father's had this this full foreknowledge know knows everything in advance. Yep, then we have one from the Old Testament, Isaiah 6316 For You are our Father through though Abraham does not know us, and Israel does not recognize us. You, O Lord, so it says Lord, but this is the the name of God that Moses gave him. So you, O you, O Yahweh, are our Father, our Redeemer from old is your name.
26:53 So again, a very explicit linkage between the Father and Divinity. Now that that's great, we will move over to God the Son, God the sons divine. Probably the most common go to and for good reason. John 11 in the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. Pretty, explicit, Pretty. Clear, pretty clear. And again, I got these from a search, but I would add 1-3 go down. You know, he created all things. Nothing came into being except for through him. Kind of like the climax of the book of John Thomas after Jesus says, all right, here I am Thomas, put your hands in my, put your finger in my hands and put your hand on my side. He said, Thomas answers and said to him, my Lord and my God. So at least the apostles thought that he was God. Colossians 29 For in him Jesus, all the fullness of deity dwells in bodily form.
27:47 So pretty pretty clear there. Yeah, Titus 213 looking for the blessed hope and the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Christ Jesus. And then the rounded out Hebrews one verse 8, but of the Son, he says quoting a Psalm, which is great. If you're quoting the Old Testament, you're bringing that together that that's saying a lot. Your throne, O God, is forever and ever. And the righteous scepter is the scepter of his Kingdom. So over and over you see Jesus as God, you see Jesus as Lord, You see Jesus possessing these divine attributes with his miracles and omnipotence and all, all, all of this stuff. He accepted worship, so he thought he was God. That's right, all these I am statements connecting him to to Yahweh.
28:30 Those are those are pretty strong. So probably the toughest ones coming up, huh, or what? I don't think it's tough, but you know, people, the forgotten people, forget about the Holy Spirit, I think. Holy Spirit is the vine. So we have Ananias and Sapphira. They lie and Peter when they lie, he says you've lied to the Spirit. And then earlier he, he equates that to God. So I'll just read this. This is but Peter says Ananias. Why has Satan filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit and to keep back some of the price of the land while it remained unsold? Did it not remain your own? And after it was sold, was it not under your control? Why is it that you have conceived this deed in your heart? You have not lied to men, but to God. So earlier you lied to the Holy Spirit.
29:11 You lied to God. So he's making an equivocation between those two. Yeah, that that connection's pretty, pretty undeniable. I'm in First Corinthians 316, Paul writes. Do you not know that you're a temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? I'm talking talking to believers. You have the Holy Spirit in you. Temple of God. Yep. So these has to be divine for that to be the case. 2nd Corinthians 317 through 18. Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty. But we all with unveiled face, beholding as a mirror the glory of the Lord are being transformed into the same image from glory to glory, just as from the Lord the Spirit. So pretty clear we're we're equating this Adonai which to the spirit again, divine titles.
30:00 I like this one. Hebrews 914. How much more will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal spirits offered himself without blemish to God, cleanse your conscience from dead works to serve the living God? So the Spirit's eternal that that speaks volumes. Yeah, yeah. That's kind of like case closed there. Psalm 139, seven through 8. Where can I go from your spirit? Oh, the Spirit is omnipresent. Or where can I flee from your presence? If I ascended the heavens, you are there. If I make my bed and shield, behold, you are there. So again, you could read this if you, you know, put with all the other stuff. OK, I think we can make the connection that the Spirit's omnipresent. And if he's omnipresent, he's divine. No, I I like that. I like that Psalm passage because you, you can look up God's Spirit in the Old Testament and it's, it's not nothing.
30:46 There are there's several verses that speak to the Spirit in the Old Testament. All right, so like we kind of talked about at the beginning, it's clear, it's implied, but it's kind of new with the New Testament. And so it took the church a little bit of time to kind of formalize this and work this out. And like, how do we want to talk about it 'cause it's like, kind of like we were talking about how do we find a person? Like we know what what it is, but how do we talk about this in a way that is true to what the Bible says? And like we said, the term Trinity never used in the Bible wasn't even using Christian literature until the 2nd century. However, the concept was present in early Christian thought and the Bible itself.
31:30 Now that that is really, really good. The Council of Nicaea 325. So you can kind of see the centuries kind of going on a little bit and and you don't necessarily need to define something until there's a problem. And then you start getting, you know, Arianism, these these things are starting to to pop up and be be problems. And so they need to be together and and kind of fit figure this out. Like what what's going on that that council of Nicey affirmed that the son was of the same substance as the father in the face of Arianism. Maybe we'll get a Christmas episode about it later on this year. Which Arianism denied Christ divinity. Yeah. And then a little later on 451, the Council of Chalcedon further clarified the relationship between Christ's divine natures and human natures, 'cause that was a, you know, all right, who is this person?
32:18 Jesus, you know, you know, And so we have one person, two different natures. And so those two together really help kind of shape our, you know, kind of our foundation that helped put words to what we believe Athanasian Creed was. I guess it was never adopted in a council, but he wrote it and a lot of people, you know, I think quote it and stuff so. Yeah, Athanasius, good. Good for you. It's probably worthwhile just to go back, read over these, you know, from time to time set up these kind of rails to stay, to stay inside of because it's not it's it's something that definitely matters. And I think most people are just ignorant. I don't think people most the time are like, I love modalism, but it's just like kind of by by the way, they are kind of processing things.
33:08 So I think you've got a couple of helpful, helpful ideas for us from your boy Greg Cockel himself. That's right. So Greg has two articles on and the title is the Trinity a solution, not a problem. Cause a lot of people go, they view the Trinity as like this thing that we and, and it's really not the problem. You know, maybe our understanding is the problem, but kind of just a summary of those articles of the first one. He's really gonna talk about how, you know, it's just not this, the abstract theological concept. It's central to our Christian faith. It answers some of our most challenging questions about God's nature. The Trinity shows us how God can be love even before he's created everything because there's love between the Father, Son and the Holy Spirit.
33:54 And it helps us understand the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross as an expression of God's love, not cruelty. And the Trinity explains how Jesus's finite suffering for us in time could pay for an infinite, you know, amount of human sins or the infinite punishment of human sins. Because God, as Jesus sacrifice carries out sorry. Because as God, Jesus's sacrifice carries an infinite value, so it can cover all those sins. Practically it it helps us out. It's a major solution seeing those intrapersonal relationships that I think about that, that that is something that's very important about about our God. And then you're right, if you know Christ is not God, that's a problem.
34:43 We are in a whole lot of other trouble. Yeah, he's got a second article. Again, I have a like a paragraph summary of it. But really, if I were to hit the highlights of it, it says it's just not, it's not, it's not a doctrine that we invented or a theological puzzle, but it's a revealed truth that's in the word that underscores God's love, the significance of the cross, the basis of Christian salvation or salvation. So it's not a problem. It's really a glorious solution that unifies God's self revelation to us. I I love this question. What pronouns do you use for the Holy Spirit? I guess in today's culture, we're always, we're all about pronouns. Am I missing the boat?
35:24 It's a It's as simple as he is that he has. It is, yeah. I, I some people have been like, you know what? A what? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, it's not a what? It's a he. Yeah, I, I guess we're coming on the this is coming kind of on the heels few weeks back of pneumatology where, you know, Holy Spirit has personal attributes, can be grieved. It helps counsels these things that would be strange for a force to perform. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And and then Greg Kochl's first article kind of addresses this, but the Trinity can also be practical solutions for some of the tax we get from outside. So you may or may not be familiar with the so-called divine or cosmic child abuse argument, but basically the argument is that God the Father is sacrificing his innocent son and men. That's horrible.
36:15 Like if you were to say, all right, Jordy, Oh no, you're going to basically be tortured to death, but it's OK 'cause by you dying, it's going to save all this world and be like, that's what's going on. That's so bad. But this argument really falls apart when you realize Jesus is God. So it's not like God is sending God in itself. God has provided himself a lamb. If we were to quote what what happens with Abraham? And so Jesus being one of the persons, God willing, he takes on the cost of sin out of love for humanity. And he's not God's not inflicting violence on some third person. It's really the Father's inflicting violence on the Son, but they're all part members of the Trinity. That's good that God can build the just and justifier of our faith.
37:07 I like this here too. Because we have a trinitarian God. It influences how we worship, I think. I think that's good. Pay attention to a song lyrics. You know, you're praising God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Spirit. Sing about it today. There you go. It's it's good to think about these things impacts your prayer. You know, I don't know, there's I mean, I don't know if you're in this debates, pray in Jesus name, nothing else. Like you. I mean, it's, I mean, you know, how do we pray? You know, some people are pretty strict on some of this stuff. I don't know. Well I think the pattern in most prayers you see are to the Father in Jesus name. But I think there is maybe 1 lone prayer to the spirit or something. I'm just going off of what I've heard the podcaster say. I won't say which podcaster but a podcaster out there. But you know, all three are are God. But I think the pattern, the normal pattern, is praying to the Father.
38:05 You won't catch me praying to the Holy Spirit, am I? I'll look at that word to the Son. You see some you probably 90 percenter to the Father and then you had 10% of the prayers to the Son in the Bible. Now that's that that I think thinking about these things is, is very important. And when we look at, you know, this intrapersonal relationship that that God has, this relational nature of God that does serve as a model for love, unity and diversity within the church, that as a church we are united. But there's very diverse, very diverse people across time, across cultures. And I think that is reflected. You look at our world as a very diverse world and that that is reflected in our God.
38:45 And then finally, we've kind of hinted at some of this, but, you know, knowing the Trinity and then knowing the roles that they take in our salvation. And if you look at Scripture, it, you know, they they do different things. The Father draws us to himself, compels us to himself, just like Peter and Silas were compelled into the prison. Yeah, there you go. The Son accomplishes our salvation through his death and resurrection. The Spirit regenerates us to bring about salvation, seals us, gives us gifts for service, sanctifies us as we live our lives. And so these different roles that they play, it really helps us understand, you know, more about our salvation and helps us have AI think a deeper appreciation for what God's done for us.
39:35 Yeah, I think that's good. Each person of God, I think is involved in every aspect. But we definitely do see the Father planning, the Son executing, the Spirit applying, and that's good that economic Trinity, not to displace that ontologic Trinity where they're all Co eternal and all all God. Good ways to to talk about these things. Some people you start talking about the economic Trinity and they get all bent out of shape too. That like you're, you know, giving all a a whole different thing and you're like, no, no, everyone's everyone's guy Co. Eternal. Go read. Go read some creeds to spend your afternoon. That's what you should do all. Right. Anything else to say? I've got nothing else. All right, that's our take. Thanks for listening to Take Two. Find us wherever you find podcasts and on YouTube for those who want to watch our video cast.
RSS Feed